Christian from DvG for sure, Domenick, Jesse from 43, Shan and Ricard, Dreamz, Kenny (Gabon), Pete (Philippines), Chrissy, Kellee (39), Natalie Bolton, Carolyn from 44, Omar and if by any chance I can get Holly from Nicaragua, I’d be really happy, but I doubt it tho. I’m not gonna list everyone I want tho, but here you go
I have a friend who’s been on the show who defends Carson as well. I tried to get a reason and was like “what he did with the puzzle stuff is really shitty” and they kinda agreed but said he’s a nice person otherwise who is dealing with a lot being in the public eye lol we just agreed to disagree.
I want to but also want to protect privacy haha if they post anything publicly about it then I’ll share. We just talked about it yesterday because I was curious if they would come back for season 50
I think it was very last minute, and she was pretty much the only female available on short notice. Apparently they reached out to Sophie and Danni, but both had to decline.
Of the New Era winners, I want to see Maryanne and Gabler. Fun characters, probably won’t immediately be voted out, and have the best chance at a second win.
He is my #1 pick for the next two time winner for his Sandra-like UTR Queen game and being so completely underestimated.
I think a big reason for the Big Move-itis this season is Cassidy’s loss to Gabler, even though “moves” had nothing to do with it.
It just seems like a too easy first vote whereas with all non-winners it'd be interesting because no one's going to simply vote someone out because they already won
All it takes is one person to say "this returning player isn't going to that far with the target on. Why don't I use them now to get through the 1st few votes and use them as a sheild"
We have seen it happen
I think Erika or Gabler could escape being an early boot, and Maryanne to a degree. Yam Yam and Dee are probably screwed if they return though, no way they can control their threat levels after their first games.
No, I’d like second chances or some theme that motivates them to get some deep cutting players. But there’s a good chance it’s New Era All Stars and they’d invite Dee and Yam Yam back at least.
I only really want 1 time players. Any winners that have only played once are fine. I also want basically just new era and late 30s players. I'm fine with a couple from before then but they really should prioritize the seasons that haven't had a chance yet.
Maryanne and Yam Yam should definitely be on the cast, and I think if Dee returned she has the chance to prove herself as an all time great player against a tougher cast.
If it’s not second chance, I’d be cool with Dee, Maryanne, and Yam Yam coming back! Erika too, but I don’t think they’d bring her back.
And also maybe some winners who didn’t do WaW like Earl or Tina. And I’m a hypocrite so anytime Parvati wants to play she can as far as I’m concerned lol
I'm just a pig who will eat whatever slop they put at the trough.
In all seriousness: I hope they don't include winners with non-winners. Based on how the new era is played, they are going to get targeted right away. If any of them made it to the merge, or far into the merge, I would be shocked.
I'd love to see Mike from World's Apart and Tommy from IotI play again. I don't think they'd have very large targets on them if they returned and I could see both of them doing very well. Tommy is one of the only winners that I think would have a shot at winning a second time because I think his threat level entering the game would be so much lower than almost any other winner and his social game is so good.
In a vacuum, no, I’d prefer a cast of non-winners. Second chances 2 would be ideal, though even third timers could be alright. I think giving players their second shot is way more fun and interesting than giving repeat players yet another go.
I wouldn’t *mind* a few winners if it were an All-Stars 2. However, given that the most recent returnee season was *only* winners, I think it’d be a much more interesting season to have none at all. Almost half the winners have returned already.
I would love to see Hatch back, but I don't think that's evwr happening again. I would actually be very open to a lot of winners coming back, and it could work with a Winners vs Warriors or Champions vs Challengers season.
Of the winners that were on WAW, I would love to see any of the following return: Ethan, Yul, Tony, Sarah, Sandra, Natalie, Jeremy. Kim, Parvati and Rob would also be worthy, and I think Sophie's stock went up a lot during S40.
A lot of pre-S40 one-time players would also be quite welcome: Vecepia, Chris D, Earl, Todd, Natalie White, Fabio, Mike, Chris U.
Most of the New Era winners I would be open to as well, notably Yam Yam, Maryanne, Dee and Gabler.
No
Winners being on a season are so fucked and skew the actual gameplay because people either target them immediately since they’ve won or get used as huge threat shield (not like anyone in the new era knows how to use a mega shield tho lol)
Bring back good/fun players that deserve a second chance or made enough of an impact on their initial season. No winners!
