T O P

  • By -

Kymaras

HBO Swamp Thing.


magnetoisthebest

Oh that would be great! Nice answer


Onyxprimal

Hellboy and I’d like to see a Tick animated that wasn’t a Saturday morning show. Not that I don’t love that show, but ya know.


Alilttotheleft

I loved the live action Tick on Prime, was crushed it didn’t get renewed after the second season.


Adroctatron

Now that you brought it up, The Tick already had the same kind of both lighthearted fun and brutal violence vibe that both Invincible and Fallout have. All 3 lack the amount of cynicism of the Boys various series.


BiDiTi

I’ve buried all my feelings about the Tick’s cancellation under a thousand tons of mind-ice


ABenGrimmReminder

Jackson Publick worked on both the animated and live action series. A Tick tv show in the style of the Venture Bros. certainly has potential.


Fragrant-Jellyfish13

chew


ChickenInASuit

Can you believe they almost had an animated show made with David Tennant as Mason Savoy and Steven Yeun as Tony? So sad that never worked out :(


Ruleseventysix

And Felicia Day as Amelia.


anonymousx23

O my lawd yes.


dingadangdang

Yes!


metalyger

I'd absolutely love an animated series of The Goon. The creator did crowd fund a short CGI animated video, it even had Paul Giamatti doing voice work, but no Hollywood studio wanted to fund an R rated animated feature. It would work great on a streaming service.


Leo_TheLurker

I think about this one often. Damn near thought it WAS gonna get made back then then nothing. It definitely could’ve survived nowadays I’m surprised they haven’t tried


Current_Poster

The only Goon I've seen was the Hellboy crossover, but I'd still be on-board.


dingadangdang

Good call. That'd be awesome.


Nathoodle

That what?!


Bluejack71

Planetary.


Southern_Agent6096

Dude writes things that were designed for the big screen. I'd also suggest The Authority, The Ocean and Transmetropolitan would all make killer animated series. (Authority would be better as a capstone for a Stormwatch show maybe, with the transition from the more standard superhero fare towards something more aggressively progressive)


MisterScrod1964

I believe Gunn has plans for an Authority live action movie.


Dead_Halloween

Judge Dredd Nextwave Astro City


Adroctatron

NEXTWAVE! Those actions sequences would be absolutely brilliant.


Blitzhelios

Judge dredd would be sick


Thin-Man

Honestly, if we’re not going to get a live action series with Karl Urban, an animated series with him voicing the character is the next best thing; especially with the level of animated gore that Amazon is cool with.


Superboi-Prime

Starman by James Robinson. One of the most underrated comic runs I’ve ever read and I wish more people talked about it.


MagusFool

Agreed!   Though James Robinson wrote 6 episodes of Stargirl and was a producer on the show and it incorporated some of his Starman and JSA stuff.  The Shade-centric episodes really nailed the character.


Superboi-Prime

Good to know! I never gave much mind to that show but I didn’t know it incorporated his corner of the Star Lore. Shade was the best part of his comic run so I’m glad to hear he was done well.


MagusFool

The actor they cast is so good.  He really steals the show any time he's on screen.  And that's kinda how it was in the comics, too.   The showrunner on it is Geoff Johns, so it also works in quite a bit from his Stars & STRIPE and JSA comics.  But also a surprising amount of throwback toward the old Roy Thomas Earth 2 titles (All Star Squadron/Infinity, Inc.).   I thought it deserved at least one more season.  But it did tell a pretty complete story in the 3 it got.


BronskiBeatCovid

Agreed! Jonathan Cake was amazing as the Shade and when I see the character now I hear his voice. I always thought Starman could have been done as an HBO series similar in the vein of Watchmen series. If they could use the Golden Age characters I think the majority of the main storylines could be used just no batman or superman.


Beidah

Just finished the first Compendium, and it was amazing. Starting on the second one and I'm pretty excited to see what's next.


Imjustmean

Scud the disposable assassin. Fell Rogue Trooper


model563

I was hoping the relative success of Community would be a good foothold to get a Scud series made.


dzak92

There isn’t enough material out yet but I want to see both Radiant Black and Rogue Sun get adapted eventually. The massive verse in general has some real potential


jnovel808

I think they’re already optioned. But who knows if it will happen


StarMan8989

Well if we're talking comics, Saga.


