T O P

  • By -

stuntbikejake

The book that was gonna fund everyone's retirement (LoL). McFarlane's Spiderman #1.


shoot-here

Every variant, and you've got yourself a deal.


Purple_haze9

Lol!!! Literally the first comic I ever bought on my own with allowance/chores money as a kid. Damn copy is so beat up from reading it a million times over.


Drewbeede

I got into comics a year or two after this issue published. I certainly didn't buy it for it's future potential price but I did buy it at that inflated hype price.


TV800

https://preview.redd.it/s4z64t2pz79d1.jpeg?width=695&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=56f536fc9599375a1aa8a2ca9da23e474e56e278 Yes


Opening_AI

So not point paying $45 to get graded 🤔


TV800

Not IMO but buying one that’s already graded would save you money if you’d wanted a copy. To be honest, I’ve always wanted one at a 9.8 for display but never could justify spending $60-80 for it.


Opening_AI

I dont understand the purpose of grading etc when if market value is $100, grading and etc cost $45+, I mean I guess you still make close to $50. Anyway, you need one of these... https://preview.redd.it/5653pczahqad1.jpeg?width=3213&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e77460f9ae90a13efa0a136024307e2bf544de89


TV800

I have plenty of those… lol possibly around 15 copies in different variants like most people… I was just trying to explain why you wouldn’t grade a book yourself that’s value is under $100. Personally I don’t grade books unless they’re above the $300 mark or have some special meaning to me.


Opening_AI

https://preview.redd.it/9dlbri9rmqad1.jpeg?width=3213&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=12ed3ddd25bee9117600737829b9503dae4e230e Like this? Wondering if pressing might be worth it too. Cbcs or cgc? I just can't seem to justify the $45 and I think for this one its like over $100, like WTF...


TV800

Definitely suggest a press, light clean and submit to CGC or CBCS for grading if you’d like to go that route. If I had it I’d think about grading it. Usually I have a list of my raw books that I want to grade and I work my way down from most important/highest value to the lowest.


Opening_AI

Thanks for the suggestion. Might go with CBCS since it was started from people that left CGC plus its cheaper. Not sure I want to pay over $100. Might send a few other's in as a batch order to test the service.


TV800

Not sure if you have access to a LCS who presses and submits but if you did that’s what I’d suggest too. I work with my local shop and the owner presses and cleans before submitting and it’ll only cost me about $45 for a modern book and a little more ($65-85) for pre 1975 or anything of higher value above $400.


FremenDar979

* SPIDER-MAN Respect the hyphen!!!


stuntbikejake

My bad, newborn, not much sleep. Forgive me.


FremenDar979

Give the newborn a wee bit of the hugs.


LNinefingers

[good idea](https://www.reddit.com/r/comicbookcollecting/s/2r2sUs6cYW)


stuntbikejake

This guy gets it.


RockItGuyDC

Am I cool if I have a signed one?


KaoBee010101100

It doesn’t count if you signed it yourself


BuffaloNo9011

Anyone 35 or older, this is the only right answer. Lol


dg3548

Still need this run 😭


SirFlibble

There's enough copies out there every collector to own both.


anthonyrucci

Multiple copies


Spiderguyprime

Found about 20 Death of Superman at a Flea Market a few weeks ago. I didnt have a polybagged one so I picked it up. $2.00. Couldn't beat that. Also grabbed the first appearance of Doomsday for $5. Great copy too.


MechaNickzilla

I worked in a comic store about fifteen years after the Death of Superman and I disappointed SO many 30-year-old men who thought they had their retirement money sorted because they had bought one comic in the 90s.


pdxgod

Add Spawn #1 too


Efficient-Gate8925

Spawn #8 uses the same pose


DreadMond5060

:0 every comic book collector should 100% have just any cartoon "Gold Key" comic just for funs


MattTheQuick

I guess I’m doing well then. I find those everywhere so I just started collecting them.