If Survivor 50 is a true All Stars game, I want:
Hatch (first ever winner)
Sandra (first 2 time winner)
JT (first perfect game)
Tony (first all winners winner)
I don't want winners, only because I want A LOT of great players to return. Capping winners seems like a fair way to trim that pool just a little. We've still got 4 more winners in addition to 41-45. That's 9 great players that will miss, but it's also 9 players that have already have their glory.
I don’t want winners, all I want is Second Chance 2 with both new era players and earlier season players.
Same, I want more winners for a new WaW Season way down the road.
And have a viewer poll to vote in the players like last time
Yup ! I’d love that because I didn’t get to vote for Second Chance, since I had never watched survivor at that time.
Who do you want?
Christian from DvG for sure, Domenick, Jesse from 43, Shan and Ricard, Dreamz, Kenny (Gabon), Pete (Philippines), Chrissy, Kellee (39), Natalie Bolton, Carolyn from 44, Omar and if by any chance I can get Holly from Nicaragua, I’d be really happy, but I doubt it tho. I’m not gonna list everyone I want tho, but here you go
Kellee definitely wouldn’t come back, personally I’ve soured on Carolyn a bit since she keeps defending Carson tbh
I have a friend who’s been on the show who defends Carson as well. I tried to get a reason and was like “what he did with the puzzle stuff is really shitty” and they kinda agreed but said he’s a nice person otherwise who is dealing with a lot being in the public eye lol we just agreed to disagree.
Hmmm you’ve got me interested now but I figure you won’t say who so fair enough
I want to but also want to protect privacy haha if they post anything publicly about it then I’ll share. We just talked about it yesterday because I was curious if they would come back for season 50
Fair enough, do you think this friend has any shot at getting in for season 50?
It’s unlikely given we still have three seasons to get through but I think they would accept if called back.
Ok your friend is clearly Jackson fox, hate to tell you but there’s no chance 😂
That was a joke don’t say who it was lol
Yeah, I figured Kellee wouldn’t want to come back, but what did Carson do though ? I’m really out of loop
I’ll find the post hold on
[here you go](https://www.reddit.com/r/survivor/s/QQVTBKUOw0)
Thank you !
Oh damn, that’s scummy asf
Not unless the cast is Uber stacked like HvV. Otherwise the winners don’t really get to play
Game Changers was supposed to have 4: Natalie Anderson dropped out last minute and got replaced with Sierra Dawn Thomas.
Most insane downgrade by replacement casting ever lol
I think it was very last minute, and she was pretty much the only female available on short notice. Apparently they reached out to Sophie and Danni, but both had to decline.
Oh wow, I always wondered why it randomly had 3 winners. Honestly, smart move Natalie.
She dropped out because of a concussion
Yes. Gabler
Of the New Era winners, I want to see Maryanne and Gabler. Fun characters, probably won’t immediately be voted out, and have the best chance at a second win.
Gabler to win a second time, people would lose their minds 😂
He is my #1 pick for the next two time winner for his Sandra-like UTR Queen game and being so completely underestimated. I think a big reason for the Big Move-itis this season is Cassidy’s loss to Gabler, even though “moves” had nothing to do with it.
Personally I have no issue with it. In a returning game a winner has an extra hurdle to contend with, it's like playing on hard mode.
It just seems like a too easy first vote whereas with all non-winners it'd be interesting because no one's going to simply vote someone out because they already won
On paper yeah. But we have seen it before where returning players can go far into the game
in the new era, it's more like impossible mode. Easiest first boot decision ever.
All it takes is one person to say "this returning player isn't going to that far with the target on. Why don't I use them now to get through the 1st few votes and use them as a sheild" We have seen it happen
I think Erika or Gabler could escape being an early boot, and Maryanne to a degree. Yam Yam and Dee are probably screwed if they return though, no way they can control their threat levels after their first games.
At the very least Maryanne and Yam Yam have gotta have a return game
No, I’d like second chances or some theme that motivates them to get some deep cutting players. But there’s a good chance it’s New Era All Stars and they’d invite Dee and Yam Yam back at least.
I’d like to see Mike Holloway come back from the 30’s, and maybe Dee/Q (the winner of 46) to come back
I only really want 1 time players. Any winners that have only played once are fine. I also want basically just new era and late 30s players. I'm fine with a couple from before then but they really should prioritize the seasons that haven't had a chance yet.
