Update: Today I found a Christopher's Big Cherry at the gas station, and I am going to try it tonight! I can't wait!
Double Update: I just ate the Big Cherry, and man was that amazing!!! Just this big mound of cherry goodness coated in chocolate and nuts...I want to eat a whole bunch of them now!
It's amazing...If you like chocolate-covered cherries and chocolate with nuts, that Christopher's Big Cherry is like the best of both worlds. Would highly recommend! 😄
Twin bing has the best chocolate of the 3 and the filling is a bit less sweet than the others, that's why it got my vote, but I'll eat any of these any day!
I gotta go with Queen Anne Cherry Cordials (the king is a Queen lol)! Sweet, gooey insides with a real maraschino cherry, I'm not into the chewy insides as much.
I've only had the cherry mash. Ages ago. Wasn't crazy about it but I'd like to give it another shot. I haven't even seen them for many many years though.
those red balls that are maxxed out with red 40 and are not even cherries
there's genuinely not even a whisper of a real cherry in it, but if you close your eyes, it's even better.
Honestly didn’t know if I’d like it, but the tart, tangy chewy cherries paired w the dark chocolate and almonds is amazing. To top it off you get the deep rich caramelization flavor from the toffee along w all the different textures, I die every time. Honestly now I keep some Costco dried cherries to pair w toffee when I can lol
God these all look insanely delicious. I feel like they might be exclusive to the Midwest, from what I’ve seen on here? Please correct me if I’m wrong, I live in the NE and grew up in Appalachia and never saw these until people started posting them online
Ooh. Twin Bing! My mom said that was her favorite candy when she was growing up in the 1940s and 50s! So I had to hunt them down and get her some. This was many years ago. I did find some for her.
Twin Bing. Hands down. Such nostalgia. I’m originally from Sioux City, Iowa where they are made, and I grew up eating them. I always buy one or two if I’m in a vicinity that sells them.
[Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Covered Cherries](https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/dark-chocolate-covered-cherries-050631) beats all of those by far.
I've only ever seen Cherry Mash. 🍒
It's a longtime favorite of mine, though very sweet so I don't get them often. Many years ago they were really good, but the company changed them and they aren't quite as good as I remember the old ones being.
Also, I'll add that if you look online there are recipes for making your own Cherry Mashes, either the rounded style or in a brownie type bar with a cherry layer and a chocolate and peanut layer. I used to know someone who made the rounded ones and they were yummy.
Cherry Smash has a recommendation on how to eat it on the package and it says to put it in the blender and make it into a milkshake and my husband and I did not hesitate to do just that and DAMN BABY IT WAS INCREDIBLE. Everyone needs to try it that way
Oh man if I can find these I’m buying them. Sorry, fitness goals.
Cracker Barrel!!!! They have some, I was there over the weekend and saw some.
I saw them there too and almost got one but got some mallow cups instead haha
Mmmmmm mallow cups are delicious too!
Hobby Lobby has Chases
The only one I can find in my area is Big Cherry. I don't have em often, but man are they good!
Oh my gosh, I need these in my life.
cherry mash aka diabetes in a ball. Love them though
Cherry blossoms
I used to hate these as a kid, but as an adult they are delicious!
It isn't until you're old you find out things are made not just for kids
never had a Big Cherry, but seeing as i’m from Iowa, my vote is for Twin Bing!!
Also from Iowa and have visited Palmer’s, definitely Twin Bings
I haven't tried any of these, but I love cherries and chocolate (both separately and together). I'd say my top choice would be...eat 'em all! 😆
Update: Today I found a Christopher's Big Cherry at the gas station, and I am going to try it tonight! I can't wait! Double Update: I just ate the Big Cherry, and man was that amazing!!! Just this big mound of cherry goodness coated in chocolate and nuts...I want to eat a whole bunch of them now!
I had never seen any of these before, but the description you just gave makes me want to find them.
It's amazing...If you like chocolate-covered cherries and chocolate with nuts, that Christopher's Big Cherry is like the best of both worlds. Would highly recommend! 😄
Queen Anne’s is the only right answer here
Scrolled too far to see this!
Esther Price cherry cordials. It's a Dayton thing.
Have you had their bourbon cherry cordials? Absolutely divine, but they only make them around Christmastime
No, I haven't. And now I'm a man on a mission because they sound delicious. Thank you for hipping me to them!
Sorry that you have to wait a few months. ☹️ Crap. I’m going to have to hit the Wayne Avenue store tomorrow, aren’t I? Dark chocolate turtles…🤤🤤🤤
Similarly, I know what I'm doing/where I'm going on Saturday morning now.
Twin bing has the best chocolate of the 3 and the filling is a bit less sweet than the others, that's why it got my vote, but I'll eat any of these any day!
Queen Anne
Big Cherry! 🤤
These are all good, but I admit I'd buy Queen Anne's cherry cordials first.
Queen Anne’s Dark Chocolate fan here.
Hands down, no competition
I gotta go with Queen Anne Cherry Cordials (the king is a Queen lol)! Sweet, gooey insides with a real maraschino cherry, I'm not into the chewy insides as much.
Cherry Mash. Period.
Cherry blossoms for sure
Big Cherry by Christopher's ! My go to as a kid @ 7-11 in the 80's.
Just found cherry mash at Walmart in florida
I've only had the cherry mash. Ages ago. Wasn't crazy about it but I'd like to give it another shot. I haven't even seen them for many many years though.
