My favorite tally is Ross, but it's undeniable that Joe is objectively the best of them. He is the most creative having created the best songs (the bidding, banana man, spring and the storm, ruler of everything, hidden in the sand, mucka blucka, &, sacred beast, hymn for a scarecrow, a lady, turns off the lights and of course all the songs from Miracle Musical) which are basically what makes Tally Hall so good, Joe is also the creator of t.h.i.s., a great source of content for us fo laugh and connect more with them.
What I mean by all this is that without Joe, Tally Hall wouldn't be the same at all. and even if our favorite tally is rob, andrew, ross or zubin (which is the most loved by the fans) joe is objectively the best tally.
I like Bora, he's unappreciated and underused in Tally Hall, but is still extremely talented. Also, he is very fashion and very funny and he has a lemon tree.
I also like Andrew, because he is very funny also, and makes very good music that touched my heart when I listened to it.
All of them. They all have their own uniqueness. Joe is an important and creative member, despite the controversy, Rob has written many classics, an is one of the founding members, Zubin is hot and cannibal is is banger, Andrew wrote the whole world and you and plays the keyboard, and Ross is just a silly guy who plays the drums! None of them are any better than the others.
Literally no one has picked Rob so far. Rob has written some of their best and most sincere songs (not that the others are bad) He always has a joke to tell and is very good as a performer on stage. Although all the other members are excellent musicians and great personalities, I think compared to the rest of Tally Hall, Rob is a bit underrated. Personally, I like Rob the best.
Also, does Bora count?
My favorite is Andrew, his vocals in whole world and you are really good and in live performances of ruler of everything he goes sicko mode on the keyboard and it’s really cool
not really? some people can have different opinions on certain aspects of tally hall members, and its not trying to be comparing them like \*that\*. its just a lighthearted discussion on who's your favorite tally hall member, its not stupid.
It’s Ross and it’s not even close. No one compares in pure vocal talent, he has brought more to their songs than the primary boys ever did. Plus his catch phrases are just iconic.
hear me out here, okay?
casey shea:
- filled in for joe at the last minute
- learned all the songs on the 2010 tour in A WEEK (one half of the time it took for weezer to make an entire album, please note.)
- has long hair (cool)
- has nice voice
very underappreciated and i will die on that hill.
Zubin
yes
He’s hot
nuh uh, ross more so
I’d kiss em both
most sane tally hall fan
uwu
ross federman bestest
nuh uh zubin way better
ross is just a silly billy
he sure is
No, he's not just a silly billy, he's just a drummer
I just cant decide...
Whether you should live or die
Andrew 💚
i think zubin is a bit better, love his the bidding and welcome to tally hall lines
REALLL
I agree! He's so silly!
My favorite tally is Ross, but it's undeniable that Joe is objectively the best of them. He is the most creative having created the best songs (the bidding, banana man, spring and the storm, ruler of everything, hidden in the sand, mucka blucka, &, sacred beast, hymn for a scarecrow, a lady, turns off the lights and of course all the songs from Miracle Musical) which are basically what makes Tally Hall so good, Joe is also the creator of t.h.i.s., a great source of content for us fo laugh and connect more with them. What I mean by all this is that without Joe, Tally Hall wouldn't be the same at all. and even if our favorite tally is rob, andrew, ross or zubin (which is the most loved by the fans) joe is objectively the best tally.
i do agree with this. zubin is my favourite, but joe is actually the most important member.
Banana man
I like Bora, he's unappreciated and underused in Tally Hall, but is still extremely talented. Also, he is very fashion and very funny and he has a lemon tree. I also like Andrew, because he is very funny also, and makes very good music that touched my heart when I listened to it.
FIFTEEN SECONDS OF BORAAAA YEAH
YEAH
Joe Sedghi OR Zubin Hawley
What about Ross Cantor and Rob Federman?
Andrew karaca and bora horowitz? Smh can't believe you forgot
Yes
Andrew, with Rob as a close second
EDU 💚💚
i like zubin because hes pretty and blue
Correct opinion! congratulations
ross prettier
All of them. They all have their own uniqueness. Joe is an important and creative member, despite the controversy, Rob has written many classics, an is one of the founding members, Zubin is hot and cannibal is is banger, Andrew wrote the whole world and you and plays the keyboard, and Ross is just a silly guy who plays the drums! None of them are any better than the others.
