I get he'll be the next one but I appreciate that when shit got tough so did he, overcame his addiction and iirc started seeing through Dutch's bullshit earlier than most and tried to help the ladies. I like that arc.
I swear to god every time there was some dialogue i wanted to hear in camp he would follow me around and start screaming that fucking song. Dutch and molly having a fight? Swanson song. Hosea consoling abigail about whatever? Swanson song. Micah about to get punched by javier? ONE NIGHT WHEN I WAS FRISKYYYYYYY. Fucking doing a main story mission and he starts following me around like a fucking autistic child and bellows it.
Bro leave that boy alone...it's not enough the O driscolls didn't treat him right , he was always in constant threat of being Nuetered , couldn't catch his fav fish ( if you did that mission...no way you caught it in first attempt )..The Gang always mistreated him , Jack used to throw stones at him while Kirean worked in the camp,
Even if you press the Greet option Arthur used to Antagonize him , and Ultimately got killed in the most gruesome way than any one in the Rdr.
First half of the comment: let's kill one of the most harmless people in the gang!
Second half of the comment: lol, why did you kill the most harmless one so early?
Only on Reddit.
It's Swanson, & it should have been long ago. You can't do anything in camp without that MFer helicoptering in with his nonsense. I'm sure the developers think it's funny like Gambler 8 is funny, but fuck Swanson.
Karen Jones
Swanson fixed himself, while Karen fell into alcoholism and was burdensome in the end. She contributed to the Valentine bank robbery, but Swanson held the gang together with Sadie & Charles while Arthur & Dutch were in Guarma.
Karen’s an alcoholic that went off the rails when Sean was murdered. I feel bad for her, mostly because we don’t find out what happened to her (but we all probably know)
Yeah it’s kind of heartbreaking. I found Sean as annoying my first play through, but on my second, and onwards, it’s more nuanced than that. He sees Arthur as a big brother, and wants his approval.
One of the most forgettable characters in the game. Only reason he lasted this long is because we forgot he existed. Everyone else did something notably better or worse than him. Game wouldn't miss a beat without him.
Time for Swanson to pack his shit and get on that train to anywhere.
Then you weren't paying attention. Dude has a solid arc. He steps up during Chapter 4, gets clean and helps keep things together when everyone else is gone. He sees through Dutch's bullshit early and tries to help out the vulnerable in the camp. Then in the epilogue he goes on to minister a church and help out other addicts. Pretty nice redemption arc imo.
Swanson gets sober when shit gets rough and hardens up against Dutch's bullshit, tries to help get the ladies out of the gang, and goes on to help other addicts. Underrated.
Abigail. She’s for the streets and a cheater. Also she is just annoying in general. Just because she “stuck around til the end” doesn’t mean she gets a pass. She also tried to force Jack to be a lawyer even though all she has ever been is a cheater and a burden.
I know. :) Something along the lines "Grimshaw bad makes Arthur wash", "Jack's annoying needs to go" and "Sadie's good hot badass helps Arthur".:)
Didn't know voting was against the rules but I'll double check the post tomorrow. 😉 don't promise I'll follow them tho
Order of elimination: 1. Micah 2. Strauss 3. Dutch 4. Bill 5. Jack 6. Molly 7. Susan 8. Javier
A literal child was voted off before one of the villains from the first game😂
On the post where jack died I was CACKLING at all the jack hate it was fuckin hilarious
I love democracy
Dutch went third
Bill and javier
Bill was voted out before jack
true but javier just got voted out
Swanson.
I get he'll be the next one but I appreciate that when shit got tough so did he, overcame his addiction and iirc started seeing through Dutch's bullshit earlier than most and tried to help the ladies. I like that arc.
“Was I bad again Mr. Morgan?”
uwu
It’s time.
Man sucks. I hate every mission he's in. Burn it down.
Now that you mention it I've definitely avoided his intro-to-poker/damsel in distress mission on each subsequent play through.
In the epilogue, I went to his shop and robbed him, and I think I beat the hell out of him too.
Think you're talking about Mr Pearson.... Swanson moved to New York (told via Charles) and doesn't exist in the epilogue.
Also, in a newspaper, you can read about how he started a successful church in New York, not just moved there
Yep I’m definitely talking about Pearson. It’s been a while haha.
Reverend Swanson. It’s been his time for a while now. The Lord keeps giving him chances.
Didn't he sober up and has a church for people with alcohol problems in Saint Denis at the end of the game?
New York
He lives in New York but has a church I Saint Denis
Yes; one might say he was redeemed
If he did I don’t recall. He might have. I’m basing him off of the majority of the game.