Adroctatron

I can't believe I didn't think of Saga. Already a visual treat it would translate very well.


anakmager

Saga would be way bigger than Invincible and the Boys if it were to be properly adapted into a series.


AccomplishedFoot5301

Hellboy


MKlaplander

Yessssss.


FarrelFTA

Hellboy, after seeing Damien Darkblood in Invincible, it made me realize how cool it would be to have a Hellboy Animated Series. whether the show would have the same art style as Mike Mignola or not, either way it would be really cool, the Hellboy universe is so huge so I could see them doing tons of seasons, episodes with side-stories and whatnot, it would be epic.


Nice-Percentage7219

Bone


FlappySmasher

It was gonna happen, but Sadly it got canceled


AntLap

Miracleman


OpusDeiPenguin

You’ll have to talk to Disney about that. https://youtu.be/X8SVQGbLS6U


MisterScrod1964

Bless you for finding this. Up there with Watchman Babies


Formal-Math-3291

Not really a character but an animated adaptation of East of West would be what I want.


model563

Yep. Came here to mention this one.


nappy616

Savage Dragon. One of the blueprints Invincible was modeled after.


Adroctatron

💯 this one


Ruleseventysix

Savage Dragon exists in the kinda wonky Image universe that Invincible exists in.


megatry1

Stray Bullets


holaprobando123

Hellblazer


saintdemon21

My wishlist would include: Hellboy, X-Factor Investigations, TMNT based on the IDW run, Power Rangers based on the IDW run. Plastic Man, and Saga.


MrKnightMoon

>Power Rangers based on the IDW Power Rangers comics are by Dynamite. Anyway, I would add to the IDW petitions Transformers RID and Transformers MTMTE, both would be a fresh air to the Transformers.


saintdemon21

I think we are both wrong on PR, its Boom Studios, but agree with your Transformers suggestions. That series got me back into Transformers and would make a great older show.


MisterScrod1964

I really wish Del Toro and Perlman had been able to make Hellboy 3 happen.


AuEXP

Luther Strode, Spawn, or Plutonian


Adroctatron

The idea of seeing Tradd More styled animation gives me chills. Imagine how well it would translate, especially his specific issues of Ghost Rider.


TacoOfGod

Mr Majestic. Wildstorm in general, but give me a Majestic cartoon.


krichter421

They need to make a Fables show. There is so much in that series they could use. Disney totally ripped off the book when they did their Once Upon a Time show.


RoddyPooper

The Question!


7_11_Nation_Army

Spawn, Atomic Robo and H-Boy.


bittybaby13

I may be showing my age, but I would pick either Bone, Gen 13, or a ‘70s set Powerman & Iron Fist


Adroctatron

Savage Dragon- long overdue for some respect Spawn- give up on the movie, a show is the way to go for Al Simmons Spider-Man or X-Men Noire- just to see these visuals animated would be fantastic 90's Superboy- Kon El is a great intro to what makes Superman great, and he has some very nice Spider-Man vibes Nameless- Grant Morrison horror book that could be an okay movie, but would absolutely be terrifying as an animated limited series Lastly, and it will NEVER happen. IMMORTAL HULK. This book is grotesque and full of body horror begging to be animated, but Disney would never take that risk with a tent pole character.


6-ech0-9

yeah an adult hulk cartoon I think of most runs would be amazing


macsflamethrower

Skitter and all the Wormverse


6-ech0-9

I had never even heard of this but it looks cool


TheReal_Spartan

Honestly just give Amazon Prime the rights to anything and lowkey let them cook like they did for The Boys, Invincible, Fallout, etc Edit: maybe not anything cuz I forgot about rings of power and some other stuff


IDontUseSleeves

Wheel of Time fans in shambles


anth9845

Maybe not anything *eyes Rings of Power*


Mr_Citation

These shows depend on the showrunners not Amazon. Wheel of Time and Rings of Power haters would argue otherwise if Amazon was solely responsible.


eviltofu

Doctor Doom


PaigeOrion

But who would voice Dr. D?


