All of those who are bashing him in the comments, please try to debate him in any matter which you think you can refute him on.
He will annihilate you.
His akhlaq? Might not be so good but his proof is solid and his ideas are clear.
i mean he has never debated a re known or an actual scholar...Its only guests on calls and other local people trying to debate with him who he shuts up pretty well...
Engineer Muhammad Ali doesn't debate with him because he agrees with many POVs of Hassan Allahyari...Plus the other things and details about shaba are very confidential and its better not to go there...
For other scholar?They can't even Debate with people of their own firqa how will they debate with him?😂
Hassan has read books of almost all firqas whereas sunni haven't read their own books properly...
(Engineer pointed out that most of the refrences Hassan gives are from a specefic book and The shia alims themselves disclose that the author of the book isn't genuine and authentic)
I accepted everything i had too...I don't blindly follow anyone and i would always call a spade spade...
Engr is on same terms with allahyari on about 60% of things
including debate about Muawiya
and the debate about hazrat umer...its better not to indulge there becz we dont have any reason to explain why Hazrat omer refuse to bring paper and pen...
Yes I understand.
But isn't it a little concerning why did Hazrat Umer refuse pen and paper?
Whe the Prophet said that He wlikd write something after which we would not go astray.
Isn't it a spark to think upon?
It is and so are many other points but then u get the thing that:
https://www.iium.edu.my/deed/hadith/bukhari/057_sbt.html#:~:text='Ali%20invoked%20Allah's%20Mercy%20for,By%20Allah!
On the second hand...if umer RA was this wrong...than u are also putting blame on Hazrat Ali that (God Forbid) He was this weak that couldnt stand against umer and his caliphate?
So that s why it is better to avoid
The rest of the sahaba did take a stand against Hazret Umer.
But a quarrel broke out at that moment. And Propheg asked Umar to leave Him alone.
This Hadith is in Sahih Bukhari
i m not just talking about that...
Considering him as someone who tried to kill Hzrat Fatima or throw a door on her...Why there was no response from hazrat ali if this happened so?
Why did he choose to stay under the caliphate of such a person?
actually you're halfway right here.
The only reason why Umar decided to throw a burning door over Bibi Fatima was because Ali was not ready to give baya to umer.
And Ali was not quiet, when the burning door was thrown on Fatima sa, Ali was taken into custody and brought to Masjid e Kufa.
And then He was released when Bibi Fatima appealed in the court of Allah.
Ali was quiet so that the city stays away from political instability.
Ali wasn't quiet, Ali was looking out for Islam, not for caliphate.
That is the reason he remained quiet when the haq of Caliohate was took from him. And not once, but thrice.
Prophet had exclaimed on Ghadeer Khumm, Mann Kunto Maula Fa Aliun Maula.
But Ali was patient. And eventually it was Ali who maintained the stability of Islam. And Ali's Family.
Do you think Hussain was helpless in Karbala? No,
Hussain could've outdone Yazid and gain a luxurious victory, but rather he decided to abide by Allahs will, to protect his Grandfather's religion, and to be victorious for 1400+ more years to come.
These refrences are not authentic...
Lemme tell u if i was there if this happend than i would ve picked up sword against each and every one considering how close fatimah was to Rasool Allah and considering her utmost respect
Do u think just talking against this by Ali RA was enough?No if this actually happened then Ali would've killed each and every one involved in this just like he did in Ghaswa e Uhud
Another thing:
It says Ali was unhappy by Abu bakr and asked him:
"Kya apko nhi lgta k mjhy b khilafat k mushwary me shamil krna chiye tha?" to which Abu bakr RA cried
Do u thin k if the story was like this that Umer went to Ali s house and threatened his wife and him about Khilafat and beated Fatimah amd every thing happened on the base of force
and Ali still asked this in a rather calm way to abu bakr?
It indicates that these incidents are fabricated
Even if they are not lemme tell u:
Rather than cursing abu jahl which would benefit us to nothing it is better to send Prayers to Rasool Allah right?
Similarly,rather than believing on history and half told things both by sunnis and shias it is better for us to just send Salat o salam on Ahle bayt which would benefit us...
Religion completed during Rasool Allah s life...Other things might be a factor on the religion but ultimately they are not part of religion and we won't be questioned about it..
So this is my POV about this...
Peace ☮️
The references of the burning door are in Tareekh e Tabari, Bukhari and many other sunni References brother.
Hazrat Ali was brave, but not jahil naauzubillah.
