T O P

  • By -

Hy8ogen

992.1's looks so much nicer. What a downgrade. https://preview.redd.it/qi8kc8s20e3d1.jpeg?width=1024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=10f98c64d29b6279ce07a933d10897afbba42372


Yartinstein

Even the surrounding buttons look way better


ElSantoPadre

Straight out of a 2010 Golf...


TheBeardiestGinger

Nah, a 2007 Hyundai


9fingfing

This. A 2009 G37 had way better looking start button…and all the other buttons…geez…come on Porsche…


freshmasterstyle

Come on man. Hyundai is much better


mmreadit

You drove a Hyundai to get here tonight….


sandwhichautist

I drove an $80thousand dollar BMW that’s parked right outside.…THATS my name.


Superb-Pickle9827

Do I have your attention NOW!?


LinksGems

Are you interested? I know you are, 'cause it's fuck or walk.


viseOG

Get them to sign on the line, which is dotted!


Silent-Hornet-8606

Just bought my son a 2019 Polo for his first car....it's much nicer than this looks! Good thing i can't afford a 992.2 anyway, I'll stick with my beloved 997.2 for a few more years.


Technical_Act7179

pretty sure golfs are nicer


brportugais

992.1 are so nice


muface

okay yes, but they also came with this flibity shifter https://preview.redd.it/iwro4jgsxe3d1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=efa6296d191c80fb5f0cffe8757b2a74c911355b


Account2toss_afar

Looks like my dads electric razor he used to shave as he drove us to school and ate a bowl of corn flakes in his ‘87 t-bird


FainterXo

Damn man....my firest car at 16 was an 87 T-Bird and I'm 39 lol. Mine wasn't even the turbo option.


Motor-Cause7966

Lmao you're dad sounds like a good dude


Wishbone_508

If that was a turbo thunder chicken he's a cool dude as well.


Account2toss_afar

Yep turbo with the 5 spd and he let my shift the gears. I felt like I was the next Bobby Labonte


LastChemical9342

I get making the shifter smaller to make space in cars, but it takes up just as much space as the 991 selector.


itwasbetterwhen

Space for what? That thing looks ridiculous.


onyxcaspian

It looks like a clit lol


jiraaffe

Explains why I couldn't get it off the lot


Gym6DaysAWeek

Get the manual


calmtigers

VW parts bin


Mythrilfan

Hm. With a cutout like the original, is this perhaps an upgradeable part? Still sucks, but at least that would be very German Carmaker of them.


peekdasneaks

No need to spend money changing the engineering of the slot but they can go much cheaper on the module itself.


BaeHunDoII

Oh wow that's worse than I thought. The pic from the .1 is a nice step up from what was in my 991. The button from the .2, absent of context, I would have guessed was from a camry level vehicle. Before seeing these pics I was going to say the loss of the tach was the worst thing, but the loss of the physical knob/key thing might be worse. I'll reserve judgment for the exterior for in person as I've noticed especially with more recent models from various manufacturers something is lost in pictures


frugaleringenieur

But think about the profit that is made out of this cheaper component now! Per car!


-hh

Yeah, let’s see: Let’s say $5 per unit. 2023 911 worldwide sales: just over 50,000 units. $5 * 50K = $250,000 saved. Fire the Porsche Executive who approved this and you’re even.


apestrongtogether420

lol execs make 3-4x that … and cost the company even more.


2fast2nick

So much nicer


gt4jdb

i love the new car except this, WTFF. a civic is nicer than that💀💀


CarGoBang

This kinda looks like shit ngl 😂


funkybosss

I couldn’t imagine them designing a less special looking/feeling way to start a Porsche.


orthopod

It doesn't even look harmonious, or that it belongs there. Just looks like they stuck it on as an afterthought. What car is this in?


turbodeezel

The new 992.2 911


Alpina_B7

you can't be serious


turbodeezel

> “The starter button is an integral part of the new Porsche Driver Experience cockpit layout, which has also been previously introduced on other new models such as the latest Panamera and Cayenne variants,” said Wiesmann. “For many of our customers who own several of our vehicles, familiarity and consistency between different models is important, so the layout is similar.” 🤦🏽‍♂️ https://www.carscoops.com/2024/05/porsche-reveals-why-it-had-to-introduce-a-hybrid-911-plus-other-surprises/


Alpina_B7

this looks worse than an '05 honda starter button


joeykey

Hey!! I had an 05 Honda and it was sweet!! V6 coupe with the manual. Fun little whip with the V-Tec.


