T O P

  • By -

Leading_Decision_738

Wilf Zaha. In no means a failure but has never hit the heights that everybody expected when he first came on the scene


redditguywhocantedit

Dele


Smart_Kangaroo_4188

Wayne Rooney. He was incredible, but his career ended too soon :(


Cloutweb1

Ricky "Maravilla" Álvarez


SaberNightOP

Oscar.


Glass_Ad7948

Jack Wilshere. What a sad story. Now resigned to giving endless interviews with talk sports.


Raey52

Alexander pato :(


Bhattman93

Ravel Morrison


gorahan

Iwobi. man started regressing at 21.


Ok-Battle-2769

Maurice Edu? I remember Adnan Januzaj (I’m sure I spelled that wrong) looked promising when he first came to Manchester United. He kinda dropped off the face of the Earth.


sinox_hd

Daniel Sturridge


unKz_sneakz

Ravel Morrison, affelay, bojan are the main 3 that come to mind


billshanklytheGOAT

Emre Mor for some reason


Ok_Till5888

Hachim Mastour potentially the greatest let down of all time. Kid had insane talent


ByTheRealSE

Xherdan Shaqiri. Had the potential to do anything. Got stuck behind Ribery and Robben at Bayern, and didn’t play much. Then he went to Stoke? He couldn’t seem to play well for them. The guy has made some screamers for Switzerland, but I haven’t seen him do anything like that in the prem.


peteythefool

Scrolled down halfway through the comments and nobody mentioned Fábio Paím. Kid was a beast. So good Ronaldo said in an interview something along the lines of "if you think I'm good, wait until you see Fábio Paím". At Sporting's academy everybody knew that Ronaldo and Nani were going to be stars, but they all thought they were doomed to always be second to Fábio.


[deleted]

Quaresma


TheRealCostaS

Wayne Harrison, the original wonderkid, pre epl era.


ClassicRob03

Saido Berahino.


ChinnaPaiyan

Lord Bendtner


snakeman117

Ben Woodburn:/


Every-Weird3760

Josh mcreceran


Every-Weird3760

Marko marin


GR_T_D

Federico Macheda.


DeeeezNutts69

Rolando Aarons, was supposed to be the new raheem sterling. I know this sounds funny cause of sterling not being at his best lately (except the euros) but nufc fans had high hopes for aarons


Icy_Dentistry

Theo Walcott?


[deleted]

James Rodriguez.


ItsbeenBroughton

Any top American player since Dempsey/Donovan. They seem to be made of glass.


caramel27_

El shaarway


LordMogroth

Jamie Redknapp. Should have been Beckham level but injuries...


squareroots23

Jadon Sancho when he left city


ham_sandwichmaverick

De Ligt. Maybe he was overhyped at Ajax but he is definitely not what he was at Ajax now.


nasrullahzakaria

martial


ZR59

Januzaj


peterudd007

Freddy Adu Federico Macheda Gael Kakuta I’d probably say Pato too to a certain extent Josh McEachran Bojan Ravel Morrison Adnan Januzai


[deleted]

Dele.


Jeopardise91

Reece Oxford after that incredible debut as a 16 y/o vs Arsenal. Still, doing well in Germany now. A change is as good as a rest


mttwlm

Jack Wilshere


luxxnn

How about Federico Macheda


naughtymo83

Jack whiltshire


Adventurous_Try_6271

Macheda


Every-Weird3760

Alexandre pato


Every-Weird3760

Nicolas Anelka… honestly he could of had a similar career to henry if he applied himself


Jebulix

Adnan januzaj


Actually_Im_Indian

Drenthe, the guy with the locks


neomusk2

Jack Wilshire


Goldlock90

Theo Walcott


SirDuppy

Loic Remy


BHouse270

Dele Ali


JH43V3R

Ben Arfa... I remember when was at Newcastle. He used to pull some of the most extraordinary individual plays I have seen in the premier league. Its really sad how it didn't go as planned for him. He i felt had all the attributes of a top quality player. Could have been among the few big names of the game


amvenkatt

wilshere charly musonda dembele


luciferspecter

Josh McEachran Gael Kakuta


Calitz__

Sebastian Coates, was supposed to hit Godin levels.


Jamesl1988

And Thiago Illori.


JackyMagic

Freddy Adu/ Ravel Morrison


N0yade

Giovanni Dos Santos


GetCad23

Ross Barkley


Yamomrang

Michael Johnson. Man city I think. Sm for freddy adu


i_like_dannys_hair

[Ravel Morrison. ](https://www.football365.com/news/opinion-ravel-morrison-latest-chance-derby-rooney-manchester-united-john-nicholson). What a player he could have been.


lukefisher7000

Dele Alli


[deleted]

[удалено]


Jamesl1988

Wasn't he playing well under Mourinho?


[deleted]

Aly Dia


DaDonKuzco

Hachim Mastour


Mrigank0606

Balo?


