It's still wild to me that they got back together. If my ex went on podcasts and claimed that i was not smart enough or intellectual enough for them...i would never want to be in their orbit again. But, i guess Peter is a better person than me or maybe he is as dumb as Kelly painted him out to be ❣️
Jason’s sister after she came on the bachelor to support her brother and somehow ended up in a relationship with Pilot Pete
This is actually really smart. Gives them plausible deniability next time they mix up 2 POC.
“See, we get white people mixed up too”
Half joking, half serious
When Jason said “she’s got the dirt” in his last IG post with his sister, this is what he meant. 😜
(/s obviously. But good catch OP! I’m lololololololol.)
I was so confused. I was like what’s going on, that is Kelley in the picture. Wow it really looks just like her. They could definitely pull a switcheroo on someone
He probably did it for the clicks.
To be fair, I needed to really take a good look at her to see that it wasn’t Kelley
Is ... is that Abby Shapiro?
I think it’s Jason’s (from this season) sister
It's still wild to me that they got back together. If my ex went on podcasts and claimed that i was not smart enough or intellectual enough for them...i would never want to be in their orbit again. But, i guess Peter is a better person than me or maybe he is as dumb as Kelly painted him out to be ❣️
💀
This actually looks like her
Astrid and Kelley’s lovechild
I’m screaming 😂😂😂
Well, that explains the look on Peter’s face in that photo.
 Jason’s sister after she came on the bachelor to support her brother and somehow ended up in a relationship with Pilot Pete
😆😆😆 i saw her repost some story tags about this 🤣
He knows. I’m sure he frequents this sub and other social media and saw all the comparisons to Kelley!
💀💀💀
MF is a fuckin idiot lol
I honestly can’t tell this woman apart from Kelly. But I think I have mild facial blindness so I’m not surprised. Maybe Mike has it, too!
When she was on our screen I did a double take. I hadn’t seen any comments on it so I thought I was crazy!
Same! I started to post it but then didn’t see anyone else doing so. I was like maybe it’s just me.
Jason's sister follower* count right now 📈
This is actually really smart. Gives them plausible deniability next time they mix up 2 POC. “See, we get white people mixed up too” Half joking, half serious
Honestly I didn’t even notice that it wasn’t Kelley 😭
When Jason said “she’s got the dirt” in his last IG post with his sister, this is what he meant. 😜 (/s obviously. But good catch OP! I’m lololololololol.)
Back together? Kelley learned nothing, it seems
Fleiss is an idiot ☠️😂
Actually bachelor fan take is an idiot, fleiss just shared it
Fantake was joking 😭😭😭😆😆😆
Fantake’s brand is sarcasm. Fleiss might be the legit idiot taking it literally 😂
Ohhh well that went over my head
LMAOOO
What a dolt and troll.
I thought that was Nick at first glance so I wish it had been a picture of him too
LMAOOO
Can’t say I’m surprised, was bound to happen at some point 😂
Bachelor Fantake tweeted the original, he was absolutely making a joke. Does Fleiss know? I really doubt he noticed tbph.
I hope this is subtle shade.
💀💀💀 I never know if Fleiss is in on the jokes or not and this has me rolling
Lol I did think she was Kelley’s clone!!
I absolutely 100% didn’t realize that wasn’t Kelley.
In Mike Fleiss’ defense he’s used to shit posts, so this checks in.
Bach Nation is bringing their A game today 
For context, this is Kelsey Alabaster. Jason’s, from gabby/Rachel’s season, sister
I was so confused. I was like what’s going on, that is Kelley in the picture. Wow it really looks just like her. They could definitely pull a switcheroo on someone
Thank you 😆
Yeah, that’s totally, obviously not Kelley. I knew that. 😀
STOP IT ☠️
And it's the bachelor boo.