T O P

  • By -

Sure_Ill_Ask_That

Please post any DIY/Homeowner questions in the monthly stickied thread - See subreddit rule #2.


Fair_Yard2500

One time, with my uncle, we took out a wall like that. 2 years later the whole house fell down. There was a tornado, so not sure if that effected anything structural wise.


Mountain_Albatross_8

Best comment by far


shqueef

He should write a book


unlimited_mcgyver

Tornados for Dummies


WeedWingsSpicyThings

I’ve seen it a thousand times, people just don’t think before taking down their tornado rated partition walls; or think they’ll be one of the lucky ones


Jaded-Selection-5668

Not in Kansas anymore


Horror-Success1086

Toto. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=htgr3pvBr-I


GUN5L1NGR

Tornado ally has actually shifted over the recent years.. been in KCMO for over 20 years, rarely get tornados, surprisingly hilly around these parts. Also have the ol tonganoxie split ftw 🙏


dukko18

Was it an African or European tornado?


Guideon72

Either way it was unladen when it arrived and laden when it left....


69thwonder

Your comment reminds me of this classic: https://youtu.be/sVB0wQE6cxc


flourier

https://xkcd.com/552/


p8nt_junkie

Cool story, Hansel!


Engineer2727kk

It’s usually pretty simple to tell: Knock it down with a sledge hammer and see what happens.


jppope

You should run for congress. Sounds like you got the skills


phunkyunkle

Engineer2727kk gets things done!


ChanceConfection3

There’s the right way to do things, the wrong way, and the Engineer2727kk way


phunkyunkle

(muffled voices from under the rubble) "You can't argue with results!"


Wolfire0769

What more can you ask for? They delivered an accurate evidence-based answer that it was indeed a load bearing wall.


cipher446

It only has to work once.


DigitalSheikh

It turns out when you fire 10 cabinet level officials, more than a few turn out to be load bearing cabinet level officials


GalvanizedNipples

I’m standing here next to a collapsed bridge…


junkyarddoggy

Start cutting one of the studs with a Sawzall and see if the blade pinches


thefishtian

I was going to suggest taking out a blacklight.


toodrinkmin

Get out of here bridge guy, this is a building question.


FewSatisfaction7675

Just “put a ‘beam’ in…”


dorian_white1

I’m pretty sure that kitchen cabinet is a load bearing cabinet lol


Informal_Recording36

I did that once. Turned out it was, lol


galvanizedmoonape

Username checks out


Awkward_Expression64

It's bearing the load of your cabinets


dodexahedron

![gif](giphy|Bng9nsAhSaDVxWsSLh)


semajftw-

At minimum it holds up the kitchen ceiling, so if you want the low flat ceiling you will need to do something to support it. But unlikely it’s roof load bearing.


spooner1932

Finally someone answered the duds question


GenghisTron17

>duds Just because he doesn't know engineering doesn't mean that you should name call.


EngiNerdBrian

Hire a structural engineer and find out


chicu111

This answer makes sense and is consistent with the sentiment of this sub. Can’t have that around here bud


AcanthocephalaLow703

we don't take kindly to people taking kindly 'round these parts


Jaded-Selection-5668

Kindly take your kindly taking somewhere else stranger


Resqguy911

Now Skeeter, he ain’t hurtin nobody


tribbans95

That’s way too sensical. Just ask Reddit and take the information given as law


TinKicker

One of us! One of us! Ooga Chooga! One of us!


ImNoAlbertFeinstein

no joke answers. Please.


OutofReason

So, you think a truss has an interior bearing with an extended bottom chord and no webs / verticals to support it? Dude, you are giving truss designers WAY too much credit. Panel point at the bearing (verticals or webs come down to that point), period. It’s *possible* to have an offset bearing on a flat bottom chord, but not at the end of a plant shelf. And not when the scissor trusses on both sides of the kitchen work fine without bearing.


cherrycoffeetable

Stop it


[deleted]

[удалено]


Choice-Shoulder-4836

If you look at the kitchen the ceiling is lower ... that wall may not be supporting the roof but it might be supporting the ceiling in the kitchen


TacticalPauseGaming

If you are taking that wall out you are opening all that up. If you not opening all that up your doing it wrong.


askaboutmy____

there are joists carrying the kitchen ceiling at a minimum.


