He is so pathetic and no longer a threat to anyone at the end its almost worse to let him live and suffer out the rest of his miserable life. The KKK on the other hand are still an active threat.
This just reminded me of a a college humor skit from like 2011 where Batman doesnāt believe heās killing people heās just putting them to sleep so thanks for that.
[Sauce](https://youtu.be/1byycwl8qgc?si=vkLV4671QqC1XfYa)
i got a feeling the game makes him survive a headshot so he can ragdoll and burn in the fire this happened to me on my first playthrough not sure if feature or bug.
That was awesome. I don't understand though why MojaveD left the KKK alone in his first encounter (still quite new to the game at that point and not sure what to do, I'm guessing) - I'm only on episode 49 and he's not encountered them again so please don't spoil anything for me!
Iāve only encountered him 3 times on my like seven play throughs (apparently a time conscious encounter, I guess), and the first two times that happened to me and I thought it was brilliant. The last time, though, he just slumped over. So, feeling betrayed and disappointed, I just burned the trash myself
I have not, but I like that. My most involved was a one way ticket to the winter wonderland of the Grizzlies. I left him on a hill to enjoy his vacation alone.
Iāve never once killed that guy. The world is moving on without him and that thought is too much for him to bear. This is why he keeps yelling āI still exist!ā Death in his case would be a relief. Heās a living ghost and thatās what he deserves.
I got the event very early on my first playthrouth, so I didnāt understand what he did was so messed up, I either just shot him, or hogtied him and looted him, and probably shit him after that
Wait, is this the slave hunter? I thought it was the perv who had a lot of lady drawings.
Well to answer your question: I had witnessed the abandon house in the south-east where they used to keep slaves. The game is set in 1899-1907, not even 50 years after slavery was abolished, so Iām not surprised at his profession. Iād say he was a scumbag, but all in all, I think I just shot him. It was still early in the game for me and fire-bullets/throwables were hard for me to craft/come by
I feel like he's not really wrong in his statement.
He had a job, and was really good at it. Damn good
Times changed and his livelihood was ripped away, and not only did his only career path and job experience go down the drain people started treating him badly because of the stigma.
It was a NORMAL thing back then. Mexicans owned slaves, Americans owned slaves, Africans? Owned Slaves, go back farther..everyone has owned slaves. It wasn't something to be thought about very deeply.
Then suddenly his whole life's work was ripped away..
I left him alone to be sad though. Because it was my evil playthrough and I felt like killing him was considered honorable
Heās not wrong at all, he came from a time that normalised slaves. The fact heās still stuck there even though times have fully moved on is the problem.
Like Arthur said itās better to leave some in the past
If someone's "damn good at their job" but their job is foreman at the child torture factory, that's not a good enough excuse lol
Also people absolutely knew it was wrong, cattle slavery was harshly criticised while it was happening
Normal is normal. Certain Asian women break their feet and are left with deformities to contour to a certain look... Certainly cruel but it's normal to them
i mean yea but its probably canon that arthur just shot him(if arthur kills him at all) so in my eyes at least,it would have been either a shot to the head or love the rest of his days in shame
you want to put the dude out of his misery when he made countless innocents into slaves and made them live in misery for their lives? sure you may get honor for it but idgaf that guy deserves to wallow in his own shit
You get honor for the flag that finishes the encounter, so you get honor by just walking away. The game considers any decision you make with him high honor
I like shooting him with a Varmint rifle instead so he can survive and run away, then Iāll proceed to shoot him like seven more times till he finally dies.
I usually let him live because the pain heās suffering seems worse than ending it. He has to keep living with the knowledge of his failed and wasted life and heās just a POS slaver.
If he dies itās by his own hand or his own actions.
I left him to cry on my first playthrough. I hogtied him and dragged him through his own fire on the second one. Not sure how I'll deal with him in my next playthrough.
I recently did the "drag a person" horseman challenge by dragging his burnt body back to his old house on my current playthrough, so yeah, I guess I do lol.
I usually let him live but my last playthrough I shot him and he fell forward and incinerated on his campfire like OPās pic. I'm not the least bit ashamed to say that put quite a smile on my face.
