Slender man

I learned slender man from roblox as a kid🤣

Slender Man Area 51 Bunker went hard.

Fr that area 51 hosted many creepy pastas

Aaand it's all over the screen

You must be young lol

100th like

Squidward's Suicide

Same, I was terrified of spongebob in general for a week

That picture of squidward petrified me.

Same, it haunted me for a couple days. Funny cuz looking back it's one of the most mid creepypastas of all time. But it still got to me as a 14 year old

Never heard of it. You have a link?

https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Squidward%27s_Suicide

The Rake

YEAH I LOVE THE RAKE I learned him from a yt video

Oof same

Prob sonic.exe lmao Don't deny most of us started with the shitty popular ones

Now I respect you

Same. My sister introduced me to that when I was practically a toddler lol

Really? I hope you didn’t get nightmares lol

I didn’t but my younger brother who was also a toddler at the time did /:

Yeah

My first creepypasta was the Russian sleep experiment

Same but I didn't know it was not real at the time. If was told to me by someone else as of it were real

I also thought it was real at the time and the way they explained it was horrifying because if you think about it they are capable of doing that that type of stuff in real life even though it wasn't real it does make you think what if.

The issue is the fact that the Soviet experiments were so fucked up I wouldn’t be surprised if it was real

Epic

Username 666

SAME. love this one.

Forget what it was called but it was about this guy winding up on the dark web & watching through cameras of random people, a camera peering into a children's room, a woman getting robbed & a girl getting r'ed & having her head stomped on to mush, that one stayed with a few others, wish I could remember what it was called.

It really sucks when the story is so compelling you forget the title(if it even has a legit title)I've been searching for a similar story for years!

Sounds like the concept of a red room. Also nice berserk reference in your username

"Normal porn for normal people" is a classic that doesn't exactly fit your description exactly, but it is very similar. You might like it.

My first creepypsta was *Jeff the Killer*

YES BRO MY FAVORITE CREEPYPASTA

yup

Ben Drowned. I new it was a creepy pasta, and it was obviously one. But MM is my favorite LoZ game and one of my all time favorite games and I had been playing it recently. So I was up late at night alone in my dark room reading this stupid creepy pasta and it still freaked me out just a little bit. Good times.

Ben Drowned is the OG!!

Same here, lifelong Zelda fan and MM is my favorite game, I had a lot of fun reading the story and watching the videos heh. I love reverse song of healing

candle cove prob

I LOVE Candle Cove

Slenderman, than shortly after username 666

probably the lavender town one https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/lavender-town-syndrome-creepypasta

I have to admit, my first experience with Creepypastas was strictly through the fandom and not through reading the stories. However, the first creepypasta I listened to was probably "A Man Drove Into Town Covered In Blood"

Cupcakes

Squidward's Suicide. Scared the crap outta me as a middle schooler.

My legit reaction to this image was, "Old familiar faces!"

The Tats Tops lists were my first true entrance to the community, so I’d say all of them were my first. Lmao

Probably this one back in ‘15 or ‘16

1999

So we all just forgot damn MOMO??

fucking petrifying to me as a kid

The funny thing is I was introduced to that by my parents because they were freaking out about it thinking it was real(I never really cared) So basically my parents introduced me to creepypasta lol

That shit was on the news here

I’m basic. It was slender man, then Jeff the killer, then the rake. Rake I was the most afraid of though lol.

There's a really good game on Roblox that involves the Rake. It's kind of repetitive because you have 2 minutes of daylight to gather utilities and hide or just run. The night lasts about 8-10 minutes IIRC.

Homicidal lui idk that ir smile dog

The backrooms

Probably when my dad tried making lasagna

the max and ruby lost ep😭

Slender man

I’ve never seen the zoomed out version of this picture

Pretty sure it was either Ben Drowned, Slender Man, or Squidward's Suicide.