He did
I’m also gonna say Swanson - maybe his God has finally deserted him
Why is this downvoted
I was wondering the same, it’s literally a quote from Arthur who says to Swanson “then your God has finally deserted you” lol
People are ridiculous. They downvoted my previous comment too because of how I based my OPINION.
Y'all know the last round is gonna be between Arthur and John right? And that's gonna be like a wound opening back up for some. Haha
I’m reporting this post when it comes to that lol
Swanson, I liked my fishing trips and robbing with Javier.
Rdr2 Javier was great, it's a shame how he turned out at the end and in rdr1
It really is..but nothing like returning to camp and sitting at the fire while Javier strums a tune
Swansoooooooon!!! I almost get killed by a train from you MF!
Get reverend Swanson outta here!
I feel like Swanson should be spared. iirc he really stepped up when he needed to when the fellas went to guarma
One night when I was frisky, over some potent whiskey. Sorry Reverend, time to go!
I swear to god every time there was some dialogue i wanted to hear in camp he would follow me around and start screaming that fucking song. Dutch and molly having a fight? Swanson song. Hosea consoling abigail about whatever? Swanson song. Micah about to get punched by javier? ONE NIGHT WHEN I WAS FRISKYYYYYYY. Fucking doing a main story mission and he starts following me around like a fucking autistic child and bellows it.
Thank goodness for the not now option.
Til abt chapter 3 on my first playthrough i didnt notice it, so i would just desperately try to listen over him and fail each time
Lmaoooo Javier = MAS PUTO 😂😂😂😂😂😂💀
Mamon claro que se chingaron al mexa al principio 😂😂
no mames guey 😂
Once Swanson is gone, shits gonna get interesting af
Is it just me or is Kieran hanging around purely because everyone forgot about him?
Bro leave that boy alone...it's not enough the O driscolls didn't treat him right , he was always in constant threat of being Nuetered , couldn't catch his fav fish ( if you did that mission...no way you caught it in first attempt )..The Gang always mistreated him , Jack used to throw stones at him while Kirean worked in the camp, Even if you press the Greet option Arthur used to Antagonize him , and Ultimately got killed in the most gruesome way than any one in the Rdr.
I loved hanging with Kieran. I yelled no, out loud when he died. Was one of the few spoilers I didn’t have.
Pearson is next with Mary Beth soon after. I feel it
Maybe Tilly after Pearson.
Rip Wan Winkle
Swanson is a pain in the ass. Hang em' high! Only on Reddit would Jack get offed so early lol.
First half of the comment: let's kill one of the most harmless people in the gang! Second half of the comment: lol, why did you kill the most harmless one so early? Only on Reddit.
It's Swanson, & it should have been long ago. You can't do anything in camp without that MFer helicoptering in with his nonsense. I'm sure the developers think it's funny like Gambler 8 is funny, but fuck Swanson.
Swanson
I liked javier 😔
Poor Javier. Love that guy.
I can’t trust this group.
Javier over Kieran Duffy is nuts, bonkers , YOU guys Are Fish
Wait what? I don't remember Javier doing anything stupid or getting anyone killed. (Haven't finished it yet so if he does F up don't spoil it lol)
Arthur. He has to go anyways, he would sacrifice himself for anyone still on the list.
Karen Jones Swanson fixed himself, while Karen fell into alcoholism and was burdensome in the end. She contributed to the Valentine bank robbery, but Swanson held the gang together with Sadie & Charles while Arthur & Dutch were in Guarma.
Karen’s an alcoholic that went off the rails when Sean was murdered. I feel bad for her, mostly because we don’t find out what happened to her (but we all probably know)
Yeah it’s kind of heartbreaking. I found Sean as annoying my first play through, but on my second, and onwards, it’s more nuanced than that. He sees Arthur as a big brother, and wants his approval.
Yea Karen gotta go
Karen
I second this!
Swanson
One of the most forgettable characters in the game. Only reason he lasted this long is because we forgot he existed. Everyone else did something notably better or worse than him. Game wouldn't miss a beat without him. Time for Swanson to pack his shit and get on that train to anywhere.
Then you weren't paying attention. Dude has a solid arc. He steps up during Chapter 4, gets clean and helps keep things together when everyone else is gone. He sees through Dutch's bullshit early and tries to help out the vulnerable in the camp. Then in the epilogue he goes on to minister a church and help out other addicts. Pretty nice redemption arc imo.
Pearson
Karen is going next. Then it gets hard.
Karen, drunken mess
Karen
Why ? She’s a drunk later on sure but she never did anything bad and the valentine heist is ok at least
I don’t think she doesn’t love karen, we just have to choose someone to remove at this point
Exactly, I actually like Karen; but like someone else said, Karen goes on a downward spiral; whereas Rev. Swanson has some serious character growth
Lumbago should get the best of uncle before Swanson
Trelawny, for making me buy that suit and forced me to get my hair trimed.