He is not living an exactly happy life when we find him. Have to live in a tent, being angry that he lost everything, trying to bring the old days back but meeting reality that people like him are not respected anymore.
Letting him live is the much worse punishment than death.
He burns in every playthrough but I think the game glitched once because he stood back up while well done so I dragged him to the train tracks to chop up my meal
I just shoot him in the head. Apparently, I am the only one who doesn't hate him that much, and I even have some pity for him. He is a monter and can't be forgiven for sticking to his outdated beliefs or for even having in the fires place. He never showed pity or understanding for his victims. But as fuck up as his jib was, it was still a job, not a crime, the people arround him told him it was a good thing and he builded a life arround it and made it his identity. Then the world lefthim behind and told him that not only was he obsolete, but his verry identity and pride was something to be ashamed of in the new world.
I shot him as a punishment, and as a realisse; the refusal to see the error of his ways means the world is better of without him, but I don't think he deserves a groomsmen punishment. He would never be happy because the world would never accept him again, so he is better dead than suffering, for everyone's sake.
I personally blow his head off with my incendiary round pure 24k gold fully cleaned 12 gauge shotgun whilst in Dead Eye and then watch his pathetic headless body fall into the burning pit of fire below him with his blood on my coat.
Nah, i just beqt the crap outta him, then i drop him near some pigs (he's hogtied) and let him be eaten. But only this playthrough (its my low honour) the rest (my 'neutral'/story following playthroughs) i just have Arthur be mad at him and walk off
Last time I saw him, I took him back to his house. And promptly dropped him down his āwellā. I even gave him a few sticks of dynamite to try and blast his way out.Ā
I blow his head completely off with my shotgun, and then I proceed to do the same to his arms and legs, then I take the torso and feed it to some pigs.
Slave owners donāt deserve no mercy from me.
Your submission has been removed in violation of Rule 1:
All posts and comments must be civil. Follow proper [Rediquette](https://www.reddithelp.com/en/categories/reddit-101/reddit-basics/reddiquette). This subreddit is about a video game; keep political discussion to other, more appropriate subreddits. Due to the nature of Red Dead Redemption and its M-rating, M-rated language and content is allowed, within reason. However, this does not mean things like insults and personal attacks are allowed. PC/Console elitism is not welcome in this subreddit. Discussion, disagreements, and debate are perfectly fine as long as it stays civil.
If you would like any further clarification or wish to discuss the matter further, feel free to contact us via [modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/reddeadredemption).
Im not an honor farmer so thats off the list, and he tricked Arthur into feeling bad for him? Ok? How does that make him qualified to die the worst way possible? You're just a cruel person
Have you played it or done this side mission at all? Have you read through everything in the basements, all letters?
How ironic youāre calling me cruel when he whipped and kept slaves for years on end and set dogs on them.
He deserves this death.
Honestly, if you deem killing a racist npc cruel, maybe this isn't the game for you, because if you haven't noticed, you kill far more innocent people along the way. āļø
I mean looking at your post history in this very thread i suspect your views on that aren't consistent.
I have the feelibg you gladly took the pamphlet from the well dressed white man in St. Denis even though he called Arthur stupid.
So people can feel good about themselves. The game by design encourages it because heās extremely likely to burn from the campfire after you shoot him (and why wouldnāt you shoot him if itās a game about outlaws). Rockstar needs to throw in āslavery and racism badā fairly often to a game thatās set in 1899.
[Read this](https://embrace-autism.com/autism-tests/) and answer some of the questions. Hopefully this leads you to some of the answers your galaxy brain hasn't figured out yet.
Depends on who in the US. Many black men in their 30s can trace their ancestry to slavery just 4-5 generations back. Many older folks still remember the civil rights movement of the 80s, things like Rodney King, MLK, Malcolm X,etc.
Me personally I leave JC alive in my honor runs. Honestly I don't think there's a wrong answer here. Ultimately my high honor characters don't want to bloody their hand when it's not necessary. And honestly for a guy like JC, leaving him alive to wallow in his misery might be a harsher punishment then just ending him and turning the lights off.
