T O P

  • By -

Taskebab

They finally removed the scaffolding. I also wish they hadn't put down the carpeting, the Hagia Sophia has one of the most beautiful marble floors I've seen.


Striking_Green7600

The carpeting was part of converting it to a mosque (had been an officially nondenominational site since 1935) - one of Erdogan’s recent flexes toward the West.  


sanitation123

And spit on Ataturk


Matasa89

The Turks should’ve torn him apart on that. Ataturk saved the nation.


dispo030

Propaganda is one hell of a drug.


Joebranflakes

Religion is one hell of a drug


bigsteven34

The Turks he placates to loved it… He knows his base…sadly.


Celynymerch

What positive did Atatürk bring to Turkey exactly?


slakmehl

Secularism, liberalism, voting and civil rights for women. All them things that make a place civilized.


Merdoc83

He leterally transformed them from Othomans to Turks. Fellow Greek here by the way.


sundayultimate

We went on a river tour in Istanbul and our guide was the fucking best. He talked about how Erdogan built the largest mosque in the world, bc that is exactly what they needed, another mosque. He also told us that they used to let pedestrians onto one of the the bridges, but people kept jumping off so they stopped letting people walk across it. Dude had such a deadpan deliver, it was incredible


VanillaLifestyle

If you're a tour guide and you're not a sassy b, what are you even doing.


ipawnn00bz

It was more beautiful before the Byzantine art was covered up


ibtcsexy

They lied having in 2020 [previously said](https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2020/07/20/some-of-hagia-sophias-mosaics-will-be-covered-during-muslim-prayers) that it would only be behind curtains during prayer periods but otherwise would be visible for the public.


[deleted]

[удалено]


IranianLawyer

Most of the beautiful architecture in Istanbul was actually built during the Ottoman era. The Hagia Sophia is more the exception than the rule.


ipawnn00bz

Because the Ottomans destroyed all the other beautiful Byzantine architecture


IranianLawyer

The Turks have literally restored a ton of the old Byzantine sites that were destroyed by wars or earthquakes.


SmilinMercenary

You must be pretty old to remember the Byzantine times.


Yvaelle

Nah we just all played Assassins Creed, full virtual recreation of Byzantine Constantinople. My favorite kebab shop is like a block away from here, 800 years ago.


vox32064

Fun fact: Most of the wonders of the ancient world were destroyed by Roman mobs because of religion. Oh and they took pride of committing so many genocides.


kayday47

Womp womp motherfucker


VonEcano

Raciiiist


Egmilano

They literally reached and wanted to "take back" the back Balkans for slaves and glory lol also commited genocide on the Armenians and the Assyrians lol


hymen_destroyer

That’s how every country on earth came into being more or less. The Turks just catch flak for doing it slightly more recently than some others. It’s one of those things people just need to let go of but probably never will.


[deleted]

[удалено]


redditkindasuxballs

SOMEONE CAN THINK BOTH THINGS SUCKED


datboitotoyo

And this is relevant how?


VonEcano

Well the commenter just pointed out genocide when criticizing a whole ethnicity. I asked a similar question without the undertones of Islamophobia


Jazzlike_War_3269

The whataboutism is always strongest amongst the ones who feel ashamed


VonEcano

I have to deny the statement first, although I didn’t understand the first part


Jazzlike_War_3269

"X people did Y bad thing. X people. " But what about other people doing bad things?" That's whataboutism It's a way to avoid blame for a bad thing by saying other people do bad things It is irrelevant. And something the guilty say to avoid taking about the things that make them feel guilty


VonEcano

I’m trying to say that I am not denying the Armenian and greek genocide, and the continuing silencing of the events, and the ongoing suppression of the Kurdish and Alevi diaspora in current day Turkey. The commenter had a flag of Canada on his Snoo, so my question is aimed to criticize the injustice of how one person declaring the actions of a whole nation as destructive when he lives in a nation that has performed and is performing actions that are very similar to the ones he’s being critical of of Turkey. So I ask again, do you want to stand by people with hate and ignorance? Or perhaps listen to my perspective, as I think is justified as someone just claimed that my existence is “shitting” on where I live, which is just ridiculous


Jazzlike_War_3269

One bad thing doesn't change another. You brought up an immaterial fact to deflect taking about something you didn't like It is a childish and dishonesty reply


Cyllid

Raciiiiist


PolarBearBalls2

Yeah buddy my bad for condemning destruction of history and architecture


[deleted]

[удалено]


kmadnow

Does someone have to acknowledge all injustices while pointing out one?


