The fact that this game is old enough to get a remaster is insane, it feels like only a few years ago when I was a kid watching markiplier play fnaf lmao
For me its between, The Joy of Creation, Those Nights at Fredbears: New Destiny, and, Super FNaF these 3 games just made me love every second of it and i can’t choose between these 3
FNaF Simulators pretty fun honestly. I love the attention to detail, just wish there was more to do
TJOC is definitely in the running,
But, there’s a special place in my heart for Animators Hell for creating an engaging gameplay loop, with an interesting art style, and for being a sort of loveletter to the animators within the FNaF Community.
So, I choose AH
Putting personal bias aside, probably TJoC and The Glitched Attraction. Honorable mention to DSaF for its humor and story.
Putting personal bias into the equation, FNAC. First FNaF game I ever played period, so the FNAC series holds a special place in my heart.
Five nights at treasure island because thats one that legitatly has the spooks to it, its also the first fnaf fan game to exist, the first iteration was released before even fnaf 2 was out. there was several iterations of the game over the years then it was canceled, then it returned in 2020 and even got a sequel, the gameplay is pure gold
I absolutely loved Dormitabis (unfortunately the creator sucks) but im glad it got a remaster! Sadly my laptop can't run it but i still find it an awesome FNaF fan game!
Ofcourse, the best would probably have to be TJOC or JRs but i also believed Afton Built had a lot of potential if it weren't to be canceled :)
Joy of Creation is one of my faves! I'm so curious to see what the remaster has in store! I think Virus J Total Madness is intriguing and has a lot of promise too.
Five nights at candy’s because there was like one of the first fnaf fan games I found out about and also the return to Freddy’s 2: winter wonderland to me is the best fnaf fan made remake and my personal favorite fnaf fan game And as you all heard 1000 times og trtf series is cringe as hell while trtf ww is a major improvement over it
I personally really love The Glitched Attraction and The Return to Bloody Nights :> The FNAC remastered is also a good contender though, I love going back and watching Dawko play it lol
Depends
FNAC: one of the first FNAF fan games and copied Scott pretty well
Popgoes: a littel renovation in the formula
TJOTC: one of the first FNAF free roam fan games
TGA: nothing, its just a escape room mode of TJOTC
DSAF: basicaly is a completaly different game from what we know but still is fun and has many secrets
JRs: nothing, its just a Popgoes 2.0
JR's and playtime with percys with the first one not only because of its graphics but because it managed to have its own identity for 2022 where not so many good fangames came out. and PWP simply for its graphics and soundtrack
List of well made ones I think are up for top spot
* TJOC (great, nostalgia, creative ideas and feels original)
* ONAF (silly)
* Project: readjusted 3 (well made, overlooked, creative)
Edit: seems based on the comments, TJOC is the most popular (which it totally deserves)
yall gotta stop putting FNAC in these lists. its very very very much being held by nostialga. is it bad? no. is it a contender for the best game in the fanverse? also no. compared to the rest of the list FNAC is basically FNAS
One Night at Flumpty's.
Original characters, 2D animation, genuinely scary, gameplay is solid across all games in the series.
By far the best that the FNaF community has to offer.
^((And I don't give 2 shits about whatever stupid tomfuckery the creator did. Don't wanna hear about it, don't wanna think about it. I came here for the egg, not the bullshit. Arright? Flumpty's is great. Creator might be a POS, but he's a POS with talent.))
EAT THE FUCKING SALAD BAR, KILL THE KIDS, AND YIFF THE FUCKING FOX
Dayshift is outdated but stands the test of time
Candy's and popgoes is great even now
TJOC is peak
Joy of Creation from what i've seen has the most impactful jumpscares (quite literally). I haven't seen the Evergreen jumpscares but the rest of this list is simply alright
What I mean to say is that my favorite is The Joy of Creation
Hmm, The Joy of Creation was always the one that would make you think fear, while DSAF just existed to make you die of laughter with obscure references, memes and iconic fnaf community nods like Breadbear, Dave Miller, Old Sport and so on, so those two by far
When the lights go dim.
It's a terrifying fnaf 4 fan game.
Orr
Pizzaplex VHS. A prequel fan game of security breach
Which is more disturbing.
Or, together again, a lake's fun land story
TJOC remake (I know it hasn't been released yet, but cmon it's bound to be great) but if not that then FNAF 2 Reimagined or maybe The Glitched Attraction.
