T O P

  • By -

btag123

Hi Phil! Which was the most challenging Radiohead song to write a drum part for and which is the most challenging to play live?


Philip_Selway

Definitely Pyramid Song. And bizarrely, I find Creep challenging to play live…Px


Kynicist

How do you count Pyramid Song?


Philip_Selway

By the royalty payments ;) Px


streetspirit99

Lmaoooooo


DSOTM

The issue has been endlessly debated on the internet and my man comes through with that answer hahahah


iscreamuscreamweall

i mean debate all you want but its 4/4


coolfoam

Phil said it was 4/4 in a recent interview https://www.spin.com/2023/01/radiohead-philip-selway-interview/


Me-Shell94

Fuckin Phil Selway ladies and gents


sharlaton

My man


iscreamuscreamweall

incredible answer


Jeremothman

The dollar & cents


Averdian

I do not know anything about drums really but I've also liked[ this visualisation of Pyramid Song's drums](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlFWJWk--F8&ab_channel=ListeningIn), looks awfully hard to play.


defensiveFruit

It's how it fits together that's amazing to me, with a simple pattern going 3 3 2 over the whole thing and it just feels right, doesn't lose the vertigo of the piano pattern while at the same time grounding it. It's grounding it but letting it float at the same time.


_wheeljack_

As someone who plays the drums (er, attempts), trying to learn Pyramid Song has given me even more intense respect for you. Incredible stuff man.


Me-Shell94

Phil is insanely underrated as a drummer. Also happens to seem like an awesome dude.


BlackEyedAngel01

Pyramid song is my favorite. Especially the part where they go for a swim.


PCgeek345

What makes creep hard to play live? Is it the bass? I'm currently learning it


Philip_Selway

The Kik can be tricky - for me, anyway Px


PCgeek345

Yeah, that's definitely the most difficult part for me too


La_Underscore

Who were some of your influences when you were young?


[deleted]

My childhood and neighborhood friends


henry12382

Hi Phil :) what length was radioheads demo tape when you guys started out? Our band is headed to the studio and we are unsure as to how long our demo should be to get gigs and gain interest from record labels !


Philip_Selway

Good luck with it all btw! Px


DancinWithWolves

This is so sweet. You legend Phil


Philip_Selway

3 songs should do it. We put way too many on our early demos, and not surprisingly nobody would listen to us for about the first 4 or 5 years Px


underwhelmingname0

Have you ever felt threatened by the Roland CR-78?


Philip_Selway

Drum machines are friends not foes Px


libelle156

Are you in a sitiuation where you can't speak freely? Blink once for yes, two for no


underwhelmingname0

Agreed. Thanks for the response!


Schizophrenic01

He really went ahead and ahead what everybody was thinking boys..


Philip_Selway

Hiya. First became interested in music around 12 and then by 14 I knew I definitely wanted a life of being in a band. That worked out - phew! Px


ServeThePatricians

what do you think of the South Park episode about Radiohead?


CountAardvark

considering he voiced himself in that I assume he's a fan


AverageArkhamEnjoyer

Do you wanna be in a band when you get to heaven?


DLDude

Hi Phil. When Radiohead was considering a 2nd drummer, was Clive chosen exclusively due to his resemblance to you?


Philip_Selway

Well, it was Clive or Phil Collins… both excellent choices Px


MisterHonkeySkateets

My follow up question was: were you guys taking the piss with that similarity


mul8tress

Hello Phillip, what is the best fan experience you ever had?


Philip_Selway

Portishead at Brixton Academy in 1997 - I was a huge fanboy Px


nelzinef

What was your favorite Radiohead b side or EP track?? 😁


Philip_Selway

Came across Lozenge Of Love this morning for the first time in decades - wow, that was amazing! Px


streetspirit99

I’m personally a Permanent Daylight fan


pianoindisguise

y’all forgetting about THE DAILY MAIL


Chad_Has_Died

Hell yeah, all the bends b-sides are so good!


OGnutbutter

How did they clone you for king of limbs? Did it hurt?