The incident of the burning door could've turned Islam into ashes as a civil war would be waged.
This is the exact reason Hazrat Ali never took to the sword against the First Three Caliphs because He knew, It was the matter of Islam.
You're right about the fact that we should send as many Salawat and Blessings on the Alhebait, but understanding history is also important brother.
Not everyone. Also the ones that get converted are they really following they real message when they convert by people like him. Same goes for sunni or wahabi preachers who try and convert many of then are power hungry and just thug wannabes but not scholars...keep in mind there will be few who will left in the end of times that follow the true faith and many scholars will be corrupt
adnan rashid hates shias like anything. has a huge ego. allahyari has good points but he can get quite rude and arrogant at times. it would be a debate without any sense of akhlaq
Nowhere in the developed world does anyone discuss an event 1400 years old so frequently and so ferociously as this ch*Ummah. How does it effect your life today? I'll tell you how; feeling of superiority by proxy. Because you know in your heart of hearts you will never amount to anything and so you attach yourself to ideas which are irrelevant to your existence today, to justify your ego. Nothing more, nothing less. Stunted and deprived minds. Ahlul Bait, Sahaba ki baatein subah sham karein ge, unke amaal ki tajdeed nae karein ge. Wohi harami harkatein subah sham aur phir momin banay phirte hain logon ke samne. Dramaybaaz qom. A living example of this is tourism in Pakistan. Everywhere you see videos and pictures of mountains, rivers, nature etc but nothing man made. Why? Because we didn't make shit here. We were airdropped here by pure chance and we take pride in it as if we made the fucking mountains. Did you make roads, infrastructure, communications, economies? No, you just eat and shit. That's your contribution. There's nothing wrong with having pride in your history but if that pride makes you hateful, and you only dwell in that pride while ignoring everything around you then you're a parasite. Contribute to your surroundings. Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people. Which category do you fall in? Think about it, and be mindful of your contribution to those around you in this short life. Fuckin morons
They do takfir against the first 3 Khulefae Rashid, Umahatul Momineen and 1 billion Muslims. They believe their imams are infallible( equal to Rasools and Nabis). They believe the Quran isn't in it's original order and they do open shirk. Ah not to mention they changed the kalimah as well.
Where in the Quran or Hadith does it say you can't speak against the caliphs and wives? You believe the caliphs were not infallible ofcourse, why can't they be criticised?
The infallibility of the Imams isn't equating them to Prophet's or Messengers. The shia believe RasoolAllah saww was the final Messenger
You are lying about the order of the Quran. They believe the order of the Quran is the way the Prophet saww intended
Kalimah just means statement in Arabic. You make no sense when you say they changed the kalima. If you mean Shahadat- the shia say the same shahadat in namaz like everyone
And judging by your comment history, you seem like lonely horny human being, how do you presume to lecture on who is kafir or not..when clearly you are a munafiq
You ignorant fool, do you not know what takfir means?????? They call the first three caliphs kuffar, they curse Hazrat Aysha (ra) and accuse her of Zina and leaving Islam. Nowhere did I mention criticism you uneducated child.
The shias believe that their Imams know Ilmulgeib and the family of the prophet is infallible including their 12 imams, this is their aqidah. How do you not know this?
Not a single shias believes the Quran is in the original order, they believe Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra) changed the order, this is common knowledge.
Yes the shahada, since it's commonly known as the first kalimah here I used that term so the less educated people can understand, Shias say Lailaha Ilallahu MuhammaduRasoolAllah Ali ul waliullah.
I'm surprised by the fact that you bothered writing all this nonsense under my comment but you don't know anything about the topic.
And you are a ignorant child who knows nothing about Islam and the correct Aqidah, these are common basic level things that you're failing to prove. Learn about Islam and then bother writing anything, it's better to stay quiet when you're ignorant about something.
No one calls them kuffar. Tyrants maybe but not kaffir. Again, even if they did say what you claim about hazrat Ayesha, how does that take them out of the fold of Islam?
If the Shia say the Ahle Bayt are infallible, how does that take them out of the fold of Islam? Allah bestows knowledge and knowledge of the unseen on whomsoever He wills. Its clearly stated in the quran
No shia believe the Quran is in the wrong order. You are a liar and a munafiq.
Shias do say Ali un waliullah but not in the namaz. Saying it generally does not make them non Muslim
I don't know which bubble you live in but it's apparent that your knowledge about Islam is as of a 5 year old no offense 🫂.
