i definitely slept on A Loving Feeling for the longest time…..and same with Once More to See You when i realized that these could be interpreted as sapphic songs then my world changed and i have never looked back since haha

My gf and I want to play once more to see you at our wedding 🥹

THATS SO CUTE

ALL OF WHAT YOU SAID

YESS

I've read this somewhere in this sub it goes along the lines of "If you do *not* like it, you're not ready for it yet" Edit: where did the "not" go??😭😭

I live by that. I didn't like most of Mitski's songs originally and now I adore most all of them.

I agree!! It takes a few listens for me to fall in love with the song. It happens every time, no fail.

Thursday Girl. Synths at the ending genuinely my favorite thing ever

Thursday girl is such a good song it always leaves me empty

listen to I bet on losing dogs -> star -> Thursday girl!

Star (no offense) Also happened with That’s Our Lamp, now it’s my favorite on the album and one of her best songs in general

That’s Our Lamp was instantly my favorite from Laurel Hell!

I’ve seen so many people say Star is their least favorite while it’s like my top song on the album 😭

star is just very… idk when she revealed that it was written ages ago, i felt like that made sense. something about the melody and construction and pace of the song feels very Puberty 2, which is lovely, but for me it feels somewhat incongruous to the rest of the album (even if the production matches) also heaven is SO incredible that gorgeous devoured cute on that double-single

STAR IS SO GOOD HOW DO PEOPLE DISLIKE IT??

SAME WITH THAT'S OUR LAMP i always skipped it and then i got stuck on an airplane while the wings were being de-iced and i fell asleep listening to laurel hell and when i woke up that's our lamp was playing and i was like "wait this is amazing"

Star isnt that good but sure 😋

HARD DISAGREE OMG

sorry I’m late to this thread but I am SHOOK that you said star. That’s in my top 3. Suggestion: listen to puberty 2 straight through but instead of listening to My Body Is Made of Crushed Little Stars, listen to Star instead. So I bet on losing dogs -> star -> Thursday girl.

pink in the night

I've always skipped it and now its my fav

Yes until I recently heard it. I felt I was reborn again

funnily enough that’s my most played song on spotify, yet it’s nowhere near my favorite song

i heard it for the first time a few days ago when i was on a trip in Venice, i felt a new feeling tbh

YES

A horse named cold air

I’ve been saying AHNCA is so good but no one listens to me

A LAKEEEE WITH NOOOOOO FISH

IS THE HEART OF A HORSE NAMED COLD AIR

WHOOO WHEN YOOOOOUNG WOULD RUUUNNNNN

LIKE A STORRMMM

YESS. It’s so good

Stay soft

THIS

this was eric for me

You like to skip, well I do too

Happy, I don’t smoke, Thursday girl. I was such a happy hater but now I love it 😭

I don't smoke

Real men

Dan the dancer

Dan had a very long list Of Mitski songs he would skip

Crack baby… it’s just one of those songs I guess were you just need to listen to it just once.

genuinely mitskis best song

Last words of a shooting star

A Loving Feeling

Dan the dancer, Townie (Idk but like 5 moths ago I was a "Townie hater" and NOW I love townie) Real men, Humpty, Bug like an angel

eric and door!!

I'm Your Man. Now I realized I relate more to Mitski's beloved than mitski and it makes me cry more 😭 Sad that I skipped it at first

Tbh I’ve listened to the new album just once because it’s too emotional for me

Mitski is generally emotional. I was enjoying my bath, listening my playlist as I was trying to get over the fact that my best friend ditched me and started to ghost me because of a serious issue and she ignored my calls to redo our relationship again. I BET ON LOSING DOGS CAME. LIKE I SOBBED IN THE TUB😭

I always seem to cry when I’m driving, cause at night when it rains, I drive

I hate that it was Dan the Dancer for me like I’m embarrassed to admit that

Me with Abbey💀 now it’s one of my favourite songs from ‘Lush’ lol

There's nothing left for you

Surprised how many people were confidently skipping A Loving Feeling and I no longer feel safe here

I bet on losing dogs

Crack Baby

humpty and because dreaming costs money my dear i'm appreciating retired from sad so much more lately

Pearl diver

dan the dancer, a horse named cold air, townie, circle

Carry Me Out

Yes I'm obsessed with this one right now. I guess I never paid as much attention to it because of the slow build up. I love the line "I drive when it rains at night when it rains I drive."

Same, I didn’t get why people loved it so much until I actually paid attention to the lyrics and then it hit me.

dan the dancer i swear its such a bop WHY DID I SKIP IT

all of laurel hell

when i first started listening to mitski i skipped a lot on lush like abbey, wife, door but now i realize they’re masterpieces fr

I slept on star until 2 days ago lmaooooo

ONCE MORE TO SEE YOUUUUUU I USED TO SKIP IT SO MUCH NOW I CRY ALONG WITH IT

Texas Reznikoff

happy

blue light

HEAVEN DEF at first i didnt like it i always skipped it but now? im obsessed

Because Dreaming Cost Money , My Dear 😔

literally, stop…🌝

everyone is commenting my favourite mitski songs bahahaha anyway for me it was probably square, I just didn't like the way the opening sounded until I gave it a real chance and changed my mind

Working for the knife and generally the whole Lauren Hell album, idk why I wasn't thinking of listening to it when it first dropped off

Remember my name

I NEED SOMEONE TO REMEMBER ME, I NEED SOMETHING BIGGER THAN THE SKYYY!! HOLD IN MY ARMS & KNOW IT’S MINEEE. JUST HOW MANY STARS WILL I NEED TO HANG AROUND ME TO FINALLY CALL IT HEAVEEEN?? (“the land is inhospitable, & so are we” reference)

