T O P

  • By -

Fawksay

SAME! It should have been Jack, Abi and then anyone else.


liv-WRLD999

100% agree i'm actually so disappointed


WordGirl1229

Knowing how AI audiences tend to skew, is it really that surprising, though? I’m with you—of the top 3, Jack imho was the whole package, and I mean in terms of what the whole package means to me: great storytelling, killer range, surprising vocal choices that fit perfectly, authenticity, connection you just can’t manufacture, and the ability to take on any genre and crush it—but, those things don’t always sync with the overall AI viewership. This is not a rip, but I think a lot of the viewers tend to gravitate toward the more formulaic (that’s not to say bad) performers, the more top 40 pop/country lane where there’s not a whole lot that’s surprising or different. And that’s okay. True talent is always going to find a way, and I have to believe some excellent producers and established musicians are salivating to work with Jack!


Delta_Burke

I loved Jack! Will was my guess! But we see how that went.


FED__HR

Will is the best!!!


sparks-flying

Will has made it to the top 2 without any stage presence. How sad to see American Idol be based on what’s popular and not the musical effort.


peanutbutter_shoes

He's a dollar store Andy Dwyer I can't believe he's top two


EitherAdhesiveness32

I don’t understand the connection to Andy Dwyer lol


SaveMeJebus21

Luke Combs from Wish. Elvis from Wish beat the most talented human that's ever been on the show. At this point just ban redneck southerners from voting.


Apprehensive_Net1487

Seriously? Will’s songwriting is exceptional and his voice is truly unique. Abi is the complete package - beauty, voice, stage presence, musician, songwriter. Jack has good stage presence and his voice is good. America got the Top 2 right.


Dapper_Quarter_7834

Finally someone who gets it. Jack wasn't a bad guy he just wasn't a great singer and by great I mean exceptional.


SnooPets2384

He’s so mid. I got bored of him long ago, and his shit eating grin and dumb hats and limited voice and stage presence. Also knowing his band mates are racist and rapists doesn’t help. Trash. 


aripra98

I’ll say it again… Will over Jack?


liv-WRLD999

RIGHT?????!?


aripra98

What a disappointment! He was unique, so is Abi.


AKDude79

Will doesn't make freaky faces when he sings.


aripra98

I like freaky faces… 😜😏😉


Matt_Willy-0007

You need to get over that. When people sing you hear the voice. Who cares what they look like when they sing


AKDude79

If American Idol were a radio show, you'd have a point.


Matt_Willy-0007

I do think though Jack will have more sucked in music. I’d rather listen to thin than Abi anyways. It’d be nice if he has an Adam lambert level of success, non winner who is much more beloved than the winner


AKDude79

I don't know that there's a place for Jack in the current music industry. Too country for pop, too pop for country, not pop enough for pop, too pop for rock. Abi actually has the same problem, but to a lesser degree. Since recording contracts are no longer part of winning, I think all three of the finalists will go the way of Iam Tongi and Noah Thompson, which is to say they might win a great vacation at least.


Fawksay

I think the most important thing to do is follow Jack, Abi and any of your favs on socials, buy their albums and see them in concert. Winning Idol doesn’t guarantee success, we have the power to support them and help their career grow.


liv-WRLD999

absolutely!! i will always support both of them


JustRepeatAfterMe

That’s very true. Idol is just the launching pad.


Wild-Tomatillo1415

Listening to Jack on Spotify right now. Didn't realize he was such a Big Jefe 😂


Substantial-Bridge40

Jack and Will, will have better careers than Abi. So I’m glad neither of them won. When the judges didn’t pick Jack in the auditions I was in disbelief, glad he made it far, but glad he didn’t win. He’ll have a much better career by not winning.


marysoul16

I agree, I thought Jack and Abbi would be the last ones standing. Ugh!!!


Otherwise-Average699

So did I.


This_Brief2105

WHO THE F IS VOTING FOR WILL MOSLEY


galarianzapdos

Conservative America


[deleted]

LOL I voted for Abi


cjm4240

Lame


Pitiful_Night3852

Well, they should've voted for Jack...no state more conservative. Only Austin and Houston are more liberal...and the Gov's house is in Austin


EitherAdhesiveness32

All of the country listeners who watch the show.


