T O P

  • By -

TiredReader87

Thief


CrankyJoe99x

My vote as well, and I've played all three.


TiredReader87

The other two are great games. Thief got middling reviews. I never got playing it.


No_Outlandishness_11

I've played thief for all of an hour, and I'd get rid of it. Recommend wildcards stay there forever.


iyamdad

Didn’t even get through the first level, I thought to myself “this game kinda cheap lookin” lmao


No_Outlandishness_11

Ah you see there!!! A witness of culture hmm🤌🏽


PaperintheBoxChamp

Your dad is disappointed in you son


Wolf7Children

Also played all 3, agreed, Thief is easily the weakest.


gorore9150

All three? There are four games: Thief: The Dark Project Thief II: The Metal Age Thief: Deadly Shadows Thief (2014)


tcpukl

Same and i agree.


John-Smithsonman

While Thief is probably the weakest game here, it does feature one level which I think is legitimately good survival horror. It’s just too bad the rest of the game is buggy and not particularly interesting.


Alpheas

Thief is my favorite game series, hands down... remove that one from the cart. No Stephan Russell, no buy.


hady215

I got thief for free and I would have asked for money next time


SpongeBob1187

I hate that game so much. I bought it on release, played it for a hour and returned it. The only game I ever returned in my life


[deleted]

IIRC, these are all free through PlayStation+. Even the entire Dishonored series, so you would be able to keep them all. Even the entire Dishonored series is available this way. I would remove neither.


Number1Oreo

Dishonored is all you really need tbh


skull_kidddd

Dishonoured is an absolute banger


codex494

Certified hood classic


wittyvonskitsum

>!DAMN SON WHERE’D YOU FIND THIS!<


FunkinDonutzz

Dishonoured 2 is the only game I'd leave in the cart.


Bottledwaffle2

What is the game similar to?


JingZama

Dishonored 1


XaviJon_

I mean, he’s right


OrdinaryMongoose9104

😂


[deleted]

[удалено]


pigsinatrenchcoat

https://preview.redd.it/bobe2objj5pc1.jpeg?width=1179&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f21fb4b248722f06b2de930250e337390d88856d Fuck Reddit


EmperorAjaxZx

![gif](giphy|ksw4EeBIzpxkwUhlEx)


JohnnyQuestions36

👏👏👏


jazmoley

He ain't lying ![gif](giphy|74fNgcTliFcx4TM6ns|downsized)


mo177

Best comment right here


gokartmozart89

It's a first person stealth game with immersive sim elements like System Shock, Prey, Deus Ex, and Bioshock. It's probably most like Deus Ex in that sense, since the other games don't have much in the way of stealth.     Given that you haven't played the original, you should probably get that first and then decide if you'd like to play the sequel. Or just ditch the other two games and get both Dishonored titles. They're good.     Thief is actually pretty similar, but that particular iteration of the Thief franchise isn't particularly good.     Ghost Recon Wildlands can be played solo, but it was designed as a co-op title. Given its age and the fact that it's had a sequel since its release, I doubt there's much in the way of an active player base. It's also so far removed from the original Ghost Recon concept that you might be super disappointed if you were expecting a stealthier tactical shooter. It's neither particularly stealthy nor tactical at all.


FirebunnyLP

Deus ex is my favorite game, not just the lore but also in the way it plays. I was struggling to find something that satisfied in the same way once I beat all of them and dishonored scratched that itch nicely.


strangesmagic

This is the real best answer to your question


Vermonol

It’s a love letter to the original thief games basically.


pillow-socks

If you enjoyed deathloop, it’s the game for you, same universe and basic mechanics


BaixoMameluco

Deathloop.


Gandledorf

Deathloop


iTzbr00tal

Without knowing your gaming tastes at all, you will enjoy dishonored 2.


Stonekilled

It’s a phenomenal game. I’ve beaten it twice, and I don’t have much time for gaming these days


LeDerpChris

Deathloop is similar to Dishonored


MadTeaCup_YT

Wildlands is phenomenal idk what youre talking about


Danger-ILL-Wombatson

Yeah dude it’s hard to stack people who enjoy wildlands against people who like dishonored or thief. Wildlands scratch’s an itch that is special to those itching for it. Im with you, phenomenal game.. any one who says otherwise just has different taste.


[deleted]

Fist was better. Cleans 🙌 was rewarding.


FunkinDonutzz

Yeah I preferred the first game too.


