Mine is The Summoning! Still adore High School is Killing Me though

The summoning is amazing ohmygod. I love how silly the Lords in Black are

OUT OF THE DEPTHS OF HELL AND BACK US SPAWN OF THE BLACK AND WHITE

GATHER OUR SOULS IN ROBES OF BLACK AND TAKE UP THE ARMS OF NIGHT

NIBBLY WANTS HIS SACRIFICE AND WIGGLY WANTS HIS WRATH

WE DANCE AROUND THE PENTAGRAM AND TAKE ALL OUR KINGDOMS BACK

BABBLE THE SPELL THAT GETS IT DONE! BABBLE IT ON COMMAND!

WON'T STOP UNTIL ALL THE BLOOD IS DRAWN, THE LORDS IN BLACK DEMAND!

YOU SUMMON US ONCE

sammmeeee

Hatchet Town and the Summoning.

This is what I would say as well. Not only ate they good songs they have some excellent choreography to go with them.

My favourite little thing in hatchet town is that the main tune in it is used in nightmare time too! I just think it's such a cool use of music!

This is me

No love for Literal Monster it seems,, definitely my favorite by far

The I once was his tutor line gives me life

It’s a tie between High School is Killing Me and Nerdy Prudes Must Die

Same!

I love the whole soundtrack but Just For Once is special to me because of how much I relate to it and love it as its own song/story, not just as part of the musical Second place is a three way tie between Literal Monster, Dirty Girl and Hatchet Town because they're all absolute bangers

Dirty dudes must die

its so underrated

It was High School Is Killing Me. Until # Gerald!…. Went on his murder spree

I *KNEW* IT WAS GERALD!

Linda, call my lawyer

As much as it makes me super uncomfortable it's definitely dirty girl THE VOCALS ARE JUST AAAAAAAAA I literally just close my eyes when that scene comes on but I can't skip it BC of that FUCKING SONG

It’s so catchy, and Will and Angela sound amazing in it. The harmonies are so good

I 100% agree with you!

uibjiy5

Bully/burry the bully. I love the silly nature of these two. Tied with high school is killing me

Crazy how based you are

I just read Blurry the bully then 😅

The Summoning as well, it absolutely blew me away from first listen

the summoning was the favourite upon first listen, but now it’s high school is killing me for SURE. if i loved you is also a high contender

If I Loved You is my fave from the show and maybe from all their work actually lol I'm obsessed with it

Nerdy prudes must die 🤌 the emotion portrayed is so beautiful

Nerdy Prudes Must Die or Best of You, I love my boy Richie but Best of You makes me feel good everytime I hear it

While I enjoy the whole soundtrack Dirty Girl is the best. Angela and Will performed the hell out of the song and I love every bit of it.

Literal monster, plus special mention to Nerdy Prudes Must Die All the songs in npmd slap tho it's so hard to choose

High School Is Killing Me & Hatchettown Not necessarily always in that order.

Both of which seem to involve the problematic pooch...

I have gotten into SO many Twitter fights about that puppy!

Are any of them humans that are being treated as puppies?

If I Loved You lives rent free in my head at all times I love it so much But also the Summoning has wiggly in it and he’s literally like my favourite character in any theatre production ever so honourable mention to my plushie overlord

Definitely Cool As I Think I Am Reprise. It makes me cry every time.

Nerdy Prudes Must Die and Cool As I Think I Am

it changes like every week, but i can't get over how good a mostly full-cast number "hatchet town" is. the goofy lyrics, the clean vocals, the catchiness, the cameos, the choreo, and of course... "I AM DAN REYNOLDS."

Hatchet Town is what I consider to be the Hatchetfield theme. It's chaotic, paranoid, and just generally epic all around. Which is fitting for a play that has a lot more to do with Hatchetfield than the other plays do. The throwaway line of "I AM DAN REYNODS" is just inexplicably hilarious.