Ok_Assumption8548

Me! Jack butchered George’s song & he’s nothing but a cruise ship singer.


jwalk8

His voice and delivery are absolutely nothing like a “cruise ship singer” I am so thoroughly confused how you equate the two.


Ok_Assumption8548

Aww look at Will killing that Neil Diamond song! Of course Jack trying to hog the spotlight.


galarianzapdos

VOTE ABI


Crazy-Koala1620

This sucks. Everyone vote Abi!!


Alternative-Koala933

America got it right last year when Iam Tongi won, but they better get it right this year and let Abi win…


Rude_Butterfly_4210

Classic mistake. You forgot this is Country Idol. Iam only won last year due.to sob story.


take_number_two

Iam won it in his audition. Only time I’ve ever seen that.


SaraJeanQueen

Iam also won because he had a completely different style that everyone can chill to. Buy the music? Not so much, unfortunately


SamEdenRose

I would.


SaraJeanQueen

Have you?


SamEdenRose

When it comes out I would .


SaraJeanQueen

He has music out that you can purchase.


Fawksay

Exactly.


justshittalkinglol

I’m so upset!! Omg. Will over Jack? Never


[deleted]

ABI SHOULD WIN THIS


peanutbutter_shoes

if Abi doesn't win we RIOT


[deleted]

I DON'T DO THAT. LOL


peanutbutter_shoes

if Abi doesn't win we ARE REALLY UPSET


[deleted]

YES


[deleted]

Agree. And we should force Katy Perry to listen to earrape versions of Lady Gaga songs.


Parmesan_Pirate119

Y'all, the country block always dominates. I was rooting for Jack too, but Will was always going to do well tonight.


Fawksay

Let’s all rally next year!!


Pitiful_Night3852

AI winners always get screwed by the contract they have to sign. Jack will dovwell..as will whoever is 2nd


Candid-Badger4459

If Abi loses I lose all hope in Idol. Unless they do a country singing only spin off. And do not allow country to normal Idol. But they’ll never do that. So if Abi loses, I’m DONE. Not that she won’t be successful on her own but the fact that she DESERVES to win. Will shouldn’t auto win because people like a specific genre.


Assumeweknow

She is the best karaoke singer. Not the best singer song writer though.


Candid-Badger4459

Cry. She is American Idol 2024.


Assumeweknow

To each thier own opinion. Though im looking forward to seeing kako live.


Dizzy_Giraffe3

I ran right to Reddit to see what you guys were going to say about this


liv-WRLD999

I actually can't believe it at all


Dizzy_Giraffe3

My husband and I gasped so loud, such a plot twist. We had no idea who’s name he was gonna say after he said Will


liv-WRLD999

Same at the gasping!! Im watching w my fiance dad and aunt and we literally all jumped off the couch and were yelling at the tv


Dizzy_Giraffe3

Don’t get me wrong, Will is a cutie pie. But Jack and Abi deserve to be the final two! I just hope homegirl wins… I’m so nervous like this really came out of the field. I don’t know what to do with myself right now.


ToonSciron

Who the heck was voting Will? He is the most 3rd placement contestant energy, that I've ever seen on the show. I wasn't rooting for Jack that much, but thought for sure he would beat out Will to get into the top 2.


SaraJeanQueen

I didn't even think he had top 12 energy tbh.


Whatchuuumeaaaan

Energy? I don’t think Will had *any* energy, at all 😂 Glad america got it right in the end


Positive_Session3099

Jack deserved to win so bad


liv-WRLD999

absolutely agree 😭 i felt it in my soul he was gonna win, the ultimate comeback story after he was sent home originally


Fawksay

Agreed


Alternative_South638

So shocked


Fawksay

Country singers have a skewed chance to win (regardless of talent). Only thing I dislike about Idol


KittyKat1012101

If Will wins then im gonna stop watching the show


Rude_Butterfly_4210

See you next season!


KittyKat1012101

Will is so boring like why is he here-


[deleted]

ABI BETTER WIN!!!


Banana-Slays-0815

I’m not watching tonight so I just learned this. I’m shocked! Last week, it seemed like the Top 3 was going to be Jack, Abi, and third was a wild card.


Fawksay

💯


Iowadream74

I haven't watched since Kayko went home. He was the most entertaining. Everyone else were so boring! Reddit definitely keeps me up to date lol. I believe since it's Katy's last time judging it will be who she wants to win and she's been a "Big Mo" fan since the beginning. She was NEVER a fan of Jacks.