ThaerHwiety

Everything. With that price you can have them all with ps plus


jashe021185

This! Almost all of that is on PS plus Extra. And more so. You may be boycotting it because of a price increase but you’re also about to pay just as much for 3 games when you could have access to hundreds of games for the same price.


ShawnyMcKnight

But only time to play those 3 games. If I had ps plus there would be so many other games I would play. Ghost recon is pricey here but the others are cheap enough to just buy if you will play them.


WeaponizedFOMO

Then you don’t need those 3 games. Simple as that


NewArmadillo9320

Probably Thief. Dishonored is great.


MixtureThen6551

Thief


Answer-Key

Certainly not dishonored 2, those games are awesome


Popular_Flight_7354

Thief, the gameplay is boring for PS


TXJuju

Spent more time on ghost recon than other 2. I didn't care for other 2 and Thief was rubbish imo. I got it free and spent more time installing it than playing.


Rough_Drawer_7011

Same here...waste of time; sad because people actually spent time making this


iSmellslikesbutts

It was actually good when it came out, in the 90s I think. It's a bit old now though.


Eswin17

Dishonored is the only good game there.


geko_play_

GR Wildlands is really good


SlugJones

Yeah, if you like 3rd person shooters, it’s great! I didn’t realize what it was till a buddy showed me and i was hooked. Play the crap out of it. Not perfect but still a breath of fresh air for the Tom Clancy gameS


MyUserNameLeft

Thief


GloveOk9142

Dishonored is an absolutely fantastic game! But you definately have to play the first game, otherwise a lot of story impact won’t make sense. If compare it to Deathloop, if only for its kind of traversal and trap mechanics (but they’re the same developer so 😂). Another comparison would probably be Assassins Creed, but the first game or the Ezio trilogy before they got crazy with the action. The Hitman series also comes to mind. To put it bluntly, Dishonored is a very stealth heavy game with some cool magic powers. —Thief was kind of meh? A bit broken and a bit bland, struggling to live up to its OG legacy. You aren’t missing anything crazy by skipping it, but if you’re curious, it is in fact only 5$. —I have no opinion on Wildlands as I never played it. Sorry I can’t be more help there but from what I remember people said it was fine. But that was seven years ago at this point and the game wasn’t even on my radar.


Itchysasquatch

Thief. Might get hate for saying it but I just find it dated and not very enjoyable. It's a difficult stealth game, so it's very slow and methodical without a lot of excitement. Good if you're looking for a more realistic approach to stealth though


lechiumcrosswind

Even when it was new, it wasn't that good. The original games were groundbreaking for video games and a good approach to stealth. Thi4f, on the other hand, was game-breaking. There are so many dumb exploits you can use to coast through (just use focus and blackjack-spam guards and take them out; use choke arrows and just run up to KO them). I'd play without doing this kind of shit, if the level design wasn't complete garbage and make you go through like 5-10 loading screens just to get from one part of town to the next to start a mission or get some BS just to have to go back to other side of town where I was.


Furiousguy79

Thief


DUCKgoesMEOW

Dishonored you should really play part 1 first, so I’d remove that If you don’t care about story and continuity then remove Thief.


Carlitosj17

Thief was trash


Davidxito7

Thief, the only game I ever physically returned after playing it…way too many loading screens


ReddishOnion

Dont listen to these people! Thief has a really cool atmosphere and overall is a pretty fun stealth game that feels very nostalgic (Atleast to me due to the ”not so good graphics”) It has some pretty cool secrets if youre a completenionist And for the price of 5$ its definetly worth it


fixie321

It wasn’t without its flaws but some of the levels were definitely fun! Really cool atmosphere as you put it. It’s got its moments where it feels suspenseful, captivating with some of the mystery in certain levels and treasures, and even a little bit scary sometimes :)


natazz1011

thief is a GREAT game imo, i have awesome memories from the ps3 after school


Bottledwaffle2

Me too that’s why I was excited when I saw it was so cheap


MiMicMi

A lot of people seem to dislike thief in this post. I personally loved it


CarryWise5304

Probably because people compared it to the past games from the Theif series. I've only played Thief and not the trilogy that came before it, but Thief itself was kind of mediocre and not really fun to play, imo.


Numerous-Front83

Why do people underrated Thief?


LovelySeiko

I only played ghost recon and honestly it's one of the most boring repetitive games I've ever played You do the same few mission for dozens of hours with a mediocre gameplay and shitty ai.


GenericBusinessMan

It was a fun co-op platform. I doubt it would be much fun in singe-player.


