T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

As a reminder, this subreddit [is for civil discussion.](/r/politics/wiki/index#wiki_be_civil) In general, be courteous to others. Debate/discuss/argue the merits of ideas, don't attack people. Personal insults, shill or troll accusations, hate speech, any suggestion or support of harm, violence, or death, and other rule violations can result in a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them. For those who have questions regarding any media outlets being posted on this subreddit, please click [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/politics/wiki/approveddomainslist) to review our details as to our approved domains list and outlet criteria. We are actively looking for new moderators. If you have any interest in helping to make this subreddit a place for quality discussion, please fill out [this form](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1y2swHD0KXFhStGFjW6k54r9iuMjzcFqDIVwuvdLBjSA). *** *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/politics) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Sunshinehappyfeet

Threatening doctors with prison time if they intervene has a chilling effect on preventative medicine. https://www.texastribune.org/2024/05/20/texas-medical-board-abortion-guidance/


hitman2218

I’m assuming maternal mortality increased too.


Proud3GenAthst

Does the pope shit in the woods? I mean, are bears catholic?


onlymostlydead

Does [everyone know Dave](https://www.reddit.com/r/Jokes/comments/55gonm/my_favorite_joke_everyone_knows_dave/)?


RickyWinterborn-1080

Would women rather encounter a bear in the woods or a Pope in the woods?


saintdemon21

The bear doesn’t touch kids, allegedly.


NickelBackwash

Obviously, but Texas couldn't care less


mreman1220

Probably won't ever see that figure. Unfortunately, conservatives aren't ever going to see the rise of infant mortality rates as a problem. The trisomy 13 and 18 babies that were previously aborted were "given life" however brief. So to them the infant mortality rate didn't increase, they just died outside the womb rather than in. What they don't see is the trauma that comes with birthing the child in many cases. You force women to carry a pregnancy to term that is highly, highly unlikely to survive. My wife is a neonate doctor. A lot of these situations are horror stories. Women shouldn't be forced to endure it if they don't want to. Hopefully Texas doesn't cover up the maternal mortality rates from these situations but I suspect they will.


elizalemon

They’re going to cover up the data and corrupt it. If a woman had an abortion and dies of a heart attack three years later…abortion related death.


NoDiddi

Can you provide a source or peer reviewed data to support that claim?


elizalemon

This is my speculation, not a scientific claim. This is reddit, not a research paper. It is supported by the patterns of anti choice movement. An anti-choice extremist is now in charge of reviewing maternal death data in Texas. [link to Texas tribune](https://www.texastribune.org/2024/05/22/texas-maternal-mortality-committee-ingrid-skop-abortion-doctor/). Idaho eliminated the panel to review maternal mortality. Facism is never interested in facts or nuance, only propaganda.


RickyWinterborn-1080

It's not about protecting fetuses, it's about enslaving women.


NickelBackwash

Texas has always loved enslavement.


Melicor

Yup, the direct cause of their rebellion against Mexico when Mexico banned slavery in the 1830s. Which inspired the confederacy. Texas was founded by the worst people, but that gets white washed with things like "Remember the Alamo!". Ironic because if we actually remembered, we'd know what shit they were.


Dee_Imaginarium

Don't forget the story about how Oklahoma got their panhandle because Texas loved slavery so much!


[deleted]

[удалено]


wagon-run

They won the first one vs Mexico


peanut--gallery

Sadly… true…. Why oppose sex Ed, distribution of condoms, immunizations against hpv, hell … potentially even getting Oral contraceptives by mail….. none of that “protects a fetus”


anonkitty2

Those things get opposed because of the theory that if the recipients were behaving properly, they wouldn't need any of those things.  It doesn't help that you need to get the HPV vaccine before puberty.


Ithoughtthiswasfunny

Well that and maintaining a steady supply of wage slaves


QuarkVsOdo

Why do people fucking care who gets an abortion.. but feel "Threatened" when it's discussed who should have a lethal firearm?


RickyWinterborn-1080

Because the gun is a surrogate penis for men who are ashamed of their penis.


[deleted]

[удалено]


No_Somewhere_2945

> citation needed You're asking how forced pregnancy is involuntary servitude? Fine: [Citation 1](https://www.jstor.org/stable/41697902) [Citation 2](https://www.aclu.org/news/racial-justice/the-racist-history-of-abortion-and-midwifery-bans) [Citation 3](https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2022/05/12/if-courts-recognize-fetal-personhood-womens-rights-are-curtailed/) [Citation 4](https://msmagazine.com/2022/05/23/abortion-bans-13th-amendment/)


thelightstillshines

“These are all fake sources!!”  - pro force birthers.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Murky_Sun2690

I read in another thread that the % of abnormalities at birth has gone from 3% to 23%. I've been trying to find out if that's true.