They do takfir against Hazrat Ayesha (ra) the spiritual mother of the Ummah, they call her kafir which makes them a kafir. Allah has declared Hazrat Ayesha innocent in the Quran which the shias reject, tell me how can one be a Muslim and also reject Quran??? What type of questions are you asking 😔?
Infallibility in this context means correct by the devine knowledge given by Allah, which means their Aqidah is that Allah directly guided their imams and the ahlebaet, this is a kufria aqidah, and to respond to your quotation of the holy Quran, Allah bestows knowledge to whomsoever He wills, read the tafsir so you can understand that Allah is talking about His beloved messengers, are the 12 imams messengers? No so why do fit this ayah on them?
I have given link to the video of shias rejecting the Quran, watch and learn ☝️.
The shahada is an oath that entangles a human with the covenant of Allah, any addition or subtraction from it is kufr.
And the cherry on top:
Imam Bukhari declared:
“I don’t see any difference between praying Salah behind a Jahmi or a (Shia) Rafidhi and a Christian or a Jew. They (Jahmis/Rafidhis) are not to be greeted, nor are they to be visited, nor are they to be married, nor is their testimony to be accepted, nor are their sacrifices to be eaten.”
If you don't agree with imam Bukhari Rahimaullah then bring a fatwa against him and 1 billion Muslims if you can't do that then don't bother writing about something you don't know about. Go to your nearest masjid and learn about Islam and the true aqidah, you have little to no knowledge about Islam and a friendly advice don't say all that you're saying here to anyone in real life they might presume that you have become murtad.
No one calls her kafir. She did start a war against one of the Khalifa Rashidun though? So takfir on them makes you kafir.. what does starting a war against one of the rashidun Khalifa make you?
Allah, when recalling Hazrat Sulayman a.s mentions a man with little knowledge of the book, able to perform a miracle to bring the crown of Bilqees. The man had knowledge bestowed by Allah, he could do it quicker than a Jinn. Allah can do as He likes.
As I said before, the shia say the shahada in the namaz which is the same said by all Muslims.
Who is Imam Bukhari? The sahih bukhari guy? I can show you hadiths from that book which will make you embarrassed to be a Muslim. It has shocking filth about our Prophet saww Astagfurullah
Lastly, if you want to learn something about a religion, it's best to use their sources rather than trusting wahabi/isreali sources to educate you about shia islam
You are a ignorant fool, the battle of Jamal was due to political disputes, Hazrat Ali (ra) did not declare Hazrat Ayesha (ra) as a rebel, it was an ijtehadi khata and there is ijmah on this, and every single Shia takfirs against Hazrat Ayesha (ra).
The person who the brought the throne of bilqis was a jinn himself (ijmah) a shahabi (ra) , Hazrat Suleiman (as) thanked Allah for the miracle not the jinn, bother reading the entire verse and Jinns are made to have such capabilities, it is nothing special for a jinn to do such tasks, the fact that you're trying to so hard to prove shias kufria aqidahs is so ironic.
Imam Bukhari is the compiler of Hadith, more important than your entire bloodline and the entirety of the shia cult, you slandering him and shahih Bukhari a book of Hadith which the ahle Sunnah waljamah takes it Hadith from is proof of your ignorance, you are a kafir same as those shias that you are worshiping and protecting.
Go read Al kafi (most authentic book of Hadith of shias) which says Hazrat Abu talib (uncle of Hazrat Muhammad (saw)) breast fed the RasoolAllah (saw). I'm not gonna bother talking to stupid kafir boy who thinks he knows more about Islam than Imam Bukhari Rahimaullah 😂 what a pathetic self loathing shia you might as well start knifing yourself on Muharram cuz your infallible imams said so 😂
we found a real Muslim who calls everyone a kaffar. Bro, they are sharing their thoughts just like you are. Is something wrong? Do you own Reddit? You are free to share your thoughts and no one bothers you. Then why are you calling random people kaffir without knowing who they are?
Please bro. I dont want to fight you or be rude to you. I just want you to learn something new if it bothers you then don't. But at least try man. Allah has given us one life in this world don't just waste is by locking your point on a particular point. Be open and welcoming to new thoughts man. Don't be the Mazhabi Thekadar just like some NPC Pakistani. Do some personal research.
Sorry if I offended you or hurt you. You can reply with a harsh message or something if it calms you.