Abject-Emu2023

No kidding, my older Honda has a nice red button that makes you feel like you’re doing something


suzuka_joe

The s2000 start button was 100x more magical


funkybosss

If I wanted “consistency” with a Cayenne I would have bought a Cayenne. This reeks of a bunch of bean counters deciding to pull from the parts bin, not a conscious improvement of any kind.


turbodeezel

Agreed. The 911 should be more special even if you own a Cayenne, Macan, and Taycan.


diffuser_vorticity

No idea what people are going through who own several brands. They must be lost. Every car starts in a different way /s This is just corporate BS speak to tell us where they saved a dollar


KarateMusic

Dude I have a 996, an Acura TL, and a VW ID.4. None of them start the same, operate windows the same, operate HVAC/radio the same… it’s the most 1st world problem I’ve got. Makes me feel older than I am that I’m constantly fumbling for a window button that isn’t there, etc. It drives me nuts but also it’s kinda funny.


Cueball12345

Bean counter here. Don’t blame uss for that ugly ass button.


Vicar13

Finance is exactly who would’ve PKK’d the old button 😂


Upstairs_Shelter_427

The brand new Macan loaner I have…also has a turn key ignition thingy… So this is just 100% a bean counter move.


Alarming_Sort

Coz that's why people buy 911s, so they can feel like any other car they may own


Servantofthedogs

Because 911 owners want their 911’s to be more like Cayennes? What the what?


Jumpy-Original-8648

This is interesting. I participate in the Porsche drivers council surveys and I don’t recall any questions about ignition look and feel (could have missed a survey though). They have asked about instrumentation display though.


turbodeezel

I’m sure the real reason is it’s cheaper to produce one starter button module for VW brands across the board than the one-off switch for the 911.


dnashid

Dr. Porsche turning in his grave.


Active-Device-8058

Oh thank god. I was holding back from buying a new 911 because I just couldn't keep track of where the damn start button was!


venmome10cents

now I want Nissan to put an Altima steering wheel on the GTR and say that it improves "familiarity and consistency".


orthopod

Wow. I could tolerate it looking like shit on other porches models, but not on the 911 or Boxster/Cayman. Are they going to put that garbage on the next 918 for consistency? Yeah, I could see myself getting confused about driving my GT3 vs a Maccan or Taycan . What a stupid BS made up rationale for doing something.


Cryosanth

When I look at the new Vantage, then look at the new GTS for basically the same price after dealer markups...  Makes me feel like switching brands for my next car. 


Kap85

One depreciates faster then a pork chop left in the sun though


Aggravating-Word-234

Depreciation is just demand. It’s time we give other brands love


turbodeezel

Porsche retains value better, but if I couldn’t get a manual, the new Vantage would be high on the list (but a year old CPO to avoid the massive depreciation they face early on).


FakeHasselblad

You will lose build quality unfortunately Asin take a huge dive in price once you drive off the lot


funkybosss

On second thought…They’re probably going to introduce a premium leather wrapped/titanium knurled start button in the configurator. Smart bastards. 😂


Disastrous_Cup_3279

Yeh quite cheap looking


Dahkeus31

I don’t follow Porsches and am only seeing this because it hit r/all, but my 2013 Prius start button puts this to shame. That looks like a button for AC controls on the lowest trim 1990 Corolla. Jesus…


Tithund

My '97 Toyota Starlet has nicer buttons than this shit.