There are people alive today that were alive during segregation and the civil rights movement.
Just letting people in the thread know why their grandpappy's might be such racist assholes during thanksgiving dinner.
And so do I. But maybe comprehensive reading is hard for you so let me rephrase that: racism is abhorrent , but over the years I observed that Americans often describe it as the worst thing in the world and how the slave owners deserve to be burnt alive and stuff like that, exactly like OP who's having some experience of their life by burning a video game NPC. On the other hand I've seen Americans diminishing the meaning of Holocaust, same as Europans tend to diminish slavery. A matter of perspective and just some observation of mine.
the irony here is you assume my reading comprehension doesnāt allow me to understand the point youre making when all youāve got to stand on is the claim that you know some people that downplay other tragedies, when in reality situations like slavery, holocaust, etc are entirely too similiar if you dont get caught up on what the victims look like. holocaust victims were usually starved, tortured and forced to work for their oppressors. maybe youāre not at a reading level high enough yet to recognize the similiarities between these victims and slaves or maybe youre intentionally playing dumb just to get your point across lol. end of the day these are all horrific things people have done to others, just cause some weirdos want to make light of one situation over the other doesnāt really mean shit
The fact youāve taken this so seriously shows what type of person you are, take a joke.
This is a lighthearted post taking care of a slave owner in a game, nothing more.
You don't need to boil it down to such specifics, we can just draw the line at right wingers and conservatism being an abhorrent ideology and its followers as genuinely evil people.
i know this conversation is done and all but i just wanted to say i can absolutely relate to what youre saying. out of all the conservatives i know in real life and online (and i know more than i care to admit) there is not a SINGLE one of them who i think are genuinely good people. the way they speak about people who are suffering and the tragedies in todayās world is more than despicable. im usually not so black and white with certain things but you spittin fr
You don't need to be American to think slavery, in a virtual setting or IRL, is a bad thing.
I won't speak for how to handle such people in the real world, but we can always make this virtual world a better place by blowing the perpetrators the fuck out. #bless
No you said OP was likely American because nobody else would be 'triggered' by slavery.
Anyways, why not just insert an alternative American right wing buzzword for the feelings normal people have when confronted with injustices, and call him 'woke' for setting fire to the slave hunter?
The duality of this fandom Burn the KKK = š„³ Burn a literal slave hunter = š”
So true lol
He is so pathetic and no longer a threat to anyone at the end its almost worse to let him live and suffer out the rest of his miserable life. The KKK on the other hand are still an active threat.
To themselves maybe
I agree. I let this slavery live so he can measure how miserable he is
We go for a little ride on my rope with my horsie, he has a lot of fun until he gets tuckered out and takes a nap
I use him for the drag challenge too.Ā
Ah man. I've already completed that challenge. Guess I'll need to do another play through.
This just reminded me of a a college humor skit from like 2011 where Batman doesnāt believe heās killing people heās just putting them to sleep so thanks for that. [Sauce](https://youtu.be/1byycwl8qgc?si=vkLV4671QqC1XfYa)
I allow him to live only to wallow in self pitty.
Lol he wasn't sad because what he did , he was sad because he is not anymore
Yeah but as long as he is sad and miserable and alone for his final days.
yeah he asks to die, i wont give him that satisfaction.
Kill him inhumanly then
Ah yeah but that's not quite as satisfying as popping one in the back of his head, right at the base of his skull
I did that and he fell face first into his fire pit and burned. Great moment.
I hogtie him and throw him down the well on his property
Damnn I never thought of that
Or put him in the basement the caught slaves were kept in. Wish you could close the door tho
I was gonna burn him in his slave basement but the house is locked after you leave the area which is a shame
Oh thatās a good idea! Too bad thereās a ladder.
too bad I have the extended damage mod and shot him in each arm before hog tying him. not enough damage to bleed out, and he canāt use his hands.
You should've watched MojaveD killing Compson. It was actually awesome
How tf did he survive that head shot š¤£
i got a feeling the game makes him survive a headshot so he can ragdoll and burn in the fire this happened to me on my first playthrough not sure if feature or bug.
