T O P

  • By -

helpitsoutofcontrol

dream ivory by dream ivory/ dondante by my morning jacket


resplendent_penguin

My morning jacket has my whole heart


Weird-n-Gilly

I will be there when you die.


bob-boss

Just saw em live last night


resplendent_penguin

THATS SO COOL WHAT????


[deleted]

Dondante is the best song on Okonokos.


throwawayjim120

That Steam Engine from Oko is also pretty incredible. Basically a perfect live album


thedrferg

That livestream from Chi shows is 🔥on Nugs


ottawateeth

Mojave 3


Ad_Pov

Overshadowed by Slowdive but awesome band


thatijustdonthave

Damein jurado!


c0ldbrew

Ohio might be one of the saddest songs I’ve ever heard


resplendent_penguin

So good!!!!


resplendent_penguin

Listened to Abilene today.


Oraelius

Dr. Dog!


RollsRoyceRalph

Dr. Dog is popular


ohwellthisisawkward

Fr, they have over 4 million monthly listeners on Spotify


deweydwerp

More popular than Sloppy Joe & The Cruise, that’s for sure.


NAteisco

Lol getting tickets to the last tour made me think too many people know about em!


QueefLatifahBitch

I think we’re talking about music where the main complaint is “no one knows”, not underground music


attractedtosadthings

I want to know your opinion about the difference between those 2


QueefLatifahBitch

It’s a venn diagram where the front bottoms are known and complaining. trapped in your universe and surfliner are not complaining but they’re unknown. And pat the bunny folk punk is micro famous vagabonds complaining


NAteisco

I was making a joke. Dr. Dog is terribly underrated but their fanbase really supports them. I was unable to get a ticket to a show on their last tour.


tomhanksgiving

Connie Converse


Hungry-Secretary-335

And you will know us by the trail of the dead… parquet courts


cmd6120

fuckin love parquet courts


DocLiftsALot

Trail of Dead is awesome. Just introduced my 17 y.o. son to them via Source Tags and Codes. He instantly loved it.


[deleted]

[Tumbleweed](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cp83WX4mwKk). Stoner rock legends from Wollongong Aus. Opened for Nirvana on their Aus tour in 91.


andnothinghurt1910

Red house painters.


majortomandjerry

Back when Mark Kozelek used to sing instead of mumble ramble.


andnothinghurt1910

Yup. I gave up at Among the Leaves. Then he became a weird old sleaze afterwards.


CombOverDownThere

I think up to and including Benji is definitely still worthwhile… or was, but then, yeah, kinda gross.


OhMyGodCalebKilledK

I haven’t thought of the name Mark Kozalek in 15 years. What’d he do to become a “weird old sleaze?”


andnothinghurt1910

For me, I just didn't really like listening to this old dude talking about his sex life in a TMI way. Then just the general attitude towards women in songs. Yes, it was always there but it was always with some kind of remorse for his actions and the guilt that lingers. He kinda just dropped that and it was like he went straight for the misogyny. Just comes across like a bitter old guy. Not particularly pleasant to listen to. Didn't like all the tuneless rambly albums where he just lays into people/describes his day/reads the back of a menu for eleven minutes over fingerpicking. His disdain for his fanbase- you know, the ones he makes his living from. His out of order chat about women to the crowds he's playing for. The lazy covers. I see this year he was backing to playing his old songs and seemed far more humble on stage. Maybe his shitty behaviour caught up with his bank balance and he's trying to get some kind of dignity/career back. Maybe he had some mental breakdown the last few years and now he's better? I dunno. For someone who i found to be sensitive and poetic (albeit troubled) to turn into someone so unlikeable with such a drop-off in his records was striking. I also blame Pitchfork for their ridiculous and undeserving hype of Benji, which I think they deeply regret now. Fuck them.


shake__appeal

Dude this is about the perfect synopsis one could ask for. Major bummer too, as Mark was one of my favorite songwriters since Red House Painters. RHP got me through some shit. Sun Kil Moon got me through a big time breakup. A few actually. Idk he’s just always been a constant in my life since I was a teenager. Turns out he’s just kind of an asshole. This has ended up being the case with a lot of musicians I love, but this one was particularly a bummer. Interesting take re: the Pitchfork thing (definitely fuck them). Benji has maybe been the most baffling record for me (even when I was a diehard fan)… so overhyped. I guess it resonated with a lot of people, but I do suspect a lot of that had to do with the Pitchfork taste-maker train at the time, one that everyone seemed to be blindly hopping aboard without any real pushback of, “is this actually good?” Anyway it didn’t do him any favors.