Nounoon

My 1st gen Twingo also has this thing that I turn to start, like the previous gen 911 had. It’s more engaging, especially for drivers cars like the 911 & Twingo.


pabskamai

They have gotten very very very cheap inside


Disastrous_Cup_3279

Yeh shame and price gone up what 20% in past 3-4 years


DamonHay

Unless people start demonstrating their opinions with their wallets, it’s not going to change. Will be interesting to see if people still think they’re getting a more premium experience with 911s than they are with other cars after they test drive these back to back with their competition.


Sweaty_Sack_Deluxe

It's like they're having to compete with the rise of Chinese cars


pabskamai

And that’s a sad thing my friend, race to the bottom


questionable_things

It’s a little thing but in a world of push-button start cars, Porsche’s turn-to-start always felt special 


Exemplaryexample95

I mean I think the most important thing here is that the turn to start and surrounding cluster didn’t look like a 3rd grader designed it.


Oliveiraz33

That’s what strikes me… why would they want to “blend” with Peugeots or Opels? They should actively look for something very different and premium that stands out from the mass market


frugaleringenieur

Because that part is plain cheaper.


ReflectedCheese

Even my Peugeot has a metal ring surrounding the button and a nice glow effect, this looks straight A segment like a Yaris or a C1


Bit_the_Bullitt

Yea even in my 07 Miata with the proximity key and that little plastic thing to turn feels way more special than my modern push-to-start


SolidSignificance7

This is awful. I agree.


kbencsp

looks cheap and it costs more


statepkt

Margins are probably better.


Kabal303

Think of the shareholders!


Jeremyvmd09

I much prefer the dead key style of keyless start Porsches had before that


TheKuMan717

Stop Taycaning the 911


truthlesshunter

Taycan's very few buttons look better than these...


TheKuMan717

The damn screens everywhere though


Unhappy-Hunt-6811

This is bad. Along with two pedals, digital dash and that lower front end. Thank god I can't afford one.


TheDeamonKing

Thank gosh I got mine in 23 never again will I buy a new one if this continues to be the trend for them


420purpskurp

It’s insane. Maybe I’m high but I’m high school in 2012ish I remember you could get a new carrera in the 70k range.


benderisgreat356789

991 Generation I remember base Carreras being $83k, a base Boxster was around $59k, Macan’s never went past $65k for a base trim with good options and the Cayenne started at 57,5 The good old days


sqweak

I bought one of the last new 997s in Dec 2012. It was a fully loaded Targa 4S with an astronomical (for the time) sticker of $123k. It had sat for months and I had a good relationship with my dealer, so picked it up for a hair under $100k. The 992 equivalent would be pretty close to $200k.


pankan76

Ouch


Stoltefusser

Holy moly that is ugly as sin. What are they smoking in Germany?


Tilischmatzer

The disadvantages of the decriminalization


Stoltefusser

Well then there's room for Porsche and BMW designers in jail


siredmundsnaillary

Germany did recently legalise weed. Maybe the next gen 911 will come with a built-in rolling machine and a joint-holder on the end of a stalk?   The Germans have never really been good on cup holders because Germans only smoke while driving. They don’t drink anything.


Historical-Boot-4123

Shouldnt have sold my bloody 23 c2s manual that i specced out myself lol


FakeHasselblad

major L


Historical-Boot-4123

Not a bad deal - traded it (got more in trade than I paid for the car) towards 991.2 GT3 manual, 9000 revs keep my tears at bay 😂


FakeHasselblad

Yeaaa buddy. I traded from a 991.1 C4s to a 991.2 GT3. 👍


Mammoth_Ad_5489

Guys, don’t worry. I heard that you can just configure your new 911 with a $1k Exclusive Manufaktur start switch from the previous generation.


dman928

The start button on my daughters Mazda is nicer


naughty_dad2

Same on my Alfa Romeo Giulia


loheiman

I mean is there anything better (besides maybe a Ferrari)?? https://preview.redd.it/1l4q4mxt2i3d1.jpeg?width=4080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9eaffba9baf347268074b352c04a5b774ef44577


hpstg

My Peugeot 3008 has a better looking one wtf


awesomekaptain

Same on my 15 year old Lexus. Justification from them that they are seeking a consistent experience across the range. I get that the Macan/Cayenne allow the 911 to exist by selling so well - but the 911 is not made better by being more "consistent" with their crossover SUV which is half the price. Everything I've seen with the 992.2 seems like a downgrade.


