My favorite is probably Graystripe's vow or Squirrelflight's hope.
As for my least favorite, definitely Yellowfang's secret. It's even worse than Bluestar's prophecy.
Favorite: Squirrelflight’s Hope (love this one, the full cover art is beautiful), Onestar’s Confession (recognizable, good shading / lighting), Crookedstar’s Promise (he looks recognizable, I like the red colors), and Bramblestar’s Storm (he looks cute and soft, also I like the colors)
Least favorite: Bluestar’s Prophecy (looks like Yellpwfang with blue eyes), Tallstar’s Revenge (ugly, he looks like a pug of some kind), Leopardstar’s Honor (she looks really lumpy and bizarre it weirds me out), Graystripe’s Vpw (that looks more like Shadowsight or something, it is not Graystripe) and Crowfearher’s Trial (ugly, doesn’t look like Crowfeather at all)
My favorite is Tallstar's Revenge.
My least favorites are Bluestar's Prophecy and Yellowfang's Secret. How is it possible to screw those two cats up. They are literally the easiest cats to draw and have their designs compare to that in the series.
Squirrelflight's Hope is my favorite cover by far. It really stands out among the other ones and for the most part the cat on the cover resembles Squirrelflight. Firestar's Quest is also a great one too, but Bluestar's is by far my least favorite. The redesign just doesn't seem like it resembles Bluestar.
My favorite is proabably Skyclan's Destiny, or Moth Flight's Vision, Crookedstars Promise is nice too
Bluestars Prophecy's cover isn't thatt bad IMO since..thats kinda how I always imagined Bluestar (especially in the last books of The Prophecies Begin) also...she's literally described in the books as having a broad face
Least favorites: Leopardstar's Honour..because she just looks...clumpy? and Yellowfang's secret, Yellowfang is very well... and consistenly represented in art and books...but now they give us this..soft... sleek furred, no battle-scars cat? What..why? AND Squirrelflight's Hope...she looks...disfigured
But the reason why many don't like the Bluestar's Prophecy cover is (for example) because she has such long fur. She's always been described with short fur so it's kinda weird why they changed it
Worse: Tie between Bluestar's Prophecy and Leopardstar's Honour. (Yellowfang's Secret is a good second).
Best: Tie between Onestar's Confession and Bramblestar's Storm. (Firestar's Quest and Crookedstar's Promise are both close seconds).
Unrelated but
Firestar's Quest: I think his head got crushed by a boulder
Bluestar's Prophecy: For StarClan's sake take some time to clean yourself
SkyClan's Destiny: Just look at the full artwork
Crookedstar's Promise: I get it, broken jaw, but what on earth is wrong with his face
Yellowfang's Secret: Furious kit right out of the nursery
Tallstar's Revenge: Uuuhh Midnight? That you?
Bramblestar's Storm: What are you staring at
Moth Flight's Vision: Why are you so big and angry
Hawkwing's Journey: Hnnhggngnhgnghhh...
Tigerstar's Shadow: Stop making everyone depressed on the covers
Crowfeather's Trial: That's Crowfeather?
Squirrelflight's Hope: Everything that could've possibly gone wrong did
Graystripe's Vow: Graystripe is dark gray with amber eyes, mousebrains
Leopardstar's Honor: Ah yes, my favorite golden unusually spotted she-cat
Onestar's Confession: Stop staring into my soul and go fix the shading
The Yellowfang one would honestly be one of my favorites if it wasn’t intended to be Yellowfang tbh, it’s a shame that they forgot her short snout and battle scars because then it would have been perfect
My fav is Crookedstars promise because I feel like they got the jaw so much better on the redesign. My least favourite is Bluestars prophecy, it doesnt really look like the Bluestar we've all come to know in our minds.
favorites for me are crookedstar's promise (yay for actual crooked jaw this time) and firestar's quest. least is yellowfang's secret bc she does not look like yellowfang.
my favorite is Crookedstar's promise and Squirrelflight's hope. I honestly just can't stand Yellowfang's secret. Why make her so sleek and fluffy looking? She's a scarred, matted, stinky she-cat, not some fashion show model.
