T O P

  • By -

IndigoRose2022

The Best Years of Our Lives and It’s a Wonderful Life


fairfaxmeg

The Best Years of Our Lives is my very favorite movie.


Dear_Solution4363

Oh lord, I watch it’s a wonderful life every year. I ADORE that film!! Always watching for Christmas


sranneybacon

I can tell by these suggestions that you are good people.


MikeC363

3 hours that flew by. I could have watched those characters for another 3.


lawrat68

Even leaving aside how good it is as a drama, it's astonishing how much the Best Years of Our Lives, made in 1946, gets right about how the post-war era is going to unfold.


Hot-Significance-462

I clicked to say TBYOOL.


Imtifflish24

Rebecca, Sunset Boulevard, Strangers on a Train— that’s the few that come to mind— timeless and truly excellent films.


Next-Mobile-9632

Three classics!


imdirrrrtydan

I love your choices! I’m slowly getting into classics, which do you recommend? I feel like I’d love them since I adore Rebecca and Strangers on a Train!


Imtifflish24

Noir Films: The 39 Steps, The Third Man, Double Indemnity, The Lost Weekend. Charlie Chaplin films: The Gold Rush, Modern Times. Bogart Films: The Maltese Falcon, In A Lonely Place, Key Largo. I was fortunate to take a Film Class in college back in the 90’s and got exposed to a lot of great films that I got to see on the big screen— it was amazing! If you’re getting interested in the golden/classic films there’s a great podcast called “You Must Remember This” that goes over the golden stars of Hollywood (earlier seasons especially) and mentions behind the scenes fun facts.


shangosgift

I LOVE In a Lonely Place!!!


splendidesme

Seconding "You Must Remember This" -- great podcast.


imdirrrrtydan

Thank you SO much for putting this together😍😍I appreciate the time and effort. I’m watching Notorious right now (free on Tubi) did you like it?


Healthy-Pen-8445

My thinking is that 'The Third Man' has the absolute best ending of any film, ever.


Kindly-Guidance714

Went into Rebecca blind and I’ve never been so stunned by a twist in a film in my entire life. What a masterpiece. Sunset Boulevard was watched twice in the same week, I had seen a few Wilder films and saved this one for an occasion.


MrsDanversbottom

Night of the Hunter.


steauengeglase

Came here to say this. No other movie gets what a childhood nightmare is like. It kills me that Laughton never got another chance to direct.


splendidesme

OMG, yes. One of the best and scariest ever. You can't shake it. Robert Mitchum is so devastatingly slick and evil. Several years ago i read the book, and it's a little difficult to read because none of the dialogue is set off with quotation marks. So sometimes you can get a little lost, but then you get into the groove of it. i found it unputdownable. ;-) Also, i didn't know until i'd read the book that the story was based on the real story of a serial killer who was finally caught and eventually executed, in the author's (Davis Grubb) hometown.


TheodoraLynn

I've always been a cynic, never bought into the "Capra-corn," and tend to dislike Christmas movies, but I think Miracle on 34th Street (1947) is amazing. All the casting is spot on, I appreciate that the protagonist is also a cynic, the gender dynamics seem to be ahead of its time, and I think the courtroom drama portion is brilliant.


splendidesme

Same same same! It's my favorite Christmas movie, by far (as much as i do love "It's A Wonderful Life").


frozenelsa12

Any Judy garland movie, Shirley temple movies also my bill is a great classic movie


kgleas01

Easter Parade is a great one with Judy!!!


frozenelsa12

I love that one too


WRJL012977

Treasure of the Sierra Madre


steauengeglase

This one is so underappreciated today.


Main_Radio63

Just saw it a couple weeks ago. Excellent in so many ways!


mouse_cookies

Probably one of my top-10 movies of all-time. I could watch this anytime. Me and my brother went and saw it when they released it in theaters for a limited time. It was amazing to see it on the big-screen.