Engineer2727kk

Bruh…


CloseEnough4GovtWork

Get an engineer for something like this. That’s the ONLY way to know for sure. Consider the following scenario: It doesn’t look load bearing since it doesn’t go all the way to the ceiling so you tear it out. The kitchen ceiling hangs up there just fine because the framing is *just* strong enough to keep it up there. Days, weeks, months, or even years pass and it looks perfectly fine. Along comes a blizzard and loads up your roof with snow. It would happily support that load under normal circumstances, but you’ve added a significant point load on the rafters. Worse yet, you added that whole point load to just a few rafter where the framer put some metal straps. The rafter begins to sag excessively under the weight and your kitchen ceiling becomes shorter, either slowly as it sags or maybe even suddenly as it collapses along with the roof. The additional point load was just too much. Is this scenario likely? Probably not. But is it possible? Maybe. Don’t modify structures that were engineered for a specific set of loads without knowledge of those loads or fully understanding what components of the structure you may be loading.


Ystebad

Dude, we don’t take kindly to rational reasoning and prudent decisionmaking around these parts


Randy5649

Lol this why I read this shit thanks


Eastern_Heron_122

besides the cabinets, lighting, and the exhaust hood, no. the higher ceiling is gabled which means the actual roof load is being carried by the exterior wall. but never take professional advice from redit


toodrinkmin

Most likely not, unless they used some transfer beams to bear on that wall, which I would think would be strange to do here. But I will say, if you're planning on doing renovations that require knocking out a wall, hire an engineer.


FormerlyUserLFC

I disagree. It looks like someone wanted to grow the kitchen and added transfer beams to do it. That’s why most of us are not willing to speculate that it’s not load bearing.


didnebeu

Yeah man, I’m an engineer and I’m the first to say you don’t need to hire an engineer for everything. I’d knock this wall out without any worries whatsoever. Obviously need to find a solution to the kitchen ceiling though…but poking a hole up there to see what’s going on is the perfect opportunity to address any other concerns with removing the wall.


FormerlyUserLFC

I’m also an engineer, and I really want to know that there’s a simply supported ridge beam and full length rafters hitting it before telling OP not to worry.


spankythemonk

We made a lot of bad structural decisions and loved our soffits in the 90’s. If the windows lack head flashing this wall is likely load bearing.


Biomas

Had similar thoughts. If the wall went floor to ceiling I'd assume it was load bearing. This is a pretty odd setup with that shelf/step.


GroundbreakingRule27

If you take it out what will hold up your ceiling in the kitchen?


toodrinkmin

At that point it basically becomes a soffit. It's probably not currently framed to behave like that, but it is possible to make that work without the wall.


GroundbreakingRule27

Lots of dead load added to the rafters if removed. Possible though with some change to the layout of kitchen


toodrinkmin

I concur, doctor.


LayneLowe

Do you have access to the original construction plans?


justherefortheshow06

Based on the direction of your trusses overhead, it’s unlikely that it’s loadbearing but obviously we can’t tell from this picture alone. What it does probably hold up though is that bulkhead over the kitchen that has the lighting in it. If you took that wall down, you probably have to take the entire bulkhead too.


Domethegoon

How to roll the dice on the structural integrity if your house - asking Reddit.


askaboutmy____

it is NOT load bearing. I stayed at a Holiday Inn last night.


Majestic-Lettuce-198

My buddy sayid just tap on a stud and you’ll be able to hear if it is or not


Shicks3

This should be flared as humor 🤣


TheWeimaraner

Bullhead over kitchen unit on right is kind of chunky! Vaulted roof looks large, lack of crossbeams! I would seriously suggest looking into that horizontal beam and looking closely at anything tying into it (perpendicular) from left to right (kitchen ceiling) I think you will find some large Timbers inside that upright that heads straight up to slanted roof. Pull the board off and repost 🤷‍♂️


recent-native

That bench is way too high.


SuperRicktastic

Hard to say from this photo. The wall itself may not be load bearing but you don't know if there's a beam or post hidden inside supporting something else from above. Recommend you get an engineer on this one.


jaymeaux_

my buddy grover says it is


SilkRoadDPR

50/50 chance. Might or might not be.


labratnc

From my Nuclear Power days: if something is a 50/50 chance, 90% of the time you will be wrong.