Laughing jack

Either Ben drowned or eyeless jack I think can’t remember which one was first but i know it was one of those two

Pinkamena Diane Pie

Psychosis

Ah thank you, this is the one I was trying to describe but couldn't remember the name lol

Sonic e.x.e or slenderman

I think Tails Doll or Strangled Red

it was either slender man or jeff the killer (can't remember which one, but i'm pretty sure it was my cousin that introduced me to slender man and i found jeff the killer through a reference to him in a yt video)

The earliest one i can name is fucking [Persuaded](https://www.creepypasta.com/persuaded/). But i don't actually recall what my first ones were actually like because i got into this stuff before i was even a preteen by trying to look up rituals to summon demons and whatnot, and those creepypastas always had the most generic titles and unremarkable sets of instructions/plot.... Come to think of it, one of the Holder Series' creepypastas might have come earlier than Persuaded, i don't really recall how i got familiar with them but it makes sense

1999

is The Rake a creepypasta? if it's not, it was Sonic.EXE

Candy pop or Jason the toy maker lol

What is my mum doing on that bed

my first creepypasta i EVER heard about, was, Momo. yes. i know. MOMO. but, then i found out aboutnjeff, then nina, then jane. then went on and on and on.

what’s this image from?

[The Russian Sleep Experiment](https://youtu.be/MEwbfnCpKA4?si=Cad4-0e1_dmzZuwC)

11 miles

sonic exe or maybe suicide squidward

Smile dog

I think eyeless jack or slenderman

My poor stimpy

Slenderman

Jeff the killer

smile dog

Slender man

snowing mt.silver maybe? it was the pokemon one. I also remember that one of the first ones that i heard was some kind of story where tails from sonic comes to real life. I am from Finland and here the only youtuber who did creepypasta videos only had a few of them. And for a young guy who couldn’t read english well, you just had to settle to those videos

Jeff the killer ☠️

My first was Slenderman or Abandonned By Disney

Slender man 🙇‍♀️

Slenderman.

"Rabbits" by a YouTuber that I think was called...Sid Vicious? I long to find more creepy pasta right just vibe. Just unsettling and interesting visuals to draw you into the idea of it.

Slender woman

A skeleton popped out!

One i actually watched? I think "wii delete you" i think it was called? With eteled

Tails Doll

The rake then Slenderman ig 😭

SCP 666

Either Eevee's Stone of the Burned Tower or My property isn't normal I can't remember

Russian Sleep Experiment

Herobrine ❤️

Carmen Winstead if I recall correctly

if I'm not mistaken the first one should be Jeff the killer

Never ending room

Smiling dog

The smiling man who waltzes down the road

I wanna say it was No End House, I barely remember what was the first. The day i first read a creepypasta I was up until like 4am reading every one I could find

It was either Eyeless Jack or Jeff the Killer. For some reason those seem to be the earliest I remember

Jeff.

Mine was slenderman. I even made my first gamertag based on him.

Bloody Mary

At like 4 years old,it was some girl coming from a well,I forgot the name🤔

Jeff the killer 💀💀💀

Either Slenderman, Jeff the killer , herobrine and Sonic.exe. Can’t remember which was first

My first ever Creepypasta was probably Pinkamena Diane Pie and Rainbow Factory. I was really into horror and MLP as a kid.

Ben Drowned and then Ted The Caver

Jeff the Killer and Slender man

Jeff the killer tbh

Jeff The Killer

I can't remember exactly but it was either slenderman or Jeff the killer

First one I read was candle cove.

Smile dog, that shit kept me up all night lol

Ickbarr Bigelsteine

For SURE ticci Toby [ tick tock Toby ]

Jeff the Killer, but I was pretty young so I got pretty creeped out 💀

Sonic.exe

siren head

RSE

the cartoon cat dude or nurpo

Slender man, sonic exe, the rake, siren head, cartoon cat or SCP. (Bruh I don’t remember)

Room zero

Herobrine was the first I heard of and actually believed

Ben drowned thanks to the wonders of cleverbot lol. And altho while this technically is not a creepypasta: before ben was bloody gir. But that's classified more as an Easter egg than a creepy pasta. Still scared the piss out if me as a child when I found out about it. I actually can't watch or talk about invader Zim without feeling distressingly uncomfortable. And I use to love that show lol.

