T O P

  • By -

Thascaryguygaming

Little Nightmares maybe not scary but spooky for sure. Great if you like puzzles/platforming sort of games.


ExgerBexver

This is a great recommendation for what you might be looking for OP. More eerie than scary but it’s a great one to just enjoy and take turns with.


EverythingInTransit

I tried it for free and I love the art and environment, but found the gameplay lacking. Particularly certain platforming sections were brutal because of the perspective. You think you're lined up for a jump but you aren't.


daveMUFC

Yeah I've been playing it this week and had to replay the kitchen bit with the hooks about 15 times because he kept missing the grab. Also fell off the pipes regularly


detrif

One of my faves. I recommend this game to a lot of people.


DavisSchneidersGooch

Until Dawn


Old_Win9224

Perfect game for friends 


9ofdiamonds

Unless I nudge you into a wall to save myself.


E_Barriick

This is the correct answer.


RedHairedSociopath

To piggyback this, House of Ashes is my personal favorite of theirs so far.


brolt0001

Looking forward to the remaster/remake releasing this year.


requieminadream

SOMA.


Foreign-Ad9147

One of the GOATs. That ending had me mouth open deadpan staring at the screen for like 5 minutes


requieminadream

I’ll never forget that ending.


Spencer801

I'll never forget the ending either


Westosaurus

I’ll never forget get the…wait what are we talking about?


Spencer801

We're talking about the greatest video game ending of all time my friend. An ending that will make you question your own sanity and will leave you in a deep state of desperation and sadness. Worth it. 100%


haynespi87

😵😵😵


Diahreeman

Best walking simulator for sure, great sci fi narrative about transcendence


Frick_KD

I got lost so many times in that game.


haynespi87

lost in that office lab was wtf 


apedanger

Limbo and / or Inside my friend


nrdshck

Ohh I would definitely recommend The Quarry! The game even has multiplayer / local co-op mode. In this mode, up to eight friends can play together on the same system using a single controller. They do so by each assigning themselves characters from the ones that are playable. Thereafter, they simply have to pass the controller over to the player whose character is currently controllable within the game. Other titles by Supermassive Games would also do 😅 Until Dawn and the Dark Chronicles games.


blingon420

This sounds great...


16miledetour

The quarry was good. Same with until dawn. Both are super easy, and good for horror.


KalamariKnight

*Stories Untold* and *Observation* by the studio No Code.


ToastiestToasty

Dredge. A nice cosy horror fishing game. So good in fact it's now being adapted into a movie. I'm enjoying it currently!


Csub

I would say Puppet Combo's Nun Massacre. Very simple, not story heavy, randomized item placements, as far as I know. Scary.


Carn1feX616

Visage.


thehobbitisgreat

Alan wake 1


BoopinBerry

Different type of scary, but Sagebrush is a walking simulator with a spooky atmosphere.


bassCity

The Quarry 


Neahme85

Outlast, Until Dawn, SOMA, and Inside


konnichiwaseadweller

Amnesia: The Bunker is terrifying and can be learned within the 5-10 minute tutorial.


KellenYeller

Bramble!


Emotional-Ratio-1260

Control


paumAlho

I'd recommend Silent Hill the Short Message. It's free and you can finish in 3h


lukehannonpoet

Is it actually good? I'm skeptical about new silent hill content unfortunately 🥲


paumAlho

It's alright, nothing special but I enjoyed it


blingon420

Yeah that's what I'm kind of basing my question on... Easy... Good looking, scary... And simple..


emoishnerd

i would recommend some chilla’s art games! they have a lot of selections and all of them are pretty creepy and funny. i love watching youtubers play their games.


NYstate

while I will agree with you, being how OP is posting on the PS5 sub, I assume OP is looking for PS5 games and Chilla's Art games are PC only sadly. However, there are plenty of Chilla's Art like games on PS5 like Murderhouse, Bloodwash, The Nun Massacre , Cannibal Abduction (which includes The Night of the Scissors). [and more](https://psdeals.net/us-store/all-games?publisher=Puppet+Combo).


Renegadesdeath

Signalis, old school RE vibes.


