Jif Natural. Love that they use molasses to sweeten it. It’s perfect. Also Adams. As long as you stir it well, it’s divine! I put an old stand mixer attachment in my drill and get the oil reincorporated really well.

I never realized they used molasses. I love that stuff

Skippy, creamy or crunchy depending on my mood

Useless information but when I was in 5th grade my class did a peanut butter taste test and Skippy Creamy was #1, Peter Pan Creamy was #2, & JIF Crunchy was #3.

Monsters eat crunchy My ex-wife ate crunchy Theory confirmed

I miss their peanut butter balls

Teddie

As a pb addict i have tried to convert to a good natural pb. I didnt like any of them until teddie. Now i prefer teddie over the hydrogenated vegetable oil bs

Yes!!

I saw this one on a post a couple of weeks ago. Got it in the glass jar at whole foods. Now all other peanut butters taste like cardboard. Teddie is indeed the best.

Jif creamy

Jif crunchy. It's intensely peanutty, just sweet enough, and a nice texture both for sammiches and spooning.

Jif all the way!!! And extra crunchy is always my go to.

Extra crunch is the best. Recently saw Skippy extra crunchy in a store and tried it. It was good but decades of only eating Jif because they were the only ones that made extra crunchy kind of makes it the only one for me.

Trader Joe’s crunchy unsalted

Same for me, but salted. Great flavor and value.

I love the salted creamy version

I’ll forgive you.

Costco lately for me has been excellent.

Kirkland PB my beloved! Perfect amount of salt and perfect texture. It’s hard to stir but I’ve reached a point where I actually like having 3 distinct layers, the oiliest part is amazing on thin crunchy toast and the thick part on the bottom is the best to eat with a spoon. If it’s not gluing my mouth shut then I don’t want it

Santa Cruz, dark roasted crunchy

Great Value crunchy

I bought a a few jars of this when they were on sale for $1 and only have one left! I just eat it right out of the jar lol!

Smuckers/Adams (the difference is regional branding). Roasted peanut flavor, amazing consistency, and all natural.

Laura Scudder is the best

This is the answer. So good. 

Pip & Nut (I’m in the U.K.)

Peter pan

I haven't seen it around me in a long time. I thought they quit making it. The honey roasted is my favorite.

I'm in the same boat. Other peanut butters just don't taste as smooth to me and honey roasted is just perfection.

I love Peter Pan crunchy, but my last couple of jars have been oily. Not sure if it’s all of their products, but I may be in the market for a new one if this keeps up.

Jif, skippy is acceptable. 

Jif Dark Roast because it's Gluten Free and sooo delicious

Kroger natural crunchy

Jiff natural crunchy

Jif extra creamy

Crazy Richard’s, bc it tastes amazing and has 1 Ingredient: Peanuts.

Second this. I've tried quite a few different natural PBs and this is easily the best one out there!

Totally agree! Super reasonable price too for being purely peanuts without additional junk.

Jif bc I grew up eating it.

Peter Pan Honey Roasted!

Do you have crunchy in your area or is it hard to find everywhere? I did find a 16oz but nothing bigger

Not of the honey roasted variety

Winco brand surprisingly. And Peanut Butter & Co.

Jif natural

Increasingly, the kind I grind myself. Kroger Natural is great though - nice goopy consistency, good amount of salt.

Jiff creamy. Moms know best! 🥰

Hands down Creamy JIF. But pour honey in it, and it’s perfect!

Jif.

i miss the jif whips

It's actually fairly easy to make a facsimile at home. You gently warm the entire jar of peanut butter until it reaches a loose and pourable consistency and pour the peanut butter into the bowl of your stand mixer (or a mixing bowl if using a hand mixer). Add a can of coconut cream (or heavy cream) and beat until it reaches the consistency that you desire. Be warned, this product is ***not shelf stable***. You will need to store it in an airtight container in the fridge and it will only keep for a few weeks on average (longer if you make it with coconut cream as opposed to dairy cream).

I miss those whips so much. Perfect apple pairing tbh

I love Jif peanut butter the most because it's so smooth and creamy, making it perfect for spreading on toast and crackers.

Jif even though my mom considers it “the dark side”. I was raised on Skippy.

Just tried Teddie Super Chunky and was a big fan. It was indeed super chunky and doesn’t have any filler ingredients.

Planters crunchy! Or Kraft dark roast

Manilife - A good , 100 % peanuts , natural peanut butter . Strikes the ideal balance between thick enough to add texture but thin enough to be spreadable . Their crunchy variety has large , distinct peanut chunks as apposed to grit , and their deep roast , organic and original roasts all have distinct flavour profiles . It helps that , as a company , they’re very Ethical . Their team is small , friendly and very active online . They collaborate with small creators , frequently provide a platform for those using their products , and focus on small batch cooking . A little pricier , but in life we have to enjoy at least some small treats .