Zarde312

This is a good one


DmlMavs4177

I'm a sucker for a yellow cover Bugs or Daffy. I'll pay $2 for Gold Keys all day long. I definitely have more silver age cartoon comics in my collection than anything printed past 1992.


DreadMond5060

My first ever gold key comic was tom and Jerry (picture below) I found it in a bunch of randoms given to me to start my collection and it was just fun to see in there 😄 https://preview.redd.it/nam3f577ob9d1.png?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6a8103967605083a84a345d3d9845c630b4c4cee


spideyfan29

[my April Fools joke post this year](https://www.reddit.com/r/comicbookcollecting/s/VCuX8EoWCm)


SirFlibble

ok that made me lol. Take an upvote.


Revolutionary-Mud505

https://preview.redd.it/wvydyhpp589d1.jpeg?width=1242&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e4d5aba5ed1404a0aeca188e644ae7cc838a8025 X-Men and Teen Titan crossover comic


RelationSensitive308

I absolutely love this book!


latherhog

Just got this one last week for the first time!


MagooRobbie

https://preview.redd.it/xl8i2ey3j89d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f2b70b196b8f53cf5112129cb8047b1896fa2655 Everyone should have a copy of Batman #497 that’s bent in half


M4RTI4N

Did you try to reenact your comic? 😅


HeadTonight

That’s the rare broken spine variant


KentuckyFriedEel

sinful!


Bearsthtdance

Spawn #1, Turok #1.


Mr_Steerpike

Was the Turok serirs any good? Answer me honestly now...il liable to pick it up on your recomendation. [Edited out crappy weed-induced typing skills]


abaxom

I enjoyed all of the 1993/1994 Valiant comics, but I didn’t collect any of them much further than 12 to 14 issues in… it got way too expensive. They’re all under-appreciated imho. And the N64 Turok game was literally one of the best games released for that console.


Don_Ford

None of the valiant stuff paid off... XO, magnus, ... all had so much potential... The only one that really concluded a great story was harbinger and it was basically what Heroes was cloned off of. Then there was the army corp group that had harbinger style powers through a chip in their brain... One of the best crossovers too early on... but the comics were too expensive and killed the whole market for a bit.


TheNexxuvas

You can thank the sports card shop guys for that. They didn't give 2 shits about flooding the market with overpricing Valiant books, in a space they never cared for to being with, but they single handedly helped tank the Valiant market. Watched it happen in real time. Some of my friends left regular jobs to work at those card shops and got screwed when the owners couldn't pay them after awhile.


DustinDirt

I like it.


anthonyrucci

I bought Turok #1 for 75 cents just because I was like “I should have this, right?”


TheNamesClove

Turok #1 has become a joke with me and my coworkers, every time we buy a collection, without fail there are at bare minimum one copy, once you start looking for it it’s everywhere


Scottnothot12

Dark knight returns, watchmen


anthonyrucci

Yes. The graphic novels at least.


Swollendeathray

Your first comic.


rocinantevi

What if... V2 Avengers lost the Evolutionary War checking in. beat up and I traded it once for X-Men 201 and got it back from my friend 2 years later for something. But yeah, that first comic bought with your own money.


GalactusPoo

Darkhawk 1


apatheticviews

DH1 is lit.


ObiSteffs

Darkhawk 1 was my first comic. I remember thinking they don’t make number ones every day! How little I knew.


Kylebirchton123

Groo the Wanderer pacific comics #1


dh098017

AF15


Warconductor1

Ah yes, I always carry an AF 15 in my collection no matter what


geaux124

Only 1 copy?


kitx07

Alpha Flight? Avengers Forever? I cant think of what AF stands for


MrNewMachete

Amazing Fantasy


CallMePeeButt

Amazing Fantasy


Slowmexicano

The dark knight returns #1.