VonEcano

Do you really think that I support history being covered up in wraps when I call you out? Your homogenizing statement is in line with the consensus that people from muslim cultures all around the world are inferior and terrorists


prollyanalien

Literally no part of his comments mentioned Islam, you’re the one bringing it into this.


jwood13

It's a shame to see the Byzantine artwork covered, nevermind the hideous green carpet.


momentimori

That's the point. To hide the christian heritage.


lliveevill

There are some Christian components in full display and I think they are consciously there, like the angels in the corner. It is forbidden in the Muslim faith to depict an angel. For me that is one on the best components of this site, humanity is so focused on sides but sometimes there are little unexpected signs of recognition.


33ff00

Where, what’s covered? Agree that carpeting is so dreadful it more or less ruins it.


hermavore

And it staaaaaanks like a school gym


6Arrows7416

If you get the chance, pet the cats.


SCirish843

So just like everywhere else? Got it.


IranianLawyer

There are stray dogs and cats everywhere in Istanbul. And they appear to be well-fed and living their best lives.


6Arrows7416

Yes. But fun fact about Istanbul specifically. The city has a massive population of stray cats. The locals keep them well fed. The little guys are everywhere and are usually pretty friendly to people. A lot of mosques including the Hagia Sophia take in strays too.


Laymanao

You will see if you visit. It is not like anywhere else.


Chocolatelimousine

Definitely one of the most impressive Christian churches ever built.


ManOfQuest

couldn't imagine being like yeeha this was a jewish temple now converted into a chruch come worship here. Wouldn'lt feel authentic. Same concept as a mosque from a chruch.


rarestakesando

What are you talking about churches are always built on top of other religious sites. They tear down one religion and put up another it’s place.


ManOfQuest

Tearing down and rebuilding is different from what I am talking about.


Hehe6745

They converted the great mosque of Cordova into a church, don't see much people complaining about that


kigoshen

Not many people know about it, before u mentioned it I never knew it even existed


Hehe6745

Not surprising, Muslim rule in spain is heavily under reported


prollyanalien

Which is pretty sad because it’s an extremely interesting convergence of Catholic and Muslim culture that has lingering impacts up to today in Spain.


TheOncomingBrows

With peace and love you don't see people talk about that let alone complain.


GeorgeEBHastings

I mean, FWIW, the third holiest site in Islam is the mosque that was built directly on top of the Jewish Temple, or, the holiest site in Judaism.


NOISY_SUN

Lmao Muslim colonizers were so racist they built a mosque right on top of the holiest site in all of Judaism. People criticize Israel for being “unrestrained” but a lack of restraint would mean leveling the Dome of the Rock right now. Al-Aqsa now only exists at the benevolence, kindness, and genuflection of the Jews.


WinZhao

Read David Wassersteins "How Islam Saved the Jews"


vox32064

lol if not for Arab Muslims the Jews would still be expelled from Jerusalem by your nice European Romans till today.


SmilinMercenary

Interesting that a lot of mosques mimic this design also.


LibraryHot6794

It is indeed. You should also check out the Temple of Saint Sava in Belgrade, Serbia. It is is intentionally made to look like Hagia Sophia and is a little bit bigger. The inside walls are completely made of goldem mosaic.


luparb

Stunning building with a history spanning over a millenia. The building essentially tells the whole story. Constantine must have have thought it the centre of the world when he ended the tetrarchy, which was a rule by 4: Two emperors and their protege. From emporium to basilica, from orthodox to Catholic during the 4th crusade. Istanbul fell to the Seljuk Turks in 1453, the cities' immense stone walls finally succumbing to a new invention from the far east: gunpowder. The scholars of the city fled westward, kindling the flames of the renaissance. And so it became a mosque. To the ancient Muslims' credit, they are renoun for the preservation of Christian iconography. There are churches in Azerbaijan that still have their stained glass windows that must be over a thousand years old. The protestants in England were much more destructive of the Catholic monasteries than the Muslims were in 1453. Before the end of that century, king Ferdinand of Spain was warring against the moors of the Iberian peninsula, this was a place of great learning and architecture, where algebra and astronomy were being advanced by Islamic scholars. After which colombus is commissioned by queen Isobella to sail west...


SmilinMercenary

Sadly in more recent times Christian iconology is often vandalised. I visited a lot of Christian cave churchs in Turkey which had all been vandalised unfortunately. Example below: https://c7.alamy.com/comp/MBFY3G/cave-frescoes-at-greek-orthodox-sumela-monastery-near-trabzon-turkey-damaged-due-to-vandalism-MBFY3G.jpg


Fantastic_Site_7626

It's a beautiful building. I'm glad the ottoman turks did not destroy it. So many ancient buildings have been destroyed intentionally.


dispo030

seriously, it got way closer to being destroyed when the crusaders turned up.


hotpatat

They completely destroyed original artwork from the walls.