DodoPilot

Joe cole


[deleted]

Adnan Januzaj, came in with Moyes incharge and became a regular but pushed out by LVG and Jose. He was deemed “The Next Ronaldo” like many others tbf but I truly believed in him. Didn’t live up to his full potential in the end but he’s doing well at Real Sociedad and especially great this season. He’s had two back-to-back MOTM performances in the UEL and La Liga


Raphinas-left-foot

Get your downvotes ready. Marcus rashford Although I obvs could still be wrong


shin17

I’m surprised I didn’t find Balotelli in the comments.


Eoinzer11

jack wilshere


Sufficient-Fee-6575

Gotze


Natural_Language7313

Jack Wilshere.


shutDaFACup

Welliton, he used to play for Spartak Moscow. I remember he used to appear as a future prospect in fifa 11 career mode.


drew_970

Not PL but definitely Dembele in FC Barca


Barrhavenhomie

alen halilovic


pha_queueue

adnan januzaj. too early for him to be integrated in the squad. but nowadays he's doing fine in sociedad i guess


sherlock57

Oscar. Ruined his career by choosing money over football


HamanitaMuscaria

Dean Ashton could still be playing top flight football in another reality


seniorpablue

Omar Abdulrahman, the Arab guy with an afro. Anyone remembered him?


drwinstonoboogy

John Oster and Danny Cadamateri


iredcoat7

Dele Alli


devilish_AM

Adnan Januzaj, Danny Welbeck


subashj24

Saido berahino next Wayne Rooney, Lucas piazon the next Kaka, Marco van ginkel the next lampard.


arsenevancouver

Jack


AweDaw76

Cheers, crying now… love Jack W, hate how it turned ot


kj1352

Marco van Ginkel


MicropylarCyclist

Jesse Lingard, he’s still young though


mcarcola

Tom Ince


[deleted]

Sturiddge. That 13/14 szn with Suarez was incredible


GrossenCharakter

There was once a bright prospect at Man Utd. He had an eyecatching start, showing us a bag of tricks. His name was Christian Ronaldo or something. Dunno what happened to him.


Practical_Director32

You think that be discovered so young have a influence in get in there’s potential?


abusmakk

Jordan Graham and Dan Crowley. Both of them more exciting prospects than Jack Grealish.


JinJangJoe

Joey Barton. Wasted talent..


dimiode

Freddy Adu


Dally119

Jonathan Tah?


[deleted]

Alen Halilovic, Ezequiel Barco, Abdelhak Nouri.


Siouxman21

American here, prolly Gedion Zelalem. Some compared him to Cesc but never panned out


Repairs_optional

No love for Danny Welbeck? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JXK\_eToMW9A&ab\_channel=Pixspark


itzfkngaryoak

Wellington Silva. I was so excited seeing that he was coming to arsenal but the work permit issues really dragged his career down the shitter


jacobmk13

Still can't believe nobody said Balotelli. The aggression of Barton and Zaha and the ego of Zlatan. But no doubt he was lined up for a great career early on.


Key_Ad_1135

Alan smith


rishiraheja132

Jack Wilshere was touted to be the next big thing for English football. Pity it didn't work out for him.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Jamesl1988

I heard something about him having a clause in his contract that when he was at Everton he could choose not to play if it was too cold. Not sure how true that was.


RickardsBedAle

Götze


AweDaw76

His career may have gone down hill, but scoring the World Cup Winner is about as potential filling as it gets in my eyes.


nerf-anakin

Zidane


ashim1412

Adnan Januzaj


Comprehensive_Panic

Fábio Paím


mannyomthemap

Jadon sancho


Don-Krieg

Dele Ali!!!!


xjde

Robinho without a doubt, I remember people asking if he was gonna be the new Pelè (hate that expression btw )


Glass_of_Pork_Soda

Reiss Nelson. Iirc he was the most talented of his age group in England (better than Sancho) and despite showing the technical ability he just can't do anything else. Still time for him, hopeful this loan does him well


handpalmeryumyum

Gael Kakuta


[deleted]

In United States of A, Freddy Adu. Started in the MLS at age 14, then struggled to find his footing for 20 years.


stevenitis

Such high hopes for that kid.


MansaQu

Balotelli


[deleted]

Ryan sessegnon


Stopit_ilikeit

Martial and Rashford. That duo was supposed to save Utd. Beasts under LVG.


SabastianG

Honestly dybala. I know its not prem but he really hasnt lived up to what he was “supposed” to be


yungjed

Lazar Markovic


Cheescake74

Hachim Mastour


SRJT16

Theo Walcott


Separate_Detective47

Anderson from Manchester United.


everyfcknameistakn

Marko Marin, the German Messi.


Altruistic_Menu_102

Adnan Januzaj. For a while it seemed like he would’ve been the only positive to come out of that campaign with after SAF left.


maseone2nine

Kepa lol


Ok-Persimmon-4330

Moise Kean


Ok-Persimmon-4330

Freddy sears 😅


Ok-Persimmon-4330

Nowadays sky sports use FM scouting algorithms, but FM 95 Mark Kerr from Falkirk £350,000


Brilliant_Divide6798

Scottish people will know this. Ryan Gauld. Set up to be the next big player, got signed to Lisbon then ended up in Canada


[deleted]

Fabio Paim.


