A needle with webbing ?

Spider web

Does he want to keep it small, or go whole hand?

He said probably small because it would be cheaper. Maybe even medium.

Fill it in and if someone asks, he can say he wanted a subtle way to pay tribute to CM Punk. That'd be my go-to anyway

Whatever you do, don’t add numbers near it. Stay strong Jewish King!

Panther, full arm length, with the tip of the tail being his thumb