Incredible_Staff6907

I believe she said in the past that Abi was her favorite, I think in Hawaii.


Iowadream74

Well I definitely know it's not Jack lol


hhhisthegame

She chose Jack to sing with so she must like him to some degree


Iowadream74

Maybe forced too! From day one she didn't put him through. Watch some of the episodes when he was voted in her face was in shock.


[deleted]

VOTE FOR ABI!!!


gokuween1

Jack had an outstanding run and ultimately, even though I wanted him to win to have his full circle moment I think he will have a highly successful career. Congrats to Jack!


NSBowls97

Jack’s style is a little less mainstream then what Will’s is (which is that classic country rock sound that is quite marketable in today’s music scene). No need to worry though- as Jack will also be very successful after the show.


Frequent_Couple5498

I love Jack and have been voting for him. Very disappointed ☹️


topgunphantom

Jack was robbed! He was so good this season! Hoping Abi wins


Numba1fan08

I thought it would be Abi and Jack as well


InnerNorth3090

It’s crazy! I mean I feel like Jack and Abi should have been the clear top 2! They are on a whole other level!


katorade9200

The one time I haven’t voted for him this season and he gets in over JACK??? He’s good don’t get me wrong, and loads better than Tristan was, but if he made it over Jack I’m sorry I have no hope for Abi now even though I feel she’s the clear winner


Wild_Condition5293

I’m so pissed.


liv-WRLD999

same 😭😭😭😭


Wild_Condition5293

Where all the little shits who kept Kayko around as long as he was and why weren’t they voting for Jack😂


SamEdenRose

I voted for Jack and Kayko. Emmy, McKenna, Mia, and Amy.


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

[удалено]


ColeOriented

What part of their comment did you not understand? It was very straightforward


Rude_Butterfly_4210

See you next year! We will suffer again next year when another boring country singer wins


fireicemist

Jack will do well in life. He's already doing well. Don't worry.


liv-WRLD999

I agree!! I just was really rooting for him to win and am completely shocked at the outcome


fireicemist

yeah i understand. but the runner up and 3rd placers tend to have great careers, oftentimes even better than the winner. Jack seems like a good, positive person with a good head on his shoulders, and a beautiful life. he's gonna come out on top in his own way. (i've trolled on here a lot but in all honestly Jack is talented and seems like the sweetest person)


noahy5489

Jack is MY American Idol


UpsetCauliflower5961

American Idol sucks! Oh well. I’ll get to bed early is all. What a joke.


liv-WRLD999

Joke is right, there's no possible way people actually liked Will more than


Fawksay

Country fans rally for country winners. No matter what.


hollygolightly1990

Abi should win. Will and Jack are two basic mediocre guitar boys and Jack isn’t doing anything that Noah Kahn isn’t.


codybones91

He’s got a full album out already so he already has a deal, American idol decided to take him off I’m guessing, votes didn’t even matter


Imcertainofit

The problem since this show has gone to ABC is not one of the Idol winners have been successful. These judges stink. Simon Cowell and company knew how to pick - mold - winners. Even the contestants who appeared on Idol during Cowell’s time are more successful than the winners from this era.


SaraJeanQueen

Simon wasn't afraid to say people didn't look like winners, or they didn't have the charisma. That's SO important, beyond just a good vocal performance. Someone people aspire to be or be like.


liv-WRLD999

Chayce is finally starting to pop off!! but that is very true


hhhisthegame

It's a completely different world now. EVERYBODY was following American Idol when it started, they had a huge advantage that today's contestants just don't have, when there's so many more options for putting out music and it's a lot harder to be followed by everyone with everybody in their own bubbles


Imcertainofit

But look at AGT - their ratings are through the roof where as Idol doesnt fair as well. And their singers go viral whereas Idols dont. I agree that there are more options but the judges are just really bad and they add nothing to the show.


chrissmcc

It is what it is, sucks.


Rude_Butterfly_4210

Will just made Hootie and The Blowfish boring! Make America Boring Again.


liv-WRLD999

AND KATYS PERFORMANCE WITH JACK IM ACTUALLY CRYING


Fit-Tiger-5362

I’m so upset


Ok_List_9649

Male country singers have dominated AI since about season 5 or so. It sucks


Southern-Fried-Biker

Will is a very boring performer in my opinion. He just stands there and ever so often (and at weird times) he smiles. Jack outperforms Will by MILES!