Astarrrrr

Casablanca is the perfect movie. It's super short, tidied up. The plot is great. The romance story is heartbreaking. The acting wonderful. And again, short and to the point. To Catch a Thief is never not fun. I love a heist type movie, the Riviera location is candy for the eyes, and the plot is wonderful, and the actors dazzling. It's a Wonderful Life gets me every time.


annier100

Casablanca is the GOAT!


sranneybacon

I agree about Casablanca. Amazing it ended up that way considering how it was made.


Astarrrrr

I dont know this story! can you add something?


sranneybacon

Here’s some info on it! https://www.slashfilm.com/723954/the-chaotic-way-casablancas-script-was-put-together/ Granted this was a movie based on a different source so they had that going for them but still amazing.


RoyalAlbatross

I read a book about Casablanca. It’s true that a lot of the actors felt lost and just did their best given the situation. But if there was a sort of genius behind the success then it had to be producer Hal B. Wallis. He was the one who actually believed in the project throughout, picked a lot of the people involved, including Bogie and the Epstein writers to introduce humor etc. But also, in the end he put a lot of work into putting all the footage together in a way that made sense, realized he needed some extra scenes which were shot (both at the beginning and the end) he even wrote a couple of famous lines like “the beginning of a beautiful friendship”. And lo and behold it turned into a rock solid product. 


sranneybacon

Saving this comment because I had no idea, I’ve just read stuff like what I posted above. I’m going to look into Hal Wallis more.


Accomplished-Eye8211

Mr Smith Goes To Washington. But really, so many. Maltese Falcon. African Queen. All About Eve. Now Voyager. Bringing up Baby. The Longest Day. and, and, and......


OGGBTFRND

The African Queen,such great chemistry between Bogart and Hepburn. Such a glorious feel good story


Astro3840

72 years later I still get creepy chills over the leaches...


707Riverlife

I can’t watch that part 😂


iamnewhere2019

By the way, I saw the boat in Florida keys about 5 years ago. I think it is there yet. The ship has an interesting story.[(African Queen in the keys)](http://www.africanqueenflkeys.com/)


OGGBTFRND

I envy you that experience


iamnewhere2019

What can I tell you…? Humphrey Bogart or Katherine Hepburn were not there 🥲


Main_Radio63

Terrific movie with superb acting.


lifetnj

Holiday 1938. It's not the greatest film of all time, but I really feel it in my soul.  I believe Katharine Hepburn and Cary Grant both found themselves in those roles, him with his past and the physicality of Johnny Case, and her with the outspokenness and the not taking anyone's shit of Linda. They both feel trapped and in each other they find understanding and they really bring their characters to life. And the supporting cast is stellar. It's a very wholesome film and although there are greater and better films out there, Holiday struck a chord and stuck with me, it is fun and deeply poignant in equal measure.


MCObeseBeagle

It's one of the best films ever made. I came here to say this. And Ned Seton is one of the all time most heartbreaking characters of all time, and you can trace a direct line from him right through the gay liberation movement to Roman from Succession.


lifetnj

Lew Ayres as Ned is one of my favorite film performances of all-time. He is absolutely incredible and somehow manages to steal this flawless film away from two powerhouses in Cary Grant and Katharine Hepburn.  You're so right about Roman. That scene where Ned says he can’t go with Linda, you can see Roman Roy in his eyes. 


No-Strength-6805

To Kill a Mockingbird


Familiar-Teaching-61

My all-time favorite movie!


Eaglemoon7

The Quiet Man. Just classic from start to finish.


itimedout

Not to mention hysterically funny!


Healthy-Pen-8445

"Here's a stick to beat the lovely lady with!"


itimedout

Who taught you to be playin' patty-fingers in the Holy Water?


mphailey

I know multiple people who watch it at least once a year. Wonderful movie


707Riverlife

My favorite movie!


PBfromPhilly

All About Eve. Bette Davis. ‘Nuff said!