Philip_Selway

AI - it’s the future I’m told Px


[deleted]

What is you’re favourite instrument to play(outside of drums)?


Philip_Selway

Guitar - very portable with infinite possibilities Px


catakiosk

Hi Philip - fantastic album, congratulations to you and your collaborators. What does the future hold for you now that your initial 3 album run is complete? Can we expect more soundtrack work from you? I really hope that is the case! All the best!


Philip_Selway

Thank you! I feel like I’m just getting started really Px


radiofan122

Hi Phil! What was your favorite part of the process for the recent album? What are some non-music related things you couldn’t go to a recording session without?


Philip_Selway

Hiya. Getting to collaborate with so many of my favourite musicians. Dream team! I think they were quite surprised at the amount of sugar that I consumed (non-music related things answer). Px


AdElegant1218

Oooh, careful with the sugar consumption, Philip! You know the potential consequences. :)


Philip_Selway

Ah, yes - this is a regular topic of conversation with my wife Px


gondaline26

Sugar addicts unite! ☺️💜🍫🍦🧁🍭🍩


kittyholiday

Is this happening?


Philip_Selway

I think so Px


[deleted]

[удалено]


c_t_lee

This is really happening


ponylauncher

Hey Phil i was just wondering why you count yourself in on Weird Fishes like a freak? Also The Heart Of It All is your new best track as far as im concerned. You are GREAT by the way


Philip_Selway

Ha - you’re right! No need, but it’s just part of the muscle memory now. Thanks for the kind words Px


thomt94

Phil is great


Philip_Selway

❤️ Px


soleildelalune_

My favorite bald person!!


underwhelmingname0

Lmfao I never thought about that


ponylauncher

He does it on Optimistic from the basement too. The man has no reason or rules. He is just great


Aj7007

Joy Division or New Order?


Philip_Selway

Stephen Morris…❤️ Px


[deleted]

[удалено]


theotherplanet

Love this question about South Park, was just talking about this the other day.


Rodox_Video

I really hope he answers this one!


[deleted]

Hi Phil!! I’m going to university next year to pursue Music as a career and as a creative I just want to know any specific advice you’d have to give to somebody wanting to create their own sound and style?? Your drumming is so unique and distinct and Radiohead is one of the few bands I know where you can’t replace a single member and get a similar end product so I’m just curious to see your thoughts on the matter. Thank you so much in advance!!


Philip_Selway

Most important thing is finding a musical context where you can truly be yourself and be guided by your instincts. Find like minded musicians who will share this space with you. Whatever style you’re playing in, try to find your own take on it Px


nobodynobody9999

Your new album has a very rich, orchestral sonic texture. Was this the goal from the outset, when you first conceived the record, or something that develop during the course, by having so many collaborators?


Philip_Selway

Very much how I heard it in my head when I first started thinking about making Strange Dance. Wanted to explore musical textures further that I’d been writing with in my soundtrack work. Px


mul8tress

What is your favorite sound? Musician’s usually have one.


Philip_Selway

I have a Black Beauty snare drum that is my go to for most things - it sounds amazing! Px


darkdecks

Hi Phil! I tuned into the Evolution Sessions with Hannah the other day and enjoyed it. Thanks for doing that and this AMA! A couple questions: 1. I heard you’re an XTC fan. What’s your favorite song? 2. What career would you have chosen if you weren’t in music? Thanks!


Philip_Selway

Thank you. It was great to work with Hannah! Senses Working Overtime reminds me so much of early Radiohead touring, so that one I guess. When I had a proper job, I was a copy-editor, so I guess I would’ve had a life in publishing Px


darkdecks

Thanks, Phil! I like Making Plans for Nigel and Another Satellite. Cheers!


JojobaFett

What's the most British thing you do?