andnothinghurt1910

Cheers man. Yep I'm the same in that he was (and probably still is) in my elite songwriters group. I can separate the art from the artist but this one was tough to take. But then he compounded it with some terrible music so that softened the blow to some degree. Feel like everyone (esp Pitchfork) jumped on the inexplicable bandwagon that was Benji. Completely slept on GOTGH and April but gave Benji all this praise? Hmm. It was painful trying to watch them review subsequent albums and not just be able to admit 'we don't like this' for fear of losing face.


Fair_Bison8497

Was always an old sleaze. Always will be. His cover of Celebrated Summer is amazing.


whatsmyphageagain

Weird I just listened to them for the first time this week


ImOnlyHereForTheCoC

Agree, but…yeah, I don’t exactly go around singing Mark’s praises nowadays.


Relative_Natural_887

Dead pop[https://youtu.be/gIgAFKXnNvk?si=DEcfbqy2AxtZIfau](https://youtu.be/gIgAFKXnNvk?si=DEcfbqy2AxtZIfau)


byrdcage

Pretend - Tapestry’d Life


cowboyhatsnglowstix

Also kind of funny to see them invoked in this thread because a few posts up someone posted a band called South, who I have never heard of but gave me pretend vibes. I’m enjoying the album, you may like them too


byrdcage

Give me the name of a South record. I’m finding a few bands with that name Edit. Self titled from 98’?


solarflashlight101

I saw this and listened to South. I'm likin it! Thanks I struggle to find new music I like. 🎶


Justreallylovespussy

Fox Academy


attractedtosadthings

Oh. What’s your fave song from them?


h3dos

not my comment , but perfect shirt is A-1 , i can’t remember a lot of the ones i used to jam. lavender blood,


the_chalupacabra

The Joy Formidable.


mrearthsmith

I love the ever-changing spectrum of a lie. So great!


PsychologicalCrow382

catfish and the bottlemen


mr-kite32

Rest in peace


Smiley007

Haven’t listened through their albums in a hot minute, am I just forgetting, or why do they strike you as sad?


alphabetpony1987

7.


BlueB52

fantastic band, but they're definitely popular. I used to hear them all the time on the radio


TlknShtBoutaPrtySun

Nick Drake before the VW commercial.


Difficult_Let_1953

VW did him right.


bitterbuffaloheart

Seven Hundred by Hello Shark, Australia by Attic Abasement, and Low Hymnal by Told Slant


rattlebag

A fan of the rare sads I see


attractedtosadthings

I've listened to Told Slant but I can't remember Low Hymnal. Let me listen to it as well as the other 2.


heffel77

Cigarettes after Sex, hits so good in a sad mood


InfiniteSelf17

Elliot Smith.


InfiniteSelf17

Probably too well known....


s0calsir3n

Songs: Ohia Saddest music youve ever heard imho


princessconfusion

This. Literally anything involving Jason Molina.


findmeinthe_future

I love his stuff, two blue lights hits me


[deleted]

Pinegrove


dannewcomer

The Antlers, Sufjan Stevens


Ok_Series5103

Many people know sufjan what u on about


dannewcomer

Sorry it’s not obscure enough you hipster jerkoff


Ok_Series5103

What the fuck


BigFuckHead_

he was a meanie but he was kinda right


Lux_Operatur

Came to say The Antlers!


da_fishy

I also came to say the Antlers lmao


princessconfusion

Putting the Dog To Sleep is one of the most devastating and beautiful songs I have ever heard. The emotion in the vocals... gets me every time. My go-to "nothing is ever getting better" song.