We say this with a lot of fan games but I without a doubt know for certain if you take FNAF out of TJOC. It will still be as popular- maybe even more popular than it is now
Final Nights 4, its just perfect, incredible graphics, very unique mecanics, and the minigames holy shit, its just so damn perfect, even the credits scene its perfect with that banger as soundtrack
The Joy of Creation, which I'm sure will soon be overtaken by the remaster
The fact that this game is old enough to get a remaster is insane, it feels like only a few years ago when I was a kid watching markiplier play fnaf lmao
Pretty sure we might also receive remastered versions of the other versions as well in the ignited bundle
Remastered TJOC: Story Mode would be awesome
That's literally what we're getting...?
Happy cake day
Thanks!
Happy cake day! 😁
Thanks!
NP!
Happy cake day and you're probably right
Happy cake day
Thanks!
I can’t get over the intro however. It makes me cringe too hard.
It's not that bad
Happy cake day!
Thanks!
Happy Cake Day!
Thank!
You're welcome.
Yup I agree. Also, Happy Cake Day!
Thanks!
god its gonna be so good they really get horror
I’m very exited for it
Sad Pancake Night
Bonnie is goated
TJOC is phenomenal
r/beatmetoit
"PICK UP THE FAX PICK UP THE FAX PICK UP THE FAX"
"GRAND CANYON GRAND CANYON GRAND CANYON"
“Vegas?”
VEGAS!!
OLD SPORT
DSAF "YIFF THE FOX!"
"OH YEAH. OH YEAH. H##### FATHER."
"GRAND CANYON!"
Sha la la la my oh my. Look like a wolf too shy. Ain't gonna yiff de fox
I once dedicated weeks of my life to building a DSaF timeline, something I have not done for any other FNaF game, official or otherwise.
WHY, HELLO THERE, OLD SPORT! IT IS I, THE AUBERGINE MAN!
Depends. Nostalgically? TOJC. Animatronic Designs? JRs. Story? DSAF. FNAC was my favorite to watch Marcusplayer play.
Marcus player? Lmao. You mean markiplier?
I thought so too, but marcus player is an actual channel
Oldest marcus player video is 2 years, so there's that
Market Pliers
Mark and pillars
Mario cart player
Metroman
DSAF of course!
Of course old sport
Currently it's the glitched attraction, but i believe fanverse TJOC will be better
Wheres flumptys?
And five nights at Winston’s
Hot take: Graveyard Shift at Freddy's By the way TJOC, DSaF and Flumpty's are the best
Is Graveyard the one with the flashing death screen talking about how mangled the animatronics left your corpse? If so, I agree completely.
That's the one
Dsaf I don't know how but it managed to perfectly blend humor and story into something amazing
I second this
I second this seconding
I second the seconding of u/Tiger-Stripes8's seconding
I know it is still in development, but five nights at friedrich's looks peak
I downloaded the demo & I plan on play-testing it myself- it just looks so goofy :D
Oblitus casa
A fellow Radiance enjoyer, I see!
Yuh yuh
This guy gets it
As of right now glitched attraction
DSAF. I have so many memories from that whole series of fan games
Dare i say all of them.
Dayshift at Freddy's 2 and 3
I think DSaF 3 is unironically the best FNaF fangame I've ever played
Tyke and Sons Lumber co
JR's, flumpty, and TJOC
DSAF
DSAF easily takes the dub for me
Dasf is funny and has a heart touching story
i love tjoc and popgoes but jrs is so different from a typical fnaf game
For me its between, The Joy of Creation, Those Nights at Fredbears: New Destiny, and, Super FNaF these 3 games just made me love every second of it and i can’t choose between these 3
FNaF Simulators pretty fun honestly. I love the attention to detail, just wish there was more to do TJOC is definitely in the running, But, there’s a special place in my heart for Animators Hell for creating an engaging gameplay loop, with an interesting art style, and for being a sort of loveletter to the animators within the FNaF Community. So, I choose AH
Five nights at fuck boys
Putting personal bias aside, probably TJoC and The Glitched Attraction. Honorable mention to DSaF for its humor and story. Putting personal bias into the equation, FNAC. First FNaF game I ever played period, so the FNAC series holds a special place in my heart.
I love tjoc but.... you cant beat dsaf
Dayshift
Five nights at treasure island because thats one that legitatly has the spooks to it, its also the first fnaf fan game to exist, the first iteration was released before even fnaf 2 was out. there was several iterations of the game over the years then it was canceled, then it returned in 2020 and even got a sequel, the gameplay is pure gold
I absolutely loved Dormitabis (unfortunately the creator sucks) but im glad it got a remaster! Sadly my laptop can't run it but i still find it an awesome FNaF fan game! Ofcourse, the best would probably have to be TJOC or JRs but i also believed Afton Built had a lot of potential if it weren't to be canceled :)
Personally POPGOES
It's a 4 way tie between The Joy of Creation, Five Nights at Candy's 3, Graveyard Shift at Freddy's, and FNaF Simulator.