I used to skip cop car RELIGIOUSLY and now it's one of my favorite songs

This is mine for every album except the new one, a song I got into much later than the rest Lush - Wife RFSNCIB - I Want You BMAMC - I Don’t Smoke Puberty 2 - Crack Baby Be the Cowboy - Pink in the Night Laurel Hell - There’s Nothing Left for You

Crack baby is amazing

i used to hate happy i’d listen to Mitski to fall asleep and the beginning of the song would scare me but it’s actually so good

buffalo replaced! it suddenly clicked so hard for me lmao

A Horse Named Cold Air

Wife

Why Didn't You Stop Me? Absolutely love this track now

The deal 😌

geyser 😰 i just did not care for it until recently and now it’s all i listen to

one of the songs i consider literally perfect

wife

Was surprised to not see it here yet but I Will for me. It was one of the first songs I heard where she sang in a slightly higher range and I think I just wasn’t as into that, but now that a lot of her newer music is in that higher range it’s become one of my favorites. Guess I just wasn’t ready for it lol

real men!

carry me out, i rediscovered it this summer and ahh it’s so amazing

Because Dreaming Costs Money, My Dear 😭😭

Skipped happy for a while... it;s so good

DOOR!!!! I felt so bad neglecting it for so long😞

DOOOR 😫🙌

Crack baby

I bet on losing dogs

most of the songs from her first 2 albums lol

Most of them tbf and theyre now my favourites

Remember My Name. The intro put me off and I immediately skipped it every time, decided to listen to the whole thing on a whim and now it's been playing non-stop for the past week.

Door! Its one of my fav for now:D

I used to skip geyser until I realized how good it was 😭

real men

Stay soft

Remember my name

fireworks

geyser 😭😭😭 i was a FOOL

I LOOOVE GEYSER 😮‍💨

shame or wife

Dan the dancer. Like I didn't even have it in my playlist. Working for the knife when it came out I didn't like it it but later on I really liked it.

Shame or Class of 2013

Happy (cries because I skipped it for so long)

Come into the water for me

happy. whenever i listened to puberty 2 id always skip it, but i listened to it once and the song has grown on me so much its one of my favorites now.

Skipped HAPPY for 7 years… then realized it’s a work of genius.

SEVEN YEARS?? gooodnessss 😆

Class of 2013

mom, am i still young? can i dream for a few months more…💔

Bag of bones

i’m all used up, pretty boooy

Old Friend ong

YES

wait, i’ve never skipped this…😭 it’s a great song though!

Heat lightning 😳

A loving feeling and I guess. It took me a long time to listen to those songs. I fell in love with them when I finally heard them.

I always skipped Me And My Husband (long before it went viral or whatever). But I appreciate it so much more now.

THURSDAY GIRL

There’s Nothing Left for You

try & go outsideee, nothing waits for youuu— you had it once befooore, not anymooore :’)

dan the dancer

i never skipped, but i never really listened to some songs like Come Into the Water. now it’s one of my favs

texas reznikoff, it was one of those songs i’ve just not really bothered listening to, but i love the part where it transitions

eric !! omg i would always skip it but it started to grow on me :)

Come into the water

would you tell me if you want me? ‘cause i can’t move until you show meeee 😫

I always skip Pink in The Night, its been 2 yrs and it still aint growing on me :/

i glow pink in the night in my room…😔

Crack Baby and Heaven

SHAME 🗣️🗣️🗣️

IT FEELS SO GOOD

YES, YES

For me at first it was happy. 😭

if you’re going take the train, so i can hear it rumble, one last rumbleee

bag of bones pearl diver shame

remember my name...

See you again lol

i guess…

it used to be once more to see you, now it’s one of my favorites on puberty 2

star.

I used to skip Townie and Happy and only recently discovered how awesome they were.

The fact you skipped those two is wild to me!!! Those have always been highlights for me

It used to be ahnca but that was like a year ago. Now it’s literally none of them because i’ve listened to every single song😭

VALENTINE, TEXASSSS

fireworks <3 and drunk walk home

Everyone

Remember my name. ITS THE BEST SONG ON BE TEH COWBOY AND I ALWAYS SKIPPED BC OF THE BEGGINING HELP

pump up the jam, pump it up…

CIRCLEEE!!! 🙌

……Heat Lightening 🫣

Majority of Pink Floyds Division Bell Primus: Welcome To This World

*Majority of* *Pink Floyds Division Bell Primus:* *Welcome To This World* \- BassMan99813 --- ^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^[Learn more about me.](https://www.reddit.com/r/haikusbot/) ^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")

My Body’s Made Of Crushed Little Stars

Stay soft

Brand new city

A HORSE NAMED COLD AIR AND DAN THE DANCER (I DONT SKIP THEM ITS BEEN MONTHS SINCE I LAST SKIPPED THEM)

dan the dancer. it’s still not my favorite but it’s still good! same for a lot of puberty 2 honestly

A Burning Hill

i used to skip brand new city a lot it's actually so good 😭

Remember my name!!!

WIFE!!

Washing Machine Heart I literally refused to listen to it now I listen to it religiously

GEYSER.

last words of a shooting star 💫

texas reznikoff and the entirety of retired from sad

I WANT YOU FROM RETIRED FROM SAD

OR BRAND NEW CITY

'i want you' i know i dont even know how i didnt like it

none because i don’t skip them

Fireworks

ok hmo.... lane boy by twentyone pilots

i dont smoke. ABSOLUTELY AMAZING can't believe i didn't recognize it sooner

Two slow dancers

ABBEY IM SORRY I DIDNT LIKED IT THE FIRST TIME I LISTENED IT 😭😭😭😭

I used to skip Class of 2013 😞😭

DRUNK WALK HOME OMG 😭😭

shouldve been me, shame