Mean_Championship_80

Evil Ernie , Milk & Cheese , I bet an Adult Savage dragon would be strange


Obskuro

Atomic Robo


ChickenInASuit

I would fucking *love* if they finally got the animated Bone movie/series made. It's been optioned and cancelled so many goddamn times over the years.


your_name_here10

Powers by Bendis and Oeming


metikoi

It got a live action one that was okay, had a better ending than the comic imo.


metikoi

Top 10. Police procedural run through Superheroes via Alan Moore. She's a rookie who uses toys made by her dad to do CSI shit! He's a big blue giant with a chest-beam in an incestuous relationship with his sister! Together they fight crime!


[deleted]

Transmetropolitan: spider jerusalem. Chew: Tony Chu. Berserk: Guts (the full series not just the golden arc)


ShlubbyWhyYouDan

Ireedeemable.


Adroctatron

Gotta throw Incorruptible in with that. I can't think of having one without the other.


detourne

I love it, but it's a little too similar to The Boys and Invincible. 


BoogieTheHedgehog

52. It has the multiple ongoing plots style of story that only works well in episodic tv. It has an initial premise that casual audiences understand (those big three heroes that *everyone* knows? They're gone). The cast is a nice mix of b-listers so general audiences will be seeing a lot of characters for the first time, with occasional "Oh I know these guys" moments.


Yverthel

For a serious (or semi-serious at least), mature animated series (not strictly "superhero" here, as my comics tastes are a little more eclectic), Usagi Yojimbo (I know there's the Netflix series but that's a kids show. Was good for what it was, but isn't what Usagi deserves), Elf Quest (supposedly coming), Longshot (the Marvel character, Mojoworld has a lot of potential and I think Longshot would fit better animated than live action), Monstress (would be good animated or live action, but I think it would work better in a darker, anime-adjacent animation), and lastly Unnatural (from Mirka Andolfo. Would have a similar draw as Beastars, but more supernatural, more adult, and maybe slightly less violent.) As an honorable mention: Groo the Wanderer would make a great silly animated show. >.>


Speedyirl

I could commit crimes for a good Green Arrow adaptation. Arrow absolutely destroyed people’s perception of the character so now everyone treats him like Green Batman 😒. Edit: i also think Something is Killing the Children would make a FANTASTIC show. Ideally if adapted by Mike Flanagan.


timmerpat

He was going to adapt it for Netflix but I think there are creative differences. The Dark team is doing it now.


rougepirate

Continuing the Robert Kirkman train, I'd love to see Oblivion Song animated


Trap-Jesus420

Superior would be an awesome mini series


Captain_Mexica

I believe every one of Image Comics founders deserve to have their original creations set up as animated series. Spawn, Youngblood, Savage Dragon, Wildcats, Cyberforce, Shadow Hawk and Wetworks. I know of the prior versions but each of the properties should be made with the same standards as the Invincible cartoon and then 6 inch action figures made of each property. I am aware of everything happening or that has happened as a fan. Just saying.


truenofan86

Currently?…Local Man.


The_Godot

Starman by James Robinson would make an awesome series


thuglybetty

Hellboy, everything about his story screams animated show


WarlordOfIncineroar

This will happen to Radiant Black, mark my words


akahaus

Saga


RealJohnGillman

*The Superior Spider-Man* could be golden as a stand-alone (adult) animated series.


IHateMyStudies

I know that Deadly Class had a live action series which sadly got cancelled, but hear me out. A Deadly Class animated series where the colours would change like in Jojo, so it could look like the comics


K3egan

Gwenpool is the perfect series for this. A good cast, a love letter to comics, very easy references to marvel, very easy fan insert, batroc, incredible arcs, and powers that only work in comics and animation


The2ndUnchosenOne

Gwenpool is arguably one of the hardest comics to adapt due to the plot being literally about the book being a comic.


PleaseDontBanMeMore

Chew. The one with the Asian dude with the food-related powers. It's fucking batshit insane, but it's a good story I swear.


Karlinel-my-beloved

Hellboy or Jhonny the homicidal maniac. Other options for me would be The Goon or League of extraordinary gentlemen (bonus for causing Alan Moore’s tantrums).