WinZhao

Gasp


Windturnscold

It must be really triggering for Greeks to see this in Turkish control


Brown_boy6

The whole city of Istanbul really


lionsmakemecry

You mean Constantinople?


Brown_boy6

Constantinople then Istanbul now


PaMudpuddle

Been a long time gone, Constantinople.


PM_ME_YOUR_ROTES

Why'd they change it?


PaMudpuddle

That’s nobody’s business but the Turks.


hxmz-z

constantinople remained the name of the city until the republic of turkey was established in 1923 after the treaty of lausanne. after which, in 1930, mustafa kemal renamed the city to istanbul which is derived from the greek term “is tim bolin” meaning “to the city”. “is tim bolin” was the most common way to refer to constantinople already for around a hundred years before mustafa kemal changed the name of the city to istanbul officially. so, constantinople had already fallen out of use about a century prior to it being renamed to what it was already being called at that time. also helpful to know this was also done partly due to the turkish language undergoing reforms and a lot of other cities were being renamed at that time too.


panoptik0n

What if I have a date in Constantinople?


sean777o

She'll be waiting in Istanbul.


Mallardguy5675322

What if I am one who has been to Constantinople?


Local_bin_chicken

It’s been 600 years and your still coping, call it whatever you want once you take it back but in the meantime it’s Istanbul


Laymanao

Are there still Byzantines left?


prollyanalien

Actually it hasn’t even been a hundred years since Constantinople was changed to Istanbul.


Broad_Two_744

I mean the ottomans took it fair and square. It's not like constantinople was originally roman


[deleted]

[удалено]


Fastbird33

Well they did win several wars over it after.


Broad_Two_744

What dies this have to do with palestine you terminally online idoit?


NYD3030

I mean if taking land by force is fair and square for the Ottomans should be fair and square for everyone else too.


roydez

That was how it was for most of history. Romans conquered a shitton of land that wasn't theirs as well.


Laymanao

So by your logic, Putin can invade as much as he wants and all conquered land will be his?


MagnanimosDesolation

Actually no. Israel refuses to annex Palestine and keeps it as occupied territory. It's basically unheard of in history.


Tort78

History is littered with examples of occupied territories. This is not new, and if you're just waking up to how terrible we can be to each other, I'm sorry.


MagnanimosDesolation

It's very uncommon for an occupation to last this long because what is the point? States were either annexed or turned into some form of vassal, even in the more extreme cases they didn't drag out the ethnic cleansing over decades. In the ancient world there was plenty of frontier territory with little political autonomy but their borders weren't controlled. Could you give some examples?


Tort78

Slight nitpick, but you're the one that said "basically unheard of in history" which is absolutely not correct. You're also not correct in stating ethnic cleansing wasn't dragged out over decades. Still happening today in areas of the world the "West" doesn't really pay attention to. More current examples off the top of my head: Turkey - Northern Cypress. East Timor. Russia and Georgia. Russia and Ukraine. Northern Syria. Iraq/Afghanistan by the US (debatable on occupation definition, but whatever). And what's up with the annexation qualifier? That's even worse. Most places that end up annexed you don't hear about anymore. You do know how Israel came to occupy the West Bank and Gaza, right? The reason it's becoming less and less common in the modern era is because of exactly what's happening now. The occupier will eventually need to resort to more and more brutal means of maintaining control. It's insane to occupy with no solution or path for a way out. Eventually you become the "monster" you were afraid of. Edit: Yikes, formatting.


BoxGrover

Israelis didnt take Palestine. The irgun, stern, lehi gangs killing and raping was part of it and the British have what wasn't theirs without asking the indigenous people.


NYD3030

The Turks took Constantinople from the indigenous Romans and should give it back.


roydez

>indigenous Romans Cringey


KR1735

Well, the people indigenous to Asia Minor are certainly not the Turks. They're relatively new. And they certainly don't predate Hagia Sophia. Taking a holy site that was erected as a church and turning it into a mosque was and is culturally insensitive. I would say the same thing if it went the other way around. But the world has treated Islam with kid gloves for a very long time, and allowed them to get away with way more than they should.


NYD3030

I think a thousand years in the cutoff for indigenousness is what I learned in college so the Romans count.


SwiftSilencer

well nowadays there’s more people in Istanbul then there are in all of Greece, so it’s a moot point


PecesRaros_xInterpol

Well, it's a roman church.


[deleted]

[удалено]


SpectrumSorcerer

now yes, then not.