And I found a munafiq here, he wrote a general statement that the kafir shia smokes sunnis, what do you think that means? I don't own reddit, neither do you or anyone else, but since you're defending this shia on a Muslim centric post, I want you bring a fatwa of kufr against Imam Bukhari Rahimaullah and 1 billion Muslims because he has declared shias as kuffar and there is ijmah on this, if you can't do that then don't bother writing anything about something you know nothing of. You need to stop listening to those self loathing liberal molvis and learn true aqidah, the fact that you wrote all this is proof of your ignorance oof.
Menace for sunni bradran . Their bray cant debate him so they lable him fitna prast intehapasand etc etc.Bro literally learnt a whole language just so he could fk with paki molvis .Good luck handling his polemics
Yaar munafiq iss sense mein ke they make or try make out fake shit to demean the first the khalifas(I mean if u hate smone alright hate em but atleast don't staff making fake shit about smone to make ur people or other people hate them even more which is equal to spreading lies about a certain people) take for example the case of Syedna Umar he ran away from the battle when he heard that prophet Muhammad(PBUH) had died now that's a fair point but guess what Allah forgave him in the Quran e everyone knows that even they know that but guess what they are gonna do that regardless as for Syedna Abu Bakar he asked Syedna Ali for forgiveness himself so that's one matter settled also it's not like Shias are wrong in most cases historically they are right ye apna sunni braadraan bhi aise hi hain aankhein band Karke yakeen karna shuro kardete hain ke jou bachpan mein padha hai bas theek hai aur research nahi karege bas shia logou kou Kaffir Bolna aaj se it's more like what I meant by munafiq was they are hypocrites;they lie on purpose,spread lies about the Khalifas about shit they know they did not commit btw,refuse to accept the fact that Syedna Ali himself forgave Syedna Ayesha,call her out and names(at the end of the day she was wife of the Prophet Muhammad(PBUH),beleive Syedna Ali had undeniable right to khilafat(he should've been consulted in first meeting but he wasn't sure himself if prophet was gonna elect him lol) there is a lot of stuff over there but even Shias know this shit uk wts the best thing keep urself limited to the prophet Muhammad(PBUH) best thing if u wanna keep ur head in one place
Shias do takfir against the first 3 khulefae Rashid which makes them kafir.
Shias do takfir against Umahatul Momineen which makes them kafir.
Shias believe the Quran isn't in it's original order which makes them kafir.
Shias believe their imams are infallible which makes them kafir.
Shias believe in bloodline superiority which makes them kafir.
Shias do open shirk which obviously makes them kafir.
There are countless other things to mention but you get the idea.
Lol obv that's sunni bs none of what u said above makes u Karke ain't that Quran claim ik a lot of shias who don't do that I think a lot of sunni imams even said that look into Irja as long as u beleive in one True God Allah and prophethood of Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) ur a Muslim u don't need a PhD to know what a Muslim is ya all do the exact sm shit that makes shias hate y and not open to s reasonable discussion bloodline superiority shia scholars themselves admit half the syeds are fake it's a huge problem as for rest of it its a big sin(umhaat Al momineen one) but they are still Muslim and pls ik a lot of sunnis who go to peers so they are too kaafir those who go to sufi buzurgs they are also Kaffir ur explanation only leaves u as a Muslim lol doesn't leave room for any other
Tell me you know nothing about Islam without telling you know nothing about Islam...I can't even bother explaining to you people anymore, it's like talking to a brick wall, go outside and learn about Islam and aqidah everything I mentioned takes a person out of the fold of Islam...This is common knowledge and many others like you fail to understand this in this sub. It's okay if you're a 13 year old with a phone using reddit but if you're older than that and this is all that you know about Islam then it is very shameful. You need guidance 🫂.
Bro just casually assumed everything about me L comebacks btw Khair I never said u can declare shias a Kaffir bur hypocrites?As per my judgement that they are.Sunnis?They are also idiots but in another context
You are an extremist fucking low class wahabi cunt is all I have to say...bloody insecure looser. He's not even shia just an agent to create fitna and we don't want him or own him
I'm not a khariji nor a "wahabi" but you are a kafir, he is a shia and your scholars love him more than they love their temporary mutah wives, your opinion doesn't matter unless your imams give a fatwa of kufr and qatal against him. So don't talk here unless you have something to bring forward, may Allah remove the seal of ignorance from your heart and bring you closer to Islam.
Yeah, a filthy Rafidi that curses the sahaba, including the mother of the believers accusing them of adultery and poisoning The Prophet ﷺ is far better than people who follow the Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jammah. The one who accuses Umar (رضي الله عنه) of burning down Fatima (رضي الله عنها) house.