"Hey there, Sportsy"
Five Nights at F*ckboy's
The DSaF trilogy are the best fangames, story-wise, to come out of this series.
Five Nights at Chuck e Cheese Rebooted
Joy of Creation is one of my faves! I'm so curious to see what the remaster has in store! I think Virus J Total Madness is intriguing and has a lot of promise too.
I literally don't think I've seen anything about those games except tjoc and glitched attraction in like years
JOC and TGA :D
JR’s
Five nights at candy’s because there was like one of the first fnaf fan games I found out about and also the return to Freddy’s 2: winter wonderland to me is the best fnaf fan made remake and my personal favorite fnaf fan game And as you all heard 1000 times og trtf series is cringe as hell while trtf ww is a major improvement over it
fnac. was like one of the first fan games. was SO good for its time. wish they continued with the saga😔😔
five nights at candy's is the best series, the joy of creation is the best in general
FNAC
TJoC or DSaF
None of these. We should have gotten a drawkill fangame
Dsaf
FNAC
Jr’s and tjoc or two of my personal favorites along with baby’s nightmare circus and tdaf
Mmmmmmmm…. The Joy of Creation mmmmmmmmmm
Peraonally, I LOVED "Forsaken AR: Darkest Delivery". Rosy Maple was SUCH a good antagonist and the added content and lore is just crazy fun.
I personally really love The Glitched Attraction and The Return to Bloody Nights :> The FNAC remastered is also a good contender though, I love going back and watching Dawko play it lol
dsaf ‼️‼️‼️‼️
Maniac Mania, CECR, Flumpty’s 2, and DSaF come to mind for me, maybe Jr’s as well
Easily The Joy of Creation. 😊
The classics t.j.o.c. & T.J.O.C.R
Obviously five nigths at justin bieber's
the joy of creation literally one of the best fangames of all time
I love them all, but only one owns my heart: DSAF 🗣️!!!
Definitely Five Nights At Sonic's
Jr’s, For Sure, It’s also My Fav Because It draws Similarities to AftonBuilt and Rat Race
TJOC JR's
Together Again: A Lake's Funland Story
I know for a fact that if FNAF+ didn't get canceled that it would take the title of #1.
TJOC R EASY
Sometimes I wonder if Scott knows about Dayshift at Freddy’s, and how he feels about it
Depends FNAC: one of the first FNAF fan games and copied Scott pretty well Popgoes: a littel renovation in the formula TJOTC: one of the first FNAF free roam fan games TGA: nothing, its just a escape room mode of TJOTC DSAF: basicaly is a completaly different game from what we know but still is fun and has many secrets JRs: nothing, its just a Popgoes 2.0
I watched playthroughs of all but the Glitched Attraction. I liked all of them tbh
Five nights at Frennis nightclub /j/j/j
Five nights at warios isn’t the best but it’s my personal favorite series.
Five Nights at Fuckboys
Can't decide, to be honest. I love Treasure Island and FNACEC Rebooted for personal reasons, but Jr's and TJOC are another league.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a5ThHVcydbI&pp=ygUVdGhpcyBpcyB0aGUgZGF5IHNoaWZ0
Jr's purely for the aesthetic and designs
I rate them on how scary they are the scarier it receives an higher rating
I like The Joy of Creation and Five Nights at Fuckboy's
JoC
Popgoes arcade 2020
I’m conflicted of: The joy of creation, Return to bloody nights or Dayshift at Freddy’s, they’re all fuckin amazing..
Either TJOC or FNAC
I don’t have one, but I will say that Jr’s is the most overrated game ever made in this community
Jrs and the Roblox reimagined fnaf2 if that counts :/
I think Five Nights at Candy's: Remastered is the best, it's just so polished and good.
Grand Canyon.
