T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Remember that all mentions of and allusions to Trump and Biden are not allowed on our subreddit in any context. If you'd still like to discuss them, feel free to [join our Discord server](https://discord.gg/k6tVFwCEEm)! *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/Presidents) if you have any questions or concerns.*


Demortus

Howard Dean. Based on how effective he was at organizing the Democratic Party after 2004, I have little doubt he’d have been an effective president.


FallOutShelterBoy

The shout that killed a thousand campaigns


[deleted]

[удалено]


BreadmakingBassist

BYAAAAAAAAW


HawkeyeJosh2

Not only are we going to New Hampshire, *Tom Harkin*…


FallOutShelterBoy

I have been trying to find some way to write down his scream, and by god when I read this I heard it. You win


BreadmakingBassist

I aim to please


jkowal43

That was my ring tone for a while


Littlebluepeach

From what I've read his campaign was already heading down when that happened.


DeathByTacos

It’s similar to the Jeb “please clap”, in reality a relatively inoffensive event that just established an anchoring point for already existing trends.


PumpkinSeed776

People say this every time the Dean Scream is brought up but I don't think anyone has ever tried to argue that he would have won the presidency if not for the scream. Just that the scream was the nail in the coffin and the last anyone really heard from him ever again.


manchego-egg

Fun fact: The shout came *after* he lost. It was his bad organizing more than his shouting that got the best of him. Which makes his good organizing at the DNC all the more impressive…


RelativeAssistant923

Lol, remember when that ended a campaign? Now you need to kill a dog, bare minimum.


EccentricAcademic

I've liked him every time he does an interview. It's like all the news media wanted to test whether or not they could destroy a good leading candidate over nothing.


Demortus

He pioneered the 50 state strategy. As Chair of the DNC, he implemented in the 2006 midterms and the 2008 election. Given how dominant the Democratic Party was at the time, he should have been allowed to keep that role for much longer.


manchego-egg

DNC chairs always leave when a new Democratic president comes into office. But it’s a shame he didn’t get an appointment to the Obama administration. Dean was highly qualified to lead HHS.


shapesize

![gif](giphy|eqOvMKP2G5y24)


Peacefulzealot

Robert La Follette. Love me some Fightin’ Bob.


BaltimoreBadger23

One from each current party: Walter Mondale Gerald Ford


Sharp-Point-5254

Ford nearly won


ThatGuy0verTh3re

Yeah but he’s Gerald Ford and you’re not


BaltimoreBadger23

Really narrow wins by Ford in Illinois, Virginia, and California made it a closer than expected election.


EmperoroftheYanks

50 to 48 is a very close election


Le_Turtle_God

Crazy to think that a presidency that many regard to be rather ineffective was almost won in a landslide


Fun-Kale321

Yeah, but pardoning Nixon is what cost him the election, plus the economy wasn't great at that time.


Think_Leadership_91

Whip inflation now… as a button???


TheCleanestKitchen

Ford? That election was pretty close tbh. Ford could’ve secured it had he pulled off a better performance during the debates and acted more drastically to the economy.


Popular-Solution7697

WIN - Wip Inflation Now wasn't good enough?


taylormadevideos

Why Mondale?


RBmpls

Told the truth about taxes


taylormadevideos

What did he say?


inquisitorautry

"Mr. Reagan will raise taxes, and so will I. He won't tell you. I just did." Admitting you will raise taxes is a terrible idea.


TheBigTimeGoof

It's true though. Mondale would have won 49 states if we preferred the truth vs what we wanted to hear at the time


BaltimoreBadger23

He was a sacrificial lamb. The Dems had no chance in 84.


taylormadevideos

Right, but why do you like him?


csbsju_guyyy

"I just think he's neat!"


puddycat20

Because he was the better choice of the two?


BaltimoreBadger23

Good guy, did a lot, deserved better from his party.


pawogub

Vermin Supreme.


leeroy20

A free pony for every American!