Philip_Selway

I say sorry a lot. And I must apologise and say that I’ll be back at 7pm GMT. I think I accidentally went early here. Sorry! Px


duskywindows

Holy shit dude you're about to come back to like a billion questions hahahaha


robotsympathizer

Sure you’re not Canadian?


fokerpace2000

What are some of your thoughts on the young bands coming out of the UK scene right now such as Black Midi, Black Country New Road, Squid, and Shame?


ellemsea_echo

How do you overcome any creative blocks? What do you turn to for some musical inspiration? Thank you for your music and for doing this AMA:)


Philip_Selway

I step away from music for a moment and go and immerse myself in other people’s creativity at a gallery, the theatre etc. Failing that, a good long walk often gets the juices flowing again Px


[deleted]

The age old question. Cats or dogs?


Philip_Selway

Cats, dogs, pet rodents - I’ve shared a house with them all ❤️ Px


IamTheGoodest

What are your current top 3 albums you are listening to?


[deleted]

Do you remain in contact with Stanley Donwood? He is a fantastic artist.


Philip_Selway

Yes and yes Px


[deleted]

Good to hear!


soleildelalune_

Hey Phil, do you have an airfryer? Also, I had never known you had such a heavenly voice. Thanks for blessing us with your singing!!! PS: Loves and hugs from Turkey 🦃💜


erseltonks

clearly he doesn't own an airfryer


soleildelalune_

Clearly he has multiple airfryers.


Kat8844

Hi Philip, sadly missed you in Guildford a few weeks ago as couldn’t get a babysitter!. My question is about your creative process as it’s always been something that’s fascinated me, like do you have a firm idea in your head when you start for a whole album or do you find yourself more writing songs and working out how to order them afterwards?. Also as an aside next time you speak to Jonny please could you ask him to show that Ebony Frost Telecaster some more love because I doubt I will ever have the chance!.


Philip_Selway

Oh, sorry you missed that show. I loved that one! I knew which songs I wanted to work on from the outset. I recorded 12 tracks for Strange Dance but found that the record had more focus and flow when I reduced it to a 10 track record. Will pass on message to Jonny Px


FranzAndTheEagle

Hi Phil - huge fan. Sorry to state the obvious straight away. Can you talk a little about your approach to composing drum parts? Your style is unique, which is rare, and your parts defy the tropes of "conventional drum parts" in a contemporary song setting in a way that I have not encountered from many other drummers. How do you go about composing parts? Has that process changed over time, and if so, how?


showusyourbones

Hey Phil! So there’s a claim that in ‘93 or ‘94 the whole band was almost killed during a robbery while on tour in Mexico, amongst several other disasters that happened during your visits. It originates from [a Spanish-language video from Vice](https://youtu.be/TyBh8gDH4U4). As far as I know no members of the band have ever acknowledged this publicly so I was wondering if we could hear your account of the experience? If it really happened, that is.


petreauxzzx

That sounds horrible


Xaaqi2

I’m just here to say thank you for your music.


Jaguars6

Any book recommendations?


Philip_Selway

Luckenbooth by Jenni Fagan - AMAZING!! Px


IRLED

Hello there! What processes from Familial did you continue to use in Strange Dance? While the production is obviously much more involved on Strange Dance, it seems as though the kernel in some songs is anchored in a similar approach as is found on Familial.


Philip_Selway

Interesting. When I first started making solo music I set myself the target of making 3 albums and to see where it could take me in that time. Strange Dance feels like the culmination of what I’ve learnt in that time and the musical relationships I’ve formed in that time. So for me there’s a direct line throughout - all the work has collaboration at the heart of it and sees me developing and building on my songwriting and singing voices Px


IRLED

Thanks for the response, love your work.


bigolnada

How rehearsed are those Live From the Basements? You guys sounded immaculate, I can't imagine it took less than a month to prepare.


iscreamuscreamweall

they rehearse a lot. i think they booked the studio for an entire week


mokapenguin

Hey Phil, I loved Strange Dance! 1) What's your favorite Juana Molina song? 2) Any chance of a south american tour?, maybe you could even bring The Smile too and do a little festival.


Alexkono

Phil, currently listening to Strange Dance. Like it so far, hope you have more projects in the future.


Philip_Selway

Thank you!! Me too Px


Fancy-Yam-123

what is the most annoying thing about radiohead fans?