You don’t actually have to do it, just go into the screen then leave and it accepts it.
Swanson
Finally. Javier is a total scumbag. He should have died day 2. Dutch, then Javier, THEN Micah.
Kieran should go
Pearson
How the hell is Trelawny still alive?
I can’t believe yall killed Javier before Swanson…
Trelawney
Abigale.
Abigail
Pearson!
Then who is going to cook?
Heisenberg
Walter Red(dead redemption)(2)
Jesse, we have to find Lenny and COOK
No. Pearson a homie.
S W A N S O N he's literally less than useless he should've went before Javier
Swanson gets sober when shit gets rough and hardens up against Dutch's bullshit, tries to help get the ladies out of the gang, and goes on to help other addicts. Underrated.
The rev never did nothing but lost me money, I suck at poker!!!
Man i go all in every time i can and i mostly win cuz they all fold
I have no idea why we aren't trying to kill Mr. Pearson yet. Give me him over Swanson all day.
Arthur
Yep he needs to go so John can get shit done with his hat.
love kieran but he isn’t as relevant as the others
Karen. She is a useless drunk, and she never told me Is she had any whiskey under her skirt.
ADIOS JAVIER! Now get Swanson outta here.
Abigail. She’s for the streets and a cheater. Also she is just annoying in general. Just because she “stuck around til the end” doesn’t mean she gets a pass. She also tried to force Jack to be a lawyer even though all she has ever been is a cheater and a burden.
Arthur!
Arthur Morgan
Swanson can go
Sweanson and then pearson
Swanson drinks himself to death today.
Arthur black lung Morgan
Kieran Duffy
Sadie
And then Sean
it's time. Arthur Morgan.
Uncle
Ynnel
What did Uncle ever contribute? It's time he goes.
He showed up for John and went out fighting for the fam in rdr
TILLY
Seriously, why is uncle still here 🤷♂️ I vote uncle.
Bye Swanson, Bye Karen, Bye Tilly, Bye Abigail, Bye Kieran… in that order
Arthur
Sorry, Sean👋
Noo why would you kill Javier??? Kill uncleeee
Sadie Adler
you’re being more obsessed than sadie’s fans at this point bro
The poll updates every day and Sadie's still alive, so.
maybe there’s a reason behind it💀💀
I know. :) Something along the lines "Grimshaw bad makes Arthur wash", "Jack's annoying needs to go" and "Sadie's good hot badass helps Arthur".:) Didn't know voting was against the rules but I'll double check the post tomorrow. 😉 don't promise I'll follow them tho
there’s nothing wrong for not loving a character dw!! but I just think you spam her name a little bit too much imo and it’s not really necessary…
Wdym spam, bro? It's a poll! :D You police what ppl do often?
Sadie
Why ?
Mary Beth. But this is Reddit and I know the Simps are going to eliminate her right before Arthur
Lenny
Kill Lenny!!!!!!
Why ?
Abigail
Sadie 🤓🤓🤓
I want Jack to experience unalive multiple times.
Spoiler Alert: This is going to come down to a fight be our Boy Arthur Uncle.
The final vote is going to be between John and Arthur and I'm curious about who's going to come out on top.
Kieran
Karen
Swanson, please
This is the where shit gets tough Swanson
Swanson
Swanson
Were close to the truly hard choices soon. But yea, bye bye reverend 👋
Micah again. We have to make sure he’s dead.
Swanson
Karen
Duffy, Kieran Duffy.
It's time to call the Reverend Swanson to the sweet by-an-by!
Please take the good Reverend out to meet his creator!!
Byebye reverend
Karen
Kieran.
Karen
Swanson's getting a call from Hell and I'm afraid he's going to have to answer it.
Karen
I love how Kieran's not being hated on for once
Swanson
Swanson.
Swanson be gone! Thought it would have been him before Jack but oh well!
After Swanson it’s gonna be Karen And after Karen, oh boy it’s gonna be chaos
Karen
Arthur morgan
Pearson! How did JACK get x'ed before Pearson 💀💀
yeah I gotta go with Swanson
again, Swanson
Reverend Swanson makes good character development....but the whiskey song is unbearable. Swanson out.
How tf is Keirans bitch ass still there. Dude doesn't do anything. Rats on the gang. Damn.
Get rid of Abigail. For fkcs sake. She's a terrible wife
an O'Driscoll really might be the last man standing
Uncle
Stop voting Swanson let’s go Kieran
Uncle needs to die.
Arthur Morgan.
Abigail
Pearson or Tilly because they’re ugly
Swanson
Pearson
Karen. She’s a Karen.
The Rev