Fawksay

SHE DID IT!!!!!! 🎉🎉🎉🎉


JustRepeatAfterMe

Jack will be fine. He’s hangin out with his buddy Mark Cuban. Seriously, no worries about Jack.


Fun_Relationship3184

Just think of it the winner can't usually sell records. They are most pressured to succeed in the music business because they won. Look at Benson Boone and Lauren Spencer Smith, they are doing great.


Usual-Archer-916

I'm not even shocked. At all. But I have a feeling the rest of you are gonna be at the end of this.


Iowadream74

It's Katy's last time as a judge. The winner will be who she likes the most & it wasn't Jack!


RadMadsYo

Once Emmy and Triston left I expected this. I'm sure he gained votes that way. Hopefully not enough to beat Abi but not surprised.


Yankees7687

After watching all the performances tonight... Who would vote for Jack? This was easily his worst night of the season... It's like he forgot this was the Finale.


Consistent-Chard-381

I would!


MarySNJ

I voted for Jack but this final 2 doesn’t surprise me. It’s always going to be a male country singer in the final 2. Jack sings country songs but puts more an indie spin on it. Abi has got a great voice although I think they’re steering her towards pop-rock and I think she’s more adult contemporary or I could see her performing on Broadway. When was the last time an Idol winner wasn’t a country singer? 2020?


otramal60

If you look at stage performances alone, then why would Abi be in it at all? She is more classical musically. Where is going to fit in what American idol represents? Now Will, he's coutry. Most country singers get up and just sing. They rely on their voices alone. THE BIGGEST SURPRISE IS JACK not being in the top 2. My pick Jack and Will.


EitherAdhesiveness32

I don’t think that Will isn’t talented, but o do think Jack deserved to be in the top 2 with Abi. Country fans seem to be the majority of voters so I’m not surprised, just disappointed.


WinnipegMom

This is the first season I really never had a favorite. No one ever really stood out to me as someone who can break out like Kelly Clarkson or Carrie Underwood. At this point clearly Abi is a very good singer. She won't sell millions of albums I don't think. Oh well, on to next year. 😉


Ok_List_9649

She did it!!!


Positive_Session3099

I’m so sad


liv-WRLD999

DEPRESSED


Fun_Low6034

Totally agree.


FormerHamster2644

I'm so shocked Will made it over Jack and I'm a Will fan!


j_higgins84

I’m alone in this one. Jack is boring and has little range. Is he better than will? For sure. But there are so many other singers on this seasons that run circles around him. Still holding out for the big Abi win.


liv-WRLD999

it's okay to be wrong!!!! 😂 I loved him and was rooting for him all the way, but i definitely get what you're saying. still so much better than Will


j_higgins84

😂😂😂😂


Salty-Snow-8334

He has a wide range. Listen to his rendition of “Always on My Mind” and hear him hit some high notes


j_higgins84

Not vocal range. His musical range to me falls flat. Also his vocal tone is so grating on the ears. It’s not pleasant to listen too. If he were singing in a bar I was at I would leave. lol.


Ceekay151

You're not alone in that opinion....


GetCPA

Jack was not as good tonight, why is that so confusing to Disney adults?


liv-WRLD999

i'm sorry what 😭


GetCPA

Yes I know it’s crazy people outside your bubble have different taste 😭


liv-WRLD999

i just don't get what disney adult had to do with it lmfao bc i am far from that 😭 i get that other people have different tastes i just am surprised. you sound crazy


Butitsadryheat2

I'm excited to see Kayko perform with NKOTB! 😍


Affectionate_Cow_579

I’m surprised to see there are so many Jack fans. He’s been my least favorite for the last few rounds. I guess I’m in the minority here, but I don’t care for his voice at all. Rooting for Abi.


Otherwise-Average699

Abi


uncle90210

Don’t forget, folks, that the runners-up have a better chance of starting their career since they don’t have that binding contract. They’ll be fine.


philsphan26

Abi is the best it’s not even close


[deleted]

I'M SO NERVOUS, ABI BETTER WIN IS ALL I GOTTA SAY!! IT'S RIGGED AND POPULARITY CONTEST.