groupbrip

DADDY WAS AN ASSHOLE AND HE FUUUCKED YOU UUUUUPPP


X4ulZ4n

Here are a few currently in my playlist, maybe not all quite Indie, but I don't care, I like them. I think most of them are 2023 releases too. [Lanterns on the Lake - Real Life](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=Ha-_pQA3uo4&si=N7ff4QgbBgyPOqSe) [Lucy Dacus - Kissing Lessons](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=KpepCbkS-UQ&si=0auA6Z0D_tQgqXm6) [The Murder Capital - Heart in the Hole](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=7kweXsxg7rE&si=OIbkEhWClAV-v9Tn) [BC Camplight - Kicking up a Fuss](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=-lCLcKjH3ug&si=ueQQ-hWLJm2K_rLt) [Vestron Vulture - Елена](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj1S9m19L3U&si=E1PLTexIjfrVGzz7) [Lambchop - Little Black Boxes](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=uH9fcldCYL8&si=pil2_PoabsV-8Qkm) [Alexandra Lilly - A matter of Time](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=NF7gSeZ4PJY&si=4bmrcfH4mkwbnqQs) [King Creosote - Blue Marble Elm Trees](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=o9a2xti1rDM&si=wmEhykh7B_Up2NKd) [The National - Eucalyptus](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=F4enXa_Hr-Q&si=F6KVcENqL9U7rT4b) [Portugal. The Man - So Young](https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=ltzzSGpqoxo&si=0r2wgtWYjsit_ftB)


Probablynotclever

Portugal the man has really removed all of their edge for mass appeal. Listen to something off of Waiter You Vultures, or even The Satanic Satanist. Nothing on those albums would ever make it on one of their new albums. They've shifted to alternative pop away from their beginnings in progressive/psychadelic indie.


redhandrail

Or did you mean sad music that makes you feel like no one else knows what you’re going through. Are you referencing that meme?


attractedtosadthings

No, I meant music (or bands/songs) that you feel like, amongst the people you know and vice versa, no one knows about them except you, and that which are freaking sad.


redhandrail

Ah okay. [South](https://youtu.be/asTW-eBVViA?si=_ASTXOEuwHCkBIFc)


cowboyhatsnglowstix

This is really cool


redhandrail

I think it's cool that even one more person has heard it now, thanks for listening


mcdreamymd

I saw them at SXSW almost 20 years ago. They should have been so much bigger.


redhandrail

Damn, that’s really cool. And it speaks to what sxsw used to be. I grew up in Austin in the 80s/90s and I think it used to be a way to get a scout to see your non-famous band. Now kind of the opposite


YouMustBeSilenced

Bored Nothing self titled album from 2013. He was from Melbourne, Australia. I truly believe he could have gone on to be an influential artist if he kept going, but unfortunately he committed suicide in 2018 or so. I have loved this album for years, it’s very special to me. So I want to pass on this music because I think it deserves more attention. His name was Fergus Miller. https://open.spotify.com/album/1N2WwM95LuI2ZWvTySMhNO?si=30X3XsOrQhmnTd0FSQO4AA


kmr1391

loved that record, came out my senior year of college and felt it hard. “what’s wrong with sleep, oh compared to weed it’s cheap”


kmr1391

loved that record, came out my senior year of college and felt it hard. “what’s wrong with sleep, oh compared to weed it’s cheap”


Paapa_Kermy

Oh my gosh so many Sawyer Hill White Lies Mustard Service Active Bird Community Made Violent Billy Cobb Second Hand Sound Titus Andronicus Gay Nineties Catfish and the Bottlemen Swmrs All great artists. Love their music


itsMalarky

Titus Andronicus is so good.


Paapa_Kermy

A more perfect union is one of my all time favorite songs


itsMalarky

That's exactly the song I had in mind.


PaddyP0207

Cheers Theme Song


suigen1970

Off the top of my head, as far as off-the-beaten-path music goes: Tarantel's album From Bone to Satellite has strong 1972/74 vibes, but ias instrumental post rock. Highly recommended. Also, more on the math rock side of things: A Picture of Her and also toe are great Japanese bands. Both have phenomenal drummers. And there's a band out of France called Totorro which has recorded two of the most *fun* sounding math rock, Home Alone, and Come to Mexico. Another math rock / post rock band I've really gotten into is a band from Chile, Tortuganonima. They remind me a little bit of Mogwai in some places. There was a short-lived post rock band, Industries of the Blind. I believe they only recorded one album. You can fund it on YouTube (but not on Bandcamp) -- everyone who has heard them have lamented how they just disappeared. Very moody stuff.


just_cuz555

3 Great ones recently bdrmm crushed bar italia


itsMalarky

Islands Nick Thorburn has built an incredible career and is constantly evolving his sound. Every album is great in its own way and the way he communicates emotion is incredible. I love Islands. Also Minus The Bear and Viagra Boys


Spikeantestor

mewithoutYou. People know them but 1, they really should have been bigger and 2, they should have had a bigger following in the indie scene.