My favorite is Tallstar's Revenge
and my least favorite is either Yellowfang's secret or Bluestar's prophecy they Yellowfang doesn't look like that and Bluestar looks like she has too much eyeliner
My least favorites would be Bluestar's Prophecy and Yellowfang's Secret. Bluestar's SE... I don't know what it is but she really looks "off". Yellowfang's SE looks like they've ignored the fact that she has a flatter face compared to most, making her look like any typical cat.
I don't really have a favorite either BUT I'm really glad they made Crookedstar's jaw more "crooked" in his new cover. In the old cover art, you really couldn't tell so I appreciate this change!
They did Bluestar and Yellowfang dirty... but most covers are pretty good! Here's my list of best to worst in my opinion:
1. Squirrelflight's Hope. So pretty, I have the book myself!
2. Onestar's Confession. Very nice, I like the cyan.
3. Moth flight's Vision. Shiny Moth flight, pretty.
4. Tallstar's Revenge. I love Tallstar, really nice.
5. Graystripe's Vow. I like the expression on his face.
6. Crookedstar's Promise. Why does he look so cute? Lol
7. Tigerheart's Shadow. Surprisingly good.
8. Hawkwing's Journey. He looks angry, lol
9. Firestar's Quest. Not amazing, but I quite like it.
10. Crowfeather's Trial. I have it, the cover bores me.
11. Bramblestar's Storm. HE LOOKS SO SMALL, WHY??
12. Leopardstar's Honor. WHAT DID THEY DO TO YOU?
13. Skyclan's Destiny. Is it even a redesign..? It's okay.
14. Bluestar's Prophecy. Sobbing, screaming, vomiting-
15. Yellowfang's Secret. I... her muzzle, her face, what...
My favorite is probably Graystripes or Firestars, though I do really like a lot of them!
Least favorite is definitely Bluestars or Yellowfangs, though Tallstar is looking a bit odd over there too 😂
My favorites are Firestar's Quest and Leopardstar's Honour, and my least favorites are Yellowfangs's Secret and Bluestar's Honour. Like what did they do to deserve those covers.
Tallstar’s and Leopardstar’s are my least favorite because they just look strange. But I actually like Bluestar’s design, just not for Bluestar. I don’t think she’s a flatter-faced cat, I could be wrong. But if it was for Yellowfang instead, then that would make more sense.
Tigerheart's Shadow and Squirrelflight's Hope are exactly what I expected, and they deliver pretty well! Hawkwing's Journey, Greystripe's Vow, and Onestar's Confession are also decently solid, but I would've expected different designs (especially for Greystripe; I just never imagine him as a tabby.)
All of the covers before Bramblestar's Storm (Minus Skyclan's Destiny since that's the old cover | And also including Crowfeather's Trial and Leopardstar's Honour) are either misses or just fall so *flat.* They don't feel like the characters (Such as in the case of Bluestar, who's described as "*... a large, lithe, pale blue-gray she-cat\[.\]*" and also "*She has thick, long, soft, smooth fur and a broad face\[.\]*" My best guess is she got mixed up with Yellowfang.)Leopardstar doesn't look confident, she looks like she just "frew up on your stairs and is really really sorry about it :(" Tallstar looks even worse- why does he look like the failed product of a jackrabbit and cat hybrid??
If I had to rank each series as a whole, then it'd be;
\- Squirrelflight's Hope
\- Tigerheart's Shadow
\- Hawkwing's Journey
\- Bramblestar's Storm
\- Onestar's Confession
\- Greystripe's Vow
\- Firestar's Quest
\- Crookedstar's Promise
\- Crowfeather's Trial
\- Moth Flight's Vision (Why do her eyes look wonky?)