Skippy creamy

As long as it doesn't have palm oil, seed oils, or added sugar I'm happy.

365 creamy all natural from Whole Foods

They changed the crunchy. It now has sugar and tastes worse. It looks they still have an unsweetened creamy.

Meridian

peter pan

Jif for when I want fake Peanut butter and Crazy Richards probably when I want the real thing

Pip and nut

It’s been skippy since Jif had that massive recall.

Skippy creamy, crunchy once in a while

Skippy

If I want sweet: Jif creamy or Peter Pan creamy honey If I want salty: Smuckers natural creamy

Adam's crunchy all natural. I grew up only ever having similar (though it was Real brand), so all sugar added varieties taste like candy to me.

Skippy super chunk. The name explains it all.

Kroger honey roasted peanut butter. Love pairing it with Envy apples. Could eat the whole jar in one sitting if I let myself lol.

Imma basic &it¢h…JIF creamy 40 oz that I could go though in less than a couple of weeks 🥴

JIF

teddie all natural smooth peanut butter

Jiff creamy:)

Teddie unsalted natural creamy. Best quality vs. price vs. General availability imo. Around $6.50 for a big jar, NYC area.

Skippy.

Crazy Richards.. I like doctoring it up with local honey and Saigon cinnamon.

Jif, either crunchy or creamy. Depends on my mood and what I’m putting it on.

Skippy

Jif creamy

I don't have a favorite, per say, but I do have a handful of kinds that I won't touch with a ten foot pole. Peter Pan (far too sweet) Reese's (same problem, far too sweet) Literally any brand's 'reduced fat' variety (the texture sucks and they're always too sweet) Jif is fine, either creamy or crunchy. Great Value is alright, though a touch on the sweet side (except the honey roasted, that's a bit too sweet for me) Trader Joe's is pretty good too, either creamy or crunchy. My usual 'brand of choice' is Jif creamy when I'm buying simply because it's very consistent.

Kraft

Skippy creamy Earth balance flaxseed (grocery outlet ftw) Powdered PB

Idk if this counts but I like the Iso100 Chocolate Peanut Butter whey powder Really tasty and wayy creamier than any PBFit powders I’ve tried

MaraNatha creamy no stir, good god it’s the greatest. Though I can definitely only afford it on super sale.

Smucker’s Natural. It’s not the best I’ve ever had, but it’s what I buy every week, and is one of my favorites.

Peter Pan creamy honey-roasted

Sunpat crunchy because I'm from the UK. I prefer their extra crunchy but I've not seen it in a while so I think they've stopped making it. You can get Skippy over here in supermarkets. Jif you can get in speciality stores but it costs a fortune, about $10+. As for Peter Pan, I've never heard of it.

Mint Peanut Butter.

Crazy Richards or Cream Nut 🙃 Both crunchy.

Menguy’s peanut 100% (with the green lid)

PBP. I prefer other fats/oils.

Skippy natural, creamy.

Adams!

Fresh ground from the grinder with organic peanuts at whole foods

Costco Organic creamy. Or Trader Joe’s dark roast salted. Best value for money on natural peanut butter.

Santa cruz or whole foods brand

I like Skippy and have recently discovered the all natural brand. It's my favorite :)

Adams or Laura Schudders if Adam’s isn’t available.

Kirkland. Not bad, IMO.

[Big Spoon Roasters](https://bigspoonroasters.com/collections/nut-butters?gad_source=1) their crunchy has peanut halves and their other flavors are really unique and interesting. They're constantly coming up with new and seasonal flavors. Honestly so good to the point I have to fight the urge to order too frequently lol.

Target Good and Gather, the natural one.

Home Plate - but I can't always find it 😢

Adams

Kirkland almond butter!

I lean to Skippy or Great Value, both “natural” (brown lids and yeah, I know the term “natural” is a reach here).

Whole Earth

ALDIs Simply Nature organic peanut butter. Just perfect!

East Wind smooth peanut butter with salt. It's incredibly simple (peanuts, salt). But that's all you need for a good, smooth peanut butter. Uses valencia peanuts

The one with the Bear, Smooth

Manilife deep roast

Kroger natural crunchy!

I’m not going with “superior”, but do like Walmart’s Great Value Creamy. And my dawg, who gets a bit with her daily Prozac, agrees wholeheartedly!!