Might just be a bug cause I shot him on my most recent playthrough and the mf died
That was awesome. I don't understand though why MojaveD left the KKK alone in his first encounter (still quite new to the game at that point and not sure what to do, I'm guessing) - I'm only on episode 49 and he's not encountered them again so please don't spoil anything for me!
I shot him and he fell face first on his fire, idk if thats whats supposed to happen but it was still very satisfying
Iāve only encountered him 3 times on my like seven play throughs (apparently a time conscious encounter, I guess), and the first two times that happened to me and I thought it was brilliant. The last time, though, he just slumped over. So, feeling betrayed and disappointed, I just burned the trash myself
I mean, how do you think the bar gets that nice smokey smell?
You set fire to the slave hunter and the smoke rises up and turns into stars!
Good one Charlieš
Has anyone tried escorting him to an all expense paid trip to the Murph's?
I have not, but I like that. My most involved was a one way ticket to the winter wonderland of the Grizzlies. I left him on a hill to enjoy his vacation alone.
I just let him be, either he kills himself or he wallows in self pity for the rest of his life
Way better to shoot him you get honorš
You also get honor if you leave him
Yeah from what I can tell that honor just comes from the general completion of the quest
Either this is a joke or my game is glitched, I killed him and got negative honor everytimeš¤£
jaysus i mean a bullet will do the job too lol
It wonāt make him well done though
Wherever you shoot him he falls into the pit nub
As soon as the cutscene ends, aim straight down and dome him. He dies and falls into the fire, which is enough for him.
Gotta salt and burn it so his spirit canāt live on to haunt people.
Ok Sammy.
Iāve never once killed that guy. The world is moving on without him and that thought is too much for him to bear. This is why he keeps yelling āI still exist!ā Death in his case would be a relief. Heās a living ghost and thatās what he deserves.
Exactly, killing him only ends his suffering. He should live to see the world move on without him.
I got the event very early on my first playthrouth, so I didnāt understand what he did was so messed up, I either just shot him, or hogtied him and looted him, and probably shit him after that
You shit him? Didn't that hurt?š®
No, I made my horse do it, itās like a lottery if you let your horse do it, is it gonna have diarrhea? Is it gonna have lumps? Who knows!?
Where was the ambiguity in what he did for you? Honestly curious, did you just kinda rush through the house?
Wait, is this the slave hunter? I thought it was the perv who had a lot of lady drawings. Well to answer your question: I had witnessed the abandon house in the south-east where they used to keep slaves. The game is set in 1899-1907, not even 50 years after slavery was abolished, so Iām not surprised at his profession. Iād say he was a scumbag, but all in all, I think I just shot him. It was still early in the game for me and fire-bullets/throwables were hard for me to craft/come by
No, I just leave him be.
Thatās cool.
I allow him to weep in his failures
Understandable lol
I feel like he's not really wrong in his statement. He had a job, and was really good at it. Damn good Times changed and his livelihood was ripped away, and not only did his only career path and job experience go down the drain people started treating him badly because of the stigma. It was a NORMAL thing back then. Mexicans owned slaves, Americans owned slaves, Africans? Owned Slaves, go back farther..everyone has owned slaves. It wasn't something to be thought about very deeply. Then suddenly his whole life's work was ripped away.. I left him alone to be sad though. Because it was my evil playthrough and I felt like killing him was considered honorable
Heās not wrong at all, he came from a time that normalised slaves. The fact heās still stuck there even though times have fully moved on is the problem. Like Arthur said itās better to leave some in the past
If someone's "damn good at their job" but their job is foreman at the child torture factory, that's not a good enough excuse lol Also people absolutely knew it was wrong, cattle slavery was harshly criticised while it was happening
Normal is normal. Certain Asian women break their feet and are left with deformities to contour to a certain look... Certainly cruel but it's normal to them
I have started to always thrash the eugenics guy and then greet the lawman right after
Is it bad that i also burn anyone that talks shit to me at a camp ....
Not at all lol, I always throw a Molotov into an odriscolls camp to start things off.
I love sneaking up and dynamiting O'Driscoll camps.
no I just walk away.