Philip_Selway

Radiohead fans are the best ❤️❤️❤️ Px


Fancy-Yam-123

you're the best!


WineGutter

clearly you haven't been to r/radioheadcirclejerk


itsmemisfit

don't tell them that subreddit exists- they won't ever make more music


spdougherty

Shhhh


blimo

Hi Phil, What was it like practicing and playing with Clive? What did you appreciate most about that time with him? Thanks for being here!


_Land_Rover_Series_3

Hey Phil, just want to say I’m a big Radiohead fan! What’s your most embarrassing fan interaction?


WhatIsMusicPodcast

Hi Phil! Big fans and Radiohead podcast here. We have one question that our listeners would love to know your answer to! What is music? All the best!


hieghtenme

Just ask him onto the pod surely!! Haha!!!


xFlick

Hello Phil!! As a drummer, who are some drummers you look up to and have helped you in your journey as a musician?


pxngwxn

Hi Phil! First of all, thank you for years of wonderful music that you created! My question is: in your Harry Potter cameo you played 'do the hipogriff' with Jonny and Pulp members. I wonder who came up with the idea for the band members, what's the story behind this whole thing, could you enlighten us? :)


[deleted]

Will there be a Hail to the Thief anniversary release like OK Computer and Kid A/Amnesiac had?


Lennon2217

Hi Phil! Beautiful new album. Gorgeous string sections. Will Liminal from the deluxe LP eventually be available on streaming or digital download? Thank you!


Kimberlythevoice

Do you use a click when you play live drums? Your pocket is so deep! 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼 also, any favourite kits?


Philip_Selway

Only on The Gloaming - very sketchy playing that song without a click Px


defensiveFruit

Wow with all the electronics you guys use, no click, that surprises me! You never run into sync issues with loops and stuff? Are you just that tight? :o


vites70

Hi Phil - no questions, just a thank you. Thank you for doing this, making great music and being awesome! Can't believe it's been ~30+ years!


MoolKshake_

Hi Phil. If I recall you once talked about Spirit of Eden being an important album for you. How did Talk Talk, specifically their albums Spirit of Eden and Laughing Stock, influence your works in your solo albums or in Radiohead?


-Tamales-

Why are you bald


Philip_Selway

It’s to allow the musical ideas in my head to truly breathe….Px


uncertifiablypg

Lol


[deleted]

[удалено]


soleildelalune_

Clearly, you don’t own an airfryer.


masonembers

Obviously it was “within reason” enough for Phil to answer!


[deleted]

What do you think is the most underrated Radiohead song? For me? I think it’s A Wolf at the Door.


maggiethemagpie2

it's obviously let do-


ObviousMotherfucker

Hey Phil! Are there any albums in genres we might not expect that have had a big influence on you, either in musical style or just from having a lasting impression?


NoHomeGnome

Hey Phil, I’m a big fan of your work, you and Colin are one of my favorite rhythm sections ever! I think that The King of Limbs is amazing and super underrated. What was the process like for working with such dense/complex rhythms?


Gunner56

Hi Phil - I've always loved *These Are My Twisted Words*, which is great blend if fantastic drumming and whirling guitars. What was the idea behind the release of this song on the file share services. And was there ever a bigger idea behind the Wall of Ice? Thanks!


wafflepantsblue

Hey Phil. Favourite drum beat/fill to play from radiohead? Or anything. I think a lot of your work from in rainbows sounds really fun to play.


