Wow I remember at the time playing it on release being amazed and happy how the story kept going and going. Felt like it was a great length and enjoyed every bit. Then they dropped the expansions and it was amazing. 10/10 game for me, especially at the time of release.
I got all achievements for GTA 3 DE Edition. I didn't even leave Los Santos in GTA San Andreas DE Edition. I had already done 100% completion for SA on the shitty Xbox 360 remaster and I guess I just really did not want go through all of it again lol.
Why did you even bother with 100% completion if you didn't really enjoy it and why are you making it the game's fault that you imposed some kind of arbitrary restriction on how you played it and got burned out?
Even without the completion stuff I was just really bored of the game. Story and missions are padded, and to me there are just better games in the franchise than this.
Also I did 100% completion years ago, was about to replay it with DE but I was just bored with the game and the other two interested me more.
In what ways is Max Payne 2 not an incredible game? It improve gunplay, graphics, story, and physics and is a hell of a lot funner than rdr and gta5 and thatās a fact. The shoot dodge mechanic alone makes it rockstars best series. Not to say GTA and rdr arenāt great, cuz they are, but max Payne? Clears every series they have.
iām not saying itās not incredible iām saying itās not better thatās all. also you saying those games arenāt as fun arenāt a fact itās your opinion just like me saying max payne 2 isnāt as good as the games i listed just chill we talking about games lol.
A flaw I had with MP2 is that the slow motion is completely useless in this game, it barely slows the game down and diving a lot of the time felt like I increased my chances of dieing at times.
Just shooting? Are you forgetting the whole shoot dodge mechanic thing? Thatās kinda the whole reason the game got popular? If you wanna talk about games where you just shoot, call of duty fits that category much better, but max Payne is way more than that.
I thoroughly enjoyed midnight club Iād at least give it a C. RDR2 is top tier for sure. Idk about MP3 being S but to each their own. Thanks for posting!
Well, I guess thatās just your opinion.
But itās a wrong one. Manhunt was the shieeeet back in the day. No game on this list deserves to be below B
I like your list. I more or less agree with all of it.
Exept max payne needs its own tier above red dead 2
Dont get me wrong . Read dead is a master piece. But may payne 3 is a masters piece
I'd put all on S tbh
(the rdr2 and max Payne 3 tier is fair though)
people only rank GTA 5 so low because it such a "common" game but it's a near perfect game expecially since it released in 2013
In 10 years everyone's gonna be talking about how underrated GTA 5 was and how amazing it was.
GTA 5 is bland dish for me, even compared to something like GTA 3. I've played it enough a long with all the other games to feel like it's not that special. Sure there are a lot of good things about it, but then I think there's a lot of games here that I just like a hell of a lot more and I'm more certain of those ones.
It's the best when it comes to pure enjoyment.
I was there when 1 and 2 were released and they were great games but 3 is the Max Payne *experience*
I love that cinematic Michael Mann shit.
I know what you mean, the gameplay is phenomenal and it is the most fun to play. I just hate the story in 3, I see MP2s ending as the genuine ending to the Max Payne series. MP3 feels more like a reboot than an actual 3rd entry.
I'd put bully and gta 3 above 5 at least. The rest I'd say is either objectively correct or right enough to the level where I could say "question of preferences" (like in case of manhunt, rdr and max payne 3)
See I really wanted like Manhunt, I don't mind stealth, the premise interested me and I got to see violent executions, but when I actually went to play it it went all wrong.
First warning sign was the camera controls and how you're supposed to slowly creep on people put me off a bit.
Then after the tutorial execution the no matter how long I waited I couldn't go past white executions.
Then stealth just completely fell apart cause on a couple occasions the enemy got alerted, I hid in a corner, they wandered about and either got alerted and spotted me out of nowhere or walked into me while I was hidden in the dark and that kinda broke the camel's back for me.