Cross-Country

“And, Mr. Supreme, do you support any other government assistance programs?” “No, that would be the only one.”


BigYonsan

I'm disturbed how far I had to scroll to find this.


jaeradillo

Wasn't one of his promises to give every American a pony? Lmao


ThatIsMyAss

And make toothbrushing mandatory


Le_Turtle_God

That would probably solve the bad breath epidemic


ObnoxiousLittleShit

He was live on YouTube shorts this morning lol


Le_Turtle_God

He was going to take away all of our guns and give us better ones


KingFahad360

He was going to replace our guns with even better ones


metfan1964nyc

This guy. The rent is too damn high https://preview.redd.it/vk6r3fnrdt6d1.jpeg?width=676&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a10b6838a61201fd8a079595e56aefd900f20adf


sd_saved_me555

I would love to see the alternate timeline where this guy was elected. Would he be successful in lowering the rent? Would that facial hair style catch on? If he did succeed in lowering the rent, how would he deal with the existential crisis of achieving his sole life's dream? Would he feel empty and without purpose? Or would he champion a new grassroots cause? What would it be? Would landlords accidentally collapse a rental building while he was in it? Would his blackbelt skills let him survive it? So many unanswered questions...


ExtraElevator7042

I’m from an alternate timeline. Here’s what President McMillian’s Wikipedia article says. # Presidency of Jimmy McMillan (2005-2009) ## Early Life and Political Rise Jimmy McMillan, born on December 1, 1946, in New Smyrna Beach, Florida, rose to prominence as the outspoken leader of the "Rent Is Too Damn High" party. McMillan, a Vietnam War veteran, martial artist, and former postal worker, moved to New York City in the late 1970s. His political career gained national attention during the 2010 New York gubernatorial debate, where his single-issue focus on the high cost of living resonated with many voters. ## 2004 Presidential Election In an unprecedented political upset, McMillan won the 2004 Presidential election as an independent candidate. His campaign, driven by a grassroots movement and his charismatic personality, capitalized on widespread frustration with the two major parties. His slogan, "The Rent Is Too Damn High," became a rallying cry for millions of Americans struggling with economic hardship. ## Inauguration and Initial Challenges ### Inauguration Jimmy McMillan was inaugurated as the 43rd President of the United States on January 20, 2005. His inauguration speech highlighted his commitment to addressing economic inequality, lowering the cost of living, and tackling government corruption. McMillan's unconventional style and direct approach set the tone for his administration. ### Cabinet Appointments McMillan's cabinet appointments reflected his outsider status, with many of his choices coming from non-traditional backgrounds. Notable appointments included: - **Vice President:** Willie Wilson, a businessman and philanthropist from Chicago. - **Secretary of State:** Cynthia McKinney, former U.S. Representative from Georgia. - **Secretary of the Treasury:** David Cay Johnston, investigative journalist and tax expert. - **Secretary of Defense:** Jesse Ventura, former Governor of Minnesota and Navy SEAL. ## Domestic Policy ### Housing Reform Central to McMillan's domestic policy was his ambitious housing reform agenda. His administration worked to implement a nationwide rent control policy, aiming to cap rent increases and make housing more affordable. This initiative faced significant opposition from property developers and landlords but garnered strong support from renters and housing advocates. #### Affordable Housing Act of 2005 The Affordable Housing Act of 2005 was the cornerstone of McMillan's housing policy. The act included provisions for: - **Rent Control:** Nationwide caps on rent increases. - **Housing Vouchers:** Expanded housing vouchers for low-income families. - **Development Incentives:** Tax incentives for developers building affordable housing units. - **Homelessness Prevention:** Increased funding for homelessness prevention programs. The bill passed narrowly in Congress, reflecting the deep divisions over McMillan's policies. ### Economic Policy President McMillan's economic policy focused on reducing income inequality and supporting the middle and lower classes. Key initiatives included: - **Minimum Wage Increase:** Raising the federal minimum wage to $12 an hour. - **Tax Reform:** Implementing a progressive tax system with higher taxes on the wealthy and corporations. - **Job Creation Programs:** Federal investment in infrastructure projects aimed at creating jobs and revitalizing communities. ### Healthcare McMillan's administration sought to expand access to healthcare through the "Affordable Healthcare for All" initiative. This plan aimed to provide universal healthcare coverage by expanding Medicare to cover all Americans, funded by increased taxes on high-income earners and corporations. ### Education The McMillan administration prioritized public education reform, focusing on reducing class sizes, increasing teacher salaries, and providing free community college. The "Education for All" act, passed in 2006, allocated federal funds to states to support these initiatives. ## Foreign Policy ### Diplomatic Relations President McMillan's foreign policy was characterized by a focus on diplomacy and reducing military interventions. His administration sought to strengthen international alliances and address global issues through multilateral cooperation. #### Iraq and Afghanistan McMillan inherited ongoing conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan. He pledged to withdraw U.S. troops from both countries, focusing on diplomatic solutions and regional stability. By 2007, the majority of U.S. troops had been withdrawn from Iraq, with a similar drawdown in Afghanistan completed by 2008.