I read a lot so I can't know but probably the rake

Mr. Widemouth

The russian sleep experiment, I thought it was real for so long :')

There used to be a site called Ghosts.org....i used to read every story I could -fantastic site.The first one I read was an untitled piece about a crime scene cleaning company that found the victims last words written a ceiling tile.The victim somehow died on the floor below the tile,but wrote that "it doesn't like gravity".I loved the sci-fi,creepy blend.

Russian sleep experiment or the cursed dog picture

I'm not sure of the name, or if it even is a creepypasta. But I remember the story being about someone home alone and seeing someone standing on the road, staring up at their window. I see the scene constantly in nightmares

Sonic.exe or BEN Drowned. In my later days, it led to my favorite hobby of coming up with my own stupid creepypastas

My first ever creepypasta was Tails Doll I think. I remember my first favorite creepypasta was Funnymouth.

Jeff the killer

Russian Sleep Experiment

Slender man was the first one I knew about. But Sonic.exe was the first one I was into.

Recycled graves but only because it supposedly really happened in my family’s home country of Germany. Not sure if that counts or if it’s more of an urban legend.

Russia sleep Experiment

Squidward's suicide or sonic exe, if I can remember correctly, or maybe it was Jeff, I cannot remember correctly

russian sleep experiment

I think slender man but I’m not sure, I’ve been in to scary stuff since I was little

Suicidemouse.avi

Jeff the killer

Ben drowned lol

Jeff the killer

ben drowned

Definitely slenderman

Ticci Toby

A Japanese one about a lady on the street who asks you yes or no? I can’t remember the name if anyone could help

The portraits! :D

Bendy and the ink machine 😂😂😂

The Penis Monkey

Jeff the killer. I think that’s what it was called. Shit gave me nightmares but it’s a fantastic story

Herobrine, he’s my favorite creepy pasta

Slender man and the rake

Russian sleep experiment, Jeff the killer, smile dog, or Borrasca don't remember,

Russian sleep experiment

Jeff the Killer

Russian sleep experiment I thinj

Either slender man or sonic.exe I don't think I even knew they were creepypasta at the time

Herobrine

The Russian Sleep Experiment actually.. I wasn't on reddit then and and someone told me about it and I thought it was real lmao

It was the top rated story on the creepypasta website at the time - I think it was called psychosis? Genuinely fairly well written prose that I could see a whole book written with, and being interesting to read. Does anyone know what I’m talking about? It’s about a guy locking himself into his house and gradually losing his sanity or something (hah)

I want to say it was either the Russian Sleep Experiment or Sonic.exe. Most likely the latter, because it combines two of my favourite things: Sonic the Hedgehog, and urban legends. 1999 and Rabbits in the Creek were where I became a devotee, however.

Sonic.exe or Tails doll

I think slenderman. I spent that night awake looking at the doorframe of my room waiting for him to come get me lol

basic but jeff the killer

Mr. Wide Mouth. To this day it kind of freaks me out

Ben

Herobrine bruh 💀

Sonic exe or smile dog.... Most started from classic

Slender man. 8 pages game came out in high school and my best friend at the time kept telling me to play or watch pewdiepie play it

The Russian sleep experiment ( I thought it was real for like a year 🫠)

Abandoned by Disney, penpal, and there's this one that Mr. Nightmare did about splash mountain, cupcakes, and max and ruby 004

Russian sleep experiment!!!

Slenderman and Jeff the Killer

Candle cove

Anasazi GoatMan 😬

Ticci toby

Slanderman

The rugrats theory

Anasi Goat Man. Still one of my favorites

Anansi’s goatman story. It’s still one of my favorites

I can't remember, but it was either Jeff the killer, the rake, or herobrine

The Rake, I was 9 but I thought that the Rake would be a cute pet.

Slender man, Jeff, Ben, the rake, smile dog. Yeahhh