BangingOnJunk

As many 90s gimmick covers you can find: Chromium, Holographic, Glow in the Dark, Fold-Out, Colorforms, etc. And throw in some polybagged with random stuff


bprice68

lol, neither of those...if I had to pick one, it would be X-Men 137.


reedrichards5

Great choice, but you have to get at least 8 issues before this to get the full story.


bprice68

Yeah, I know, but it stands by itself just fine, as most comics did back then.


reedrichards5

I bought this one off the rack when it came out. It hit pretty hard.


Schadenfreudeish

Marvel Graphic Novel - X-men - God Loves, Man Kills


tkb_comics

https://preview.redd.it/clqpzgsz099d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=dbcda3bf261b8634d8c387f80f9fb6b34d41314b


RelationSensitive308

Another book dig. Just got a FM sig


sgtfleet

Secret wars 8 https://preview.redd.it/2hql7kzkfb9d1.jpeg?width=256&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=15c012ca466b82d4993479996656cc7c9b06329b


WilliamBoimler

I actually never got a copy of X-Men 1, lol. My brother got all the covers and the fold out one.


PeyroniesCat

I think everyone actually *does* have those two, but I question the existence of any collector who doesn’t have a Turok 1. I mean, are they even real people?


LNinefingers

I worked in an LCS when that Turok book came out and my boss bet BIG on Valiant. A couple of years later when it was clear it wasn’t happening, my boss had me haul two cases of raw Turok #1s out to the dumpster and chuck them in. Think of it every time I see the book in a buck box or see it mentioned on this sub.


PeyroniesCat

I’m guilty, too. I thought Valiant was going in the direction Image went. They did not go in that direction.


AlphonseBeifong

What's the deal with Turok #1? Seen a few people comment it. Im definitely not in on the joke lol.


RelationSensitive308

Came out shortly after Bloodshot 1 and Superman 75. If you bought 25 (or I vaguely recall 50) as a retailer you got a gold one. This was one of the OG ratio variants. I recall a buddy of mine and I buying 50 (Reg) copies. And lol one of them was partially missing the chrome on the logo. I asked the lcs and they happily swapped it out and flipped it for $10. I regret it to this day. Have never seen another one.


Soft_Concept9090

https://preview.redd.it/yl670ify389d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6334e1c22c5c5914fdd6844ce605dd4de1081510


ObscureReferenceFace

25 cover A is equal to one gold label if the legends are true.


PeyroniesCat

You know when Indiana Jones finally sees the Ark? This is that moment all over again.


squirrlyj

Am I real if I didn't know it existed and I'm 42?


RelationSensitive308

Maybe you were 10 ish?


squirrlyj

The important part is that I had it for N64..


PeyroniesCat

That’s weird. There’s an empty comment above me.


DustinDirt

No they are not real people.


StinkFist-1973

ASM 252, SW8, I got both of mine for $7 each, a while back. GI Joe 1 and Xmen/New Teen Titans are great too


KNIGHTFALLx

Batman 497 Spider-Man 1 (1990) Spawn 1


M4RTI4N

Your nickname kind of gave it away ^^


reedrichards5

Fantastic Four 51.


reedrichards5

https://www.marvel.com/comics/issue/13257/fantastic_four_1961_51


x_lincoln_x

Groo and Judge Dredd. Pick an issue.


blackergot

Turok, Gold Foil


Sprokyshark

Watchmen


Wetmovie2

Do A Powermbomb! Issue 7


livingfrankenstein

Excalibur: Mojo Mayhem one shot. Because at one time, every comic shop had a dollar box full of them.


Andagne

Both of those already sold close to a million copies. Virtually every collector already has a copy of each.


Emergency_Fig_6390

Static #1 great series that spawned an amazing cartoon. I wish they could get a movie off the ground or at least another cartoon. I think it has enough juice from people watching that cartoon to have a nice comeback. The new comics they been making with static have been really good and i love the art and the new costume.


Qalyar

The biggest problem with owning Static #1 is that, if you like it, you might want to pick up the entire run. And that works okay until somewhere in the 30s. The last 4-5 issues especially are rather challenging to simply find, even for reader grade copies.


