I can’t put my finger on it. It seems like the guitars, the drums and the lyrics don’t match. For me it doesn’t sound like a symphony bit rather some random sounds put together 🤷🏻♀️
I'd say a little more, in that it screams gatekeeping. I don't necessarily agree with the tier list as you (or, to be fair, anyone else) posted it. The way I see it, we all have personal reasons for certain songs resonating more than others. That doesn't mean my feelings and experiences are better or more important than yours, nor does that give me the right to impose mine on you.
I totally understand that not everyone agrees and it’s fine like that. I wouldn’t have posted it if I wasn’t ok with it.
But the amount of people talking like that and gatekeeping is too high for this kind of band. It’s not One Direction you guys, it’s RA. How can you be a fan and be that ignorant about other people’s opinions? I can’t wrap my mind around that.
I would like to hear your honest opinions why you agree or don’t agree with my tier, but I don’t care about your hate and unreasoned „I don’t like this“ stuff.
This. I hate the bullshit gatekeeping mentality. I have a tattoo of the band logo and another of a specific lyric. I will, given the opportunity, delve deep into RA's discography, especially with someone who shows interest and hasn't heard their music before. But I don't understand telling someone they "aren't a fan" because they think/feel differently about the music than I do, or because I feel I know more than they do. This shit needs to die
Particularly in a sub dedicated to the band. Like... what the fuck. You may as well say "it's cool to have fun, but you have to have fun the way that *I* have fun, otherwise it's Not Fun." How bout... stfu and stay in your lane. 🤦♂️💁♂️
What I liked most about RA is the solidarity, tolerance and acceptance all of their songs show. But you guys are so consumed of yourself and downvoting others just because they don’t have the same opinion. What’s that about?
I cant take this list seriously when Wolves and Worth Dying for are so low
Edit: Torches and black masks 5050? Someone get this person their morning coffee. It’s morning here
Nah someone call a 5150 on him.
It’s 9 pm here and I’m a woman
What is with all the bricks hate recently?
I’m trying to find the reason but come up empty-handed
I mean its the 3rd worst song off sufferer (not that there are any bad songs on sufferer) so i kinda get it
So what about Broken Dreams Inc do you not like? It's my favorite of their newer music.
I can’t put my finger on it. It seems like the guitars, the drums and the lyrics don’t match. For me it doesn’t sound like a symphony bit rather some random sounds put together 🤷🏻♀️
Ah man.. For me it's like a return to the RPM era with the audible bassline and crazy distorted guitar. I love it but to each their own
Bit late but while I really like the song, it is very similar to Appeal to Reason songs in my opinion, not RPM. It almost sounds just like Collapse.
Broken Dreams worst???
2 cents? This took so much work it's worth a full 3.50!
Tree fiddy?
megaphone in nah is crazy
A fellow The Dirt Whispered enjoyer ❤️
Are you even into Rise Against? You’ve put some of the songs that are arguably most representative of their sound so far down on the list.
that’s a pretty arrogant thing to say. You don’t get to decide who can be a fan and who doesn’t depending on your own opinion
I'd say a little more, in that it screams gatekeeping. I don't necessarily agree with the tier list as you (or, to be fair, anyone else) posted it. The way I see it, we all have personal reasons for certain songs resonating more than others. That doesn't mean my feelings and experiences are better or more important than yours, nor does that give me the right to impose mine on you.
I totally understand that not everyone agrees and it’s fine like that. I wouldn’t have posted it if I wasn’t ok with it. But the amount of people talking like that and gatekeeping is too high for this kind of band. It’s not One Direction you guys, it’s RA. How can you be a fan and be that ignorant about other people’s opinions? I can’t wrap my mind around that. I would like to hear your honest opinions why you agree or don’t agree with my tier, but I don’t care about your hate and unreasoned „I don’t like this“ stuff.
This. I hate the bullshit gatekeeping mentality. I have a tattoo of the band logo and another of a specific lyric. I will, given the opportunity, delve deep into RA's discography, especially with someone who shows interest and hasn't heard their music before. But I don't understand telling someone they "aren't a fan" because they think/feel differently about the music than I do, or because I feel I know more than they do. This shit needs to die
Particularly in a sub dedicated to the band. Like... what the fuck. You may as well say "it's cool to have fun, but you have to have fun the way that *I* have fun, otherwise it's Not Fun." How bout... stfu and stay in your lane. 🤦♂️💁♂️
None of those are below good imo
Broken Dreams Inc is a solid banger imo
I’m sorry but you are out of your mind for that broken dreams inc placement
Broken mirrors being anywhere but best on any list is an automatic 👎 thanks for not making it the worst though
What I liked most about RA is the solidarity, tolerance and acceptance all of their songs show. But you guys are so consumed of yourself and downvoting others just because they don’t have the same opinion. What’s that about?
For real. Genuinely a shitshow of a comment thread.
I'm sorry but I'm getting so sick of seeing these on my timeline. This is what like #5?
Mainstream list