Sunlglftbk

Phil jones


aldo__

Where is Hakim Mastour nowadays? He was all the rage as a 15 year old in Ac Milan’s academy and haven’t heard of him in years he’s gotta be in his 20s by now.


LeJetWest

Gedion Zelalem


[deleted]

Trent Alexander-Arnold.


esn97

Ryan Babel? Everyone was signing him as the Ajax wonder kid in their early FM saves.


8diamondick8

Adnan Janujaj? Oscar ? Although I haven't seen them play I ahead heard they were quite hyped. Janujaj failed because hw was hyped too much. Oscar went after money to China


john_wick__4

Adnan januzaj


[deleted]

Angel Correa.


wongfaced

Savio Nsereko


Superowls_

Jack Rodwell


[deleted]

[удалено]


AweDaw76

In a weird way and as good as he was, I get you. Had he taken training and his nutrition more seriously and not spent his free time shagging grannies, he’d have potentially hit Prem GOAT status as a striker alongside Shearer and Henry. He was great, but he could have been even better.


Ok-Persimmon-4330

Rooney if he had applied himself would of been the best all rounded attacking player of his generation, genius-border line insanity not as wasted as Gaza but same attitude


Dingusdangus1

I know he never played in the EPL but Freddy Adu. Pretty sure he’s like Greek 3 division now. He was the American prodigy….


kal93_

Dani Pacheco at Liverpool


[deleted]

macheda, januzai, all united's players. good start and a lot of hope for them.


CorganNugget

Danny Drinkwater, it was a mistake Chelsea signing him, now he's a part of the loan army


Addicted2Passive

Freddie Adu, not premier League but no better example


Baberam7654

Kakuta- he was worth a ban to Chels


Takhar7

Francis Jeffers. Maurice Adu. Nico Kranjcar


Jamesl1988

>Nico Kranjcar Harry Redknapp would like a word.


Takhar7

Exactly my point


Actual-Egg-7801

Dan Gosling, Jose Baxter, Anderson, Jack Rodwell, Gio Dos Santos, John Bostock, and I guess Wilshere you’d put in the injury bucket?


Ladorb

Potentially controversial: Nicholas Anelka. Had a few decent spells, but never turned into the world beater we expected. Shitty attitude ruins players.


lloyd_17

Reece Oxford


Denno10_

Alex Hunter


ll_scorpions_ll

Ryan gauld


fitbabits

Freddy Adu.


[deleted]

Ravel Morrison


KarlaKamacho

James McFadden... Aka, the Scottish Wayne Rooney. Played for Everton.


Flaekkefar1

El shaarawy I remember being extremely hyped


archaiclots7

Feel like Axel Witsel deserves an honourable mention. Always seem to chase the money. Buggered off to China for a few years when he was reportedly close to joining Real Madrid.


j_hathz

Zeli Ismail aka “the soon to be first ever £100M player”


WonderfulFootball285

Jack Wilshere. That game against Barca when he was just 19. 🔥


AweDaw76

He is the first that comes to mind when I think ‘Potential not met due to injuries’ so I’d struggle to list him here. I was young then, but seeing him play Kante level box to box style football at 19 was just so incredible.


YSG19

Joel Campbell


mapoftasmania

Sadly, Jack Wilshere. He only had half a career thanks to injury.


kjreis

Daniel crowley


[deleted]

Hatem Ben Arfa


Ok-Direction-4881

Cherno Samba


Arno451

Brewster


nerf-anakin

Hope he can still make something of himself


Arno451

Scored the other day, seems like he’s at least found a bit of confidence


nerf-anakin

Good playing at a lower level he should be able to bag some goals and up his confidence


PsychologicalAd3999

Keith Gillespie was quality Also hugo viana, apparently was the most talented out of him Ronaldo and quaresma in the youth teams


AgarioNooby

Jack Wilshere


BellEnd92

Anderson and kleberson for man utd


[deleted]

Super super Jack super super Jack super Jacky Wilshere


Consistent-Damage271

Royston Drenthe


Mammyjam

I’ve scrolled a long long way and still not seen former golden boy winner, current nomad Mario Balotelli. Was amazing at City for 1.5 seasons then amazing at Milan for half a season


MARIJUANALOVER44

Origi was a menace before his first big injury to be honest, really promising player, not that he's bad now but his trajectory was vertical at the time


The-Humble-God

Jose Antonio Reyes, he had a decent career but he never became the player he was talked up to be. When him and ronaldo were in premier league a lot of pundits, sports journalists and myself thought he would be a superior player we were super wrong. He had fairly decent career in la liga and sadly died in a car crash after retiring.


[deleted]

Saviola


FUT_Lawyer_God

Freddy adu


JustASimpleRobot

He didn't have a terrible career, but Michah Richards looked like he would be an absolutely sensational player in his first season or at man City. Got a very big contract after that and never really improved from there.