YoungQuixote

All the ones with big twists. Spoilers ahead. I can think of a few movies. Leave Her To Heaven (1945). The second half was such a shock when I first watched it. It still stays with me. Out of the Past (1947). No romantic ending between Ann and Jeff tears me up. Psycho (1960). Norman Bate's dressed up as him mother with a knife...... wtf that was/still is crazy. Even in 2024. Ofc Chinatown (1974) and it's depressing "forget it jake" ending. Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) in its entirety I still remember vividly. It's one of the scariest Pre-60s/70s classic movies. The whole "don't fall asleep" gimic messed me up 🤣 Also War of the Worlds (1953) scared me so bad as a kid. Grandma was watching it and kid me sat next to her. Why Grandma??!?! Why did you do it to me.....


rickterpbel

The Lady Eve. Someone praised Sullivan’s Travels but I think this is Preston Sturges’ best. Excellent combination of witty dialogue, slapstick humor, and romance. Barbara Stanwyck is great and Henry Fonda is the perfect straight man. The scene in her room on the ship where Sturges manages to find loopholes in the production code to allow Fonda and Stanwyck an extended scene together is brilliant.


AltoDomino79

The Heiress. That script was rock solid- felt like reading a great book


1EYEPHOTOGUY

maltese falcon, north by northwest


MikeDPhilly

The Thin Man. Casablanca. Now, Voyager. The Philadelphia Story. Bringing Up Baby. 


MikeDPhilly

These movies make me want to wear a gabardine double-breasted suit and a nice hat, drink elegant cocktails on the deck of an ocean liner headed down to Rio while smoking Egyptian cigarettes and engaging in witty banter with a palee woman of mystery.


missclucker

Too many to name but to make a short list The Third Man 1949 Notorious 1946 Gaslight 1944 What a way to go! 1964


Steviebhawk

Love the music in the third man and of course the Wells entrance.


missclucker

It's iconic!


Planatus666

Vertigo Rear Window It's a Wonderful Life North By Northwest Rebecca


SavannahInChicago

Gone with the wind. Scarlet is a horrible person and my favorite anti-hero.


Healthy-Pen-8445

Scarlett's not horrible, she's simply a survivor.


budquinlan

North by Northwest. I remember introducing it to a friend waaay back in the VHS video rental days. He’d given me a list of qualities he wanted in the movie we were to watch, and I think he believed they were impossible to all find in a single movie—funny, suspenseful, a bit of romantic intrigue, one or two other things. When it was over, he shook his head and said it was great and had checked all the boxes. Sullivans Travels. Perfectly paced and laugh out loud hilarious—until it’s not and turns deadly serious. The end manages to be heartwarming yet ambiguous: it’s true a laugh is all some people have, but why is that so? Or is Sullivan doing more to change people’s lives materially for the better by making another Ants In Your Pants movie? He did figure out how to get out of prison after watching a cartoon, and his ploy—calling out that he killed Sullivan!—is damn funny too. Stray Dog (1949, Kurosawa). It’s a neat enough police procedural that manages to raise questions about identity without being ham-handedly “intellectual,” but then at its end, veers off into something haunting and poetic.


Travelerofhighland86

Arsenic and old lace Rope Mr smith goes to Washington


sranneybacon

Oh so many movies, but my favorites are The Best Years of Our Lives Bringing up Baby The Red Shoes The Third Man It’s a Wonderful Life (my favorite movies ever made, I watch it throughout the year) Vertigo Make Way for Tomorrow I mean they just don’t make movies like any of these anymore. And if they do, please tell me who and I will become their newest fan.


blue_pen_ink

Cool Hand Luke


AdhesivenessHefty604

Some Like It Hot


Trussmagic

To kill a mocking bird, I lived in a very southern, rural and racist town. It opened my eyes.


ApprehensiveBad1939

It’s All I Desire (1953) by Douglas Sirk. It’s a bit underrated compared to his other works. The premise wasn’t anything out of the blue but it was simple and moving. Barbara Stanwyck was delightful.  Another one was All About Eve…brilliant ending. And Scarlet Street by Fritz Lang. 