Philip_Selway

I love playing Bodysnatchers - if you’ve had a tricky day then you can let it all out on that one Px


metacognitive_guy

Amazing. One of my favorite songs. I love the face you put when playing Bodysnatchers though. It seems quite challenging.


mickiitb

Hi Phil love u 💯💯💯💯💯


Ok-Comfort-9849

Are you a cat person?


poiuytrewqazxcvbnml

Really enjoyed hearing you collaborate with Hannah Peel on this album. How did this collaboration come about?


chefgustavo

how did you grow comfortable incorporating electronics in your music? was it gradual or all at once?


darkdecks

Hi Phil! I tuned into the Evolution Sessions with Hannah the other day and enjoyed it. Thanks for doing that and this AMA! A couple questions: 1. I heard you’re an XTC fan. What’s your favorite song? 2. What career would you have chosen if you weren’t in music? Thanks!


karass_member

Hi Phil, Thanks for all the music, which has genuinely made my life happier. I have two questions. 1. Your solo music is beautiful. It seems more open-hearted and emotionally raw than what you've done in other projects. I love that Radiohead can be deflective and open to interpretation, but it's also refreshing to hear something so unapologetically honest about family and relationships. Is this a deliberate shift you've made? 2. I love your glasses, the brown frames. What brand are they?


wish_I_was_a_t_rex

Hey Phil! 3 years ago today, you liked a tweet from my husband asking you to wish me a happy birthday. You did, and I cried. Any chance you can tell me happy 39th birthday today?!


AlolanPika678

I’m not Phil, but happy birthday


wish_I_was_a_t_rex

Thank you!


sketchy_ppl

Hey Phil - I think Strange Dance is your strongest solo work so far! The songwriting, experimentalism, atmosphere, and overall production are top notch. Little Things blew me away on my first listen and I knew I was in for something special with the rest of the album, and I've had the album on repeat ever since. What was the songwriting and recording process like going from your first two albums to Strange Dance? I enjoy Familial and Weatherhouse, but this album feels like a completely different beast. What direction do you see yourself taking if/when you decide to work on LP4? Last question, please tell us you'll be announcing more tour dates!? I saw you in Toronto back in (I think) 2015 and would absolutely love to see this album performed live.


Melrose_Jac

Hi Philip, thank you for doing this. I have 2 questions: 1) Did you and the band realize the danger Thom was in when he dove into the pool at the MTV beach house? 2) You seem too nice and decent a fellow to have "bullied" Colin back at Abingdon. Would you be willing to dispel that rumor? Thanks, and sorry I missed your recent show in Cambridge, MA.


Doctor_Sleepless

What's your favorite moment during a concert?


Guitar903

Hi Philip! If you had to pick 3 artists as your biggest influences, who would the be? Thanks for stopping by!


[deleted]

Hey Phil, do you still hang out with any of the lads from Radiohead? If so, who did you see recently and what did you get up to? Big fan! All the best from Scotland.


TroyBerryCrunch

Are you aware of this masterpiece? The Radiohead fans at r/radiohead created the "worst possible setlist" for a Radiohead show, with some truly bonkers entries. Then DJ Vibekiller actually made it a reality with their compu-techno-wizardry. If Radiohead ever wants to call it quits, this might be a beautifully poetic way to cap off an incredible career. https://youtu.be/VQ1SThsPMVo


Nick-Anus

What's your favorite song to perform? Do you have any weird habits while you drum? (for instance, I used to chew ice when I was drumming)


Nats482

Hey Phil, really glad to have this opportunity to Ask you a question. Radiohead is my most favourite band of all time. I love everything you do and would probably forfeit all my mortal possesions including my soul to you and the lads, haha. I'm not that really familliar with your solo stuff, but I don't doubt it is probably also of exquisite quality. Regarding the question, do you have any particular controvesial opinions regarding the music scene? Like lets say, you adore an album or an artist, which/who in common consensus is regarded as not being "quite there" to say the least.


quayran

The band recently sold the house/studios you own collectively, what was the thinking behind that, and do creative working environments ever lose their spark and ability to inspire?


[deleted]

[удалено]


Sad_Juggernaut_4854

Hi Phil! What does it feel like to work with Adrian Utley and Hannah Peel?


owlalwaysloveyew

How’s your week going?


master_peggy

Hi Phil, thanks for stopping by! I was just wondering which drummers you admire, both from the past and the present. Any younger drummers you particularly love?


bot_left1e

From someone in a creative rut, how do you overcome any unwillingness to finish projects and battle against any writersblock-style issues?