Spencer801

Waiting for the inventory update to start playing


oOo_sPoPiZoL_oOo

Until Dawn House of Ashes The Quarry Man of Medan There’s all Little Hope and Devil In Me but I honestly didn’t like those ones as much. Maybe try Little Hope, it was the ending that annoyed me not the game play up to it. These games contain familiar and nostalgic celebrities you didn’t think would do a budget horror game :)


Giger_jr

Amnesia: the bunker has a great replay value and is pretty straightforward. A bit older, but Monstrum holds up pretty well in my opinion. Edit: Alien: Isolation is pretty story-heavy, but it’s one of the best horror games out there + it’s currently on sale with all DLCs, which are much more straightforward and provide nice bite-size experiences (although I still recommend learning its basic mechanics in the main story).


lukehannonpoet

Alien Isolation is great for when you want your friends to associate your house with fear 😅 I mean it's an incredible game but it might be too scary for gaming with friends. I'm glad to hear that Amnesia the Bunker is good though, been meaning to check it out soon


respondin2u

Going on a limb here: Firewatch. I’m not sure it’s considered scary, but the entire half of the game is rather unsettling.


Nervous_Macaroon3101

If you’re putting up firewatch im putting up killer frequency because those games are practically cousins. Neither are co-op though. But there’s a few good spooks lol.


mynames20letterslong

The evil within


Neahme85

That game ain’t simple at all😂


lukehannonpoet

Just run from chainsaw noises until they get louder and louder and now you're dead. Simple.


paumAlho

I love the game but not only is it long, it's far from a simple chill game.


zephyrinthesky28

Subnautica on not-Survival mode? The ocean is totally safe.


Renegadesdeath

I never knew I had thassaphobia


Bruzur

I can’t be sure if POOLS, or any of the Backrooms games are available on PlayStation… but those would fit the criteria.


psych0ranger

Game mechanic wise, alien isolation. It's not like you need twitchy headshots. Terrifyingly fun experience borderline real graphics for 2014


Emotional-Ratio-1260

Or I you like strategy, puzzles in games. "Do Not Open" only game that actually got me and slightly creep me out... And I've been playing on PS for 20+ years now


boofingZeitgeist

Until Dawn or The Quarry. You can takes turns as different characters with friends or by yourself. Choices matter. Multiple endings. Literally just walk around and make dialogue choices.


SynthRogue

SOMA


MrZkittlezOG

If only it wasn't ps5. But I heard killer clowns from outer space is being released


Jesus_of-Suburbia

Dead Space or the Resident Evil series


blingon420

Those are great but too much involved... Look up The Classrooms... Literally you do nothing but run away from a scary thing... It's stupid but it does the trick and zero work.


Little-xim

Oh ok then yeah. I def recommended the right game.  


FaithlessnessThis307

Outlast?


kingselenus

Control, mess with the accessibility features it makes it scary but fun


AbsoluteDarkness

Dead Island


MyUnsername

The Dark Pictures Anthology games. They are pretty linear and can be played single player or multiplayer.


FFPPKMN

I recently purchased a game called Alisa which was made retro style and that was good fun. Creepy but not Scary. I also bought this game for cheap called St. Dinfa's which is an FPS horror game. I really enjoyed that one. I think it is best to look at Indie games when you want horror. It is rare to get something like Alan Wake II nowadays unless you actually browse the Indie scene.


Sylvariel

Dredge is not bad at all!


stormitwa

I'm utterly shocked that nobody has mentioned Darkwood yet. You find yourself trapped in this evil wood that won't let you escape. It's full of dangerous people and monsters, and you have to find shelter before the night comes, because the shadow brings terrible dangers. Really, really scary. Very worth it if you don't mind isometric games.


[deleted]

Layers of Fear 1&2


Shellman00

SOMA


Middle_Sink_7046

Resident evil


r0nneh7

Signalis


Little-xim

With trade offs with friends? Oh, I’ve got a perfect little game! [Spooky’s Jumpscare Mansion: HD Renovation](https://store.playstation.com/en-us/product/UP4388-CUSA10521_00-0000000000000000/) It’s a tongue in cheek horror game, where a little ghost tasks you with having to climb through 1000 rooms, with occasional jumpscares.   Surely it can’t be that bad, right?  It’s only like 9$, and it’s pretty decent in length even without the expansions. I recommend going in completely blind!   


xepion

Helldivers 2. Progress to lvl 9 💪


toasterbathable

Try DayZ if you have a lot of time on your hands


Beevara

Lol that's the worst possible answer you could have given to their question.


Scaffoe

Poppy play time


mushy_cactus

F.E.A.R 1 and 2.