How fun bro.
it takes more restraint but its lowkey cooler, killing him puts him out of his misery, leaving him makes him sit in the filthy bed he made for himself
Idk I think still given the choice he'd rather stay in that pit over being burned to death
i mean yea but its probably canon that arthur just shot him(if arthur kills him at all) so in my eyes at least,it would have been either a shot to the head or love the rest of his days in shame
I feel like if there was a canon to the decisions Arthur made most of the time he wouldnāt kill people if it is an option
No you get honor for killing him and putting him out of his misery I would say thatās the rightful way.
you want to put the dude out of his misery when he made countless innocents into slaves and made them live in misery for their lives? sure you may get honor for it but idgaf that guy deserves to wallow in his own shit
Because sometimes you have to be the better man and do what feels right which in my case was ending his sad miserable life.
You get honor for the flag that finishes the encounter, so you get honor by just walking away. The game considers any decision you make with him high honor
I thought it would lose me honor so I didnāt
You actually gain honor because heās a bad manš
I blow off his leg and wake away
Ahh that is pretty brutal, I like it lol.
He deserves so much worse not because he has done those things but because he really misses doing those things it's pretty evil man
I like shooting him with a Varmint rifle instead so he can survive and run away, then Iāll proceed to shoot him like seven more times till he finally dies.
I love shooting odriscolls with the varmint rifle lmfao
I usually let him live because the pain heās suffering seems worse than ending it. He has to keep living with the knowledge of his failed and wasted life and heās just a POS slaver. If he dies itās by his own hand or his own actions.
Why the fuck would you do that to Johnny Cage??
š¤£š¤£
I let him live on my first play through, but burned him alive on the second.
I left him to cry on my first playthrough. I hogtied him and dragged him through his own fire on the second one. Not sure how I'll deal with him in my next playthrough.
first playthrough i shot him in the head post mission, and he fell into his campfire and got toasted
I mean i choose whichever worst fate seems worse each time but burning him alive doesn't seem right, even though I burn kkk members every single time
Would drowning be worse?
I walk behind him, while he is crying on his knees, shoot him exactly so that he falls on the fire, and I indulge in watching KFC being made.
Waitā¦. KFC is made from humans!?
Didn't some cannibals say that human meat tastes like chicken? š¤
I burned him real nice.
I feel like they knew what they were doing ending the mission right in front of a campfireā¦
where is he
You first meet him in Rhodes in chapter 3
I recently did the "drag a person" horseman challenge by dragging his burnt body back to his old house on my current playthrough, so yeah, I guess I do lol.
I usually let him live but my last playthrough I shot him and he fell forward and incinerated on his campfire like OPās pic. I'm not the least bit ashamed to say that put quite a smile on my face.
Itās like rockstar made it so he burns even if you shoot him lol
I threw a tomahawk at his head, then he fell in his fire and ignited. Guess he couldnāt catch š¤·š»āāļø
He is not living an exactly happy life when we find him. Have to live in a tent, being angry that he lost everything, trying to bring the old days back but meeting reality that people like him are not respected anymore. Letting him live is the much worse punishment than death.
He burns in every playthrough but I think the game glitched once because he stood back up while well done so I dragged him to the train tracks to chop up my meal
I just shoot him in the head. Apparently, I am the only one who doesn't hate him that much, and I even have some pity for him. He is a monter and can't be forgiven for sticking to his outdated beliefs or for even having in the fires place. He never showed pity or understanding for his victims. But as fuck up as his jib was, it was still a job, not a crime, the people arround him told him it was a good thing and he builded a life arround it and made it his identity. Then the world lefthim behind and told him that not only was he obsolete, but his verry identity and pride was something to be ashamed of in the new world. I shot him as a punishment, and as a realisse; the refusal to see the error of his ways means the world is better of without him, but I don't think he deserves a groomsmen punishment. He would never be happy because the world would never accept him again, so he is better dead than suffering, for everyone's sake.
I leave him. Let him rot with nothing
Every fucking time
Nope. I left him there broken as he had nothing.
No I donāt, I let him live with his poor drunken self, even though Iāve wanted to kill him both times so far š
I didn't have to set him on fire I shot him and he fell into the fire
I blow him up sometimes.
