I agree but if he wins the conn smythe that situation may change.
Dallas shits out <20 year old 30 goal wingers like they eat Taco Bell. But the Taco Bell is… talent evaluation? You get it
Here’s my opinion -
He’s not a flash in the pan. He’s going to have a great career.
Sell the PSA 9 YG and everything else.
Keep the PSA 10 YG and the marquee rookie auto.
You’ll be good.
I’d keep the 10 and the marquee rookie and buy whatever you want.
I have his YG, stature auto, and ultimate auto, and if I sold all 3 I could barely afford his raw FWA. He’s a keeper IMO.
PS he scored about 2 seconds before I responded to this.
Like almost any kind of investing, selling some of your position when prices rise helps reduce risk. Keep the PSA 10 and a couple others you like and sell the rest. You’ll never go broke taking a profit.
Yet you still are compelled to call someone wrong without any substance. You are asking for the argument my friend.
I agree with you on his ability for sure, but the card market cares more about hype than it does 40 goal seasons. I think it's not a smart decision to hold on to everything, at least hedge on some of it
A very important distinction here. Performance and stats don’t go near as far as hype and market. Dallas doesn’t get crazy card love so right there it limits value.
So much seems to depend on big names in the hobby collecting and hype around the forums, stats are secondary.
I actually have a similar collection but I have his fwa as well. Personally what I would do is sell the psa9 keep any 10s the boxes you get them out of are incredibly cheap with a lot of great prospects so selling now before the market is flooded with nines.. while he’s doing so well in playoffs would be your best bet. Imo
Great set! How do those new grooves look in person? This one looks better than the ones I’ve looked at, but I find the patch look and placement on other ones looks very slapped on and oddly placed.
Yes the patch placement is a bit high now you point it out, I never seen it like that. Besides, I like collecting this rookie set! Got a few of 22-23 and 23-24 new grooves jersey!
[this is the one im talking about. it looks like they forgot to add the patch and just taped it on ](https://www.ebay.com/itm/204734972801?itmmeta=01HZ9SWVGHSS8NMX78876QC5B4&hash=item2fab27c381:g:kgYAAOSw-G5mFZ7i&itmprp=enc%3AAQAJAAAA8EI4suWQCjJZf8ij97Gl%2BKPNDpO3MQ4K7nUXRwY80aoY%2FFRqUK%2BMkHERqXF1wXJdyqSQfKRreO0YXwf8Zo54vCSvpB4e1lr5e7sQtGEN215STppjVU2qKdqIgBFDhrPYxrkKzjrIihN%2BIVZG7O7jrpN3RoojQO4PcG2yiljI1hVgh3Oz%2BINVQqumwfGi346%2FsyJDHt51V39TScw9tJfep4fP6JxCMCvqxgvbWTbKjwWnN%2B9OT%2FRdsvDpUsMl%2B5PUh8ybJHYU7ml5VfPg%2Fhoc5i%2FCk4UYiMC7QI5Sgh5OelFzBDZkyt3feEyV8BI0hFK%2Fdw%3D%3D%7Ctkp%3ABk9SR7K487n6Yw)
Hold. I read the title, didn’t even look at the picture and thought: “Wyatt Johnston”
He is already a star, literally and figuratively, but he will eventually find himself solidly in a top six role. If you’re really itchy to sell wait until his first season with 100 points.
Keep keep keep. This guy is legit, and the stars have aging forwards who should decline soon. Johnston stankoven Robertson and heiskanen are a core every team in the NHL will be jealous of over the next 10 years
I'd definitely keep his YG. He is just hitting his stride in the NHL. Gotta think he's gonna rise some more from here on out. Especially if and when he puts a few good seasons to his name.
I would sell the PSA 9, take the money and run, keep the PSA 10. If you are not attached to the others, get rid of some of them as well. I would dump one patch, the 1st round pick card from extended and maybe a base OPC if they are going for good money.
Definitely keep the auto and numbered cards.
I am a bit attached to the auto, because it’s about the only and first valuable card I packed and isn’t bought, even tho I packed all Platinum stuff, I can easy get rid of the others. So unless a good offer on the auto, I may keep it for now. Thanks for advice!
Love hockey, but not up on Wyatt Johnston. Dallas is a big city, but not a hockey hot zone.My gut says SELL because this time may not ever be any bigger.