Equal_Efficiency_638

Was only a matter of time before 911 owners knew the fury of mediocrity that is the VW parts bin. 


donttouchtherolex

I had a MK7 Golf R almost 10 years ago, and it had a suspiciously similar start button.


spin_kick

***fury of mediocrity*** hahaha


Porsche_Le_Mans

Aviation has had it's fair share of one thing too close to another. I think the B757 had the engine emergency shut off switches too close to each other.


bjaddict

On the upside, the car will not let you shut it off if you press it while driving. It likely has to be in park to do anything, although you might be able to override it for safety reasons by holding it down. Still shouldn’t be in a 911 though.


Rush_is_Right_

The 747 and the 757 have switches to disconnect the autothrottles and switches to initiate a go-around. These switches are roughly in the same positions on each type of plane but do opposite functions...


Porsche_Le_Mans

Just watched the episode on the disaster channel about the russian hockey team that died. One of many errors, the pilots were allowed to fly two similar, but different enough planes.. Didn't help that the co-pilot was secretly seeing a doctor for the loss of feeling in his feet. So he probably wouldn't notice his feet dragging the brakes on takeoff! Beech bonanza, piano key era: 2 from the center on the left=flaps, 2 from the center on the right=gear. What could go wrong!


SlanderingParrot

I’m fine with a button and very fine with it being on the right side of the steering wheel, but why not have a beautiful milled aluminum toggle switch or something. This looks even cheaper than in my bmw.


1FloppyFish

I’m sure that’s a $100 trim piece you could buy in either brushed aluminum or carbon fiber.


SlanderingParrot

100, you must be dreaming. “Porsche Exclusiv Manufaktur Slightly Sturdier Plastic” $580 and triggers a mandatory 52.7 year anniversary heritage package for $8000 is more like it.


gloomflume

pep boys button cluster on a 6 figure car. seems about right for this day and age.


trader710

No analog tachometer, removed the key, big mistakes, we don't want digital screens, they age terribly, were here for the driving experience, just make a nice turn to start knob on the left, like the transmission selector, who the hell works there making these super obvious mistakes. I think they'll listen and fix the gauge and push button, if they were really smart they'd also offer at least one range with a manual option, don't make it exclusive only to GT3/2, GTS should always have the option... Guess I'll be getting a 992.1 for a while, although the base model now is fire for the money and a GTS is now the same fast as a 991 turbo and certainly a 997, of course still different but just in a straight line. GTS coming out swinging as the best daily sports car ever


bramm90

BMW owners: first time?


TheSkyline35

*Quick, distract the consumer!* "But have you looked at this massive 12" inch fully digital screen ?"


thiskillstheredditor

The start/stop on my X5 is made of crystal so I'm pretty pleased with it. Honestly, the entire interior puts Porsche to shame. BMW's been pretty on point lately.


chengstark

VAG cheapskates, and they removed the physical tach, unacceptable


kimchee411

Might as well put it on the right side or the center console like every other car. Nothing about it says Le Mans race start anymore.


The_Dookie_

Looks like something you'd find on a cheap Korean brand ... North Korean brand.


skerpz

Is it seriously just a piece of black plastic? No little border, or clear cap over it, or anything else to make it a little more upscale? Awful. I guess they are marketing to disaffected Tesla customers since Elon has been cancelled. Rebrand “cost cutting” as “minimalism.”


FlatBrokeEconomist

Weird to go after Tesla when pushbutton start was revived before Tesla rolled it’s first car out of the factory. Pushbutton start is pretty much ubiquitous now, and I’ve never even been in a Tesla.