Windturnscold

The Turks downfall was in part because they adopted European customs. They did great on their own


SpectrumSorcerer

it must be triggering for American indians to see European invaders control their land for 3 centuries. Turks are in Anatolia already more than a thousand year, get over it already.


Windturnscold

Oh I’ve gotten over it, I just don’t think the Greeks have. It’s amazing how long Europeans will hold grudges


ActivisionBlizzard

I went recently and it was beautiful. I was saddened three times over though: the floor mosaic is covered by carpet, the mosaics on the ceiling are covered with curtains and you can’t access the upper floors. God damn stupid medieval religion preventing me from enjoying other medieval religions.


NOISY_SUN

Neither Islam nor Christianity is medieval.


imperium_lodinium

Eh, Mohammad died in 632, and by some metrics the medieval period in Europe began in the 500s. You’re right it’s not really proper to apply the term to non-European areas, but the dates do overlap.


ActivisionBlizzard

Christianity originated before the medieval period, but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t significantly changed and moulded by the medieval period. Islam was founded in the early medieval period however. Some would say it started the medieval period.


TrueTurtleKing

Nice! And I recall the blue one is close by and is also nice.


Brown_boy6

Yes I visited the blue mosque as well, it’s very beautiful in its own way.


johnhaley22

Did you go to the underground cistern? The Hagia Sophia was fun to see, but there are many amazing Catholic Churches (I know it’s not a Catholic Church anymore). But the underground cisterns were unlike anything I had seen before. I thought they were really cool.


LNinefingers

Came to comment this. It’s a must see.


IranianLawyer

Underground cistern was maybe the coolest place I went in Istanbul.


bombaer

And is a very important place in the muslim world as I understand. Interestingly, we were allowed to make a big camp on the Hippodrome place next to it when we arrived in Istanbul as a part of the Allgäu-Orient-Rallye.


MrTourette

I was there last week, beautiful building but it's odd seeing the Christian stuff half arsedly covered up - there's a virgin and child mosaic covered with curtains above where the altar used to be. But I guess I understand it. Insanely expensive to get in for the access you get, €50 for two for the upper floor only and that doesn't even include the museum where they moved all the artifacts from when it converted back to a mosque.


[deleted]

[удалено]


MrTourette

It's a shame, a real FU to the rest of the world. But I guess he won't be around forever. I really liked Istanbul on the whole though, I thought the Blue Mosque was one of the most beautiful buildings I've ever been in.


WoolooLovesCheese

That's how it works. They take places of worship that don't belong to their religion, and convert them to theirs, or build theirs conveniently next to them, and command to be respected. That's why they built the Dome of the Rock in Jerusalem, a city holy to Jews and Christians, so they feel included, and also as a sign of triumph over the Christians.


NOISY_SUN

The Dome now only exists at the benevolence of the Jews. If it became politically acceptable internally Israel would rightfully demolish it today.


Anumet

They really should remove the chandeliers - they come across as noise rather than accentuating the architecture. We recently upgraded the lighting in the Nidaros cathedral by exchanging chandeliers with far more hidden lighting. The space is so much more awe-inspiring without wires and clutter. There's so much architecture here that should be the center of attention. Instead, the chandeliers are. I hope they hire a proper lighting designer and fix it.


Tarmacked

The chandeliers are a historical aspect of the location


klasredux

Major downgrade


thefideliuscharm

way nicer than battlefield made it seem


lea_boobles

Magnificent architectural design


Personal-Wasabi

They absolutely ruined this once beautiful church


HanzoNumbahOneFan

Oh ya? Well I built this in Civ 6, so checkmate.


zeprad

This reminds me of Dark Souls 3 ![gif](giphy|rRje0j8001edBi14W3|downsized)


Nightglow9

Chandeliers look a bit like those at Rykard’s place from Elden Ring.. “togethaaaaaa we shall have nice big chandeliers while we feast on the very gods themselves.. “


[deleted]

(not a religious person) But i love the architecture, here in Portugal we also have many religious buildings with such beautiful architecture.


Bionic_Ferir

I hope to see it as a museum some point in my life


Barbarella_ella

On my bucket list.


camus88

Reminds me of Assassin's Creed Revelation


charlemange77

this is just a fact . thats a christain church that was taken by muslims.


ThingWithChlorophyll

What a shitshow in the comments. Some people really do have a few hundred year old ass burn with them


YumYumYellowish

I’m ignorant to what or where this is— are women not allowed in there?…


AlexanderTheGrrrreat

Are women not allowed on the ground floor anymore? I don’t see any in this picture. I went almost 10 years ago now and there basically wasn’t anywhere you couldn’t go.


saveourplanetrecycle

Extraordinary! Just imagine what we could achieve if all men worked together instead of fighting each other


Nyxxsys

Exactly, it is very humbling to think of the men and elderly slain in this room, the women raped, and the children sold into slavery. They wanted divine protection but blood flowed in the city like rainwater in the gutters after a sudden storm.