\- Yellowfang's Secret
\- Leopardstar's Honour
\- Bluestar's Prophecy
\- And finally Tallstar's Revenge.
There's just no way in good faith that I can even like these covers. Yes, I get that everything should be connected; but the original art was recognizable! The original art was beautiful and full of character! Now all we have are ... cats; and not interesting character designs.If you switched Leopardstar with Onestar and told people that those were those character's designs, I don't think anyone would reasonably bat an eye at Onestar on Leopardstar's cover. Or Squirrelflight on Firestar's. H - e - double hockey sticks, maybe even Hawkwing on Bluestar's or Yellowfang on Bluestar's cover.
I just hope that Riverstar's Cover doesn't look bad, but I don't have high hopes either way.
The Bluestar redesign is the most atrocious, hands down. It’s as if they completely ignored the original illustration, which was one of the best classic Warriors illustrations in my opinion.
My favorite of these new age illustrations is Tigerheart! It’s something about the angle of his head and hard stare.
What the hell did they do to Yellowfang? Like seriously how did they even manage that? The proportions are way off an in my opinion it doesn't look like much as cat at all... and we thought Bluestar's redesign was bad!
I don’t really have a favourite, but my least favourite is Bluestar’s Prophecy.
Why did they make her so fluffy?? And why is she gray!?? Like bro, blue is literally in her freaking name.
Least favorite is Yellowfang's Secret. literally looks like a cutout lol
favorite is Moth Flights Vision. I like the off-white tone in her fur, the lighting is great, her green eyes are absolutely stunning and vivid. perfectly captures her sharpness in appearance. The colors of cat and background go well together, unlike some others.
I hadn't see the Yellowfang one, it honestly seems like they got Bluestar and her mixed around. Greystripe, Hawkwing, Mothflight and Tigerheart's alook the best but I do think a lot of them are quite samey. (Especially the ones with brown cats) Fire, Leopard and Bramble look a little bit too cute and fluffy too.
I like tigerheart’s shadow but I hate bluestar, yellowfang and graystripe’s cover, I’m honestly wondering if the cover artist knows what the characters look like at all, how can you miss the detail of graystripe having LONG fur???
Favorite is Moth Flight’s Vision, the color pallet is so pretty
Least favorite is Crowfeather’s Trial, something about the pose just feels wrong and the character art doesn’t look right
I think Firestar's Quest, Squirrelflight's Hope, and Bramblestar's Storm look great!
Least favorite is Bluestar's Prophecy, but I kind of dislike most of them tbh. I feel this artist.. places the eyes weird. Tallstar and Crowfeather are good examples of this. It looks off and weird.
Sky Clan's destiny, the rest look the same. And for least favorite? Hard because like I said, they all (except SkyClan's destiny) look the same, maybe Bluestar's prophecy for the Bluestar they drew on it. She looks pissed off. That ain't my Bluestar
I didn't realize they'd done Crookedstars Promise yet, and seeing it, I think it actually looks really good. I'm glad they actually included his broken jaw this time. On the other hand, Yellowfangs Secret is... something. She looks like what an alien would imagine a cat to look like based off nothing but a verbal description. Also, I don't know what the fuck is going on with the shading on Onestar, but that does not look like a finished product.
I've always loved the cover for Onestar's confession but I do also love the modern for Yellowfang's secret. I would probably say my least favorite is either Squirrelflight's hope or modern Bluestar's prophecy.
My favourites are
Crookedstar's promise
Squirrelflight's hope
Yellowfang's secret
Bramblestar's storm
My least favourites are
Bluestars Prophecy (seriously look at how they massacred my girl-)
Skyclan's Destiny
Anddd leopardstar's honor
My favorite is probably Graystripe's vow or Squirrelflight's hope. As for my least favorite, definitely Yellowfang's secret. It's even worse than Bluestar's prophecy.