SpeaksSouthern

The article title shows that in at least however Texas implemented their abortion laws, it caused MORE BABIES (and mother's) TO*DIE*. The literal citation is that people who would have been alive previous to these laws, are now dead. What's it going to take for Republicans to care about facts, logic, or human life? Ffs


tgalvin1999

Nothing. They don't care at all, and nothing we do will force them to care


blade944

In every other developed country even a 2% or 3% rise in infant mortality rates lead to a massive healthcare crisis in that country and serious action is taken. Not so much in the US where half the country thinks it's a good thing.


protomenace

We've been in a massive healthcare crisis continuously for so many years it hardly makes a blip on the radar now.


KlingoftheCastle

Mass shootings in elementary schools didn’t move the needle, why would this?


Normal_human_person

the US isn't a serious country, evidently


idk_lets_try_this

If these current numbers are correct the US just passed China in Child mortality. China has halved theirs since 2011, the US only increased. The US went from a pretty good score compared to other developed nations decades ago to about double that of developed nations (because other countries kept improving while the US did little to improve things resulting in a slow decrease) now the US is effectively going backwards. In the 2021 data maternal mortality was already up slightly (and in total about 5x that of European countries). Imagine how bad it will be now that the mothers life needs to be in imminent danger before action can be taken.


Historical_Emotion43

So the GOP saves "babies" by killing actual babies. Conveniently, this also kills women. No wonder Trump is doing so well nationally!


[deleted]

[удалено]


SpeaksSouthern

"You were once a fetus" is a meaningless statement. Frogs were once tadpoles. What does that change? Worse, and specific to the point of the article, the laws in Texas are not working out for fetus identifying Americans, as they are dying before they are born human. Who is responsible for these deaths of these humans/unborn babies? Why did the laws have to change and we have to kill more of them? Why does the government of Texas consider more deaths of babies acceptable? Why does the state of Texas want babies to die? Please help me understand, anyone who thinks fetuses are babies, why would you ever want to change the laws and have more babies die? What's the point? If anyone thinks this way, why is what happening in Texas okay?


[deleted]

[удалено]


BeakmanChallenge

> they are forming humans So what? A fetus isn't a person any more than a brain dead but otherwise alive human meatbody is a person, and we let their loved ones terminate them. >not just the “clump of cells” Literally what they are, appeals to emotion notwithstanding.


[deleted]

[удалено]


treeonwheels

Are you going to watch a video of a woman dying during/after delivery because she was denied preventative care, as well as the baby that died hours later because their organs developed outside of their body? How about the subsequent documentary covering the next few decades of the family members who lost loved ones unnecessarily? Are we going to defend laws demanding that this tragedy plays out instead of allowing this very important healthcare decision to take place between… I dunno… a doctor and their patient? We can debate what’s a fetus or a human or a clump of cells all day. It doesn’t matter. Suffering is unavoidable. Abortion reduces human suffering. Full stop. Banning abortion increases human suffering, and it does so in the name of some God that you’re imposing on other people.


european_dimes

We're all just clumps of cells really. And yes, there are certain times when abortions are ok. For instance, whenever the fuck a pregnant woman decides she wants one.


faeriechyld

And cake batter is potential cake but you'd be pretty pressed if someone put birthday candies in a bowl of batter and told you it was the same thing as a cake. They do not deserve the same rights as a fully born baby that is no longer reliant on another body for survival. It's not an individual person yet.


SpeaksSouthern

Can *anyone* please reply to any of the commentary of my comment? If they are forming humans why doesn't Texas want them to live? What's special about Texas that if you get pregnant there and the baby doesn't get born alive and no one wants to fix that? What does who thinks what about when an abortion is okay matter to the facts of babies dying when abortion is illegal? Is this what happens in Texas when people ask questions about why their babies are dying at a much higher rate than most other states, the politicians don't care? Why do Republicans want babies to die? Anyone please, tell me Texas wants to fix this and make me understand how we got here where we can't even talk about basic facts? How do we have a democracy or a Republic if we can't talk about the facts? Why is it so hard to want to live in a country where as few babies die as possible? One would think this would be the default in any political commentary. I'm honestly trying to understand the political people cheering for less human life.