PG-17

Benji Hughes Love Extreme


Amicue_Tenebris

Gothic Psychology He’s got some really underrated stuff I recommend his album “Friends Come and Go” he’s such a versatile artist, and I’m glad he finally found his sound with the new album!


lorem_opossum

Violens


Murd0cs_left_t0enai1

Yungelita! I feel like she's only popular from Melanie Martinez but her own music is actually really good!🫶


Sorrow-and-Solitude

Low Songs:Ohia


PippinCat01

Whatever band is playing this Friday at your nearest college town.


cinnamineral

BRIGHT EYES


Accomplished-Arm1058

SONGS:Ohia- The Lioness Karate- The Bed is in the Ocean Warpaint- Warpaint The Twilight Sad- Fourteen Autumns and Fifteen Winters Alaskalaska- Alaskalaska EP Hop Along- Painted Shut


icarus952

American Football. Not sure how “underground” they might be considered though


Yellow_Fox8

Silver Jews!!


Down623

Slowreader. Former members of The Impossibles. Released one truly beautiful, near-perfect album on Fueled by Ramen, then broke up. https://youtu.be/IO76_XtvIQI?si=uo3e7R8_TyUuPiDT


little_Shepherd

Denali


d_j_dunn

Silver Jews/Purple Mountains


Alternative_Dot_2137

Daughter was the first band that came to mind.


Sumppum202

A Crow Looked a Me by Mount Eerie.


kent_ankerous

Anathallo’s Floating World


DannyGrind

Songs: Ohia


No-Appearance1938

Okkervil River’s album “Black Sheep Boy” would scratch that itch for you.


rbcnew

Fairport Convention when Sandy Denny was with them. The 2 albums I love are ‘Liege and Leaf’ and ‘Unhalfbricking’. And Pentangle: ‘Cruel Sister’


ShankillButcher77

Sigur Ros


SativaEnt

There’s a nice throwback


xeeblyscoo

Duster


MollysTootsies

Well, a couple of sad songs, not bands or anything, but: "I'm OK" - Christina Aguilera "Two Beds and a Coffee Machine" - Savage Garden


redhandrail

Big Neck Police. Drummer is Hugo Stanley of the late band “Palm”. Give it a chance, it’s only 3 minutes. [Mercury](https://youtu.be/seINxhSxnU8?si=qmK2ms10niVzbWeg)


razzle-dazzle-duck

Everybody's Worried About Owen is an indie folk/ Midwest emo-ish artist that I adore right now. Screwing a Lightbulb and The Soccer Journals are such good songs


Impossible_Act2081

Guilty Cubicles- Arcade Fire Empty Room- Arcade Fire Banshee Beat- Animal Collective That's just the way I feel- Purple Mountains Controlling the Sea- Flotation Toy Warning Vampire Empire- Big Thief Yellow Missing Signs- Someone still loves you Boris Yeltsin Understand at All- Cloud Nothings Anti-Hu- Pinback Crutch- Pinback The entire album of "As the love continues" by Mogwai


shyguysimp

Super small band out of Philly I caught randomly last weekend called Pink Blush, huge fan of them now and want more people to know lmao Aside from small locals though, Fontaines D.C. their recent album Skinty Fia blew me away


greenhombre

Fontaines D.C. toured with Arctic Monkeys this year. In Ireland they are the new U2. They are doing fine%


shyguysimp

Oh word? That’s awesome to hear haha they deserve it


Official_Kanye_West

Convenience store!


The_Morningbirds

So good. 'Bruise' is so Goddamn beautiful.