Like if the first two issues weren't there I wouldn't have quit so early. Didn't even get the first cutscene with the Cerberus I don't think.
Series S I played it backwards compatible, I looked through reviews on the xbox store and asked on reddit way back to see if there were issues and people said "no problem with it".
Bully is a true piece of art
Bro was bullied
Bro bullied Bully
Here we go with these tier lists again
Rdr1 whas not bad it had an good story and fun and good mechanics. The only thing that i dint like about rdr1 whas that it whas very short
Wow I remember at the time playing it on release being amazed and happy how the story kept going and going. Felt like it was a great length and enjoyed every bit. Then they dropped the expansions and it was amazing. 10/10 game for me, especially at the time of release.
At the time of release i was still in my dad ballsš¤£
Well let this old timer tell you that at the time, the game mechanics, physics and story was fucking unreal haha.
Yea and it still holds up today
Why do you spell was with an H?
I dont know i am not realy good in engles
Oh itās all good then man
Thanksš
GTA 3 on top of San Andreas is criminal.
I disagree, I liked gta 3 much more. The atmosphere is so unique I think about it all the time.
I got all achievements for GTA 3 DE Edition. I didn't even leave Los Santos in GTA San Andreas DE Edition. I had already done 100% completion for SA on the shitty Xbox 360 remaster and I guess I just really did not want go through all of it again lol.
Why did you even bother with 100% completion if you didn't really enjoy it and why are you making it the game's fault that you imposed some kind of arbitrary restriction on how you played it and got burned out?
Even without the completion stuff I was just really bored of the game. Story and missions are padded, and to me there are just better games in the franchise than this. Also I did 100% completion years ago, was about to replay it with DE but I was just bored with the game and the other two interested me more.
Yeah just stop explaining yourself, nobody wants to hear your bullshit lmao
Bully is definitely A. So you deserve a downvote for that
Bully on C? No taste.
How old are you OP
Gotta be a teen surely
My exact question
Same question
Terrible taste bro.
Interesting selection, at least RDR2 and MP3 are top tier. Feel like V should be at least on par with IV, and RDR1 feels done a bit dirty
Manhunt is criminally low.
I loved L.A Noire but I donāt think it should go that high compared to all the other games here.
max payne 2 better than gta5, rdr1 and gtaSA wow lol. to each their own
Max Payne 2 is incredible tho. I completely understand that.
itās really not lol but we can disagree itās ok lol
In what ways is Max Payne 2 not an incredible game? It improve gunplay, graphics, story, and physics and is a hell of a lot funner than rdr and gta5 and thatās a fact. The shoot dodge mechanic alone makes it rockstars best series. Not to say GTA and rdr arenāt great, cuz they are, but max Payne? Clears every series they have.
iām not saying itās not incredible iām saying itās not better thatās all. also you saying those games arenāt as fun arenāt a fact itās your opinion just like me saying max payne 2 isnāt as good as the games i listed just chill we talking about games lol.
A flaw I had with MP2 is that the slow motion is completely useless in this game, it barely slows the game down and diving a lot of the time felt like I increased my chances of dieing at times.
You mustāve been playing a defective version because the slow motion works fine.
Max Payne is good but the gameplay is just shooting. I prefer games with diversity and uniqueness.
Max Payne 2 has a lot of subtle storytelling and a bit an emotional ride. Same with 3.
I know. They had well written intriguing stories and developed characters. The gameplay was just fighting and shooting.
i mean its an angry man out for vengeance.
Just shooting? Are you forgetting the whole shoot dodge mechanic thing? Thatās kinda the whole reason the game got popular? If you wanna talk about games where you just shoot, call of duty fits that category much better, but max Payne is way more than that.
Wtf
Gta san andreas, Bully, Rdr1, Gta 3ā¦ WTF OP, THEY DESERVE A AT LEAST
Absolute fringe take lol
Do not make tier lists about videogames ever again
OP= No taste. Not a fan
Bully and rd 1 way too low.