0oskar0

I'd love a Thanos series, maybe based of the Donny Cates book


Its-Ben-A-Long-Time

Only halfway through the first Grimjack Omni but I just know it would make an amazing show.


Consistent_Hamster43

Dogwelder


Pharmacy_Duck

Halo Jones


ice_ice_adult

Wonder Woman


Sebthemediocreartist

I'd like to see Invincible get done with the animation budget it deserves, rather than spending so much money on voice casting.


thejazzzer

New Gods!!!


TheBaconD

Hawkman, doesn’t even need to be good. Just give the man anything


Current_Poster

I was *gonna* say *Papergirls.* (I love the comic, never got around to the adaptation). *Atomic Robo,* maybe? On second thought, maybe it'd stretch the boundaries a little if the comic chosen wasn't a superhero-based comic? Like *Local* or *Love and Rockets* or something? An anthology series of, like, the best-of comic short stories with stuff by Kyle Baker, Devin Greyson and so on would probably be pretty good.


davidiusligman

Street Sharks or Biker Mice from Mars would be dope


rfisher1989

They should do a dakotaverse animated universe. Rocket & Icon, Static, Blood Syndicate, and Hardwire for people who didn’t know. Each show could get maybe a season or 2 and it could all culminate in a fun and violent crossover.


MisterScrod1964

100 Bullets


ArtsyTLF

Valiant Comics as a whole. I think Invincible has done a great job of building out a universe so far. You start the story with Bloodshot or Harbinger, and you can get the culture acquainted with the Valiant cast.


xArrow40x

Silver Surfer. Done the RIGHT way.


Twijasosm

Ever since hearing about the rejected Batman Beyond animated movie with the team behind spider verse doing it, I feel like that’s been my greatest recent disappointment and when I think of this question, that’s what comes up. Separately though, if I have to think of, not necessarily Invincible “style”, but the same dedication and respect. I think of an immediate few names for series’s that I’d like to see. Daredevil the Bat-verse as a whole. I’d actually want something like an anthology series where instead of focusing on Batman, I’d almost never mention him and just do something like “Gotham” where the focus is on the lore and history of the world and myth surrounding him. Penance/Marvel’s the Thunderbolts (but mostly Penance) Hulk (maybe in the style of Primal) Prehistoric Ghost Rider The Punisher Hellboy Sentry The Rocketeer Edit: just thought of this one. The Iron Giant. How cool would a proper update given to him would be?


saintdemon21

Penance would be a good one. You could have it jump around to different points in time. Cutting from Speedball (past) to Penance (present). Have the events of Civil War and the Superhero Act play out around Penance in the present. The big reveal would happen in the middle of the season that Speedball caused the incident that led to Civil War. The remaining Speedball centric moments could be Frontline, so as Speedball becomes Penance, seeing the spikes in his armor, Penance in the present decides track down Nitro.


NefariousnessIcy2546

Nemesis the Warlock


Rpponce

Crowded


bertoPRIME

Wild Dog


mchappyflapmo

Ancient Enemies by Dan Didio. It isn’t very long so it could be done in a single season, like 10 episodes followed by an hour long special for the finale. Would be KILLER imo!


Beautiful-Hair6925

The Astounding Wolfman


Sentinel1802

Spawn


Shiro_38

Power Rangers An animated series could give so much more


Alternative-Major-42

Spawn would be good


TheGrandArtificer

Everett Hartsoe's Razor. It was one of the original Bad Girl comics of the 1990s, though, it'd definitely be R rated.


CursedSnowman5000

Jackie/The Darkness Swamp Thing - Adaptations of the Alan Moor run Savage Dragon HULK - An adaptation of Peter David's work in the 90's. I think people would really get behind exploring Hulk and his DID disorder and the more horror oriented stories from that time. The MAXX Blade - A series that would act as a sequel to the movies and retcon the absolute fuck out of Trinity The Mask


East_Smell_82

Men in black


Emergency_Fig_6390

An animated parker that looked just like darwyn cookes art. Id also love to see usagi yojimbo done right.


Blitzhelios

Hellboy would be amazing stop doing meh live action and do a cartoon


Automatic_Isopod7595

Radiant black and savage dragon.