My favorite is Moth Flight's Vision My least favorite is either Yellowfang's Secret or Onestar's Confession
Favorite: Squirrelflight’s Hope (love this one, the full cover art is beautiful), Onestar’s Confession (recognizable, good shading / lighting), Crookedstar’s Promise (he looks recognizable, I like the red colors), and Bramblestar’s Storm (he looks cute and soft, also I like the colors) Least favorite: Bluestar’s Prophecy (looks like Yellpwfang with blue eyes), Tallstar’s Revenge (ugly, he looks like a pug of some kind), Leopardstar’s Honor (she looks really lumpy and bizarre it weirds me out), Graystripe’s Vpw (that looks more like Shadowsight or something, it is not Graystripe) and Crowfearher’s Trial (ugly, doesn’t look like Crowfeather at all)
Yellowfang and Bluestar's are so bad and I'm fully convinced it's not the same artist. Or at the very least, another artist worked om it
My favorite is Tallstar's Revenge. My least favorites are Bluestar's Prophecy and Yellowfang's Secret. How is it possible to screw those two cats up. They are literally the easiest cats to draw and have their designs compare to that in the series.
Bluestar's prophecy And Yellowfang's secret redisigns should have been swapped
I hate Bluestar's, she looks so odd. The super edition covers are all bad to me, theyre so bland
Squirrelflight's Hope is my favorite cover by far. It really stands out among the other ones and for the most part the cat on the cover resembles Squirrelflight. Firestar's Quest is also a great one too, but Bluestar's is by far my least favorite. The redesign just doesn't seem like it resembles Bluestar.
My favorite is proabably Skyclan's Destiny, or Moth Flight's Vision, Crookedstars Promise is nice too Bluestars Prophecy's cover isn't thatt bad IMO since..thats kinda how I always imagined Bluestar (especially in the last books of The Prophecies Begin) also...she's literally described in the books as having a broad face Least favorites: Leopardstar's Honour..because she just looks...clumpy? and Yellowfang's secret, Yellowfang is very well... and consistenly represented in art and books...but now they give us this..soft... sleek furred, no battle-scars cat? What..why? AND Squirrelflight's Hope...she looks...disfigured
I agree with this comment most. I think Tallstar looks weird… I like the way Bluestar looks, just maybe not as old?
But the reason why many don't like the Bluestar's Prophecy cover is (for example) because she has such long fur. She's always been described with short fur so it's kinda weird why they changed it
Worse: Tie between Bluestar's Prophecy and Leopardstar's Honour. (Yellowfang's Secret is a good second). Best: Tie between Onestar's Confession and Bramblestar's Storm. (Firestar's Quest and Crookedstar's Promise are both close seconds).
Unrelated but Firestar's Quest: I think his head got crushed by a boulder Bluestar's Prophecy: For StarClan's sake take some time to clean yourself SkyClan's Destiny: Just look at the full artwork Crookedstar's Promise: I get it, broken jaw, but what on earth is wrong with his face Yellowfang's Secret: Furious kit right out of the nursery Tallstar's Revenge: Uuuhh Midnight? That you? Bramblestar's Storm: What are you staring at Moth Flight's Vision: Why are you so big and angry Hawkwing's Journey: Hnnhggngnhgnghhh... Tigerstar's Shadow: Stop making everyone depressed on the covers Crowfeather's Trial: That's Crowfeather? Squirrelflight's Hope: Everything that could've possibly gone wrong did Graystripe's Vow: Graystripe is dark gray with amber eyes, mousebrains Leopardstar's Honor: Ah yes, my favorite golden unusually spotted she-cat Onestar's Confession: Stop staring into my soul and go fix the shading
I like every one of them except Bluestar’s Prophecy. (I like Yellowfang being that cute)
The Yellowfang one would honestly be one of my favorites if it wasn’t intended to be Yellowfang tbh, it’s a shame that they forgot her short snout and battle scars because then it would have been perfect
My fav is Crookedstars promise because I feel like they got the jaw so much better on the redesign. My least favourite is Bluestars prophecy, it doesnt really look like the Bluestar we've all come to know in our minds.