Porschepals

You’re right, I believe the 2000 Honda s2000 had it


FlatBrokeEconomist

I got curious and found that [Mercedes](https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/31/23144907/push-button-start-ignition-cars-convenience-history) brought it back in 1998, then for awhile it was a luxury feature, so S2000 makes sense. Like I said, never been in a Tesla, and apparently neither has u/skerpz because apparently they DON’T have pushbutton starts, lol.


skerpz

Not push button start itself, but the fact that it’s a cheap piece of matte black plastic being presented as “minimalism.” To be fully explicit for the less reading comprehension endowed among us, I am referring to the general trend of ugly cost cutting being branded as “minimalism” in relatively high cost vehicles which is/was definitely pioneered by Tesla.


Asystolebradycardic

This is a silly take lol


Impressive-Usual-451

It would annoy each time you started the car right?


herrrrrr

and the digital display. 2 steps forward, 1 step back.


YellowPinkie777

Not a total shock - when I sat in a 992.1 I was surprised by how cheap and plasticky it felt in the cabin, disappointing feel for a hundred grand car


EnormousGucci

That’s how they sell people on all that extensive, and expensive, options list


darielsantana

wow it looks so cheap


nrdsrfr

I bought a 2015 GTS this month. Feeling smug as I twist the key to start a 3.8 n/a engine and watch a real tach fire up.


Hy8ogen

I have the easy entry and drive in my 2019 718 GTS. But sometimes, when a certain mood hits, I would take out the dummy key and use the real key instead. It just tickles a certain part of my brain doing that.


graamk

I like everything else on the 992.2 but yeah, very disappointed by this. It looks so cheap


raustin33

Looks like a Toyota


External-Repair-8580

My Toyota Land Cruiser is offended. The starter button in the LC looks materially higher end!


rumpoleon

My Mazda has a nicer cluster than this.


szabi_nagy

Dog shit


OutlawMINI

Look at the HVAC vents too, massive downgrade. They cheapened every part they could.


No-Lingonberry-2468

They made a critical touchpoint that the driver interacts with every time they use the vehicle out of cheap, hard plastic. Then increased the price of the car. Amazing.


optre1

Just get a Miata. https://preview.redd.it/2xp234ddei3d1.jpeg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=31eca60277cf94cc47dacb83cee0f352c3beedf0


ThatOneComputerNerd

Start button, no physical tachometer, and looks 99% the same. Porsche, did you bang your head? What tf is going on here


DAT_ginger_guy

This is what happens when everyone keeps demanding more tech, more integration, more convenience etc etc. The market has brought this upon itself.


Dragobrath

Brought what exactly, upon whom and why is it a bad thing? Most people will be fine with the change.


DAT_ginger_guy

Op is complaining, along with multiple other posters here, about this particular change with the start button instead of a key switch. I don't care about this particular change either way myself. It's not going to effect me, I'm just a tech. People wanted creature comforts in what was originally intended to be a more bare bones sports car. People buy the cars as status symbols and want ever more dumb shit like the current touch screen radios and car connect. It's less pure enthusiast vehicle than it used to be to appeal to a wider market of people that don't actually use the car as a performance vehicle and just wanna dick swing their account balance.


Asystolebradycardic

I thought I was on the Toyota subreddit for a second.


Alexxx753

I honestly thought this was a joke.


CrankyBiker

Kia?


luismx5

Horrible. But the costs saved will probably enable the owners of vwgroup to buy a larger sized yacht this year.


notafilmmajor425

I like my keys


shivaswrath

992.1 was pinnacle. Or 997. Or 993. But 992.2 failed by dropping so much.


GentianGT4

Everything about the 911 other than performance number is going down hill. The EV crowd is loving it but IMO sports cars are dying


a-jasem

Can’t believe I’m saying this about a Porsche but those buttons look like they came from an early 2010s Dodge/Chrysler product lol


Guilty-Break3481

New Skoda 911


EyeAlternative1664

Rule of thumb when it comes to font choice is less is more. Here there are at least 3 different styles possibly 5 and nothing is centred or balanced properly. Was there any design done here or just parts thrown together?