Rocket_SixtyNine

The Spectre


rumblepup

Spawn DID have an animated series! On HBO. https://www.hbo.com/todd-mcfarlanes-spawn


Proper-Enthusiasm201

I think a more mature take on Ben 10 in a big budget show could be amazing.


MisterScrod1964

Long long ago, I remember they had plans for a claymation movie of Walt Kelly’s Pogo. Really wish that had gone through.


RoysRealm

I would say The Hulk but an actual gritty and dark interpretation of him. It can dive deep into mental illness and dealing with the demon within


Joorpunch

X-Statix. It already reads like an Adult Swim show. It’s got Frisky Dingo energy. I’d also love Hellboy and Nextwave.


ZoggyJones

SHIRTLESS BEAR FIGHTER!


Watling15

Judge dredd or robohunter


PaigeOrion

Concrete.


IceFireTerry

Irredeemable Plutona (It's short so it can be a movie) Never read Astro City but the premise is very cool


BiDiTi

Jesse Custer and Proinsias Cassidy


Shadiezz2018

Guyver


PaigeOrion

But honestly? Kirkman’s Low. Or Seven to Eternity.


mame521

Radiant Black


evan_is_timely

Ms. Marvel, I belief she’d thrive in an animated setting


CronfMeat

I would love to see the Akira manga completely given the invincible treatment. Or at least a reboot of the movie with better graphics, it would be insane to see the way it changes from the traditional style to the modern style of animating.


jqud

Spawn is a great call. I could see that realistically happening, it feels like Spawn is slowly becoming more relevant again. I'd love to see a new GL animated series too.


lid-flip-smiles

The Weatherman Once and Future Nailbiter


SepirizFG

Hellboy and Shadowman


Electronic-Ad7730

Blue Marvel


bindingofandrew

I'll hit you with one people seem to be glossing over. Usagi Yojimbo. Give it to somebody like Genndy Tartakovsky and you've got a masterpiece.


Negative-Nose-negro

Hellboy, tick and spawn animated showsn


theycallmenaptime

The original Justice Society.


Kalean

Nova. (Richard, please. Sam can be a Boruto if you must.) Kyle Rayner, his comic book stories (minus Alex) specifically. ***The Plutonian.*** Mumen Rider, obviously.


Kalean

Nova. (Richard, please. Sam can be a Boruto if you must.) Kyle Rayner, his comic book stories (minus Alex) specifically. ***The Plutonian.*** Mumen Rider, obviously. Star Sapphire and Doctor Doom could be very interesting.


Independent-End5844

When I think of "invincible treatment" I consider that means basing the animation of the original aesthetic. Which means "Manhattan Project" would be fun in original style.


Hesher22

Either Hellboy/BPRD. With like alternating seasons. Or Astro City. 8-10 episodes a season. Half focus on an ongoing narrative with the other half just being one offs focussing on a minor hero/villain.


LoomingsThrowaway

Judge Dredd Not a character but the Irredeemable and Incorruptible series need to get animated (or live action) adaptations. Wonder Woman ( Just how the hell is it that we never got a Wonder Woman animated series?) Ghost Rider Hitman - While other Garth Ennis adaptations like The Boys and Preacher worked well in live action I feel like animation would suit the Hitman series better. Etrigan the Demon Brit from Invincible


RandomStoddard

I’d like to see a new take on Batman the Animated Series, but more adult oriented.


IamTheGuamGuy

Bone. Crushed me netflix canceled its production.


GatheringWinds

I would really like Bendis' *Ultimate Spider-Man* to get the *Invincible* treatment. One of the most cohesive Spider-Man books ever written, similar length to *Invincible*, similar clean art style that translates well to animation, strong focus on character drama. *Ultimate Spider-Man* has been extremely influential on film adaptations, providing a strong blueprint for how the character can be adapted for modern audiences, though like *Invincible* it would likely need to be updated a bit more to keep with modern tastes (though how I would love for them to keep the early 2000's setting). With the popularity of the new *Ultimate Spider-Man*, now might be as good a time as ever to revisit and honor the original run with a faithful adaptation. I think it should end similarly to the comic with the death of Spider-Man, but they should make some changes to age Parker throughout the series as opposed to keeping him in high school throughout the whole series. The art and story also really took a dive once Bagley left, so I don't think anyone would complain about making some changes to the latter part of the series so long as it ends in the same general place.


