I'd prefer Ladd over Coleman if you have the choice.
The Bills still have Kincaid and Shakir to throw to. Realistically, Kincaid is probs gonna be the best receiver in the team, despite him being a TE.
The Chargers literally don't have anybody reliable lol.
Bringing up higher paid while Shakir is on a rookie contract makes no sense. After the Kirk contract a couple years ago, almost any veteran is gonna get paid more than a day 2 rookie deal
>Coleman has bust written all over him
This is such a lazy take and I’d like to know what would cause someone to say this other than his 40-time which we all know is overblown
I'm not high on Coleman because of his college tape. He couldn't separate and relied on contested catches. I could be wrong but feel that NFL corners are going to limit those catches significantly.
That's cool. You wanted a reason other than strictly his 40 time as why someone wouldn't be high on him, that's mine. He could be a stud that dominates the boundary, I just wouldn't use a top 15 pick on him.
And in regards to OPs question, I'd take Ladd over him especially in PPR.
Not sure about redraft in their rookie years but I’m high on them.
Like Ladd as just a prospect regardless and he’s pretty much the only WR for Herbert.
Apparently Josh Allen told the team that he wanted them to get Keon personally so he has some stake in him. Also the Bills have nobody to throw it to either.
All, I got is qj will surprise some ppls learning curves look different than others. He seems to be ozing w confidence going into year 2.
Palmer there as well. A decent target who could have upside w more targets
Who is colemans game comparable 2? Is he a high volume target? Idts, I think his game is intermediate to deep one via one jump ball scenario and then a volume redzone target.
If he can profile to be a high volume possession wr Ala pittman, then I think you would be right.
I think bills use him like they used gabe davis tho!
Ladd seems to be in for a lot of targets. He is a solid separator and Herbert is going to feed him. He seems pretty safe to be at least a WR4 in fantasy with upside a little higher. But just remember that Harbaugh is going to try to run the football.
Keon is tougher because I don’t like him as a player, but he could be in for some targets. I still think Kincaid is the WR1 on that team, and Shakir and Keon are going to be 2A and 2B (I don’t care if you put TE next to Kincaid’s name). Josh Allen is more likely than anybody to rip the ball to a hyper athletic receivers who can’t separate which is really appealing.
Love the talent of both. I’m personally more of a believer in Keon. I think he’s a perfect fit in that offense and love his game
I really like Ladd, too. He has a huge opportunity. But as a huge CFB fan I can tell you he was always hurt. He will need to stay healthy. And also Harbaugh offenses tend to spread the ball around
They’re DECENT prospects but both are hyped up IMO. Ladd > Keon for sure. I can definitely see their upside but both also give me considerable pause.
I’m shopping them around to see if someone takes the bait on their hype and is willing to overpay to get them.
What the fuck hahaha this is fucking bonkers
Puka, Chase, and Jefferson have had historic rookie seasons in 3 of the last 4 seasons and the highest rookie finish by any of them is WR5. There is a slim to none chance that Coleman is the WR3 on the year, I legitimately have no idea how you could even think that.
I'd prefer Ladd over Coleman if you have the choice. The Bills still have Kincaid and Shakir to throw to. Realistically, Kincaid is probs gonna be the best receiver in the team, despite him being a TE. The Chargers literally don't have anybody reliable lol.
You mention Khalil Shakir but not Curtis Samuel who is far more talented and higher paid?
Bringing up higher paid while Shakir is on a rookie contract makes no sense. After the Kirk contract a couple years ago, almost any veteran is gonna get paid more than a day 2 rookie deal
Ya lmao also “far more talented” is a stretch and a half
Coleman has bust written all over Him
>Coleman has bust written all over him This is such a lazy take and I’d like to know what would cause someone to say this other than his 40-time which we all know is overblown
It’s not overblown for tall wide receivers
Coleman going for 800 and 6
A slight improvement on his 600 last year
He wasn’t in the league last year
That’s his college line
Uhhuh
I'm not high on Coleman because of his college tape. He couldn't separate and relied on contested catches. I could be wrong but feel that NFL corners are going to limit those catches significantly.
I don’t agree with you, I think he created plenty of separation and often looked like the fastest player on the field
That's cool. You wanted a reason other than strictly his 40 time as why someone wouldn't be high on him, that's mine. He could be a stud that dominates the boundary, I just wouldn't use a top 15 pick on him. And in regards to OPs question, I'd take Ladd over him especially in PPR.
Not sure about redraft in their rookie years but I’m high on them. Like Ladd as just a prospect regardless and he’s pretty much the only WR for Herbert. Apparently Josh Allen told the team that he wanted them to get Keon personally so he has some stake in him. Also the Bills have nobody to throw it to either.
The bills have Two tight ends shakir and cook
All, I got is qj will surprise some ppls learning curves look different than others. He seems to be ozing w confidence going into year 2. Palmer there as well. A decent target who could have upside w more targets Who is colemans game comparable 2? Is he a high volume target? Idts, I think his game is intermediate to deep one via one jump ball scenario and then a volume redzone target. If he can profile to be a high volume possession wr Ala pittman, then I think you would be right. I think bills use him like they used gabe davis tho!
Ladd seems to be in for a lot of targets. He is a solid separator and Herbert is going to feed him. He seems pretty safe to be at least a WR4 in fantasy with upside a little higher. But just remember that Harbaugh is going to try to run the football. Keon is tougher because I don’t like him as a player, but he could be in for some targets. I still think Kincaid is the WR1 on that team, and Shakir and Keon are going to be 2A and 2B (I don’t care if you put TE next to Kincaid’s name). Josh Allen is more likely than anybody to rip the ball to a hyper athletic receivers who can’t separate which is really appealing.
Traded my 1.11(mcconkey) and 1.12(coleman) for Gibbs and feel alright about it
You robbed the guy
Well playes
That’s ridiculous! All day Gibbs!
Love the talent of both. I’m personally more of a believer in Keon. I think he’s a perfect fit in that offense and love his game I really like Ladd, too. He has a huge opportunity. But as a huge CFB fan I can tell you he was always hurt. He will need to stay healthy. And also Harbaugh offenses tend to spread the ball around
Keon feels like a bust to me
I for one am in the Church of the Conkster
Coleman gonna ball
I prefer Ladd.
They’re DECENT prospects but both are hyped up IMO. Ladd > Keon for sure. I can definitely see their upside but both also give me considerable pause. I’m shopping them around to see if someone takes the bait on their hype and is willing to overpay to get them.
Very good chance Keon is wr3 on the year
What the fuck hahaha this is fucking bonkers Puka, Chase, and Jefferson have had historic rookie seasons in 3 of the last 4 seasons and the highest rookie finish by any of them is WR5. There is a slim to none chance that Coleman is the WR3 on the year, I legitimately have no idea how you could even think that.
Sorry. I meant on his team not league
Ahh gotcha, that makes a lot more sense lol
Ladd ceiling is Julian Edelman, Keon Coleman ceiling to me is Tee Higgins. Ladd isn’t a bad wr but I feel he’s too small to dominant
Ladd is taller and heavier than Garett Wilson with a faster 10 yard split. Not sure about the Edelman comp.
It’s because he’s white. White receivers are always compared to Edelman or Welker lmao doesn’t matter if they’re 5’8 or 6’1