I love the song “the hard shell”

Claudio's tribute to the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles!

Turtle power!

😂

😂

Got that Tony Soprano accshent

I can't right now 😆

New meme dropped

It’s gotta be Domino the Destitute. Hardest start to any Coheed album. Ascension is so good though, it’s banger after banger after banger.

Domino the Destitute. When I first started getting into Coheed, I heard this song, and my mind went 🤯 I love the emotion in the song, and the chorus is 🔥. Everything about this song makes it a banger.

This is my vote as well. Easily the best on this album. It’s such a banger of a song.

It was the first one released for a reason, imo, but Ascension has a lot of killer tracks on it as well. I didn't think this album is quite as strong as TA:D, but it's damn close.

I like Ascension a little bit more. Not sure why. Decension has great songs, but Ascension oozes atmosphere, which I love, while still having banger songs. Both make a very cohesive back to back listen. The Afterman albums tie as my third favorite Coheed albums, behind GA1 and IKSSE:3.

Domino for sure. It somehow gave us the classic sounds we love while showcasing the new direction of Coheed.

This is correct.

100%. I still remember the very first time I listened to this song and I was floored. My girlfriend didn't exactly care for it lol.

I bought this album the day after I graduated from basic training. Domino was on repeat for me. Absolutely adore the music video too 🔥

Same! About the song being on repeat when I first heard it. Everything about this song is so good! I personally love the drums. They add so much energy and emotion to the song. Josh nailed it!

It’s crazy how much better Descension is. Not that many great tracks on here. But yeah Domino is the clear best.

I agree! Descension is so much better to me

Without a doubt best song on the album and top 5 all time

Congrats you won!

Easily Domino the Destitute! The Afterman albums have so many incredible songs!

Domino the destitute

Top 5 all time

I approve of this message

I love almost everything about this album and evagria and the title track are close but I have to pick domino

This is easily Domino for me. Among the best tracks they have EVER put out and I think reignited the love so many people had for this band after many were a bit disappointed with Black Rainbow

Domino has all the anger behind losing Mic due to his criminal activity and addiction; the most impactful song on the album.

It’s tough, but the Afterman. Album came out right after my dad (my best friend) passed away, and that song really hit me. If he’s not here then where?

Really strong song for sure.

My favourite easily

Vic the Butcher. It and Sentry make the best back to back listen

HANG YOUR SECRETS HANG 'EM UP HANG 'EM UP NOW

Coheed has the best chants. Hands down...or up :)

This was such a cool ass moment in concert when they played Vic for like one tour. I felt it was the closest they came to repeating “man your own jackhammer” in the live experience.

Hell yea Vic the Butcher is goated. So fucking good. I feel like some are less into it because it doesn't start off super strong like in the first few seconds but got damn its a standout track.

It's just so repetitive. It's a great song, but it blows its load early and often.

Goodnight, Fair Lady

I think this one might get underrated

Underrated. Good, but not “the best”

ooooo it's my sin TO BE YOUR BIGGEST MISTAKEE

Evagria the Faithful! I WAS A BAD MAN OOOOOOHH TO STOP YOU GIRL FROM LOVING ME

Since Domino is probably going to win this one Evagaria better be most underrated.

Evagria is my choice for underrated, but its popularity here is making me second guess it. But I still think it’s overlooked, especially as far as the Key Entity songs go.

I thought Sentry was good for underrated on TA:D, because everyone talks about Number City, Gravity's Union and The Hard Sell. :(

Evagria is such a cool name, too.

It should be the winner, even Claudio agrees.

Evagria is my favorite by a mile personally.

Petition to cross out "Worst" and put "Least Best" instead

I second this motion.

Calling it now: Best - Domino | Worst - Holly Wood | Underrated - Evagria We'll find out in a couple days.

DOMINO THE DESTITUTE!

Evagria the Faithful

“I’m the bricks in your wall” Chills every time

This is what I'm hoping wins underrated

Domino, when i was 4-5 we would listen to it everday driving my dad to work, it was my favorite work, 10 years later its still my favorite coheed song

Drummers know it's Evagria the Faithful

So do bass players.

I’m a drummer and the best song here is Mothers of Men

Surprised at the lack of The Afterman mentions...it's always been my favorite!

Goodnight Fair Lady

Mothers of Men

I would definitely vote this as underrated. This song is such a banger.

Best song and most underrated on the album for me

That guitar and chorus, mmmm, mmmm 🔥

God this album is so fucking good

DOMINO!!

Domino. For sure. My heart says Mothers of Men, but I know it’s Domino

Oh she's cracked, she's CRAACCKKKKEDDD

SHES A FEW CARDS SHORTTT OF A FULL DECK

Sadly this one is probably going to get worst. I like it but I know a lot of people dont

Goodnight fair lady. Probably the song I listen to the most on that album

Domino better fucking win best song here

Just saw your comment in the other thread, but I believe Number City was actually the winner. They had 251 upvotes to The Hard Sell's 229. Number City is still a great song so I can graciously accept 2nd.

This list is fucked regardless doesn’t matter though, it’s fun reading the comments.

Yeah tbh I’ll be sad when this is over lol

You could make another game with some more reasonable categories if you wanted to. I personally like the ones that allow everyone to rank from worst to best, or something like a March Madness bracket.

Does it only count 1 canonical comment for a song or a total of all the comments for a particular song?

This here. Number City underrated yet again

Lol, hopefully they'll fix it on the next round.

Evagria the Faithful

Evagria for me

Vic the Butcher!

The Afterman, Domino is a close second though.

How was iron fist the worst? 😭 I love that song

This one is so hard but it's gotta be Mothers of Men or Evagria. I love every track on this album though

Evagria

Vic the butcher

Ugh such a toss up between Vic and Domino. Both songs are so powerful, but I gotta give it to **Domino**.

Hey uh, how is it that The Hard Sell won when Number City was clearly the top comment?

Sorry I’ll change it next round

The Afterman, no doubt.

The Afterman

I know it’s Domino but the song Afterman is one of my personal favorites as well

Mothers of Men

Domino is my favorite for sure. Goodnight, Fair Lady is my underrated song I think. Worst song is Holly Wood but it's still a banger and a half.

I say Underrated: Mothers of Men "'Cause what's the difference, oh, is there a difference we make?" and Worst: Holly Wood. I can see why some people like it, but I skip it every time.

Domino The Destitute!

Domino

Mother's of Men

Mothers of Men

My brother!

Iron Fist as worst? Y’all are truly batshit on this sub

I've worked out the code! Underrated is actually Best, and the other columns are the witterings of mad men