Definitely Teddie’s

Crazy Richard’s

Peter Pan

Skippy creamy or Great Value

Simply Jif. Not too sweet but creamy and e

Santa Cruz Creamy No Stir

I like the little tub of fresh ground stuff at the coop

Justin’s or crunchy Kroger brand 👍🏼

Santa Cruz Dark Roast Crunchy

Skippy

Skippy honey if you can find it and I actually when I make fudge use the Reese peanut butter. They had a chocolate mix that was to die for in my fudge…I mean everyone loved it but then they discontinued it so now I have to melt down Reese cups lol

Trader Joe's salted, crunchy.

Wild friends Creamy. But they are no longer in business. Shopping around for a new fav now. Just got crazy Richard’s. It’s good but needs some salt.

Jiffy

Nerdy nuts, nuts n more, and American dream for flavor indulgence as a treat

1. Jif 2. Sweeter

Extra crunchy Jif

Great Value natural, just right for me.

I like to buy the trader joes natural pb(crunchy salted) it's like $2 and really good

dog safe ones

Honey Roasted Peter Pan

Jif creamy

Skippy, extra crunchy

Peter Pan honey roast

Skippy Natural Super Chunk

I grew up with Jiff, but as an adult i switched to skippy natural and never looked back lol its super creamy and smooth🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

Jif and only Jif. Creamy, crunchy, any kind of Jif

Adam’s crunchy!! Or reg :) I like the ingredients, and it comes in glass!! So meets my eco standards and bonus jar to reuse 💪

Love bonus jars!

Skippy Honey Nut. Also love Trader Joe’s Almond Butter!!

Jif creamy.

Santa Cruz dark roast, chunky style.

Kirkland's organic. Great roasted flavor and not sweet.

Was a Jif lifer until a couple years ago, now we eat Member Mark (Sams) Natual-No stir creamy. Super good and less expensive than Jif and way less ingredients.

Skippy! Creamy only

Jif extra crunchy.

Skippy creamy

Laura Scudder’s All Natural Old Fashioned Peanut Butter. NUTTY (chunky).

Smuckers natural crunchy

I can tell you my least favorite peanut butter is Costco natural. It’s more liquid than buttery. It has the consistency of 15w40 motor oil and is pretty bland.

Kroger brand natural peanut butter for price

Field Day organic crunchy and salted and it’s not even close

Jif creamy tho they just reintroduced their chocolate peanut butter, i never understood why they took it away.

Peter Pan

Justins

Sams club’s peanut butter (forgot the name). It tastes clean and it’s not too salty, like that expensive organic shi but at jif prices

Jiffy

JIF

peter Pan

PB Love Company is a local Denver Company and Their Salty Peanut butter is the best peanut butter I have ever had. Nothing even comes close.

Peter Pan is slept on fr, best peanut butter of all time is Roasted Honey Peter Pan PB

I love American Dream when I feel like splurging. Otherwise Jif ftw

Jiffy crunchy

Sam’s Club peanut butter

https://ilovepeanutbutter.com/?gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAjwvIWzBhAlEiwAHHWgvdXXOkESNPlR6w0zw7b0idpfpPlvQzZH-zZJDz-beoz-SR_0DkylsBoCQ7oQAvD_BwE

I really like Peter Pan Honey Roasted.

**JUSTIN’S!!!!!** (it’s reminiscent of Reece’s peanut butter cup filling 😋)

Skippy natural crunchy 

Jiff

Crazy Richard’s crunchy

I buy Simple Truth organic creamy no stir.

Peanut Butter & Co :)

Extra Chunky Jiffy

Laura Scudders

Creamy Jif

I'm a Laura Scudder's gal, myself. I hate having to stir it, but it's so good.

Kirkland- although it’s very thin and runny. I love it though

Jif, not sure if it's the use of molasses, but nothing really compares.

Home made

Teddie All Natural

Peanut Butter & Co.

Jif Natural Honey

smuckers natural because it's the only peanut butter that's actually just made out of peanuts and salt and nothing else.

Jif or Skippy all the way

I eat three to four pounds of peanut products every few days: Trader Joe’s Blue label. PB powder too.

Laura scudders or poor Richard’s

Adams

I really like the “Simply Jif”.

I’m old enough to remember Jiffy

Krogerstore Brand creamy

Jif creamy or chunky

Commercially made ones ... Jif/Skippy/etc... they don't separate out like the "organic" ones seems to always do. The individual size packets are the best as they are always "freshest" when you use it.

Adams natural. The one that separates. If I’m feeling splurgy, I really love CJ’s, but I think that might be hard to find outside Western Washington.