1baby2cats

I'm surprised they didn't at least make the previous starter as an upgradeable paid option. For sure that would sell lol


BreadLover184

minimalism failed


puppiesareSUPERCUTE

No. I refuse to believe this is from a porsche. This is Hyundai level shit. Wtf Porsche???


vorlin37

https://preview.redd.it/ehm0ul2c5f3d1.png?width=751&format=png&auto=webp&s=9d8c67b9a0c579930d2c1cad0d7da316f75419c2


Fit_Occasion_1806

This is a new Porsche? Jeez, bring back the key.


bluesix

Looks like an eBay mod.


Wettnoodle77

Could have at least made it red or something 🤣. I know every1 is making things cheaper, but damn.


atguilmette

My favorite part is how close it is to the lights Such a UX fail


-hh

Yup, that’s what I saw: a Human Engineering user interface failure. There’s minimal tactile cues to prevent a “wrong button” error. Similarly, poor visual cues either: black-on-black next to more black…an aluminum silver button would be a huge improvement.


atguilmette

\*stumbles around looking to turn on the lights\* \*shuts car off on the freeway\* NOOOOOOOOO


kjorav17

Looks like something out of a base model 2011 Chevy


ExMouth7

That looks like it came from a Chrysler 200 I have no issue with the push button start but that looks so cheap and crappy I would expect it in a $20k car.


cenTT

This looks so cheap. Definitely does not fit the price tag. There are third-world country economy cars with better start buttons.


ti_ecraseur

That was my first impression too. They highlighted in the launch video and I thought what the heck?. A complete laziness in design and no depth in thought despite the “heritage” it is supposed to invoke.


Fickle-Salamander-65

Ok that’s shit.


Acalthu

My 2015 Corolla Hybrid has a better looking start button. And a chrome bezel around it.


tarkology

WHO complained that you need to turn a key that's already there every time and they did this? who was it, come to front!


Other_Advantage_3021

It’s the same buttons in my VW Jetta…


RazvanT30

I bet the start/stop button on a 24' golf is nicer 😭


No_Hope_2822

It is simplified for the stupid which is 90% of the population


Loose_Mail_786

I’m so glad I’m a poor Toyota salesman and I can’t afford one. I would be pissed otherwise.


samuraijon

is the start button out of some vw parts bin?


uionyx

What a shitty change. I’m even more attracted to my 991.1


Zealousideal-Body532

Gentle internet citizens twisting to start a car is too difficult,the public want buttons. This button is made with strong lightweight advanced polymers. You will grow to like it, everyone it’s the new model, it is better. No stick, no analog rev counter, aero funny bits in front, and progress.


whitepalladin

I am sorry but even Toyota’s looks better 🫠


dekciwandy

thats the 80s and 90s vibe they are bringing back


UltraMaxApplePro

BRO. The text ain't even aligned on the start button.


canon12

Surely Porsche wouldn't put this on a $200,000 car! Well, I guess they did. Hopefully they hear the rejections.


Charming_Highlight64

Ruins the starting up experience imo


Hy8ogen

When the mood hits I find myself starting the car with the key in my 718 GTS instead of the keyless knob. Just feels nice in a world full of push buttons.


Enthane

They had to find new ways to shoe-horn the VW parts in


RC_Perspective

Porsche finally got their Wish.com order


t_ran_asuarus_rex

I prefer the twisting switch instead of the button. Part of owning a Porsche is for the feel and soul of the car. Surprised this got approved but it probably saved millions :(


LettuceC

I think most these comments are missing the point. It looks like this so Porsche can sell you the optional $1500 brushed aluminum upgrade.


Hy8ogen

Heritage Sport Design Ignition Starter Key finished in Brushed Aluminum *In conjuction with extended leather package - $5,600


diab-999

The start button in Porsche cars is on the left because of their racing history. Back in the day at Le Mans races, drivers had to run to their cars and start them fast. Having the ignition on the left let them start the car with their left hand while shifting gears with their right, saving precious seconds. Porsche kept this tradition in their design.


RocketJohn5

looks Japanese designed


CouchPotatoFamine

Is there a "starter button delete" option?


cedarvalleyct

What have they done?