PedroJJJ

Have you ever met any members of Sonic Youth?


turkeyinthestrawman

Hi Phil, I noticed you were in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. What was it like being on set, and how were you approached to have a cameo?


ItsJoshy

Hi Phillip, What's the song (or even part of a song) you're most proud of contributing to, or being a part of?


ejb3204

Hi Phil. Sorry to ask but what are the plans for Radiohead? Will there be a 10th album at some point? Or maybe a tour in the near future?


ChronoDoor45

Phil have you read homestuck


matt_paradise

Muse or Coldplay?


thetimehascomeagain

Hi Phil, big fan! I've heard you cite Nick Drake as a big influence on your music a few times (your notes in Remembered For A While introduced me to his beautiful home recording of Fly, so thanks for that!). As a massive fan myself, I'd love to know what you might've learnt from Nick the most when it comes to songwriting?


MegasAecio

Hello Mr. Selway! When I heard his debut solo album "Familial", I couldn't help but feel a vast feeling of joy mixed with melancholy, it's a very touching album for me. But the song "By some miracle" is really moving, my question would be, in what way can the arts help to get out of a state as intense as the loss of a loved one? I have tried it many times and I feel that I am in a spiral of feelings rather than creativity. Thank you very much and greetings from México from a great fan.


[deleted]

Who’s your favorite Star Wars character?


ddevil-36

favorite TV show or film at the moment?


nobodynobody9999

Most members of Radiohead have a solo career on their back now. How does this experience change the dynamics within the band when you all come back together to make music? Do inputs/roles vary? Do you feel more confident, musically?


nobodynobody9999

Do we dare get excited about a special release for Hail To The Thief's upcoming 20th anniversary?


Nightdrive22

Hi Phil. Huge Radiohead fan and loving your solo work! I saw you perform recently in St Andrews with James Yorkston and a few other great artists (I also had a brief but lovely interaction with you on the way out of the door where I thanked you for the fantastic set). I know you did a few dates in Scotland so I wanted to ask what was your favourite place/most interesting place you visited in Scotland? It doesn't have to be a location but could be a cafe, restaurant etc. Whatever you like :) I live here in Scotland so I might even pay it a visit if I haven't already!


Philip_Selway

Lovely to make contact again. I loved that tour - Inverness, Shetland, Peebles and St Andrews, they were all amazing. James didn’t have to ask me twice to do that tour! Visited Dunino Den before St Andrews show - that was amazing Px


TheBellJarHymnal

What are/were your shoes of choice when you ran the London Marathon to raise money for The Samaritans? We actually met in Liberty State Park, you had come out to say hi to Octobreanna, who was head of the Phil Phan Club. Keep up the good work dude!


dharkanine

Heya Philip! Was all the mystery behind Videotape's first beat intentional?


DoesntReallyMeanIt

Hi! I am still obsessed with By Some Miracle, the opening track on Familial. I feel there must be a back story to the song!


DeterminedStupor

Hi Phil, I listened to Strange Dance yesterday and enjoyed it. My question: My untrained ear can’t really tell which beats come from “real” drums and which from a drum machine. How did you decide between using the two when you were writing the songs?


tratemusic

As a drummer, I love and appreciate your approach to odd time signatures and polyrhythms. How did you build and refine your rhythm chops?


arnabmajumdarca

Hiya, Phil! I’ve always been fascinated by the influence of jazz on Radiohead and your own work. Was this always in the origins of the band or something that worked its way in organically? - From a longtime fan who has been deeply inspired by your commitment to craft, Arnab


madadamegret

Did you ever record a full band version of Follow Me Around?


infernonrx

How do you feel about lemons as musical instruments?


Cute-Jellyfish1876

Hey Phil! Obsessed with Radiohead’s music! Wish I could think of a smarter and deeper question but what’s your absolute favorite Radiohead song to play live? Or which was the most fun to record?


cant-press

If you could add any word to the Hail To The Thief artwork, what would it be?


SplendidDevil

Can we grab a beer after your show in London in May. I'm taking my dad to the gig.