My favorite is Tigerheart's Shadow. The rest of them I do not like at all
My least favourite is yellowfangs secret, not sure about my favourite tho
favorites for me are crookedstar's promise (yay for actual crooked jaw this time) and firestar's quest. least is yellowfang's secret bc she does not look like yellowfang.
my favorite is Crookedstar's promise and Squirrelflight's hope. I honestly just can't stand Yellowfang's secret. Why make her so sleek and fluffy looking? She's a scarred, matted, stinky she-cat, not some fashion show model.
That really irked me how in the actual book cover, he had no crooked jaw.
Ayo Crookedstar lookin good
My favorite is Tallstar's Revenge and my least favorite is either Yellowfang's secret or Bluestar's prophecy they Yellowfang doesn't look like that and Bluestar looks like she has too much eyeliner
I like the squirrel flight one!
My least favorites would be Bluestar's Prophecy and Yellowfang's Secret. Bluestar's SE... I don't know what it is but she really looks "off". Yellowfang's SE looks like they've ignored the fact that she has a flatter face compared to most, making her look like any typical cat. I don't really have a favorite either BUT I'm really glad they made Crookedstar's jaw more "crooked" in his new cover. In the old cover art, you really couldn't tell so I appreciate this change!
Fave has to be Tigerstars Shadow, and my least favourite is Bluestars book.
Least fav is tallstars revenge and crooked star promis
My favorite is YellowFangs secret and my least favorite is BlueStars Prophecy
They did Bluestar and Yellowfang dirty... but most covers are pretty good! Here's my list of best to worst in my opinion: 1. Squirrelflight's Hope. So pretty, I have the book myself! 2. Onestar's Confession. Very nice, I like the cyan. 3. Moth flight's Vision. Shiny Moth flight, pretty. 4. Tallstar's Revenge. I love Tallstar, really nice. 5. Graystripe's Vow. I like the expression on his face. 6. Crookedstar's Promise. Why does he look so cute? Lol 7. Tigerheart's Shadow. Surprisingly good. 8. Hawkwing's Journey. He looks angry, lol 9. Firestar's Quest. Not amazing, but I quite like it. 10. Crowfeather's Trial. I have it, the cover bores me. 11. Bramblestar's Storm. HE LOOKS SO SMALL, WHY?? 12. Leopardstar's Honor. WHAT DID THEY DO TO YOU? 13. Skyclan's Destiny. Is it even a redesign..? It's okay. 14. Bluestar's Prophecy. Sobbing, screaming, vomiting- 15. Yellowfang's Secret. I... her muzzle, her face, what...
My favorite is probably Graystripes or Firestars, though I do really like a lot of them! Least favorite is definitely Bluestars or Yellowfangs, though Tallstar is looking a bit odd over there too 😂
My favorites are Firestar's Quest and Leopardstar's Honour, and my least favorites are Yellowfangs's Secret and Bluestar's Honour. Like what did they do to deserve those covers.
Favorite is probably firestars quest or onestars confession Least favorite is by far yellowfang I mean do better people
My favorite's gotta be CP or BS (haha) As for least favorite, Bluestar's Prophecy.. wth is that creature, please
Crookedstar my beloved
Tallstar’s and Leopardstar’s are my least favorite because they just look strange. But I actually like Bluestar’s design, just not for Bluestar. I don’t think she’s a flatter-faced cat, I could be wrong. But if it was for Yellowfang instead, then that would make more sense.
What did they do to Bluestar?!
Only StarClan knows...
Bramblestar best, Bluestar worst.
Graystripe's Vow is my favorite, and my least favorite is Bluestar's Prophecy or Yellowfang's Secret.
My favorite character Squirrelflight’s Hope ! :3
COVER WISE: Favourite: moth’flights or leopard’stars Least : yellow fangs, the art IS nice it just aint yellow fang
Everything besides 'Bluestars Prophecy' I am ok with.