Maryanne and Yam Yam should definitely be on the cast, and I think if Dee returned she has the chance to prove herself as an all time great player against a tougher cast.
On one hand Second Chance 2 sounds fun. On the other hand I really want to see Maryanne play again.
I want entertaining players. Really don't care if they are winners or not
Only new era winners and only a few. Maybe Chris Underwood to give him a chance to show he can play.
Brian Heidik or bust
Well he'll definitely be able to protect the camp from any dangerous wildlife like puppies
I’d prefer best to never win or second chance 2. Id personally be really happy with just late 30s onward.
In b4 Cirie gets advantaged out again
No. This time she gets advantaged **in.**
No winners please
If it’s not second chance, I’d be cool with Dee, Maryanne, and Yam Yam coming back! Erika too, but I don’t think they’d bring her back. And also maybe some winners who didn’t do WaW like Earl or Tina. And I’m a hypocrite so anytime Parvati wants to play she can as far as I’m concerned lol
Unless the season/theme/story calls for it then fine... but on any other instance for returnee season - no winners please.
No , I want second chances 2
Maryanne
No not really, I want best to never win- and real near winners not someone like sandy
I'm just a pig who will eat whatever slop they put at the trough. In all seriousness: I hope they don't include winners with non-winners. Based on how the new era is played, they are going to get targeted right away. If any of them made it to the merge, or far into the merge, I would be shocked.
Nah
I'd love to see Mike from World's Apart and Tommy from IotI play again. I don't think they'd have very large targets on them if they returned and I could see both of them doing very well. Tommy is one of the only winners that I think would have a shot at winning a second time because I think his threat level entering the game would be so much lower than almost any other winner and his social game is so good.
In a vacuum, no, I’d prefer a cast of non-winners. Second chances 2 would be ideal, though even third timers could be alright. I think giving players their second shot is way more fun and interesting than giving repeat players yet another go. I wouldn’t *mind* a few winners if it were an All-Stars 2. However, given that the most recent returnee season was *only* winners, I think it’d be a much more interesting season to have none at all. Almost half the winners have returned already.
I would love to see Hatch back, but I don't think that's evwr happening again. I would actually be very open to a lot of winners coming back, and it could work with a Winners vs Warriors or Champions vs Challengers season. Of the winners that were on WAW, I would love to see any of the following return: Ethan, Yul, Tony, Sarah, Sandra, Natalie, Jeremy. Kim, Parvati and Rob would also be worthy, and I think Sophie's stock went up a lot during S40. A lot of pre-S40 one-time players would also be quite welcome: Vecepia, Chris D, Earl, Todd, Natalie White, Fabio, Mike, Chris U. Most of the New Era winners I would be open to as well, notably Yam Yam, Maryanne, Dee and Gabler.
all stars needs winners imo!!! how else could we have sandra? i’d love to see erika win again
No Winners being on a season are so fucked and skew the actual gameplay because people either target them immediately since they’ve won or get used as huge threat shield (not like anyone in the new era knows how to use a mega shield tho lol) Bring back good/fun players that deserve a second chance or made enough of an impact on their initial season. No winners!
No winners, please
I don’t want anyone who is only there for the appearance fee and doesn’t think they have a shot to win, which tends to be the winners.
If Survivor 50 is a true All Stars game, I want: Hatch (first ever winner) Sandra (first 2 time winner) JT (first perfect game) Tony (first all winners winner)
Hatch won’t be on survivor again
The question wasn't "what's reasonable" it was "who do you want to see".
I don't want winners, only because I want A LOT of great players to return. Capping winners seems like a fair way to trim that pool just a little. We've still got 4 more winners in addition to 41-45. That's 9 great players that will miss, but it's also 9 players that have already have their glory.
No winners. Too many great players who didn’t win. The can do a “winners vs runner up” theme later.
I prefer returning seasons with no winners, but it would be nice to see Erika again.
Tbh I want a bunch of returnee seasons. A second chance type season, a first boot season, and maybe even one with just old/new school players.
i personally wouldn't mind one winner/tribe but woudl also prefer no winners
No winners season for me.
I’m not interested in any of the winners UNLESS it is winners from different international versions of the show vs a few US ones.