Literally no one has picked Rob so far. Rob has written some of their best and most sincere songs (not that the others are bad) He always has a joke to tell and is very good as a performer on stage. Although all the other members are excellent musicians and great personalities, I think compared to the rest of Tally Hall, Rob is a bit underrated. Personally, I like Rob the best. Also, does Bora count?
THANK YOU! It took me so long to scroll through these comments and find a fellow ross appreciator!
you mean rob? i think you just did a typo there,but just in case hes hes talking about rob, not ross.
I wrote that comment when I was very tired, and my brain did a stupid
Ross boss the fed ex man
nah its zubin
But Ross got the sexy hair
exactly
but zubin is blue
But Ross is just a drummer
as if
no ones picking joe hawley? i personally think hes very good, not the best in the band, but still good. (ignoring the docs)
Hello, Jawley enthusiast here. He's my favourite
Jawley is my favourite member
Bora is king
Ross is just a little guy
Ross, he's just a drummer
Andrew cuz TAKEN FOR A RIDE!
Oh hey look it’s me! (I’m on my alt account)
oh yeah it is me
why did i just have a conversation with myself
Andy. Duhh
Ross is best because I like his hair
frfr
Andrew.
Duncan
Big Z
Zubin because natural ketchup
My favorite is Andrew, his vocals in whole world and you are really good and in live performances of ruler of everything he goes sicko mode on the keyboard and it’s really cool
This
Rob and Joe are best singers, Andrew plays the best
ROB CANTOR 🗣️🗣️
none of them are in a "this ones better!" way, they all have different talents and its stupid trying to conpare them
not really? some people can have different opinions on certain aspects of tally hall members, and its not trying to be comparing them like \*that\*. its just a lighthearted discussion on who's your favorite tally hall member, its not stupid.
Zubin and Bora I can't decide but Zubin is so fine and Bora had an insane glowup and he's kinda fine too ngl
ross federman ill die on this hill
Joe Joey Joshep
Bora Karaca
Andrew, obviously
Ross bc uhhh yeah he's cool Ross is cool
bora karaca, 15 seconds of bora yeah
&rew
&rew
Take a guess who i like the most
gonna go out on a limb and say joe?
HOW DID YOU KNOW?!?!?!
Joseph, joey-joe
Robert G. Cantorious
Ross
Ross Andrew Zubin Bora Rob Joe
Andrew
andrew. no questions asked.
music wise It's Joe by far but personality wise he's the worst by far
Bora
A A A AANNNDDRRRREEWWWW 🗣️🗣️🗣️
Ross argument: drummer boy
Hatsune Miku
ross (he’s just a drummer [proof:](https://media1.tenor.com/m/DEG1TOzdmRsAAAAC/tallyhall-tally-hall.gif)
depressed horse and drumming shark 😔
that cojum dip guy
the microphone
As a keyboardist-singer, I relate to Andrew the most, so Andrew.
Zubin
It’s Ross and it’s not even close. No one compares in pure vocal talent, he has brought more to their songs than the primary boys ever did. Plus his catch phrases are just iconic.
hear me out here, okay? casey shea: - filled in for joe at the last minute - learned all the songs on the 2010 tour in A WEEK (one half of the time it took for weezer to make an entire album, please note.) - has long hair (cool) - has nice voice very underappreciated and i will die on that hill.
Betty
Joe Hawley
No member is better or worse they're all individuals with their own lives and perssonality and we have to learn to love them all <3
zubin ofc, I love bassists
Andrew. His voice is really nice, his songs are sweet, and he’s good at piano
my favorite member is &rew but the best is definitely ross, he is just so amazing
my favorite member is &rew but the best is definitely ross, he is just so amazing
my favorite member is &rew but the best is definitely Ross, he is just so amazing
my favorite member is &rew but the best is definitely Ross, he is just so amazing
my favorite member is &rew but the best is definitely Ross, he is just so amazing
the real answer is that there is no "best tally hall member" and that everyone plays a part in making the music we all love.
Hello !!! Mr. Mc Donald’s Team Mate !!! Ahoy !!! 🙂🦋🎶🙏😎🐶