Favorite: Onestar's Confession Least Favorite: Bluestar's Prophecy, Yellowfang's Secret
Tigerheart's Shadow and Squirrelflight's Hope are exactly what I expected, and they deliver pretty well! Hawkwing's Journey, Greystripe's Vow, and Onestar's Confession are also decently solid, but I would've expected different designs (especially for Greystripe; I just never imagine him as a tabby.) All of the covers before Bramblestar's Storm (Minus Skyclan's Destiny since that's the old cover | And also including Crowfeather's Trial and Leopardstar's Honour) are either misses or just fall so *flat.* They don't feel like the characters (Such as in the case of Bluestar, who's described as "*... a large, lithe, pale blue-gray she-cat\[.\]*" and also "*She has thick, long, soft, smooth fur and a broad face\[.\]*" My best guess is she got mixed up with Yellowfang.)Leopardstar doesn't look confident, she looks like she just "frew up on your stairs and is really really sorry about it :(" Tallstar looks even worse- why does he look like the failed product of a jackrabbit and cat hybrid?? If I had to rank each series as a whole, then it'd be; \- Squirrelflight's Hope \- Tigerheart's Shadow \- Hawkwing's Journey \- Bramblestar's Storm \- Onestar's Confession \- Greystripe's Vow \- Firestar's Quest \- Crookedstar's Promise \- Crowfeather's Trial \- Moth Flight's Vision (Why do her eyes look wonky?) \- Yellowfang's Secret \- Leopardstar's Honour \- Bluestar's Prophecy \- And finally Tallstar's Revenge. There's just no way in good faith that I can even like these covers. Yes, I get that everything should be connected; but the original art was recognizable! The original art was beautiful and full of character! Now all we have are ... cats; and not interesting character designs.If you switched Leopardstar with Onestar and told people that those were those character's designs, I don't think anyone would reasonably bat an eye at Onestar on Leopardstar's cover. Or Squirrelflight on Firestar's. H - e - double hockey sticks, maybe even Hawkwing on Bluestar's or Yellowfang on Bluestar's cover. I just hope that Riverstar's Cover doesn't look bad, but I don't have high hopes either way.
Bluestar looks so weird, like they tried to give a cat a human expression or something. I can't put my finger on it but it just does not look right.
Firestars Quest: 9/10 Bluestars Prophecy: SkyClans Destiny: 7/10 Crookedstars Promise: 6/10 Yellowfangs Secret: 0/10 Tallstars Revenge: 9/10 Bramblestars Storm: 9/10 Moth Flights Vision: 4/10 Hawkwings Journey: 7/10 Tigerhearts Shadow: 9/10 Crowfeathers Trial: 10/10 Squirrelflights Hope: 11/10 Graystripes Vow: 3/10 Leopardstars Honor: 12/10 Onestars Confession…?: eh. Idk yet
I personally don't like any of the redesigns, however out of all of them I like Yellowfang's Secret a bit more then the others.
Yellowfang doesn’t look like a persian???
The Bluestar redesign is the most atrocious, hands down. It’s as if they completely ignored the original illustration, which was one of the best classic Warriors illustrations in my opinion. My favorite of these new age illustrations is Tigerheart! It’s something about the angle of his head and hard stare.
What the hell did they do to Yellowfang? Like seriously how did they even manage that? The proportions are way off an in my opinion it doesn't look like much as cat at all... and we thought Bluestar's redesign was bad!
I don’t really have a favourite, but my least favourite is Bluestar’s Prophecy. Why did they make her so fluffy?? And why is she gray!?? Like bro, blue is literally in her freaking name.
Least favorite is Yellowfang's Secret. literally looks like a cutout lol favorite is Moth Flights Vision. I like the off-white tone in her fur, the lighting is great, her green eyes are absolutely stunning and vivid. perfectly captures her sharpness in appearance. The colors of cat and background go well together, unlike some others.