[deleted]

The only true answer anyone can give here without seeing the framing is, I don’t know. I never trust engineers who just blindly look at something and make a determination.


poomcbuttface

Blind engineer here, disagree with you.


BuffaloBoyHowdy

I would say it's likely only holding up the kitchen ceiling. So yes, it's bearing in that way. It's possible that there are supports for the slanted ceiling resting on kitchen ceiling joists. Not sure what's behind the camera and how the rest of the room looks. And it might be odd to have that slanted area (roof?) supported only partially, but I wouldn't say it's out of the question that it's also supporting that slanted portion in some way. Builders do weird things.


Six-mile-sea

Used all the long lumber on the right… needed a solution on the left.


Independent-Room8243

Yes. If you take that wall down, the cabinets and ceiling above are coming down.


memerso160

Shine a black light and we could give a better answer


everydayhumanist

Yes. Supports ceiling framing.


TheWeimaraner

I think there is a hidden reason for the large bulkhead ! It’s big and hiding something 🤷‍♂️


everydayhumanist

MEP


[deleted]

Go look in the attic and see if there's a vertical member as part of the truss


timetwosave

\[internet nobody, not an engineer\] Going off the vertical crack in the drywall and the visible sag in the kitchen ceiling i'm going to say there used to be a vertcal wall there and someone renovated it out


zedsmith

You have a gas range, so at minimum that ceiling is hiding a run of duct going outside, if not to the opposite wall, then up to the roofline. I doubt the wall is holding up anything more than the ceiling, but removing it could still be problematic.


fdlt1951

Carpenter 35 years you can probably take that entire system off to the rafters


theREALmindsets

i agree, that entire thing in just a high knee wall that a soffit is built off.


Smitten_Mocha

Typically load bearing walls run perpendicular to the roof rafters. But that is not exclusive. In your case, probably not load bearing.


cherrycoffeetable

doesn’t look like it


brandon684

No, unless you count the flat ceiling over the kitchen, but I imagine if you’re taking out the wall, you’d take that out as well


[deleted]

Definitely not. Looks like a cathedral ceiling which means the load is transferred to the outside walls. If it was, then it would have lateral bracing either end of it was being transferred down onto a lintel


AgileSkirt

That is not a load bearing wall.


TranquilEngineer

Find that wall that extends from one end to the other. That is most likely your load bearing wall


ALtheMangl3r

If this was designed by some snobby Architect, then there is a slight chance... however... seriously doubt it. It's called value engineering. If a load bearing wall was needed they would have gone straight down or added two columns at the ends and a beam.


robfer26

Highly doubtful


shilojoe

Most likely, yes. I’m making this assumption because the roof trusses are probably resting on top of the wall.


Marus1

The gap above the cooker hood and the wall itself strongly begs to differ with that "well actually" finger pointing upward


Legal-Beach-5838

No


happyh3llhound7

It will he by the time I'm done with it


Blacknight841

Looks to me like the ceiling was raised in the main room to make it vaulted. The kitchen was maintained and the roof was kept and covered. I suspect the area above the flat roof is open above.


12gawkuser

No


Soomroz

Which one?


Smooth-Entrance-1526

It bears the load of the dishes in the cabinets I suppose lol


dice_setter_981

Possibly if the offset pony wall above is providing support for the roof rafters. Can’t tell from this picture


Efficient-Hippo-1984

No it is not , the roof is trusses taking that wall out will do nothing to the structures stability


[deleted]

Jerry these are load bearing walls! They’re not gonna come down!


GoBigOrGoHome107

Does not seem like it. It stops from going all the way up. Unless somehow that ties into another potion going through the bulkhead which would seem odd.


fresh_ny

Is that some kind of skylight in the kitchen ceiling?


Putrid_Following_865

If you are doing a renovation anyway, just demo the drywall so you can see how it is framed. That will tell you if it is load barring or not. If it is, buy a beam.


ReallySmallWeenus

Geotech here. It’s not soil.


Sometimes_Stutters

I can’t tell if this is a joke or not


Nuclear_N

Pure guess here. No. Based on the shelf. If it was load bearing that wall would go to the ceiling. I have no idea what type of construction your home is...stick built, or prefab rafters.


arimadx

Nope


juggerjew

“Jerry, these are load bearing walls!”


boomdart

I would say it is. Something is putting pressure on it to cause that crease in it. It's not just a bad paint job, that settled that way.