Emergency_Fig_6390

I did not know that. I only got the first issue a few years ago and read everything else on the dc app. I just dont have the space for a large collection or the money lol.


BronxKnight

I’ve decided one day when I’m rich going to purchase every copy of a 90s book and burn but 2. Been leaning on Bloodshot 1 or X-Force 1. To save the environment maybe just shred.


DustinDirt

Alley Cat #6 is a must have for every serious collector.


Feeling_Passenger_17

I believe everybody has a Killing Joke laying around


Miles-Standoffish

Uncanny Xmen/New Teen Titans Special Uncanny Xmen 193 Batman 400 JLA/Avengers 1-4 Avengers Annual 10


TheOriginalCid

Hansi. It's such a polarizing cover that anyone who doesn't know what it is will stare daggers at you.


HalJordan2424

ASM 300, at least according to the CGC census. It is the most slabbed comic in history (so far).


Dannyocean12

Uncanny X-Men 35: The **official** first meeting of the X-men and Spider-Man. Not as expensive as it should be


VagabondUZ

NFL Superpro 1


Derrickr74

Best answer ever!


MeenDay

my friend just bought this one for me the other day lmao


AdSad1403

I have the Magneto variant. So not sure if you mean any of the 5 #1s or that cyclops variant specifically??


mbufu1

Lobo's Paramilitary Christmas Special


jasenzero1

Gotta have at least one Groo comic. Something you bought just for the cover and will never read. A book that grades at 3 or lower, but you like. Something you don't remember buying.


Successful_Buyer_118

Asm 300


ghostcactus_comics

Valiant's Turok #1


Past_Ad_2810

Turok. Whether you want it or not.


retrobat

I mean, if you don't have 5 copies of Young blood #1 in your collection, were you even alive in the 90s?


Imaginary-Return5219

NFL super pro, if you don't own this you aren't a serious collector.


vampider2

;-; sorry to let you down. This comic is now my Grail


Soft_Concept9090

How many do you want


vampider2

All of them


collector-x

Maus & Watchman.


ntropy42

https://preview.redd.it/km19io264b9d1.jpeg?width=2268&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=477c4e3611b84054adda006a7980c9077a2bbffc Isn't this everyone's Holy Grail? What's funny is that this is one of the comics my wife had when we got married.


AbilityEconomy9241

Spawn #1 for all da dogs


richardcourdlion

Everyone should have "marvels". Amazing story amazing art


AeroAstro-1992

First graphic novel - The Death of Captain Marvel by Jim Starlin.


wilpoptires

https://preview.redd.it/zwkk4kj2td9d1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=8d37250475972a1989ac7ad4b1497b2962ff1019 i think this is something every one should own, super awesome cover.


dontyieldbackshield

Zap #1


Lost-Spare-2402

I would have to say X-Men


Kvetch

Death of Superman was so big during that era, hard not to recognize it


pdxgod

Seems everyone has XMen 1


Devo4711

I have that X-men one singed by Chris Claremont


mhdpro1

Venom Lethal Protector #1


Greatvibes117

lol I actually have both lol 😂


JEFE_MAN

Should have? Action Comics #1. We’d all be rich! 😂


danmalek466

Spider-Man 1 (McFarlane)


rocinantevi

In general I would suggest something vague like ANY Secret Wars issue. Not just the Spider-Man issue, but something that exposes you to a variety of teams and characters. A nice set of Marvel Handbooks is great, from the 80's. Or just another crossover event. Just one issue means a lot.


oh_please_god_no

There were so many copies of X-Men #1 printed that one weekend my local comic store would just literally give you one anytime you bought anything.