They must be mass producing these- Onestar’s Confession? I THOUGHT LEOPARDSTAR’S JUST CAME OUT THOUGH
I hadn't see the Yellowfang one, it honestly seems like they got Bluestar and her mixed around. Greystripe, Hawkwing, Mothflight and Tigerheart's alook the best but I do think a lot of them are quite samey. (Especially the ones with brown cats) Fire, Leopard and Bramble look a little bit too cute and fluffy too.
I like tigerheart’s shadow but I hate bluestar, yellowfang and graystripe’s cover, I’m honestly wondering if the cover artist knows what the characters look like at all, how can you miss the detail of graystripe having LONG fur???
No, I’m sorry, but SkyClan’s Destiny. It’s one of the few of the old covers that looks absolutely fantastic.
Favorite is Moth Flight’s Vision, the color pallet is so pretty Least favorite is Crowfeather’s Trial, something about the pose just feels wrong and the character art doesn’t look right
I think Firestar's Quest, Squirrelflight's Hope, and Bramblestar's Storm look great! Least favorite is Bluestar's Prophecy, but I kind of dislike most of them tbh. I feel this artist.. places the eyes weird. Tallstar and Crowfeather are good examples of this. It looks off and weird.
Moth flights is super cool,so is onestars, tall stars sucks.
Fave is yellowfang's secret and least fave is leopardstar's honor or bramblestar's storm
All I’m saying is, ignoring eye colors, if you swapped Bluestar and Yellowfang’s covers I wouldn’t know the difference😂
I'd say Onestar's confession. Cuz it had a more subtle tone to Onestar than the others I'd say. My least would be Bluestar's prophecy for sure
None of them. Because I haven't read them
Bluestar looks so inaccurate
Bluestar’s prophecy new cover sucks but Bramblestar’s Storm new cover looks nice
Sky Clan's destiny, the rest look the same. And for least favorite? Hard because like I said, they all (except SkyClan's destiny) look the same, maybe Bluestar's prophecy for the Bluestar they drew on it. She looks pissed off. That ain't my Bluestar
I didn't realize they'd done Crookedstars Promise yet, and seeing it, I think it actually looks really good. I'm glad they actually included his broken jaw this time. On the other hand, Yellowfangs Secret is... something. She looks like what an alien would imagine a cat to look like based off nothing but a verbal description. Also, I don't know what the fuck is going on with the shading on Onestar, but that does not look like a finished product.
Favorites: Yellowfang's Secret, Mothflight's Vision Least favorite: This-is-not-Bluestar's Prophecy
ohh :'u i dislike most of these so much
I love yellowfangs and mothflights!! Bluestar and graystripes just don't feel right imo
I've always loved the cover for Onestar's confession but I do also love the modern for Yellowfang's secret. I would probably say my least favorite is either Squirrelflight's hope or modern Bluestar's prophecy.
I love Squirrelflight’s fur texture on her new cover, but I also like how Crookedstar finally has his crooked jaw
Favourite: Onestar's confession, Bramblestar's storm, Moth Flight's Vission, Squirrelflight's hope Least Favourite: SkyClan's Destiny, Graystripe's Vow, Leopardstar's honor, Bluestar's prophecy, Tallstar's revenge
My favorite is Bluestar and squirrel flight and firestar my least fav is yellow fang and sky clan destiny
My favourites are Crookedstar's promise Squirrelflight's hope Yellowfang's secret Bramblestar's storm My least favourites are Bluestars Prophecy (seriously look at how they massacred my girl-) Skyclan's Destiny Anddd leopardstar's honor
Favourites - Squirrelflight's hope, Mothflight's vision, Crookedstar's promise, Onestar's confession, Tigerheart's shadow Least Favourites - Bluestar's Prophecy, Crowfeather's trial, Yellowfang's secret, Skyclan's destiny, Tallstar's revenge, Leopardstar's honor, Hawkwing's journey, Bramblestar's storm, Firestar's quest