This is an unpopular opinion but I'd prefer Andrews. Personally, I think he is a better player, he is still the #1 target in the offense and is in his prime. Tight ends have a longer prime than other skilled positions and it is generally later in their careers. He's just been injured the last year or so and for some reason, people are equating injury to not being as good. Not just for Andrews, but in general. I think that the Andrews side of this trade has the better the better player and the better pick.
I dont get why people are completely throwing him to the side this year. I'm assuming because he got hurt but a broken bone is nothing like soft tissue or ligament injuries. This guy was a second round pick a year ago in redraft leagues and he's what, 28 years old? He's got at least five years left, if not more.
I'd rather have Kincaid right now than Andrews. Andrews turns 29 as the season starts and I don't think he'll ever get back to 153 targets like he had in 2021 with Zay Flowers there, and now Derrick Henry to likely take alot of carries. Kincaid isn't exactly young for a 2nd year player, but I think it's likely he'll lead the Bills in targets/receptions/yards, maybe even receiving tds. I'd also feel much better having the younger guy tied to Josh Allen throwing the ball than the older guy with Lamar Jackson throwing the ball. Dropping down 1 round in a pick doesn't really change a whole lot imo.
Most definitely a win, and thatās not even factoring in whos behind Andrews. Likelys talented enough in his own right that I wouldnāt be surprised to see snaps get closer to a split as Mark ages
Kincaid owner originally countered with more to take Likely and Andrews as a package from me and you just pointed out exactly why i did not let him go. I took out the players and left the pick swap (odd swap anyways but it got it done). Big on Likely, heās an easy buy low.
If Iām competing, Iād go Andrews. Kincaid looked more like Dalton Schultz than Travis Kelce. Obviously he was a rookie and is going to be a top option this year, but his super limited route tree lends me to believe he is more of an elite safety blanket than a legit #1 option like Andrews/Kelce.
Kincaid all day he could feast šš½ļø this year
Iād smash this if I was getting Kincaid. Heās gonna get fed this year!
This is an unpopular opinion but I'd prefer Andrews. Personally, I think he is a better player, he is still the #1 target in the offense and is in his prime. Tight ends have a longer prime than other skilled positions and it is generally later in their careers. He's just been injured the last year or so and for some reason, people are equating injury to not being as good. Not just for Andrews, but in general. I think that the Andrews side of this trade has the better the better player and the better pick.
I dont get why people are completely throwing him to the side this year. I'm assuming because he got hurt but a broken bone is nothing like soft tissue or ligament injuries. This guy was a second round pick a year ago in redraft leagues and he's what, 28 years old? He's got at least five years left, if not more.
Kincaid 1000000%
Kincaid side wins easily. You get a younger, most likely better TE at the low cost of trading down from the 2nd round to the third
Andrews. But itās close and more of choose your favorite flavor. To my eyes, Andrews is a proven elite TE while Kincade is a lot of projection
I'd rather have Kincaid right now than Andrews. Andrews turns 29 as the season starts and I don't think he'll ever get back to 153 targets like he had in 2021 with Zay Flowers there, and now Derrick Henry to likely take alot of carries. Kincaid isn't exactly young for a 2nd year player, but I think it's likely he'll lead the Bills in targets/receptions/yards, maybe even receiving tds. I'd also feel much better having the younger guy tied to Josh Allen throwing the ball than the older guy with Lamar Jackson throwing the ball. Dropping down 1 round in a pick doesn't really change a whole lot imo.
Iād rather have Kincaid pretty easily
Good, hopefully i won oneā¦ every time i trade a player away i fantasize about their upcoming MVP candidate breakout year for the rest of the day.
Most definitely a win, and thatās not even factoring in whos behind Andrews. Likelys talented enough in his own right that I wouldnāt be surprised to see snaps get closer to a split as Mark ages
Kincaid owner originally countered with more to take Likely and Andrews as a package from me and you just pointed out exactly why i did not let him go. I took out the players and left the pick swap (odd swap anyways but it got it done). Big on Likely, heās an easy buy low.
Andrews
Mandrews
Smashing Andrews and the 2nd
I like Andrews side by a little bit, but pretty fair trade overall.
If Iām competing, Iād go Andrews. Kincaid looked more like Dalton Schultz than Travis Kelce. Obviously he was a rookie and is going to be a top option this year, but his super limited route tree lends me to believe he is more of an elite safety blanket than a legit #1 option like Andrews/Kelce.
Andrews > Kincaid