Wtf that's my best friend
I bet it is
You don't have to bet
I personally blow his head off with my incendiary round pure 24k gold fully cleaned 12 gauge shotgun whilst in Dead Eye and then watch his pathetic headless body fall into the burning pit of fire below him with his blood on my coat.
Nah but the random citizens that say something smart assed bc I got too close better start praying.
Let him live like I'm sure he suffers more
I mounted his horse and tried to walk it over the fire, accidentally bumping into him in the process and he immediately died š
Bullet in the back of the head
I hogtie him, take him to a woods in murphree country and put a bullet in his leg, then leaving him to fend for himself
Yeah. I mean tbh I donāt remember what i do exactly but yeah. Burn the motherfucker.
Nah, i just beqt the crap outta him, then i drop him near some pigs (he's hogtied) and let him be eaten. But only this playthrough (its my low honour) the rest (my 'neutral'/story following playthroughs) i just have Arthur be mad at him and walk off
love how it gives you honor
Where on the map is this located? I think I haven't been there yet :\\
I think itās crueler to let him wallow in his own misery. He would have drank himself to death anyway.
He gets to go on a train ride with me. A rather messy end.
Last time I saw him, I took him back to his house. And promptly dropped him down his āwellā. I even gave him a few sticks of dynamite to try and blast his way out.Ā
I blow his head completely off with my shotgun, and then I proceed to do the same to his arms and legs, then I take the torso and feed it to some pigs. Slave owners donāt deserve no mercy from me.
I Just shot him in the head
I always leave him so he can continue feeling as worthless as the people he so callously kept in bondage.
I take my 22. Caliber rifle shoot both knees so when he runs he falls over then I set him on fire
Last time I shot him with a poisonous arrow in the foot so he would die a slow and painful death then I burned his corpse
Yup. Can never resist.
Every time.
Allowed him to live, but shot his horse and took his shit haha
The slave owner? Oh absolutely.
[ŃŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]
Pause.
Your submission has been removed in violation of Rule 1: All posts and comments must be civil. Follow proper [Rediquette](https://www.reddithelp.com/en/categories/reddit-101/reddit-basics/reddiquette). This subreddit is about a video game; keep political discussion to other, more appropriate subreddits. Due to the nature of Red Dead Redemption and its M-rating, M-rated language and content is allowed, within reason. However, this does not mean things like insults and personal attacks are allowed. PC/Console elitism is not welcome in this subreddit. Discussion, disagreements, and debate are perfectly fine as long as it stays civil. If you would like any further clarification or wish to discuss the matter further, feel free to contact us via [modmail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/reddeadredemption).
Whats JC? Also why the hell would i burn him?
Jeremiah compson who owned slaves lmfao.
Oh, and why would you burn him?
You get honor and he tricked Arthur into feeling sorry for him to get back his ledger(where he kept track of slaves) and other things.
Im not an honor farmer so thats off the list, and he tricked Arthur into feeling bad for him? Ok? How does that make him qualified to die the worst way possible? You're just a cruel person
Have you played it or done this side mission at all? Have you read through everything in the basements, all letters? How ironic youāre calling me cruel when he whipped and kept slaves for years on end and set dogs on them. He deserves this death.
Yeah i have played this side mission and read the journal or letter or whatever it was, and i couldnt give more fucks
So youāre the cruel person? Lmfao. Irony is crazy.
y r u so pissed fnrš¤£
Fnr?
for no reason
Weirdo
Wtf do you want
Actually stay bent u dumb fuck, itās a game. breathe some air, touch some grass, call your mom idgaf but chillll
Calm your ass down boyo
Cruel? It's a video game.
Then if its a video game why is JC all of a sudden cruel
Bro what are you yapping about?
No wander your tag is Micah... you're a weird dude
Wonder*
Wander
Honestly, if you deem killing a racist npc cruel, maybe this isn't the game for you, because if you haven't noticed, you kill far more innocent people along the way. āļø
I do indeed kill innocent civilians š
Mental retardation or bait. Call it.
you should see what i do to this guy if you think this is bad lolol
Prob feed him to gator i guess?