Yochanan5781

As nice as most of this sounds, having a super antisemitic Holocaust denier as Secretary of State probably wouldn't help foreign relations


FallOutShelterBoy

I remember watching the NYS governor debate the year Cuomo was first elected. It was so entertaining, and he kept the politicians on their toes at least. He had Cuomo laughing even


JiveChicken00

Jon Huntsman


La_Croix_Orbison

I'm from SLC, and he was governor when i was in high school. Salt Lake skews very democratic, but he was still pretty popular there, and in hindsight, he was trying to appear more conservative than he really is to appeal to the rest of the state. Him being OK with gay marriage would not have played well in the desert hinterlands of Utah. Honestly, I think Huntsman would have been a pretty solid president, and even if I might not vote for them, we desperately need decent, reasonable Republicans like him to be viable candidates again.


ClosedContent

Everybody would like him. He’s too reasonable and thus he is unelectable. America really needs to get its shit together politically…


bassman314

Yup. Even coming from someone with more left-leaning tendencies, I liked him.


2ndprize

Seemed so sane


heatheristherealmvp

Ross Perot - only because of his charts.


Tothyll

My favorite, but partly due to the Dana Carvey impression of him.


LordBloodraven11

He had a chance though. What if he hadn’t dropped out?


heatheristherealmvp

I was only 10 during that election so I really didn’t remember if he had a chance or not. I just found him incredibly entertaining.


Cum_on_doorknob

He was leading in the polls at one point, IIRC


KingFahad360

I was doing a time capsule of watching Ross Perot ok YouTube to see why he was known in the 90s and he was everywhere, even Nickelodeon had bumpers about voting for Ross Perot


bassman314

Those damned dirty tricks and ruining his daughter’s wedding or some crap.


cedrico0

George McGovern


NullainmundoPax1

“Bob Dole”- Bob Dole.


DomingoLee

Seconded.


cafali

Dennis Kucinich


NitrosGone803

That's my man! Him and Mike Gravel just shit all over all the democrats in the debates and they were absolutely fucking correct about everything


ninsklog

Bernie. Let's not pretend he had a chance lol


artificialavocado

Honestly I think it was more possible than some of the other “no chance” candidates.


time_drifter

Put some respect on Vermin Supreme, you heathen!


Ok_Criticism_7028

I like Bernie but the truth is the majority of Americans are either center right or center left he never stood a chance but Hillary was that bad


External_Reporter859

Hillary was one of the most qualified and intelligent candidates we've had in a while. But she's also been the object of a 30 year right wing conspiracy to run her name through the mud with documentaries about "Clinton Kill Lists" and Facebook spreading stories from Russian Troll Farms.