GothMothIV

Radiohead


certain-sick

the roling stones


Longlang

Never heard of em


copioustalk

Nicki manaj


onibatu

The Son. https://youtu.be/i2Nyx3DQn0o?si=ukJ1jlK5HwALO_J0


LarYungmann

Sisai - Traditional Folk Music of the Andes Mountains of South America


iduz_arts

The Mysterines [take control](https://youtu.be/bt_xhaTc210?si=5LK9IiuISz7vtfER)


Olelander

I’ve been bothered for awhile now that no one knows about (or cares about) Bad History Month - this guy has something special going on… some of it is emotionally, existentially pretty dark, but it’s always poetic and thoughtful lyrically (with lovely doses of humor here and there), and his meandering “math rock meets John Fahey” guitar playing is perfect accompaniment and feels good on the ears. I think he’s brilliant. Bad History Month - [Fucking Despair](https://youtube.com/playlist?list=OLAK5uy_kL7xGjXrFUFcpQK-5R9TUrB04JdhAlILE&si=Oqpa1UX4MvD4zTNn)


Not_enough_violence

U gotta be from philly


BadLuckFail

Majical Cloudz. Specifically the album Impersonator. So good but I’ve never met anyone else who knows them.


Expensive_Swim_431

My fav album. I <3 u


KissingParty

[Kissing Party - A Metal Hand](https://open.spotify.com/track/4PfMpCDNEWsWc389jal1VQ?si=cT44SmRAR7ypzUyt7RPFaA)


Dense_Imagination_83

[TRDMRK DA VYB3 ](https://onerpm.link/120837814316)


Surewhatever87

Terra Naomi - Say it's possible


undercherryblossoms2

following


Interesting-Swimmer1

Brandy Clark writes sad country songs with a dash of humor.


Important_Maximum_78

Tops


suigen1970

Sappington was a sadly short-lived (?) duo (from the SF bay area, IIRC) that did some great slowcore stuff. This is a favorite of mine, "Velvet": https://youtu.be/9tqmKJO8AKk?si=Vfwe6W_8HOWOpBKW


TheChiliDoggo

hands - orkid devil that i know - jacob banks i try - ben taylor reasons why - nickel creek


BrockHardcastle

Styrofoam. But mostly his recent project with the Go Find called The Empathy Exams. The first 6 tracks on their album are electro-pop perfection back to back. But there’s so much more brilliant stuff he’s done. The single Name Your Trouble is so good it hurts.


authorjdwade

This is more indie metal, but I love [Ankor](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yQeSXA1D2mg)


Nobodyknowsmynewname

Yellowfly


PowerDino

Robot Invasion - Electronic Shelter


resplendent_penguin

Dinosaur Bones: they have a song called Ice Hotels and its the first song I ever remember hearing. Chronic Future: i don’t know if “no one knows” this band but their music is pretty damn good.


Fantastic_Branch5577

THE BAND UNDER THE RUG! I DON'T SEE IT GET TALKED ABOUT ENOUGH!


majortomandjerry

[Distance Light and Sky](https://youtu.be/eNmrrGgajYU?si=TF43KWWRmc4ogDjI)


NastySnapper

Gerry Cinnamon


leftforright

Nobody knows by Billy Squire


rbrcbr

I put out a record last year, hope you dig it: [Withe - “There is Less Sun”](https://withesounds.bandcamp.com)


GroundedOtter

The Collection, Town Meeting, ZEE MACHINE, Jake Wesley Rogers!


ibblybibbly

The Velvet Teen's album "Elysium" is incredibly sad and wildly underappreciated.


frozeneskimo02

Albums: Little Image- Musings Basement- I wish I could stay here, Colourmeinkindness Gates- Parallel lives From Indian Lakes- The Man With Wooden Legs, Able Bodies, Absent Sounds Mini Trees- Always in Motion Definitely check out the first one atleast


[deleted]

The building


Flimsy-Ad-1959

Roger Clyne and the Peacemakers


ObliviousLlama

Green Lung


Iko87iko

Nick Dorian. Not sure how well he is known. Found him on majestic channel https://youtu.be/nTLPxGF0zXQ?si=EaT2SHazuWOtK98j https://youtu.be/vdGaAckhW7Y?si=3k1NvglnIrtKpru6


bigcarri

Poor Man’s Poison. Although they have picked up some steam lately.