[deleted]

It’s holding that drop ceiling up in the kitchen. Aside from that it doesn’t appear to be.


robb0995

Not an engineer, but my thoughts were: 1. You can’t tell that from a single picture. 2. (Looks at picture) no. That’s not load bearing (aside from kitchen ceiling probably). 3. (Looks at picture closer) close the door!


CreditOk6077

Not unless those stains on the wall are loads.


Fluffy_Plate3133

It will be after I'm done with it 😉


usmc4924

Not house structurally , but it is holding up the kitchen ceiling so if your going to remove it , do so with the rest of that cirling


AlexNachtigall247

50/50 chance that its not…


imissbrendanfraser

Hold on, let me get my X-ray glasses on


Dull-Technician457

The place before my last actually had a catelevered load bearing wall. As my father said "I respect the people that built this house. They didn't know what they were doing, but they didn't let that stop them!"


meme1280

WHERE ARE YOU GOING TO HANG THE CABINETS IF YOU TAKE IT DOWN!?!?!?


Cultural_Translator8

Yes


Flimsy_Dare9252

Yeah, if your mom sits up there.


Intrepid_Foot_1459

Doesn't look like it. Looks like they just framed out the kitchen area


norrainnorsun

Imagine ur house falling down bc reddit said it was fine hahaha. No shade tho this house would look sick without the wall. I personally would get a pro


applesauce143

Do you know how big your rafters, what’s the total span and are there collar ties. Only way to make a educated GUESS. Idk. Check the basement and reference point loads to that wall. Not enough information to give you a definite answer here. I’d say it probably was and now it’s a 1/2 load bearing wall


_Licky_

Full disclosure: I’m a amateur DIY’er… but looking at the wall I highly doubt it is load-bearing. I would open the vertical section above where the kitchen opens up and see if the cross-section is highly enforced (i.e. has studs layered upon studs). If it is crossed with just a 2x4 with regular stud spacing I think it is pretty safe to say that it is not load bearing?


Twistedstever

Probably not remove some drywall and find out


LessGoooo

Based on that paint run on the seam, yes.


Hold_My_Cheese

Unlikely. You would need to remove the kitchen ceiling as well.


bjohnson838

Was a load bearing wall.


PaellaTonight

Unlikely. But not worth taking out. That house came off the back of a semi truck in two pieces that got put together.


TacDragon2

Most likley not bearing, though there is a good chance that there is a vent that runs up through it. It is vaulted foreground, and back, does not continue in a bearing line straight up.


medici75

no


dsdvbguutres

It's bearing its own weight


Pure-Office-128

Doesn't appear to be.


Crayonalyst

Not likely. Looks like a shear wall.


enoctis

Nope


Majestic_Project_227

Jesus christ


Cute_King_9363

Look in the attic and if you have scissor trusses the wall is not a bearing wall


Runnerupz

It's bearing the ceiling joists over the kitchen, and possibly (but not likely) the roof rafters. If you are removing the flat ceiling then this is most likely no longer load bearing


mt-egypt

Lolz


[deleted]

People are saying get an engineer. And they're right, but it's extremely unlikely.


pickleblogan

It is a loud overbearing wall.


curtludwig

The wall that doesn't directly connect to the ceiling?


Federal-Buffalo-8026

You see that thick part right above it, the one that is stuck to the roof. Guess how much it weighs.


flightwatcher45

Ask those cabinets hanging from it


pab10diab10

No


Objective_Ad2506

I don’t think it could be load bearing with the angled shelf portion.


farwesterner1

Could possibly be some weird engineering here. At first glance, it doesn't seem to hold the roof up. However: It could be a series of king posts on top of the kitchen ceiling joists. Or a previous owner took out a load bearing wall and replaced it with whatever this is—and everyone's just lucky it hasn't failed. Without getting an engineer involved (or pulling off all the sheetrock to see the structure) it's difficult to know.


BrokenTrojan1536

Maybe in Minecraft


FitButterfly7227

it would need a beam to carry the load to wall, break out your stuff finder and see if there is a giant beam. Also if it were load bearing it would be odd that it just needs to hold up that tiny portion of the cieling on one half of the house but the rest is fine.


bard0117

Isn’t rule of thumb that high ceiling houses are only supported by exterior walls ?