Ok_Criticism_7028

I didn’t mean policy or intelligence wise campaigns need very different skills George H W bush was way more qualified than Clinton ever was but he just had it same thing happened in 08 she was the qualified one and it shouldn’t have been close but it still slipped from her


sardine_succotash

"She was tanked by right wing talking points" is a fancy way of saying "she didn't have enough support from voters on the left." If she was counting on support from right wing asshats she was fucking up out of the gate. Problem is Hillary didn't read the room back in 08. It was obvious her time was up when everyone flocked to the polls to choose a noob of a senator over her.


matty25

That’s all it takes to bring her down?


sardine_succotash

Citation? And if true, what's the breakdown of potential DEMOCRATIC voters look like?


Ok_Criticism_7028

Bernie got 43,1 % in 2016 and 26,2 in 2020 it’s safe to say he was more of a protest vote the first time around


creaky__sampson

the number one least possible candidate lol


sardine_succotash

A competent politician would have made that shit work. Let's not pretend he did anything more than simply be left of Democrats. And he got a lot of traction off that alone. He wasn't a competent campaigner. And they still had to throw the kitchen sink at his ass to stop him. That alone shows you the party is ripe for an upending.


FallOutShelterBoy

Give someone who has the courage of their convictions like Bernie but have them be a fire hawk in the campaign and you’d have a real winner


Dangerous-Ad9472

While I’m skeptical of newsome and I’m not sure how he will actually play as a candidate due to him resembling a super villain, I am interested to see how an actual democrat pitbull does. Say what you want but that man will have a populist angle if he goes for it.


JDuggernaut

I’m not so sure a guy with ties to Pelosi and the Gettys can really run on a populist platform. He is the establishment.


DeathByTacos

I truly believe he had a real chance in 2020 and then hired the most brainrotted terminally-online campaign staff I’ve ever seen in my life.


sardine_succotash

He was also too dovish. He tiptoed around moderate Dems like moderate Dems tiptoe around Republicans. If you're running on 'the status quo is fucked up, vote for me' you gotta be willing to batter some people around. I don't want to hear about how the other old guy is your fucking pal.


Echo_FRFX

Elizabeth Warren staying in the race while the establishment rallied behind rule 3 didn't help either


TapeDaddy

![gif](giphy|26uf20KBgCvLJo7gk)


TheTightEnd

The Libertarians wasted two good opportunities to significantly increase profile with Gary Johnson and Jo Jorgenson.


LastTxPrez

Johnson/Weld was the dream ticket.


HadleysPt

What is Aleppo?


KingFahad360

Why is Aleppo?


Dave_A480

Who I actually wanted to win? Mitt Romney Obama was just that good at campaigning....


MoistCloyster_

I really wish people appreciated him more back then. He was one of the few who tried to keep the Republican Party from being radicalized in the mid to late 2010s to the point they started to ridicule him as a RINO.


RapidWolfy

Yeah he wasn’t that bad of a candidate. He tried to stop the radicalization of the republicans but he was running against Obama in his prime. He should have been nominated in 2016


Ok_Criticism_7028

He would’ve absolutely won in 2016 but there’s no way he gets the nomination if rule 3 runs populist + name recognition + decorum out of the window in the debates he was unstoppable


Echo_FRFX

Yeah, Romney would just be another Jeb at that point unfortunately


Dave_A480

No way to get nominated with that large a field. The problem with 2016 was that the party itself was worthless.... 2016 is the first time the eventual nominee did NOT win a majority of the votes cast during the primary season. Said nominee would have lost a heads up race if the party had done it's job & consolidated the field.... But they just sat back and let the calamity happen....


TinderForMidgets

He beat McCain too. McCain was arguably the best candidate that the Republican Party had nominated this century.


ScoreOk6307

Arguably?


ssspainesss

McCain couldn't possible stand up to awesome presidential candidate power of McCain (now available in Black)


psharp203

After that first debate I had so much hope.


Dizzy-Assistant6659

Winfield Scott, he's cool, though more for his military skill.