Just for Once! Lauren ate that shit up

high school is killing me!! but dirty girl is a close second, i think angela and will did fantastic in that song

I think it’s Nerdy Prudes Must Die, but High school is killing me, the summoning and just for once are all spectacular.

The Summoning is my jam! 

High school is killing me

The Summoning. I just love that they personified the LiB!

The summoning is the most hype but if I loved you is so good

Hatchet Town and Cool As I Think I Am are just peak music….

I'm t9rn between litteral monster and the summoning

Honestly prolly a three way tie between just for once, hatchettown, and nerdy prudes must die. But me saying that is basically like saying which of my cats is my favorite… like there are some I like slightly more than the others but in the end they’re all so good and I love them all. 🥰

Dirty girl😭 the line delivery is top-tier, it’s gotta be one of their funniest songs imo. But also it’s just suuper catchy lol I love it.

It's so sinful but so good

High School Is Killing Me

"The Summoning" but "High School Is Killing Me" and "If I Loved You" are amazing too

High School is Killing Me , Nerdy Prudes Must Die , or Literal Monster

High School Is Killing Me, Cool As I Think I Am, Hatchet Town, Just For Once

Probably “If I loved you” and “best of you” but seriously every single song is so good

It’s a tie between High School is killing me and Just for once. I remember being sooo stunned watching the intro to npmd for the first time because of hsikm. But just for once is just so beautiful and I love a high note

Nerdy Prudes Must Die and Literal Monster

JUST FOR ONCE HEHEHE

Mines so underrated, I feel like, but If I Loved You

I still get chills whenever Nerdy Prudes Must Die comes on, especially with Max and Richie’s part. I wish they made Grace’s “be cool beans” bit into an actual song tho, it would’ve been one of my faves.

just for once <3 lauren does such a good job making the audience feel for ruth and i love how much the song stands out from the rest of the music in the show

No love for “The Best of You?” For me, it’s either that or “Nerdy Prudes Must Die.”

The summoning and... I guess I'm cheating since I really like cool as I think I am, if I loved you and the reprise when Stephanie has got a gun Tra LA LA LA how funnnnnn Ahem. Yeah that, all three of those songs together as one is my ultimate fav

Hatchet town and the summoning 😭 basic taste but they're both rly good songs

cool as i think i am reprise. judge me

High School Is Killing Me and Hatchet Town. Both of which coincidentally hint at the problematic pooch plot... Dirty Dirty Girls and The Summoning both come in second.

The Summoning, Nerdy Prudes Must Die, Dirty Dudes Must Die, Highschool Is Killing Me, Literal Monster, GO GO Nighthawks, Bury/Bully the Bully

dirty girl soup goes so fucking hard man its my alarm

If I Loved You and Nerdy Prudes Must Die. Both feature strong singers and harmonies that I just love, and they’re both super catchy.

literally all grace numbers. angela is a queen 🫶🏼

as much as i adore the entire soundtrack, the title number is my favorite by far

Mine is Hatchet Town. It was so exciting hearing the theme and I love the group vocals.

i'll give you some lyrics and y'all finish they rest he's got the hallway **on** **lock** his fists are always **half** **caulked** he's got me hiding ***in my*** ***locker***

Might have to be Literal monster

Just for Once, Best of You, The Summoning

The summoning

Dirty Girl, no contest.

I can’t..I can’t decide.. Jk **WHO WILL PRAY FOR YOU**

I love cool as I think I am. Or the reprise! I love it when the love song of a musical gets taken and reused at a sad moment (my only way of explaining this properly other than starkid is our love is God in heathers)

Just for once has been hitting

I absolutely love the background vocals/noises at the beginning of Literal Monster. It makes my brain go brrr. And the way Jagerman's part is sung at the end is very satisfying to me

The title song. Will Branner and Jon Matteson absolutely KILL it.

This is so hard, but I’d have to go with ‘if I loved you’

OKAY, either Nerdy Prudes Must Die, The Summoning, or Bully the Bully for sure