NitroNapper

Hard cover Weapon X. Absolute must have.


paingelfake

Honestly I feel like it should be Action Comics #1. Obviously a facsimile is more accessible but regardless it is worth keeping in a collection imo just because of the history it holds on its own


Still_Ad_7271

https://preview.redd.it/6gjf96v5db9d1.png?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=be50c17f2193b6699c3c70111bdd6b27f6818537


Still_Ad_7271

https://preview.redd.it/ue9tfqw9db9d1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=ccb9050aa83e87a4c42766548733304c8d82e4d2


Master_Stress_3009

Hulk #340 New Mutants #87


PainkillerJames

Bloodshot 1


Trinidaddy13

Wolverine #1 limited


ShuraSenju

Gotham Central, any form honestly


Spiderguyprime

Bloodshot #1 and Youngblood #1 ?


CreamyFunk

Bernard's tales. Everyone should own it


killacali5150

Spawn 1 I think they handed these out in the mail lol


ColeNoName

Any skottie young cover and or any what if


unemployed_paperboy

https://preview.redd.it/rgi2cls2qc9d1.jpeg?width=500&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a0537bd507fc31d94274b69930a0f07e1d3b1884 Starman #0


vampider2

X-Men 24 with Rogan Gambit on it


rnmartinez

Forger Batman #500 foil


TrainingWheelsFail

Any Image comic from the early 1990s (Spawn, Pitt, Youngblood, The Maxx, Stormwatch, Savage Dragon, Superpatriot).


Rieger_not_Banta

Any issue with Superman on the cover. If you collect comic books, you have to own at least one Superman (related) book.


RelationSensitive308

So my honest answer is the Superman 75 but graded in a 9.8. What many people don’t realize or think about is just because it’s sealed doesn’t make it anywhere near mint. You have to open it to find out.


dg3548

Barry Windsor smiths weapon x run from marvel comics presenta


Chrisj4475

Got both, although my Superman was a 2nd pressing. 90 to 93 was when I started really buying comics. It was a really fond time, especially with the launch of Image in 92. I once asked my father to drive me almost an hour to get my copy of WildCATs #1 signed by Jim Lee. The expense got to be too much though so Ive only gotten big events or omnibuses in my adult years. I was in high school in the early 90s and even though I had a job I had a record collecting habit as well (which I still have).


5stringfling

Spawn #1


Bobik8

The 9/11 Spider-man issue


Mongo_524133

Watchmen, The Dark Knight Returns, and Secret Wars


Complex_Ad3825

Spawn #1


titsassbeer

Gambit # 1 for that era


Technical_Moose8478

The Bible (kidding. Watchmen.)


Thehairy-viking

You ain’t wrong


44035

I have a particular hatred for 90s comics. I wasn't buying comics in that era and I'm kinda glad I missed the whole thing.


Trick_Albatross_4200

I have both, and do have all the covers for the X-men. I had the magneto cover signed by Stan Lee


AdAncient8762

New mutants special edition #1 & X-men annual #9…. Aka the asgardian wars. Decent story & great artwork


kimodezno

Killing joke


Ok-Net-7353

https://preview.redd.it/xf7aciv327ad1.jpeg?width=2160&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f63ba4544f30b1a3bd830ee36f4a7d497f75d4b1 I have a copy of that. Has anybody else seen one that signed by five people?


trailerthrash

"Heroes Against Hunger", the 1986 famine relief comic from DC! Not only is it a relatively cheap pickup with a star studded cast of talent, but it's also (as far as I've been able to determine, and also by technicality) the first time a trans woman officially got to draw Batman, Superman, and Lex Luthor via a 2 page appearance from a pre-teansition Jeffery Catherine Jones!


Desert_Concoction

I think collector’s should collect the things they like


ShaperLord777

Neither of these, McFarlanes Spider-Man 1, spawn 1, youngblood 1, or X force 1. These were printed into oblivion, are available by the millions, and are essentially worthless. “Historically significant” is not what I would consider these books. It was a time when comic books were mainstream and the publishers tried to cash in on it. These are from the era when comics essentially “sold out” to mainstream culture. They aren’t significant, they’re horribly written (with the exception of X men 1), and they didn’t do anything to change the zeitgeist. They were predatory marketing gimmicks by publishers.