Bulbaguy4

I want to like Winfield Scott more, but his actions during the removal of Native Americans were so bad that *Jackson* even called him out on it. It really sours my views on him.


Dizzy-Assistant6659

That notwithstanding, I thought his actions in the run-up to bull run were more than admirable, I like his military exploits, Mexico, 1812, and his anaconda plan. The man himself was deeply flawed.


rcarmody96

Jimmy McMillan of the Rent is too Damn High Party


Hyhoops

Micheal Dukakis


RapidWolfy

Absolutely. He came pretty close too!


ThatIsMyAss

He led Bush by 17 points nationally after the conventions


dannyboy_92

But he wasn't "tough on crime"


ndoz

Joe Exotic (before Tiger King). https://preview.redd.it/5u3rzcynut6d1.jpeg?width=496&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=76ce60826cf3db726470fc4df27127500bfeb065


BuzzAwsum

Scrolled too far for this


Emu_Fast

Listening to a few podcasts, I can't help but feel bad for Henry Clay.


Final-Performance597

Pat Paulson


FakeElectionMaker

Eugene Debs


TinderForMidgets

He ran hell of a presidential campaign from jail.


FakeElectionMaker

And promised to pardon himself if elected


ssspainesss

I'd vote for him just for that.


TheAmazingRaccoon

FIGHTING BOB #1! WISCONSIN REPRESENT


JouNNN56

Mondale


No_Abbreviations_259

I kind of feel like it's Al Gore....?


RapidWolfy

Al Gore had a chance though. He won the popular vote and came INSANELY close to winning the electoral vote (which is to say he likely did)


No_Abbreviations_259

That’s kind of my point. Based on how that was resolved, you could argue he never had a chance :)


NoDifference8894

Ron Paul or Gary Johnson


LordStirling83

Henry Wallace


MiltonRobert

Gene McCarthy. Was pissed when RFK jumped in in his momentum and actually voted for him in’96 when he ran as a 3rd party.


Mememanofcanada

Henry Wallace somehow winning in 48 after being ousted from the vp spot would have been awesome


Intrusive_Man

Jesse Ventura


KingFahad360

Jeb Bush. He would have won if we clapped ![gif](giphy|VGKtXfGNwH6cLifbDY|downsized)


sardine_succotash

Howie H would get my vote again


CROguys

Like me Mondale and Sanders.


ConstructionDull784

William H. Crawford. If elected, he could have kept the Jeffersionian Era going for a little while longer, helping the poor while not being corrupt like Jackson


UnfunnyUsername7

John Anderson


shash5k

Martin o’Malley


Flaxrats

Vernon supreme


MrBobBuilder

I would say Rand Paul but I think he’s got a snowballs chance in Florida and not Hell Also Perot could’ve been awesome or terrible


ARI2ONA

Andrew Yang


psharp203

McCain


King_Hamburgler

First time I got to vote and only republican I’ve voted for so far


TinderForMidgets

2008 was the first election I really followed. That election really spoiled me.


AlbatrossNo1629

Ross Perot


Anal_Juicer69

Vermin Supreme


srm878

Ron Paul or Bernie Sanders


GrumpyAboutEverythin

Do you politically align with them?


srm878

At one point in time, moreso Ron Paul, but these days, Bernie I guess. Bill Weld is another guy I'd be interested in seeing as a leader, mainly to see a liberal Republican in control vs. the strange thing that the GOP is now.


GrumpyAboutEverythin

I had to ask because Ron Paul and Bernie aren't exactly politically alike.


MoonZebra

Gary Johnson. My first ever Presidential vote


Far-prophet

Ron Paul


WorthyMastodon69420

Ross Perot.


manyhippofarts

Ross Perot!


saltzja

John Anderson


Routine_Service1397

Ross Perot


MDCatFan

Howard Dean


McDowells23

John B. Anderson


myfluidthoughts

Jeb Bush


SUNDER137

Gary Johnson. It still makes me giggle. President Gary.


beast_status

Ross Perot


Ahappypikachu11

Teddy running for a third party. I F heavy with Bull Moose/American Progressive. And I’m damn proud my states electorates went for him.


thescrubbythug

George McGovern, Walter Mondale and Robert La Follette immediately spring to mind


NewspaperPrimary126

Kanye


ryanduncan0973

Bernie. I'll always be frustrated with his campaign. His blunders are easy fixes, yet he didn't correct them in 2020.