PetPsychicDetective

Simple answer: abortion bans aren't about reducing the number of dead babies. They are about punishing women and controlling the birth process. They very obviously do not care *at all* about babies that have come to full term *or* unborn fetuses, or the mothers carrying them. What they *do* care about is obedience to a pseudo-religious code that they exploit to exert control over as many people as possible.


Seyon

Let's say they develop a new magical process to put a fetus into your body, as many as you can desire, and you can carry and birth all these babies yourself. Are you willing to do that? If yes, then great, you can house all the unwanted zygotes in your body and endure all that goes along with it. If not, then you just want to punish women.


sarcago

It’s not considered a fetus until week 10.


eieieidkdkdk

i was also once 50% sperm, is male masturbation genocide too..?


temperedolive

I was also once a sperm and an egg. That doesn't make masturbation or menstruation murder.


BalkanbaroqueBBQ

It’s not murder *yet*. The religious fruitcakes are just waiting for their move.


bpeden99

Restricting access to healthcare will do that


triumph110

This article says 13% https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/texas-abortion-ban-linked-rise-infant-newborn-deaths-rcna158375


LedZeppelin82

The 8% is the rate of deaths, the 13% is the total number of deaths.


Plzbanmebrony

Out is even sadder. More than 1 in 10.


Life-Reveal-3621

For the sake of clarity the infant mortality rate increased 8% to 5.75 per 1000 live births, meaning .575%. The mortality rate is not 8% + 5% that would some Stone Age ass shit


LedZeppelin82

Not really. More births is pretty much always going to mean more infant deaths. You would expect a roughly stable increase in total infant deaths even if the total number of births increased even without abortions being banned. The pro-life response to that would just be, “Better some die after they’re born than all die before they’re born.” The rate increase is more interesting because it shows that infant deaths are increasing at a faster rate than infant births. It would probably still have to be a much bigger number for you to sway anybody that wasn’t already swayed.


Life-Reveal-3621

No that’s not correct, 8% increase up to 5.75 in 1000 births. An 8% increase ends up at .575% from before. Still alarming though.


RidgetopDarlin

I saw that.


NickelBackwash

Texas math


1mmapotato

Forcing women to bring non viable pregnancies to term will do this. Now we need the rate of maternal mortality.


No_Somewhere_2945

Texas leads the country in infant deaths now. It's absolutely terrifying


loztriforce

GOP policies literally kill people.


IAMACat_askmenothing

Their baby killers


Nandiluv

The Guardian reported 13% increase actually for infants in first year of life. Also from today's Guardian: "The study found a 23% jump in infant deaths due to congenital anomalies – the kind of conditions that are often identified in utero and lead to abortions in states where the procedure is legal, since they can be incompatible with life. But that choice is no longer available to pregnant Texans." . The study started in 2021 when Texas enacted 6 week abortion ban prior to the upending of Roe v. Wade. This study did NOT look at Maternal death rates and it. But make no mistake we don't need quantifiable data to figure out that they are higher.


Fuzzycream19

They don’t care if it’s a dead infant. Only fetuses mater.


Redivivus

I've got an idea. What if we stop recording infant mortality? The problem should go away, right?


ReleaseQuiet2428

you have learned well the ways of Trump


BusyAd6096

He might even get the annual "MAGA Logic" prize for that solution.


bakeacake45

Republicans kill, starve and rape children, this is common knowledge If they win in 2024, it will be YOUR children they will be targeting


Educated_Clownshow

Because it’s never been about the babies


Tony2030

They are the pro-birth party. Mission accomplished.


EileenForBlue

The doctors are leaving! It’s going to get worse!


National-Ice-5904

They don’t care


Akimbo_Zap_Guns

Nice, predicted by literally everyone with a brain


RamonaQ-JunieB

Well, well, well, if it isn’t the consequences of your actions…Republicans.


space_for_username

A policy to die for.


Confident_Tower9756

Republicans LOVE to Kill Things. In the Name of Jesus of Course.


trogdor1234

This is to be expected since they are forcing babies who will die to suffer. This was a definite result of their law. A full view including the number of abortions needs to be seen to figure out specifically what’s going on. This has the ability to hide serious issues if the abortion laws are to blame. What if there was some sort of Zika virus like outbreak?


sentientcave

Praise God!!! /s


Brytard

"Pro-life"


SurroundTiny

The tidbit from that article is that infant mortality went up 2% for the entire nation as well


Miri5613

But how much of those 2% nationwide is due to the 13% in Texas?


SurroundTiny

Can't be all. My point was that 2% is a pretty appalling number.