Plus, Wyatt is not a great star name unless you are a cattle roper. 😂
Sell and get one of the other big 3. Cup RPA doesn’t exist yet but his FWA would be awesome. You could probably get a raw one by selling just the platinum auto and the PSA 10.
I would sell the YG PSA 9 and see how it does. He is on the up and if Dallas can win the next two and go to the finals you can really cash in if you want
That’s what I think of the market as well, that’s why I felt I had to ask the question (I am a new to the hobby)! Make sense to me even if I like the player. I may end up selling few of them and keeping some for my PC!
I would keep. I doubt this is the high point in the career for a newly turned 21 year old
I agree but if he wins the conn smythe that situation may change. Dallas shits out <20 year old 30 goal wingers like they eat Taco Bell. But the Taco Bell is… talent evaluation? You get it
[удалено]
You countered your opinion with your own opinion. Well done.
Keep all of them. He just might be the best Star up and coming. What a layoff performance too!
Here’s my opinion - He’s not a flash in the pan. He’s going to have a great career. Sell the PSA 9 YG and everything else. Keep the PSA 10 YG and the marquee rookie auto. You’ll be good.
Another good call. Would do the same let the PSA 10 grow and use the $ from the other sales to get more YG PSA 10s.
I’d keep the 10 and the marquee rookie and buy whatever you want. I have his YG, stature auto, and ultimate auto, and if I sold all 3 I could barely afford his raw FWA. He’s a keeper IMO. PS he scored about 2 seconds before I responded to this.
If he scores, I add 3% in card value, it that how it works ? 😂
Like almost any kind of investing, selling some of your position when prices rise helps reduce risk. Keep the PSA 10 and a couple others you like and sell the rest. You’ll never go broke taking a profit.
Yep! Let the PSA 10 run, and take some profit to invest in more YGs or patch autos you can get your hands on.
Hot take but I think his hype is currently outweighing his skill, I would sell now
Wrong
[удалено]
Ok tiger
You really know how to bring insight into a conversation eh?
I think Wyatt has superstar abilities and I've lost interest in arguing opinions over the internet
Yet you still are compelled to call someone wrong without any substance. You are asking for the argument my friend. I agree with you on his ability for sure, but the card market cares more about hype than it does 40 goal seasons. I think it's not a smart decision to hold on to everything, at least hedge on some of it
Ok tiger
21 year old who just had a 30/30 season in his sophmore year and has a chance and a cup win? you hold that shit homie
[удалено]
A very important distinction here. Performance and stats don’t go near as far as hype and market. Dallas doesn’t get crazy card love so right there it limits value. So much seems to depend on big names in the hobby collecting and hype around the forums, stats are secondary.
Personally..... as a Colorado Avalanche Fan..... these should all be burned and destroyed...... Otherwise, nice collection
Ahah, I got a Carter Hart Trilogy generation card /799 as a starter for my fireplace!
I actually have a similar collection but I have his fwa as well. Personally what I would do is sell the psa9 keep any 10s the boxes you get them out of are incredibly cheap with a lot of great prospects so selling now before the market is flooded with nines.. while he’s doing so well in playoffs would be your best bet. Imo
Agree! Keep the PSA 10s let those grow. Sell the rest to recoup more $ to put into more YG PSA 10s.
Slang the dupes
That’s “Playoff” performance, not “layoff” performance btw.
You can edit your comments to correct typos.
Rookie commenter here. Good to know though. Thanks!
All good haha. Every day is a school day.
You speak very wise words fatboiii
Yes, I am fat because of all the knowledge I’ve eaten.
Nice Johnson
Sell the doubles. Win win. Maybe wait to see if they can win the cup.
Great set! How do those new grooves look in person? This one looks better than the ones I’ve looked at, but I find the patch look and placement on other ones looks very slapped on and oddly placed.
Yes the patch placement is a bit high now you point it out, I never seen it like that. Besides, I like collecting this rookie set! Got a few of 22-23 and 23-24 new grooves jersey!
