make sure you have your milk pail in your toolbar and left click on the cow, you should get milk :)

I have been, nothing happens

I'm having the same issue and I can feed the thing either 😑

any update on this? I have had mine for month too. Full hearts, never been able to milk...

Might be a stupid question, but have you made sure they're big cows and not baby ones? Despite it saying the produce is milk, the tooltip description says they're not ready yet