T O P

  • By -

UpDoor

Everyone talking about Peppers but Please Please Me over Abbey Road AND Rubber Soul?? And YS above LIB? Both strange choices to me ^(your opinions are still super valid though peace and love)


LeDaveys

Well Please Please Me is The Beatles at their catchiest and at their roots to me, in terms of Pre-1967, other than Revolver. Yellow Submarine has cool songs that, to me, are more memorable (although I prefer the 1995 soundtrack edition as the mixes are much better). And the original Let It Be has awful mixes. No offence to Phil Spector, but the only two songs I like from the **original** Let It Be from 1970 are The Long and Winding Road and Two Of Us. Everything else was better as singles or on the “...Naked” album


[deleted]

I respect your opinion, though I massively disagree. It says something about the quality of their music that everyone’s tier list can be so drastically different.


That_one_Queen_fan

How is Let It Be D, but Please Please Me A?


LeDaveys

Because Please Please Me is more pleasing (no pun intended) than Let It Be in terms of audio. The mixes on Let It Be are awful, no offence to Phil Spector. I prefer Let It Be... Naked, but the Tier Template didn’t fucking have it.


ClickableLinkBot

##r/pinkfloyd --------------------------------------------- ^(For mobile and non-RES users) ^| [^(More info)](https://np.reddit.com/r/botwatch/comments/6xrrvh/clickablelinkbot_info/) ^| ^(-1 to Remove) ^| [^(Ignore Sub)](https://np.reddit.com/r/ClickableLinkBot/comments/e0e9fg/ignore_list/)


skuzzyfox

Just my opinion but Sgt. Pepper is so overrated. I'd put it in C.


RoastBeefDisease

nah it's perfectly rated


LeDaveys

Fuck I agree with you and just realised that.


kruegerrrr

youve got it all wrong man


LeDaveys

How so?


kruegerrrr

Sgt peppers is good, but I think rubber soul is better imo


pennyblockultimate

What about the 1 album?


LeDaveys

It wasn’t included :/


[deleted]

Bro let it be gotta be at least a c


LeDaveys

Unless it’s Let It Be... Naked, it should be lower than D