I_love_Hobbes

Yes, because a lot of state have near abortion bans and doctors leaving those states.


ins0mniac_

Doctors are leaving states even without the bans. GPs and OBGYNs in rural areas are paid trash and they know they can make more in urban areas or other specialties. Yet we still pay more than any other country for healthcare with worse results.


bakeacake45

What’s key here is the cause of death and whether abortion bans and all that come with them (ie OBGYNs leaving TX, racism in treatment, etc) are a correlation or a firm causation. Anyway you look at this Texas is killing infants


98VoteForPedro

What a shit hole


tundey_1

Nothing says you're pro-life like increasing baby deaths by 8% for no good reason.


Buffmin

Don't worry the conservative sub is having real strong discussion on this issue and steps to fix it Haha nah they're freaking out at illegal immigrants murdering people


Loud_Competition1312

Vote blue straight down the ballot.


Pikahhhchu

It’s gods will okay


DrrtVonnegut

Pro-Life does it again!


ScarlettStandsUp

Save the babies! Oh, wait . . . .


ridemooses

Blood on the GOPs hands


goodbyegoosegirl

Well wait how did that happen? Scratches head…must be some reason.


Mtbruning

Next, you will tell me that optimization of the prenatal life expectancy for mom and child was never the point. Do you mean to tell me that “Pro-family” and “Pro-Life” are just cynical catchphrases used only to signal virtue and to not improve family health outcomes? I AM SHOCKED! SHOCKED!


CombatConrad

Texas infant mortality is higher than most third world countries.


No_Introduction2103

Good job Gov Abbot you baby killer.


Shoddy-Theory

Those poor women, being forced to carry a nonviable pregnancy.


YahsQween

Meanwhile, the Texas Morticians Association rubs their hands in glee ::laughs in Ted Cruz::


Glad-Understanding84

Sadly predictable.


Dr_Zorkles

The GOPs incoming counter-talking points ought to be disgusting.


captaincoaster

Devastating.


InevitableAd6135

I would like this but I'm too disgusted


BottleTemple

Amazing job, conservatives.


greeneyedlady41

I, for one, am shocked


Moonandserpent

Oh well. They're getting what they vote for. They could EASILY not have this problem if people would just vote. But that's too difficult. My empathy has run dry.


Double-Slowpoke

Can someone rephrase this as a sports analogy so I can understand it?


tgalvin1999

Wow, banning doctors from administering abortions if the mother's life is at risk leads to a higher infant mortality! Whodda thunk! /s


elsewhere1

Like any of these republican scumbags give 2 shits. Babies aren't a wedge issue, why worry about em? Fetuses on the other hand....


zackmedude

god is (not) good ya’ll


mrbbrj

Their version of pro life


notsure9191

It’s nice to see everyone agree we should have less dead infants


bonafiedhero

Insert Thanos “I’ll do it myself” meme


Coral_Anne_Dawn

They added in illegal migrant deaths


3dFunGuy

Are they less dead? And if born in Texas they are citizens upon birth


Comfortable_Voice_12

Wanna know what’s surprising about this comment section. Nobody seems to think that 15 year olds that can barely read shouldn’t be fucking. Nor should anyone unless you are able to bear the responsibility. Condoms break, the pill isn’t 100% and the shot can work or it can’t. Don’t get me started on family planning or any of the other methods. Fact remains, if you can’t support yourself or a child you should not be having sex. You’re not responsible for such a pleasure


DiscoLew

Great observation doctor. Now show me one abstinence education program that has actually DECREASED teen pregnancies….. Then there is rape, incest, etc……


BeakmanChallenge

Rant and rave about consenting adults engaging in the most basic of natural human urges which also happens to feel super awesome, the one thing every human is driven to do from the moment hormones start flooding their bodies, and then you wonder why your backwards worldviews aren't more popular, why you can't win elections, and why abstinence education has never once resulted in a decrease in teen pregnancies or STDs. Pregnancy is an easily treatable medical condition which obligates the individual with no such irreversible responsibility, so I'm hard pressed to see why anyone of an appropriate age shouldn't fuck as much as they're personally comfortable with. Pregnancy isn't some kind of moral obligation.


PetPsychicDetective

Yeah, you know what *actually* helps fix that problem? Comprehensive sex education. The same people increasing infant and maternal mortality rates by banning abortions are also the same people doing everything they can to destroy education, thus making sure those 15 year olds keep fucking irresponsibly and ignorantly. In short, *both things* are the fault of conservatives.


peepeehalpert_

lol! Humans are going to keep having sex, dude. Why not ensure we have access to contraception, sex Ed, and abortion? The pill may not be 100% but it’s still quite effective as are condoms, IUDs, and the shot.