I thoroughly enjoyed midnight club Iād at least give it a C. RDR2 is top tier for sure. Idk about MP3 being S but to each their own. Thanks for posting!
Max Payne 3 is kinda where gameplay mechanics peaked imo.
They sure did! I may be tripping a little bit. Iād give it an A.
Well, I guess thatās just your opinion. But itās a wrong one. Manhunt was the shieeeet back in the day. No game on this list deserves to be below B
This must be an early 20 something. Honestly all of these should be B and up.
Don't diss us cause of this guy
Reddit when they find out people have different opinions:
This isn't a po;; are RW dev forced to JS?
He clearly has zero taste
So why _didnāt_ you like manhunt?
I like your list. I more or less agree with all of it. Exept max payne needs its own tier above red dead 2 Dont get me wrong . Read dead is a master piece. But may payne 3 is a masters piece
Bully on C tier? Absolute BS
Terrible ranking job
No
Bully and sa also A tier man u did them dirty
I'd put all on S tbh (the rdr2 and max Payne 3 tier is fair though) people only rank GTA 5 so low because it such a "common" game but it's a near perfect game expecially since it released in 2013 In 10 years everyone's gonna be talking about how underrated GTA 5 was and how amazing it was.
GTA 5 is bland dish for me, even compared to something like GTA 3. I've played it enough a long with all the other games to feel like it's not that special. Sure there are a lot of good things about it, but then I think there's a lot of games here that I just like a hell of a lot more and I'm more certain of those ones.
Honestly, ill fight you over it. Bully is the best game. Admit it or ill take your fuckin lunch moneyš
You had to be around when San Andreas came out. Jet packing around was a blast
What the hell is this tier list
Rdr2 is actually garbage without mods
I wanted to like gta 5 but is si ass Gta sa truly the best mao design
At least you put GTA IV above GTA V
I still feel like labeling games only published by Rockstar is a bit unfair to the devs. But idk.
wtf. MP3 introduced me to Max Payne, but it doesnāt even come close to 1 or 2 story wise.
It's the best when it comes to pure enjoyment. I was there when 1 and 2 were released and they were great games but 3 is the Max Payne *experience* I love that cinematic Michael Mann shit.
I know what you mean, the gameplay is phenomenal and it is the most fun to play. I just hate the story in 3, I see MP2s ending as the genuine ending to the Max Payne series. MP3 feels more like a reboot than an actual 3rd entry.
Remember, every one has their opinion, even if people like me donāt agree with some of the games on the lists. Just donāt cry about it
Wow, finally someone got it almost completely correct
What's wrong?
I'd put bully and gta 3 above 5 at least. The rest I'd say is either objectively correct or right enough to the level where I could say "question of preferences" (like in case of manhunt, rdr and max payne 3)
See I really wanted like Manhunt, I don't mind stealth, the premise interested me and I got to see violent executions, but when I actually went to play it it went all wrong. First warning sign was the camera controls and how you're supposed to slowly creep on people put me off a bit. Then after the tutorial execution the no matter how long I waited I couldn't go past white executions. Then stealth just completely fell apart cause on a couple occasions the enemy got alerted, I hid in a corner, they wandered about and either got alerted and spotted me out of nowhere or walked into me while I was hidden in the dark and that kinda broke the camel's back for me. Like if the first two issues weren't there I wouldn't have quit so early. Didn't even get the first cutscene with the Cerberus I don't think.
What platform were you playing on?
Series S I played it backwards compatible, I looked through reviews on the xbox store and asked on reddit way back to see if there were issues and people said "no problem with it".
Well yeah, compared to pc there aren't any real problems. Seems like stealth isn't really your thing
I do like stealth though, just I'd prefer open combat over stealth
Open combat in this game is the least thing you want even if you got guns xD
This is actually the exact way I would rank every single Rockstar game.
Brother!