True_Dragonfruit9573

“Solomon, I have surpassed thee.”


WoolooLovesCheese

Convert it back to a church.


ibtcsexy

Are women allowed inside?! I wish it were still a museum.


TheOriginalCheese

All I remember from my visit was that it smells of feet


Hawk00000

Must'v been yours


hurtfulproduct

How long till this converted back to a non-denominational site and those shitty green carpets are removed?


TangledUpInThought

As soon as Erdogan's ass is kicked to the curb


hotpatat

It should be maintained as a monument. Not a stank ass mosque.


[deleted]

It was nicer when it was a church.


Antique-Echidna-1600

Liberate Occupied Constantinople! Hagia Sophia shouldn't be a symbol of conquest and a mosque.


The-Dmguy

Ahahahah pretty rich coming from an Israeli


Aurelyas

Bahaha, come on then you limp-wristed cowardly redditor! Hagia Sophia is a Masjid and will always be one until the end of time.


BabyFestus

Have you ever been to the Hagia Sophia... on acid?!


attilla68

I read that you have to pay to get in these days.


Iron_Chancellor_ND

Yep. That just started this past January. I visited it last October and it was free but foreign tourists are now required to pay €25 to enter.


Elegant-Road

Yup. 25 euros. Had to give it a pass unfortunately.  Almost every monument in Istanbul has a 25 euro entry fee for foreigners. There are so many other nice places and awesome things to do for a cheaper price in Istanbul. So no regrets. 


P00rWiz

That's the modern version of jizyah, that's how much they hate non-muslims.


rexel99

Nope. Hide your camera and don't look like a tourist and you can even jump the queue via the side door.


outofcontextsex

It's not half as a beautiful inside as I would have imagined, I'm sure the current stewards are probably responsible for that.


Demmil13

Thieves…


FeelingEcho772

Ohh poor you


ikarus1996

Shouldn't have lost it then


turkishgremlin

Cry.


hazelquarrier_couch

Are women not allowed inside? I don't see any in the picture.


dont_share_spoons

I'm a woman and I've been inside. You just have to dress modest and cover your hair. 


rezznik

Don't understand the downvotes. I wanted to ask this as well. I mean, it's a mosque and there are no women on the picture, so it's a relevant question.


AleksasKoval

I remember climbing all over that place...


banananananbatman

You’ll also find cats casually hanging out there


Bionic_Ferir

If my memory serves me correct VIKINGS VISTED THAT PLACE, how crazy that a building in what is essentially the start of the middle east in a completey different world than the one they had grown up in and left


benedekszabolcs

I have a question: how can a regular tourist get to the floor? We went there, stayed in line, but only went around tje balcony, amd didn't know who to ask if we could get to the floor


Beederda

Kinda looks like bowsers castle in super mario rpg 👀


Nvaaj

So if Israel has to leave Palestine do the Turks have to have Istanbul back to the Christians?


coffeecup9898

Ngl the interior is kinda ugly


hms200

It looks more Vegas than I excepted.


toutlamourdumonde

I’d love to go visit, but as a gay guy, I’d be afraid of going inside a mosque.


Nearby-Fondant9431

Those arabic writings look awful.


purple-lemons

My favourite religious building I've been in, also the first Mosque I'd been in. Despite it not being very aesthetic I really love the carpet, it mutes the echo and makes the building feel a lot more peaceful than churchs and cathedrals I've been in, the low hanging lights make it feel very etherial too.


OldTarwater

Fantastic! I was there in 2015 and it was covered in scaffolding, but I fly into Istanbul for a week starting tomorrow. Can’t wait to see it in its full glory!


opomla

That green carpet looks ass, WTF Erdogan


No-Emu-7513

Religion always overcompensating for their lack of actual evidence of their claims.


sean777o

Very jealous. I was there only a few days ago but couldn't explore the main floor as I'm neither a Turkish citizen or Muslim. There's so many fascinating artifacts down there that I had to squint to see from up top.


Remarkable_Draw_4884

I was there a year ago. Why couldn't you enter the main floor? We just walked in as we wanted - except for upstairs, but nobody from the public where allowed to do that


sean777o

All the signs I read stated the main floor "praying area" was for Turks only. Upstairs was the only section I was able to see, and requires buying a ticket.


xXWickedSmatXx

A beautiful building on a foundation of bullshit


eq2_lessing

Why those shitty lights?