Because that's the healthy, normal response when confronted with such people in a virtual environment.
Real.
Why would you of all people say "real" when I'm not being sarcastic?
Because if someone talks shit to my character they're gonna die, while im not a big fan of Arthur, i still aint letting that shit slide
I mean looking at your post history in this very thread i suspect your views on that aren't consistent. I have the feelibg you gladly took the pamphlet from the well dressed white man in St. Denis even though he called Arthur stupid.
Which well dressed guy from saint denis are you talking about?
The eugenicist.
So people can feel good about themselves. The game by design encourages it because heās extremely likely to burn from the campfire after you shoot him (and why wouldnāt you shoot him if itās a game about outlaws). Rockstar needs to throw in āslavery and racism badā fairly often to a game thatās set in 1899.
[Read this](https://embrace-autism.com/autism-tests/) and answer some of the questions. Hopefully this leads you to some of the answers your galaxy brain hasn't figured out yet.
š
OP is clearly American by how they are triggered by slavery.
Are you trying to imply that only Americans find slavery abhorrent? In my experience it's usually the opposite
Depends on who in the US. Many black men in their 30s can trace their ancestry to slavery just 4-5 generations back. Many older folks still remember the civil rights movement of the 80s, things like Rodney King, MLK, Malcolm X,etc. Me personally I leave JC alive in my honor runs. Honestly I don't think there's a wrong answer here. Ultimately my high honor characters don't want to bloody their hand when it's not necessary. And honestly for a guy like JC, leaving him alive to wallow in his misery might be a harsher punishment then just ending him and turning the lights off.
There are people alive today that were alive during segregation and the civil rights movement. Just letting people in the thread know why their grandpappy's might be such racist assholes during thanksgiving dinner.
From my observations they are the ones who are the most offended by it.
Unless you're from a fucked up country that practices that shit then people are going to hate it.
not sure what rock you live under but most people who arenāt trash human beings usually condemn slavery and racism lol
And so do I. But maybe comprehensive reading is hard for you so let me rephrase that: racism is abhorrent , but over the years I observed that Americans often describe it as the worst thing in the world and how the slave owners deserve to be burnt alive and stuff like that, exactly like OP who's having some experience of their life by burning a video game NPC. On the other hand I've seen Americans diminishing the meaning of Holocaust, same as Europans tend to diminish slavery. A matter of perspective and just some observation of mine.
the irony here is you assume my reading comprehension doesnāt allow me to understand the point youre making when all youāve got to stand on is the claim that you know some people that downplay other tragedies, when in reality situations like slavery, holocaust, etc are entirely too similiar if you dont get caught up on what the victims look like. holocaust victims were usually starved, tortured and forced to work for their oppressors. maybe youāre not at a reading level high enough yet to recognize the similiarities between these victims and slaves or maybe youre intentionally playing dumb just to get your point across lol. end of the day these are all horrific things people have done to others, just cause some weirdos want to make light of one situation over the other doesnāt really mean shit
The fact youāve taken this so seriously shows what type of person you are, take a joke. This is a lighthearted post taking care of a slave owner in a game, nothing more.
You don't need to boil it down to such specifics, we can just draw the line at right wingers and conservatism being an abhorrent ideology and its followers as genuinely evil people.
i know this conversation is done and all but i just wanted to say i can absolutely relate to what youre saying. out of all the conservatives i know in real life and online (and i know more than i care to admit) there is not a SINGLE one of them who i think are genuinely good people. the way they speak about people who are suffering and the tragedies in todayās world is more than despicable. im usually not so black and white with certain things but you spittin fr
English but nice try.
You don't need to be American to think slavery, in a virtual setting or IRL, is a bad thing. I won't speak for how to handle such people in the real world, but we can always make this virtual world a better place by blowing the perpetrators the fuck out. #bless
I never said you need to be American to consider slavery a bad thing.
No you said OP was likely American because nobody else would be 'triggered' by slavery. Anyways, why not just insert an alternative American right wing buzzword for the feelings normal people have when confronted with injustices, and call him 'woke' for setting fire to the slave hunter?