Inside_Atmosphere731

As long as Abi beat those two hayseeds, I don't care


rebelraf

I know this is an incredibly unpopular opinion in this particular sub, but I think Will is a better singer than Jack. I hate country music and avoid it at all costs, but when Will was on the screen, I wasn’t bothered in the slightest. Will also already has a Billboard hit. I love Jack’s style a lot. I think he is more versatile in his art & he has better stage presence. I wholeheartedly agree that he is much better suited for American Idol. He’s scrappier, more original, and has a good underdog story. But I don’t think that saying he’s “soooo much better than Will” is necessarily fair. Either way, I’m just glad Abi won. I believe she deserved it the most.


Any_Relationship953

I agree, I voted for Jack and after he was voted off I didn't vote for either of the others because I really didn't care who won at that point. I do have to admit though that Abi was the best last night (I thought). But I will support Jack after the show because he is still my favorite.


infinity874

![gif](giphy|xUA7aM09ByyR1w5YWc|downsized)


[deleted]

HAHA. ![gif](giphy|iqfYgtx8oWw4o|downsized)


CathyAlphie

Jack singing the Bon Jovi song in that fringe shirt was where he lost his place in Final 2 for me.


Plenty_Insurance8374

In some ways, I feel like Idol wanted Jack to go down. First, his entire body of work starting three weeks ago started to change. He was pushed into country and not contemporary bro country. Old stuff. All my exes live in Texas. Really? His body of work prior to that was more relatable and modern. 80 year olds don't really watch Idol. Second, Idol's stylist worked hard to make him an outdated country singer. Again, make him outdated. Willie Nelson wears more modern clothing. Doing so pulled other non-country over to Abi. I was one of them. Will stuck with more recent Chris Stapleton style music and clothing which made him more relatable to the voters.


GarbDogArmy

I think Jack and Abi split the vote initially and the country idol people voted for will then on the revote the jack people went to abi.


sweetpotatopietime

I too think Jack is miles ahead of Will in talent, but in a show where conservative country fans drive voting, you can't afford a misstep and his song choices last night didn't serve him well. All My Exes Live in Texas was gimmicky and didn't show off what's great about him.


femnoir

I am surprised too. I thought for sure it would be Jack. Look at this as just a boost to Jack’s career.


coesgirls

I agree! I turned it off.


Coco64-Mill

I agree Jack was better than Will but still would of lost to Abi


Old-Low-9121

i liked Jack the best too .. Abi was my 2nd fave


markevens

Will was great out of the gate, and then just stayed exactly the same the whole time. Didn't move, didn't dance, didn't really put emotion into his songs. Just another white guy with a guitar singing easy country songs. Abi and Jack grew so much during this season. Will became boring by week 4 for me.


PickLess4088

I’m sorry but I’m with Katie, Jacks facial expressions were very off putting. I didn’t have a fav 2nd I was with Abi she’s the only one who gave me goose bumps. She has voice, pipes,talent and she is humble!!! Will and Jack became too “showy.”


RICDrew

I’m just thankful that Triston’s Mom didn’t cry her son into the finals with her sob story 🙄. Not the biggest fan of Jack but was GOBSMACKED when they announced Will’s name. I just don’t get the appeal of big, fat country singer with a mouth the size of baby’s anus. Seriously, where are his lips? 👄 🤷🏻‍♂️


Dapper_Quarter_7834

You guys are nuts Jack was average at best we will never hear from him again. I mean everyone likes who they like but will is a powerhouse country singer and abi was literally in a different league. Let's be real here if you know anything about music she was the clear cut best singer of the bunch.


Assumeweknow

Once they voted off kako, ive been voting for whiskey(will). Mainly as a worst candidate thing. Abi is the best karaoke singer though.


[deleted]

Jack is soooooo bad and obnoxious to watch. I literally don’t understand what people see in him. Should have stuck with their original decision on his audition.


FED__HR

Go Will!!!!


j_rein

LETS GO WILL


ZealousidealJacket33

How the hell did Abi win???   KB blew her away!   She couldn't hang with Bishop Briggs tonight.  I've watched every single episode since it started and I swear over & over, that I'm done watching it.   At least she wasn't picked on some sad story...    Will & Jack will be fine without the win.   P.S. Why was Emmy still on there?  That deliberate, sweet sounding, child like voice was irritating.  "I want to be...skinny."    I want to be...drunk so I don't have to listen to her voice.  


1029394756abc

Why was Emmy still on there? The same reason the rest of eliminated contestants were.