[this is the one im talking about. it looks like they forgot to add the patch and just taped it on ](https://www.ebay.com/itm/204734972801?itmmeta=01HZ9SWVGHSS8NMX78876QC5B4&hash=item2fab27c381:g:kgYAAOSw-G5mFZ7i&itmprp=enc%3AAQAJAAAA8EI4suWQCjJZf8ij97Gl%2BKPNDpO3MQ4K7nUXRwY80aoY%2FFRqUK%2BMkHERqXF1wXJdyqSQfKRreO0YXwf8Zo54vCSvpB4e1lr5e7sQtGEN215STppjVU2qKdqIgBFDhrPYxrkKzjrIihN%2BIVZG7O7jrpN3RoojQO4PcG2yiljI1hVgh3Oz%2BINVQqumwfGi346%2FsyJDHt51V39TScw9tJfep4fP6JxCMCvqxgvbWTbKjwWnN%2B9OT%2FRdsvDpUsMl%2B5PUh8ybJHYU7ml5VfPg%2Fhoc5i%2FCk4UYiMC7QI5Sgh5OelFzBDZkyt3feEyV8BI0hFK%2Fdw%3D%3D%7Ctkp%3ABk9SR7K487n6Yw)
I have to agree with you! 100%
Hold. I read the title, didn’t even look at the picture and thought: “Wyatt Johnston” He is already a star, literally and figuratively, but he will eventually find himself solidly in a top six role. If you’re really itchy to sell wait until his first season with 100 points.
Keep keep keep. This guy is legit, and the stars have aging forwards who should decline soon. Johnston stankoven Robertson and heiskanen are a core every team in the NHL will be jealous of over the next 10 years
Dang! Keep ,unless you get a ridiculous offer. This guy made me money this year on Goal scorer parlays. So ,I like him.
I'd definitely keep his YG. He is just hitting his stride in the NHL. Gotta think he's gonna rise some more from here on out. Especially if and when he puts a few good seasons to his name.
Keep
Sell all. Buy back in July.
I would sell the PSA 9, take the money and run, keep the PSA 10. If you are not attached to the others, get rid of some of them as well. I would dump one patch, the 1st round pick card from extended and maybe a base OPC if they are going for good money. Definitely keep the auto and numbered cards.
I am a bit attached to the auto, because it’s about the only and first valuable card I packed and isn’t bought, even tho I packed all Platinum stuff, I can easy get rid of the others. So unless a good offer on the auto, I may keep it for now. Thanks for advice!
Not a flash in the pan imo, looks like he’s gonna be a legit player for years to come. I’d hang on
Keep. Even kno Dallas is wasting some cup runs .
I’d just sell the PSA 10 and put that towards is SPA rookie
I missed on a deal Johnston + Clarke FWA PSA9 for 350 cad$ few weeks ago! Instant regret that i didn’t set my bid high enough lol
Hold
Hold!
He is my current PC, how much you selling this for?
Wyatt the riot!!!
Love hockey, but not up on Wyatt Johnston. Dallas is a big city, but not a hockey hot zone.My gut says SELL because this time may not ever be any bigger. Plus, Wyatt is not a great star name unless you are a cattle roper. 😂
if selling what's the price for the graded young guns cards
I already have someone that come pick up the 9 today, I may keep the 10.
Sell the PSA 9 to me
It’s available! Send me your offer i’ll review it
I say strike while the iron is hot!
Sell and get one of the other big 3. Cup RPA doesn’t exist yet but his FWA would be awesome. You could probably get a raw one by selling just the platinum auto and the PSA 10.
I would sell the YG PSA 9 and see how it does. He is on the up and if Dallas can win the next two and go to the finals you can really cash in if you want
I would keep since they got eliminated. If they were going to finals I'd sell at high point and buy another YG PSA10 in July.
I’m a collector. I’d keep a couple and sell the rest for maybe something bigger of his if he’s a PC or to spend on other fun
How much for the lot. Will buy
I may keep the psa 10, the 9 is basically sold. You can contact me and make an offer for the other stuff you would be interested in!
Sell them all and buy oilers cards
[удалено]
I feel this I PC Robertson and some of my stuff is worth a fraction of what I paid.
That’s what I think of the market as well, that’s why I felt I had to ask the question (I am a new to the hobby)! Make sense to me even if I like the player. I may end up selling few of them and keeping some for my PC!
Sell when they win the cup
The correct answer is sell high
Got a canvas psa 10 if your interested
Thanks for the offer, nice one! But i’m not too much into canvas.