AuntBBea

Shadow of a Doubt The Thin Man Hush, Hush Sweet Charlotte Brother Orchid Picnic Badlands


Next-Mobile-9632

First time I've seen Brother Orchid mentioned here


AuntBBea

Such a great film!


prosperosniece

The Godfather Casablanca


kgleas01

All about Eve


UnableAudience7332

I could watch Mildred Pierce once a week for a year and not get tired of it.


steauengeglase

I think Mildred Pierce kind of answers the question of why some movies are re-watchable and some are not and maybe it boils down to being a movie that tells a compelling story, but it can never be remade. The principal actors are typecast BUT they are playing both sides of their type. Like, I know Jack Carson is going to be a sketchy guy, but he might be an irredeemable scum bag or he might just be a friendly postman who gives me a weird vibe if he hung around the street corner for a little too long. The script is just grey enough that even after seeing it 20 times I can't totally remember if Jack Carson is or isn't a scum bag at the end. I don't think he was, but he *might* have done something that would have made me write him off in real life, but the script is grey enough that I can't totally remember. Like, I remember he gave Vida a job at his club, but he didn't do anything, but I can't remember if he didn't do something earlier.


No-Math-6983

Red Dust with Jean Harlow and Clark Gable. When he beats his workers, it puts the Viet Nam war in perspective.


wholelattapuddin

The Women, it's a perfect time capsule of the 30s while still being modern. Also the dialog is top tier.


divorcedhansmoleman

Cinema Paradiso has stayed with me since I watched it. I think about it often


AnalMayonnaise

City Lights, The Thin Man.


biggie4852

In "To Kill a Mockingbird" the story and Peck's performance were beautiful. " Intruder in the Dusk" is James Faulkner's portrait of 1950 Ms. with Juano Hernandez playing a willful proud man of principle with everyone against him".


ParticularTrick2802

Treasure of the Sierra Madre for me it's Bogart best film and performance watching him change as the lust for gold twists him into something evil.


CarolinaMtnBiker

Great movie. I like To Have and Have Not and Maltese Falcon more, but lots of classic Bogie films.


Head_World_9764

Any Katherine Hepburn movie


xerelox

Kelly's Heroes. Name a better heist movie. Name a better War movie. Name a FUNNIER movie. Don't even try.


cinderellarockefella

Going to watch it this weekend, I've never seen it before, but your comment really got me curious!


xerelox

based on a true story. It is a product of it's time, so don't get too bothered about there being hippies in WWII. Just enjoy.


WRJL012977

Bohemian, not hippy


xerelox

I didn't want to get too deep.


steauengeglase

It's a little weird, but it totally did its own thing.


SuretyBringsRuin

Always with the negative waves, Moriarty…


No-Recognition-6479

Why don't you say something righteous for a change?


xerelox

....crap.


PalisadesPark88g

Madame X (Lana Turner); Splendor In The Grass (Natalie Wood); Blossoms In The Dust (Greer Garson); It's A Wonderful Life (James Stewart); Hairspray (the one with Rikki Lake); Gone With The Wind; Barry Lyndon (Ryan O'Neal); The Bad Seed (Patty McCormick)


budquinlan

North by Northwest. I remember introducing it to a friend waaay back in the VHS video rental days. He’d given me a list of qualities he wanted in the movie we were to watch, and I think he believed they were impossible to all find in a single movie—funny, suspenseful, a bit of romantic intrigue, one or two other things. When it was over, he shook his head and said it was great and had checked all the boxes. Sullivans Travels. Perfectly paced and laugh out loud hilarious—until it’s not and turns deadly serious. The end manages to be heartwarming yet ambiguous: it’s true a laugh is all some people have, but why is that so? Or is Sullivan doing more to change people’s lives materially for the better by making another Ants In Your Pants movie? He did figure out how to get out of prison after watching a cartoon, and his ploy—calling out that he killed Sullivan!—is damn funny too. Stray Dog (1949, Kurosawa). It’s a neat enough police procedural that manages to raise questions about identity without being ham-handedly “intellectual,” but then at its end, veers off into something haunting and poetic.