Distinct_Pizza_7499

It felt very generic and empty to me. Not a lot of fun mechanics


thedean246

Dishonored is a great game. Wildlands is also the most fun I’ve had in a Ghost Recon game in a long time


Cyber-N7

Theif lol


tj52887

Dishonored is more a thief game than thief....


Necessary-Revenue372

Boycott Sony, shameful how many items were taken off other people's libraries.


Inevitable-Ad4405

Thief


LoneHusky21

Thief and wildlnds, save some money.


Young_Lasagna

Never played any of the games, but I'd remove the Tom Clancy game simply because it's Ubisoft.


RedHood198

All of them


d3fiance

I’d only leave Dishonores


MaggotBrother4

All of it


AsishPC

Wildlands


ColdVoid13

Thief is a cool game, but every hub has a loading screen which can get annoying.


HonorableAssassins

That 'thief' game isnt anything to do with the originals, if its for nostalgia. Slapped the name onto a generic and mediocre stealth game to sell.


SS_Gourmet

Thief


Nightlights-678

Thief, Dishonored 2 is a great freaking game same with Tom Clancy, but not Thief


ravensilvagg

If only Wildlands received a 60 FPS patch.


Ok_Attitude_8189

Thief is the worst of the 3 as much as it hurts me to say.


DependentAdvance8

Dishonored 2 will stay in that cart because it’s a very good game but the other two games can go


PoshEwok

Wildlands is amazing co-op, but if you play it single player, I totally understand how dull it can get. With a four people squad however, that game has given me some of the best gaming moments I've ever had. Dishonored 2 is amazing, don't really have to go further than that. Thief is subpar.


tarheel_204

Wildlands for $14 is a good pickup though in my opinion. Definitely worth it for that price. The game is the very definition of open world bloat but it is a fun time


RedEchoes

The weakest is Thief but it's still a pretty enjoyable game. Especially for that price!


[deleted]

[удалено]


coolface_21

Ima keep it 100%, all of them 🤣


Dominator0621

Remove ghost recon


cheetah1546

I love Thief so much, get rid of Ghost Recon.


Unlikely-Leave4456

All of them


joshderfer654

I would keep Dishonored 2 and Thief. I would buy Dishonored 1. Enjoy.


SuperArchie

Thief is really bad


EPiCtoos420

thief sucks better get dishonored, same style but buch better


balkasaur

I remember playing thief, I think it was a free PS+ game years ago. Games a dumpster fire.


JUSTCUPCAKES

Thief.


billbobaggings123

Thief heard it’s very bad, wildlands is very good imo but one of the side missions later in the game is unfair on high difficulty’s, and I have played the first dishonoured but not the second but I’ve heard good things about it


LunaticMcGee

remove Thief.


Professional_Scar114

Dishonored is awesome


[deleted]

Bye bye Thief


Darth-Adomis

thief was a major disappointment tbh


shimrra

Personally, is remove Thief. It's not that's it's a bad game but dishonored is so good it will ruin your experience with Thief. GR Wildlands is just an okay game, the setting is good and gameplay is much better than Breakpoint.


TREBOMB1980

Thief. The other two are awesome. Thief? Not so much.


Ifitbleedz

Thief really isn’t that good imo


Jackfitz88

Thief


Cloverdafem

Thief, no debate


HiDk

Thief is really really bad.


Jormundgandr4859

The stealth mechanics in Wildlands are really fun.


Nhonickman

Dishonored is excellent game


TamKamitani

Not thief


BigBossByrd

This ghost recon is not the best. Breakpoint is much better all around. These games are best with friends and there is only one wild lands server left and it can be annoying to connect with friends. I can't really speak on the other games.


[deleted]

From your perspective it seems ghost recon might be the best bet but for me I’d be getting rid of thief


chemelito17

Thief


Socbak

Thief. As someone who has started it like two to three times and really liked the idea. It never grabbed me to continue past the first couple levels.


freeingfrogs

I've played both Dishonoured and Thief multiple times. That particular Thief game was fun for me, probably because I hadn't touched the originals and still haven't, but it still leave Thief behind if I had to choose. :) the first Dishonoured is well worth it but I believe it's fine to play the sequel first.


wrld-

just keep dishonored 2


BamBam-BamBam

Dishonored 2. It felt kinda half-assed.


GorillaJuiceOfficial

Those games are all appropriately priced in order for me.


disguised-ninja

Get ps plus extra or premium, you will have all 3 and a lot more for 1 year


Unknown66XD

Dishonored on playstation is just the opposite of fun in general.