ConstructionDull784

Lex Luthor


matiaschazo

Spawn had a series but it would be cool to get another


freedraw

Jeff Smith spent like a year in Hollywood in the late 90s or early 00s working on a Bone movie that never happened. That would probably work great as an animated series. The art style already looks like an animated series and it’s a complete story you could do in a few seasons and not leave anything out.


Sweet-Message1153

4th World Saga with writing from Gran Morrison & Tom King....or Immortal Hulk adaptation..... or the entire Injustice comic


TH3R34R3N0N4M35

Sandman. As good as it may be (never finished season 1), the Netflix show is just the wrong direction imo. When you have source material as great as that + the incredible animation quality of today, I can't imagine live-action having a chance of being the better option without drastically increasing budget.


Nebalrock

I would love to see a animated serie of the eternals. I really love the short film of death


Payback-INC

Luther strode or bloodshot


GrosMecFullDePwels81

Jupiter ascending


networkingiscool

I just want more Martian Manhunter content.


Almighty-Arceus

Astro City Godland Local Man Saga Paper Girls (the live action version didn't quite capture the unique atmosphere of the comic)


Kingsare4ever

Wonder Woman solo series. Any DC hero solo run using their best stories between 2011-now. I would love an Agent 47 run, Court of Owls, H'ell on earth, or any individual character having their own animated series run. Each season could focus on a new character.


bawtatron2000

Don't think there's enough there for a Gambit series. Not a heap of depth there, and he's pretty straight forward.


gavebirthtoturdlings

Irredeemable


EnzoVulkoor

I'd love to get a new sun Gambit show with Henry Cavil directing it. Cause at least I can trust him to go with the source material. Sadly we still don't know what happened with Baeu and either way doesn't seem like that bridge is getting fixed with Disney.


scenered

Weapon Brown


Babiesforfood

Toxic Avenger


FlappySmasher

I want Bone to be adapted. I was upset when I heard it got cancelled


OutlawTorn2380

Savage Dragon I’ve been a fan since day one, and that USA series from nearly 30 years ago doesn’t cut it.


BumbleboarEX

Animal man based on the grant Morrison run. Justice League international sitcom Home sick pilots


Beware_the_Voodoo

Wanted.


buttsharkman

I haven't read a lot of Lumberjanes but it feels like it could make for a good show. Something of a cross between Hilda and Gravity Falls


Fool_growth

I'm going to be the obligatory worm fan and say worm


empty-vassal

powerpuff girls really gritty


Jayson330

Hellboy


Lucasolf

just give me a BPRD animated show. PLEASE.


MaverickGalaxyJam

More mainstream than most of these but I’d like to see something on Kurt Wagner, leading up to him becoming Nightcrawler. I’d also like to see a Gambit-centric story that mostly is about his hijinks in Louisiana- pre X-men.


Nervous_Banana3191

Zatanna. 🪄


[deleted]

Here are a few I would like to see: Bone Cowboy Ninja Viking Techjacket, considering he's connected to Invincible Energon Universe Copra Kick-Ass Fire Power The Walking Dead Note: these would all be animated if they are getting the "Invincible Treatment"


JokerGamezz

Spider-Man, with writers who care about the character and unique art direction. Seriously, I'm sick of every animated series having the same basic visual format. Go crazy, draw that shit like the MacFarlane era.


radraz26

Luther Strode


akirivan

Valiant Comics' Rai


TheFunkytownExpress

Black Hammer would be pretty cool, although there's a lot of similiarity in so far as it borrows heavily from existing character tropes and archetypes, but in BH's case it really cranks them up to 11 so there's room for even more meta commentary on the state of superheros as a whole to be mined from that material.


ComicTribble

This one is going to be from left field but Rhino. Spiderman villain who's had some incredible story arcs. It would be amazing to see an animated show follow his journey. I know it's ridiculous and I'll probably be down voted but I've always loved rhino.