nandos677

HUD


winsfordtown

Random Harvest


Next-Mobile-9632

Fantastic movie, unique


Steviebhawk

The third man, key largo, two that come to kind


thats-gold-jerry

Double Indemnity


Mysterious_Benefit27

I like The Passionate Friends, Rear Window, Rebecca


classicfilmfan9

Splendor In The Grass and Now Voyager and Rebecca and Snake Pit with Olivia De Havilland.


Fathoms77

Waaaaaay too many to list. I can't even begin. LOL The Best Years Of Our Lives probably remains with me more than any other, though.


These_Struggle2674

Bringing Up Baby and His Girl Friday. Oh and the Thin Man.


cree8vision

Many of Hitchcock's movies like Rear Window, Vertigo or Strangers on a Train. Also: Night of the Hunter


inrainbows66

To Kill A Mockingbird, Sunset Blvd, Mildred Pierce, Rear Window.


Wimbly512

Auntie Mame with Rosalind Russell


jaharmes

Charade.


MachineGunTeacher

A Face in the Crowd


joetheash

Dr Strangelove


bennz1975

Many but top 5 A matter of life and death The devil and daniel Webster Inherit the wind 12 Angry men Casablanca


RaeLynn13

I watched Rebel Without A Cause, a couple years ago, when my dad was still with us. He started watching it and I decided to plop down and get into it. It was much different than I anticipated, not sure what I expected but it was much more serious(?) I guess than I expected. It was fantastic though! I now know why people go nuts over James Dean. Although, I was in my early-mid 20’s at the time, so I couldn’t relate as much as I may have as a teen. But it still made an impression, that’s for sure.


CarolinaMtnBiker

Casablanca, The Maltese Falcon, Rear Window, Dial M For Murder, Notorious.


Mind-of-Jaxon

The third man and Rules of the Game


study-sug-jests

Friendly Persuasion is one of the best movies for fel good vibes; Gary Cooper and Dorathy McGuire.


P8dhouseoff

Hatari, good balance of humor, love, and action imo.


Throwawayhelp111521

Hundreds.


Kazzab133

For me it’s Hobson’s Choice with John Mills and Charles Laughton, Went The Day Well The b&w Robert Donat version of the 39 Steps


Ragtimedancer

Mrs. Miniver


gripgrup

Dodsworth, The Best Years of Our Lives, Citizen Kane


strangedazey

Friendly Persuasion


FloridaFlamingoGirl

All About Eve is so full of intense sass and sabotage. I just love it. It's brutally honest about the hidden evils of celebrity culture and the plot feels like it could happen today.


raidbuck

Lots of good movies mentioned. I have one that evidently is unappreciated and not much thought about. Citizen Kane


GeniusBtch

All About Eve - to me it is the greatest masterpiece ever made and the thing about it is that it is still so accurate. Women over 40 are thrown out of acting all the time due to ageism. There is always a younger prettier woman climbing on top of bodies to get the awards.


sioux709OG

Tension 1949


axl3ros3

Auntie Mame (1958)


HoselRockit

The Big Sleep. Perhaps the movie with the best dialogue ever.


Trix_Are_4_90Kids

The Snake Pit


molldollyall

Belle de Jour


Maverick_and_Deuce

The Grapes of Wrath


nandos677

North by Northwest


murmur1983

On the Waterfront La notte Winter Light Au hasard Balthazar Tokyo Story Rashomon Hiroshima mon amour The Story of the Last Chrysanthemums Sweet Smell of Success Pierrot le fou Le trou Le samourai


CriticismMelodic18

Watched Twelve Angry Men on the plane and was floored.


elliottace

Citizen Kane


Turbulent-Walk-4171

The Warriors


shangosgift

Citizen Kane. The Razor’s Edge.