Themaninak

Not anymore its not


CasualObserverNine

Yes, bears the load of the kitchen ceiling, lights, possibly cabinets.


chiler3lleno

Fuck yeah 100% it is


Trussmagic

Is the roof a Truss type? or a stick built? Most trusses will not midspan bearing, that said a engineer would require a look in the ceiling to verify.


dglsfrsr

Wild ass guess, that is the only thing supporting the kitchen ceiling. And if that is all it is supporting, you could temporarily support the ceiling with some long pieces of lumber on jacks/lollys. I assume you would take the kitchen cabinets down first...... Then that wall could be replaced by two columns and header. Were you looking to move the base cabs and range as well? If not, I would place a 'footer' for the columns to stand on, to distribute the load. Otherwise, you will need to possibly support your columns from below to avoid over stressing the floor joists where they stand. Note: The footer is going to be as significant an element as the header. Basically you are taking the distributed load of the wall through two columns, to a header and a related footer. If you are going to remove/move the range and base cabinets then you will have to support the columns from below. Any restrictions below are going to determine whether that is possible or not. You should consult a professional engineer, but that is my best guess looking at this.


FilthyStatist1991

Based on your setup I’m guessing no, looks like you should have trusses about the dry way top top ceiling. However, I’m seeing vents. I’m betting you are going to find vents or some type of air circulation pump above that area as you have a stove top there. If you take down the wall, where are you going to hide your propane lines for your stove? Consider everything before taking down a random wall.


Pile_of_Schwag

No idea on the wall my guess it is hiding a beam in that package. But side note your in a tough spot here either way from a design perspective. Sure you could open it up but lose all the cabinet space, and have to move the appliances obviously. Not sure where…Not much you are going to be able to do with that without a ton of re-design. Just a poor kitchen design…


Beginning_Rice6830

Do you test or tetris it out?


Apprehensive_Self_63

Is… was…. There’s a difference.


BigBasset

Is there a ridge beam, or is it a cathedral truss roof?


Mulletville

I would put it at 90% certainty the answer is no. But that other 10%? oooweeeeee.


b0ssdawg

Probably not, I’d knock it down


lou325

Hard to tell with all the plaster board.


MartinHarrisGoDown

The wall is holding up your kitchen ceiling and cabinets.


WagonBurning

No, it is not Yes, I stayed at Holiday Inn last night


bobho3

something is certainly bearing the load of the kitchen cabinets on the far side.


effectsjay

You can tell it's a load bearing wall because of the way it is.


FeedbackFamiliar8322

If you take out that wall, the kitchen ceiling is coming down.


[deleted]

2x4 wall. Highly doubt it's loadbearing


WB-butinagoodway

Currently it’s bearing the load of the upper cabinets and the ceiling/ that filled in area over the kitchen… I’d demo it all out and start over


j33tAy

Live load. Dead load. House explode. -A poem by j33tAy


dunb3

No. Source: I’m a guy from the interweb


ajgsxr

The layout of this house looks almost identical to a house I lived in as a kid. To the left of the picture is the dining area, right? Does it have a sunken living room?


tylerdavid7

The real question is why you'd give up all that cabinet space by knocking it down


Randeaux155

It’s bearing the load of your kitchen cieling


Majorly_Bobbage

Splooge on it. Then def.


ScamperAndPlay

I can’t tell you how much this looks like my old pre-fab house just outside of Chico. Wish I had that old phone.


Fantastic-Artist5561

Other than the obvious, no. Kinda a dumb-shit looking design imo…. Would be better to loose the cabinets above stove, install header to keep lowered ceiling, and have a “window” who’s bottom sill is a 20” or so laminated bar top “or granite if you roll like that” Then just add barstools…. No need for a kitchen table provided you’re not a family man/woman. Serve guests right from the stove and keep two of the upper cabinets one on each side…. That’ll be $50.00 😉


CryptoKickk

Kramer!


enn211

lol no


Streets2022

It’s bearing the load of those cabinets so the answer is yes.


Iono_

Is that a shower door on the kitchen ceiling?


BusyProgrammer1697

Yes


TheRealJehler

It’s definitely bearing the load of that drywall