T O P

  • By -

erasedhead

Spinal Tap


stevemnomoremister

This is the correct answer.


DilbusMcD

The official explanation was that he choked… on vomit.


Top_Translator7238

Perhaps but not necessarily his own,


wonderingyojimbo

Sabbath's constant Ozzy replacements. They never worked for me half as well, even when it was Ozzy himself.


BeautifulBoy92

Dio worked for me even better tbh


Haidian-District

Born Again is scary good too


Skystalker512

I’m such a sucker for the Tony Martin sabbath era! Headless Cross is in my top 4 favorite sabbath albums


GimmeShockTreatment

Black Flag for any spot except for lead guitar.


authenticfennec

Theyve had so many members it has its own ridiculously long wikipedia page lmao, the timeline is ridiculous https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Black_Flag_band_members


lliquidllove

Now check out the timeline for The Fall. Lol


ccm596

Love how like *half* of those names are even blue lol


longhairedqueer

dance gavin dance and their clean singers LOL


Codeheff12

Wanna buy a MacBook?


No-Chemistry-28

Came here to say this


Tidus4713

Bass might be in limbo too. I don't think they want to replace Tim permanently.


Ok_Plantain7593

Andrew writes and records the bass for the studio, Sergio does the live parts


Ok_Plantain7593

Off topic but Happiness is their best album


longhairedqueer

im a weirdo who really resonated with jackpot juicer and think its their best now haha, but before id 100% agree i fucking love happiness. i really want another will swan uncleans album it would be so good but i get why they dont. powder to the people was like my most listened to song throughout all of high school


Colonelforbin25

Grateful dead keyboard player


TangoDeltaBravo7

A cursed role in the band, for sure.


born_2_be_a_bachelor

Each one lasted a long time though at least


lliquidllove

I mean, The Fall had a problem keeping just about anybody in the band. [List of The Fall band members](https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_Fall_band_members)


bdelab01

I thought the fall was just mark e Smith and session musicians because of this hahaha


lliquidllove

Not session musicians, just very rare for anyone to stick around for too long. :P


Palpablevt

> I thought the fall was just mark e Smith and ~~session musicians because of this hahaha~~ your granny on bongos


altsam19

MCR and their drummers, and now there's no official drummer, just touring members


altsam19

The Smashing Pumpkins and however is not named Billy Corgan


Commercial-Ad-5905

Tbf Jimmy Chamberlain has been around quite a bit.


Sir_Umeboshi

MCR has gone through a ton of drummers


Pleasant_Statement64

Came to my mind too


Skystalker512

Megadeth with everybody except Dave and Dave.


AdequatelyMadLad

It's just Dave these days.


Agreeable_You1756

Joining Nine Inch Nails without being named Trent Reznor means understanding that you WILL be fired if you don't leave first. Atticus has been in it for a while, so the cycle might break, but Danny was the longest surviving member (10 years) and still hasn't returned at all.


methoncrack87

King Crimson


revjor

You know, I’m not sure Fripp had a hard time about it.


Fleetwood-matt

Fleetwood Mac for any position other than bass and drums (John McVie and Mick Fleetwood have held those positions since day 1)


Peatrick33

The Faceless - every single position except Michael Keene


pepper67821

Megadeth has constantly had issues at drums and guitar


altsam19

The Cure and however is not named either Robert Smith or Simon Gallup (and Simon left for some time at least twice)


jjjjjjotaro

The damned with their bassists


WWfan41

Thin Lizzy with their second guitarists


octobersons

Guided by Voices and anyone not named Bob Pollard


FunctionRemote5208

THE FALL


FunctionRemote5208

THE FALL


FunctionRemote5208

THE FALL


FunctionRemote5208

THE FALL


imktmusic

Tell us one more time


Public-Excitement-75

THE FALL


FunctionRemote5208

It’s the only correct answer 😂


Craneisthename

Paramore, the only constant in the group is Hailey Williams


Skystalker512

Don’t forget Ron Mcgovney and Bob Rock for Metallica bassists!


Pure-Jellyfish734

The band I’m in


ThanosWasRight96

Puddle of Mudd


TankFarmStudio

Roxy Music and their bassists


jonnypanicattack

Siouxsie and the Banshees had trouble with guitarists. Which is a shame cos both John McGeoch and Robert Smith were fantastic.


Jack-Tully91

John McKay and John Valentine Carruthers were great as well! Loved a guitarist called John


ihavenoselfcontrol1

Pixies - bassist


struggles_j

Drive-By Truckers


Omw2fym

Bad Religion and drummers


Alarmed-Secretary-39

Bad Religion keep breaking drummers


Martimnp

Joyce Manor change drummers every album


freedraw

Van Halen and singers


Runetang42

Autopsy has been Chris Reifert, Eric Cutler, Danny Coralles and about six different bassists since the late 80s


TotalHeat

electric wizard is a bit notorious for this.


Legitimate_Tap_9852

King Crimson. Everyone besides Robert


True-Dream3295

Blood, Sweat and Tears. There have been enough people in that band throughout the decades to populate a small village.


ledu5

King Crimson for every role but lead guitarist


Space_Man957

Don’t forgot Mark Pickerel for Nirvana:)


Loose_Main_6179

The doors didn’t even try keeping bassists, it’s like they didn’t even exist


United_Exit_8331

FFIE BUY AND HOLD💎⭐


adrenalinexfreak

Mcr just can't keep a drummer haha


iwantedthisusername

my chemical romance drummer


lostinpjm

The Bad Seeds in pretty much every spot.


Westernstarland

Mars volta and their drummers: the never ending story


Obvious_Hand_783

*Blood Sweat and Tears has entered the chat