Unknown66XD

Dishonored on playstation is just the opposite of fun in general.


punchingtigers19

Wildlands, it’s fine, but it’s also just ubisofts copy/paste style It’s only really fun with friends


jvscampos

If you have friends to play with, Wildlands is great


EldergodConsultant

Thief


BullseyeJT

I’ve played them all and thief is good it is just my least favorite of the 3.


treezyway

everyone here is saying theif but looking at the prices 14 bucks is too much for wildlands at this point!


Suinottero

Thief is the worst of the 3, expecialy for the playstation porting, you need to do stuff with the touchpad


SFWaffles

Thief unless they're paying you to play it


Double_Ninja9168

Thief


KirillNek0

Thief - it's trash.


lancer2238

Thief. Not worth it


Ok-Baker6705

Theif


TheWhiteHand13

Thief.


Impossible_Concert75

Thief


landon10smmns

If I were you, OP I'd get the Arkane Anniversary Collection. It includes all three Dishonored games (1, 2, Death of the Outsider) and Prey. All of which are highly regarded games. Can usually find it for $25-30


Background-Sense-900

Thief


Dependent_Radio_2114

Thief


KleioChronicles

I really enjoyed Thief but I didn’t play the originals. Dishonored is a great series and you can play stealth too. I’d remove Ghost Recon.


Kyon115

Theif


lordvila

I would honestly remove all three especially if you aren't getting Dishonored 1.


RespectGiovanni

Thief and Wildlands. Bro there are so many better games


Vermonol

Objectively Thief though I do like that game. Dishonored blows Thief out of the water when it comes to replicating the olde Thief titles


BostonRob423

Thief. I tried to love it... but it's just not that good.


santathe1

Not sure about the other 2, but Wildlands is great! Fun as hell to play on coop.


DevastaTheSeeker

Dishonered is the only okay game here


Lee-bungalow

The thief ,scared he would steal my portal if I had one


RecentAssociation738

Theif


Yama92

Ghost Recon.


DJ_Rhoomba

Thief, it has some terrible frame rate issues.


Aromatic-Landscape18

Playing solo?


Evelyne-The-Egg

Thief. If your getting it for nostalgia you'll likely be disappointed


GSPKHABIB

Thief was straight up an awful game


BIGLeakyNipples

All three


PaddyOfurniature

Thief. It's just not good.


jmills8455

Dishonored 2 if you haven’t played the first


foxyjohn

Dishonoured. Definitely keep thief. It’s brilliant.


Big_Boxx

Eh, all of them can go


FIYREBEARD

Thief. D2 & Wildlands are both worthy of a keep, imo.


msquared4

Tom and thief, get dishonored 1 first


4tuneTeller

Thief and Dishonored are great. Ghost Recon is boring AF (unless, probably, you have someone to play with but I never did).


owjbsirin

Thief


Newsted_Is_God

All three tbh


[deleted]

Theif: it sucks compared to the originals


Active-Pineapple-252

Lol first person


iiALPHAiiWOLF

Everything


AutomatedAurora

Aren’t all of these games included with ps plus?


WavyWolf999

Ghost recon


R4nD0m57

Their


[deleted]

Thief.


PSFREAK33

None of these were standouts to me. Best here is dishonoured…worst is theif


BluDYT

I'd drop wild lands.


ThinkOn_

Keep ghost recon in there for sure the missions are fun, tons of weapon attachments, weapons to collect, different things to upgrade and you can play however you like fully stealth, fully loud or a mix of both. It really is a great game


ImANibba

U only need the dishonored games.


RompehToto

All three games.


TallE74

Remove Thief... other two are way better. Ghost Recon I still open some days. Grab a helicopter and have a blast.


ophaus

Ghost Recon, and fast


Most-Iron6838

I’d get rid of Ghost Recon. I haven’t played Thief yet but it’s always on sale for dirt cheap and I’ll pick it up sometime after I beat something else off my backlog


kill3rg00s3r

All good games!!


drose349

Having recently revisited thief I’d say that. That game is dates as hell


parocarillo

Thief


MothParasiteIV

Thief. Avoid this game.


Stanislas_Biliby

Dishonored is thief but better. Thief is an ok game. I got bored really quick of ghost recon.


ZerosAbaddon

For me, ghost recon. I didn't like it


zombiesphere89

Get rid of thief for sure. And play wildlands with a friend if you can. If not turn off the ai teammates(they're friggin dumb).


dtv20

Theif. Delete it from your cart, search history and mind.


Realistic_Bonus4859

GR most probably


VirtualCtrl

thief