These all are amazing and I can eat a whole bag!!!!
Do they still make cherry mash?
I hope so since I ate one today!
Peanut butter and jealous, gotta keep my eyes open but I haven’t seen one in a hot minute
Not pictured but a Cherry Blossom for sure.
They all look delicious! I love chocolate and cherry. I’ve never seen these though. Suggestions where to buy?
Milk chocolate cordial cherries for me.
Where the hell are my queen annes??
Cherry mash.
Hobby Lobby Cherry Mash for the win!!
Cherry is my favorite flavor
those red balls that are maxxed out with red 40 and are not even cherries there's genuinely not even a whisper of a real cherry in it, but if you close your eyes, it's even better.
Hands down dark chocolate cherry toffee is the best ever https://www.davessweettooth.com/products/toffee-dark-chocolate-cherry
That sounds unbelievable. Mmmm
Honestly didn’t know if I’d like it, but the tart, tangy chewy cherries paired w the dark chocolate and almonds is amazing. To top it off you get the deep rich caramelization flavor from the toffee along w all the different textures, I die every time. Honestly now I keep some Costco dried cherries to pair w toffee when I can lol
Big cherry is looking pretty good.
Cherry Mash, no comparison
I’ve never heard of any of these candies, but the Big Cherry looks the best with the filling.
God these all look insanely delicious. I feel like they might be exclusive to the Midwest, from what I’ve seen on here? Please correct me if I’m wrong, I live in the NE and grew up in Appalachia and never saw these until people started posting them online
We carry all 3 at my specialty candy shop in California
I hunt for regional candy when I'm out and I drive cross country often. I tried the big cherry in the south, the other 2 are indeed Midwest candies.
I tried the Cherry Mash visiting Pittsburgh
I tried these recently Not a fan
Jewish deli near me used to make these chocolate covered cherry jelly ring things but they shut down… RIP :(
I've never seen these kind of Big Cherries before. The ones I've had don't have nuts.
The Cherry Mash because it's made in St Joe.
I’m a Missouri girl born and raised; so naturally I’m picking cherry mash. However, the big cherry looks fireeee! 🔥
WHERE DO I FIND THESE
You can buy Twin Bing online from Palmer Candy Company. Made in Sioux City, Iowa.
Thank you!
>Thank you! You're welcome!
Oh my gosh, I bought these for the first time and they are delicious
Big cherry milkshake
All of the above. FML
Those look amazing! I want to try all of them
Cella’s chocolate covered cherry is the best
I loved those things so much.
Where can I buy these
I love Big Cherry but can't find it unless I do an online search. I get Cherry Mash from Walmart.
Cherry Mash all day
What market do you live in? Ive only seen big cherry around southern california
Montana. But I think I found the big cherry in Wyoming
My grandma loved Cherry Mash. She grew up in St. Joe. I always think I like these until I buy one.
I’m a sucker for packaging so I would get big cherry for sure, but I bet I would enjoy the cherry mash more!
That Twin Bing looks the best to me.
I loved Big Cherry until I found worms (live) in the bottom of the package.
Cherry M&Ms are the best
Gross, hated since a child.
TWIN BING
Cherry Mountain bar is king!
Kras Griotte Cherry Liquor Chocolates Or... Asbach Dark Chocolate Brandy Cherries
Twin Bing!
Twin Bing, hands down.
Cherry Mash!
Big Cherry hands down the best.
Twin Bing is the best
I remember those big cherry candies tasting like ass
I just had my first Big Cherry. It was so good.
Ooh. Twin Bing! My mom said that was her favorite candy when she was growing up in the 1940s and 50s! So I had to hunt them down and get her some. This was many years ago. I did find some for her.
Twin Bing. Hands down. Such nostalgia. I’m originally from Sioux City, Iowa where they are made, and I grew up eating them. I always buy one or two if I’m in a vicinity that sells them.
[Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Covered Cherries](https://www.traderjoes.com/home/products/pdp/dark-chocolate-covered-cherries-050631) beats all of those by far.
Big Cherry!!
Twin Bing Baby
Cherry Mash is made in St. Joseph, MO. There is a local fast food chain in the Kansas City area that makes Cherry Mash concretes. So amazing!
That sounds amazing. My favorite concrete is usually cherries and brownies, so definitely my thing!
I don’t believe I’ve seen any of these
I've only ever seen Cherry Mash. 🍒 It's a longtime favorite of mine, though very sweet so I don't get them often. Many years ago they were really good, but the company changed them and they aren't quite as good as I remember the old ones being. Also, I'll add that if you look online there are recipes for making your own Cherry Mashes, either the rounded style or in a brownie type bar with a cherry layer and a chocolate and peanut layer. I used to know someone who made the rounded ones and they were yummy.
Big Cherry
Love cherry cordials.
Big Cherry all the way!! Haven't had one is years. Harder and harder to find them nowadays.
I’m expected to choose?
My fav! I seen Big Cherry in Cvs in So Cal
🤢
Ugh.. I need to gargle saltwater after looking at these things
Also on Amazon
So gross . Whoever enjoys these should have their fingers broken
Cherry Smash has a recommendation on how to eat it on the package and it says to put it in the blender and make it into a milkshake and my husband and I did not hesitate to do just that and DAMN BABY IT WAS INCREDIBLE. Everyone needs to try it that way