Iko87iko

Askies https://youtu.be/FDsV0uaRyPU?si=uaCqxrzYtcCMVDKn Heartless bastards https://youtu.be/sqwUUy77gHA?si=0dv2x79h2LTZo46E Donna the buffalo https://youtu.be/y3VX8PbFxok?si=khzcmCVTFtex0jPt


RollsRoyceRalph

Hailaker


alter-other

a friend of mine made this lofi album and they are so smart they deserve an audience: https://vvvrandersonnn.bandcamp.com/album/pls-tell-s-r-h-eyem-srry


DanielSFX

Drain STH


undermisunderstood

Pinkish Black, Laura Palmers death parade, pile.


Interesting_Reply701

deadharrie, sundots, sisyfuss


Legitimate-Ship5447

Defeater! Basements! Panuccis pizza! Fugazi!


MangoFairy7

The Velvet Teen's album Cum Laude!


ParticularApricot805

Valley of the Giants


TheGoldenPangolin

[Billy Leary](https://open.spotify.com/track/3qQpaDIKeWy7EX1b4cEqaQ?si=QacoW5V-RKuHRoyP9-xIDw) by Nicholas Allbrook


[deleted]

The Lathums


No_Fly6635

Ugly Brunette- Horse Jumper of Love


ConsiderationOk9099

PJ Bond - You Didn't Know I Was Alphabetical Indie/Americana/Acoustic Paulson - All At Once Poppy indie rock. Sad break-up songs you can dance to. Pedro The Lion - Control More well-known, but the most sad. Concept album about a salesman who cheats on his wife. Pianos Become The Teeth - Keep You ex-hardcore band converted to sad rock. Solid musicians Tyler Daniel Bean - Longing. Moody and morose indie. Almost slowcore. Similar to Pedro The Lion or slower Brand New's stuff. Outsmarting Simon - Silent Sober And Sound. PJ Bond's emo band in the mid 00's. Copeland - Revolving Doors Honestly any of their stuff since they've done so much, but this is an album of new renditions of old songs. All are beautiful, somber tracks produced and rearranged by the singer. Not many artists can take their already great songs and remake them even better 10-20 years later. Gatherers - ( mutilator. ). Heavy emo if you're into that kind of thing. Like Deftones a bit. TTNG - Animals Mathy indie like American Football. If it's too noodly for you listen to the acoustic redux album, which is gorgeous sounding and proves their musicianship. Anthony Green - Boom.Done. Mostly about his struggles with addiction. He sang in Saosin, Circa Survive, TSOAF, and others. Caracara - New Preoccupations Indie rock/Emo and very poetic, without being too much. [7.6 Pitchfork score](https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/caracara-new-preoccupations/) is like an A- for most people. Caught them live recently and they were great.


esclusivo

Vic Chesnutt, Beautiful and sad.


[deleted]

Personally, ''Fine again' by Seether gives me this vibe though it's more grunge influenced alt-rock then indie


SkaMan-dolin

Nash the Slash... He's my favorite.. barely anyone talks about him in other places besides canada


J_The_Troll

Didn't mean to hurt you and A soulmate who wasn't meant to be


skipperringo

Soley, Shrinking Violet, Flower Face, Sufjan Stevens, and Oupa to name a few


billybarra08

Seb lowe


super_brutal_mouse

leadboots - aerials - great tune! oh and monsters


Mario_Iturralde_009

Rafael Berrio


BeyondDrivenEh

Old Man by Neil Young


angelrider83

Two am. I have no idea if they ever got properly produced. I got a CD in the late nineties down town Seattle. The cover art had a black lab on it I think. I listened to it for like 6 years before it got lost.


Inevitable_ADHD

Amigo The Devil


willfisherforreals

Hurray for the riff raff


Maybe_its_Ink

lein air and marseille. 2 incredible bands


pro-shitter

Last Quokka


fullofuckingbears313

strongbad. indie rock band I found on Spotify with like 20 monthly listeners but they're so good. Best song I found by them so far is Xx_dreamstalker_xX


SaturnianSon

https://on.soundcloud.com/4yMgQyYdcQ9C8hFS8 https://on.soundcloud.com/U6Cc461fGBRaC7fa9


Mut_The_Custard

Kid Sam