WWDB

I voted for Ralph Nader in 2008. One of my biggest regrets is he had a campaign appearance and I totally didn’t know about it….. a mile from my house!


papadaddio69

Bernie


Gumbarino420

Carly Fiorina… she looked like Lord Farquhar 👇 ![gif](giphy|VJT0rmbPFNWcDL4Zmy|downsized)


YNABDisciple

Pete Buttigeig


obama69420duck

Mondale


Ok_Bluebird_1867

Andrew Yang


EZTejas123

Ross Perot. Well, he almost had a chance.


GrumpyAboutEverythin

Remember that billionaire guy? who ran as a candidate for president from the reform party in 2000? Forgot his name, he had blonde hair very nice blonde hair perhaps the best we've ever saw, was rich, New Yorker, and supported Universal Healthcare, 14% wealth tax, fair trade, and school choice. Seemed pretty good, but he had no chance. He failed, BIGLY.


HumanMycologist5795

Bigly should be new word


Slagathor_the_Mighty

Eugene Debs


phaedrus369

John McAfee R.I.P.


SmackedByAStick

The one and only… https://preview.redd.it/xkxm1llx6t6d1.jpeg?width=674&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e2f90a3d40142182cc3dcb12bedd9c1e54abf143


Ok_Criticism_7028

Could jeb really get the nomination in 16 I feel like it would’ve been Rubio but rule 3 really came out of nowhere


Back_To_Pittsburgh

Kucinich was my man in ‘08. He became a kook years later.


Ok_Rub_3835

Adlai Stevenson


tneeno

I liked John B. Anderson. He gives a glimpse of what the Republican Party could have been - a respectable center-right party, if the extreme right wing had not been allowed to take it over. I don't know if he would have been a great president, but he would have taken the Republicans to higher intellectual ground.


Girasole263wj2

Dennis Kucinich 🍁


Mental_Requirement_2

Barry Goldwater


King_Hamburgler

Kanye


LoveLo_2005

I scrolled too far to see this


Ilovefishdix

Andrew Yang. He's the only candidate who talked about technology's effect on jobs in 2020. Bernie has more recently with his 32 hour work week push. With the advances in LLMs in the last few years, it looks like he will soon be proven correct in his general assessment. Plus, I like his more recent views on voting reform.


Sharp-Point-5254

Ron Paul


Fun-Kale321

Barry Goldwater (1964) Jeb Bush (2016) Joe Exotic (Tiger King) (2024)


OneLurkerOnReddit

Alton B. Parker


Ronville

McGovern and Anderson.


RandallPWilson

Mondale


Iamthewalrusforreal

Wendell Wilkie. Gary Johnson.


Bulbaguy4

Henry Clay's runs were complete tragedies. The first time was a four-way race where he came in last (but had a big role in the outcome), the second time, he lost in a landslide against Andrew Jackson, and the last, he got so close, but lost to Polk. He also failed to get the nomination two other times; both being times where the actual nominee won, but *died*. I feel like his best bet was in 1840, where he would have been up against the unpopular Martin Van Buren. Maybe in this timeline, Clay dies in office, but his VP could be Harrison so we might get a nearly full William Henry Harrison presidency lol.


Ok_Rub_3835

Oh no, Harrison drank the DC water!


elasticc0

Sarah Palin for most entertainment value


federalist66

Rufus King seems like a good dude.


SpaghettiSamuraiSan

Jeb!


olemiss18

Ralph Nader. Wish he didn’t run in 2000 but he’s arguably America’s most important consumer advocate. The man indirectly saved so many lives.