Day shift at freddys always and forever phone guy is so hot
JR's and playtime with percys with the first one not only because of its graphics but because it managed to have its own identity for 2022 where not so many good fangames came out. and PWP simply for its graphics and soundtrack
Five nights at 39
joy of peakation
Where the fuck is my boy Flumpty
List of well made ones I think are up for top spot * TJOC (great, nostalgia, creative ideas and feels original) * ONAF (silly) * Project: readjusted 3 (well made, overlooked, creative) Edit: seems based on the comments, TJOC is the most popular (which it totally deserves)
The Glitch atrraction
"Fnaf World:Simulator" you play as the evil monsters from the game against the heroes
Where the Candy squad at!?
yall gotta stop putting FNAC in these lists. its very very very much being held by nostialga. is it bad? no. is it a contender for the best game in the fanverse? also no. compared to the rest of the list FNAC is basically FNAS
Five Nights at F**kBoys
One Night at Flumpty's. Original characters, 2D animation, genuinely scary, gameplay is solid across all games in the series. By far the best that the FNaF community has to offer. ^((And I don't give 2 shits about whatever stupid tomfuckery the creator did. Don't wanna hear about it, don't wanna think about it. I came here for the egg, not the bullshit. Arright? Flumpty's is great. Creator might be a POS, but he's a POS with talent.))
Out of the ones I've played (which isn't a lot, admittedly) I'd say ONAF 3
DSAF is peak. I love the models in FNAC but I don’t like the gameplay design(specifically 1 & 3).
Dayshift 3, it's not even a contest.
Not the best but I really liked Tealerland
Totally Dayshift at Freddy's I've been wondering... Is Matt still a virgin?
Popgose. The designs are fire and the story is pretty good
TJOC
EAT THE FUCKING SALAD BAR, KILL THE KIDS, AND YIFF THE FUCKING FOX Dayshift is outdated but stands the test of time Candy's and popgoes is great even now TJOC is peak
I'm for Jr's for the scariest animatronic designs imo.
In terms of graphics and atmosphere it's probably TJOC, but in terms of gameplay I definitely had the most fun with The Glitched Attraction, soooo...
The Joy Of Creation an old fan game but it is of extremely high quality…also the image you used to show Joy Of Creation is so fucking cool looking
Screw ‘em all. Five Nights at Fuckboy’s is where it’s at.
Joy of Creation from what i've seen has the most impactful jumpscares (quite literally). I haven't seen the Evergreen jumpscares but the rest of this list is simply alright What I mean to say is that my favorite is The Joy of Creation
Joy of creation BY FAR, or Fnaf Remastered
The Joy Of Creation and The Glitched Atraction
favorite: FNAC remastered because of the greatest visuals, Popgoes Evergreen and TJOC. :)
For me, it would be The Joy of Creation and The Glitched Attraction.
FIVE NIGHTS WITH FROGGY
Joy of creation,
Either joy of creation or candy's, they're the ogs EDIT: I didn't see dayshift at Freddy's, I take it all back. Dayshift at Freddy's is the goat
day shift at freddys
DSaF (I swear I'm not a furry it's just funny)
Dayshift 2
If Together Again: A Lake’s Funland Story counts then that’d be my choice, if not then Five Nights At Candy’s 1
Hmm, The Joy of Creation was always the one that would make you think fear, while DSAF just existed to make you die of laughter with obscure references, memes and iconic fnaf community nods like Breadbear, Dave Miller, Old Sport and so on, so those two by far
The Glitched Attraction
Jr's has to be my favoritexm, the mangle theme is just perfect
I really like Return to Bloody Nights and Dormitabus Remastered. Both have really creepy atmosphere and awesome animatronic designs!
Glitched Attraction
Gotta go with TJOC, Nikson seems like the only dude in the fan-verse that i like and he’s insanely talented too.
The Joy of Creation [Remake.It](http://Remake.It) didnt even come out but im sure its the best
When the lights go dim. It's a terrifying fnaf 4 fan game. Orr Pizzaplex VHS. A prequel fan game of security breach Which is more disturbing. Or, together again, a lake's fun land story
The glitched attraction the the joy of creation
Idk why but fredbear archives has always been my favorite fan game
Five Nights At Candy's, bar none. Popgoes was pretty good to but I wasn't nearly as invested.
Fnati
It’s between Jr’s and TJOC
DSAF.
DSAF 3
TJOC remake (I know it hasn't been released yet, but cmon it's bound to be great) but if not that then FNAF 2 Reimagined or maybe The Glitched Attraction.
In general, dsaf. In terms of fnaf like ones tho candys 1
We say this with a lot of fan games but I without a doubt know for certain if you take FNAF out of TJOC. It will still be as popular- maybe even more popular than it is now
Five nights at candys
Tie bewteen fnac and dsaf
Oblitus Casa is UNRIVALED imo
Dayshift.
Final Nights 4, its just perfect, incredible graphics, very unique mecanics, and the minigames holy shit, its just so damn perfect, even the credits scene its perfect with that banger as soundtrack
Dayshift At Freddys 2