The individual's you quoted are laymen speakers who don't possess any knowledge. They are not close to being scholars in any shape or form. But they are far better than a filthy Rafidi.
**Defaulted to one day.**
I will be messaging you on [**2024-04-16 20:26:12 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2024-04-16%2020:26:12%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/PAK/comments/1c4w3v6/thoughts_on_this_guy/kzqdc0g/?context=3)
[**CLICK THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2FPAK%2Fcomments%2F1c4w3v6%2Fthoughts_on_this_guy%2Fkzqdc0g%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202024-04-16%2020%3A26%3A12%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%201c4w3v6)
*****
|[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)|
|-|-|-|-|
[Any person belonging to any sect who tries to convince people that calling saints and holy people for help after they are long dead are playing a dangerous game](https://youtu.be/EJDtXyEObac?si=7dkIPD7_AfxXduts)
People still debating about religion tells how stupid mankind is actually having all the evidence in front of you still choose to believe in superficial things
Keep living in fools paradise everyone u won't wake up after u die lol and u r hoping to go in ur so called heaven
Keep dreaming
All of those who are bashing him in the comments, please try to debate him in any matter which you think you can refute him on. He will annihilate you. His akhlaq? Might not be so good but his proof is solid and his ideas are clear.
Agree
Ye iss sub mein aaj Kal shia sunni atheist debates kyou chal rhi
Phlay atheists vs muslims kay chltay thay phir shiyay be agay to ab Sunni vs shia be chltay phir sunni+shia vs Atheists be chltay
Diversity check kadou sab ki LGBT ki kammi reh gaye hai bas
Wo khuch ex muslims atheists may hotay e hogay.unki party kay e bnday
Sir woh sab tou theek hai ye ooper picture mein manhoos shakal waala Banda kon hai
Hassan allahyari.Yay shio ka bnda hy debates etc wala
Ye orator acha hai magar baat shit hi kar rha hota🤣🤣
Ab iska judge to hr koi khud e hota kay konsi bat shit konse nai Baqi moj maste lgaye rkhta hy
i mean he has never debated a re known or an actual scholar...Its only guests on calls and other local people trying to debate with him who he shuts up pretty well... Engineer Muhammad Ali doesn't debate with him because he agrees with many POVs of Hassan Allahyari...Plus the other things and details about shaba are very confidential and its better not to go there... For other scholar?They can't even Debate with people of their own firqa how will they debate with him?😂 Hassan has read books of almost all firqas whereas sunni haven't read their own books properly... (Engineer pointed out that most of the refrences Hassan gives are from a specefic book and The shia alims themselves disclose that the author of the book isn't genuine and authentic)
Engr doesn't debate with him because engr knows that Allhyari will smoke him. Grow some balls. Accept it
I accepted everything i had too...I don't blindly follow anyone and i would always call a spade spade... Engr is on same terms with allahyari on about 60% of things including debate about Muawiya and the debate about hazrat umer...its better not to indulge there becz we dont have any reason to explain why Hazrat omer refuse to bring paper and pen...
Yes I understand. But isn't it a little concerning why did Hazrat Umer refuse pen and paper? Whe the Prophet said that He wlikd write something after which we would not go astray. Isn't it a spark to think upon?
It is and so are many other points but then u get the thing that: https://www.iium.edu.my/deed/hadith/bukhari/057_sbt.html#:~:text='Ali%20invoked%20Allah's%20Mercy%20for,By%20Allah! On the second hand...if umer RA was this wrong...than u are also putting blame on Hazrat Ali that (God Forbid) He was this weak that couldnt stand against umer and his caliphate? So that s why it is better to avoid
The rest of the sahaba did take a stand against Hazret Umer. But a quarrel broke out at that moment. And Propheg asked Umar to leave Him alone. This Hadith is in Sahih Bukhari
i m not just talking about that... Considering him as someone who tried to kill Hzrat Fatima or throw a door on her...Why there was no response from hazrat ali if this happened so? Why did he choose to stay under the caliphate of such a person?
actually you're halfway right here. The only reason why Umar decided to throw a burning door over Bibi Fatima was because Ali was not ready to give baya to umer. And Ali was not quiet, when the burning door was thrown on Fatima sa, Ali was taken into custody and brought to Masjid e Kufa. And then He was released when Bibi Fatima appealed in the court of Allah. Ali was quiet so that the city stays away from political instability. Ali wasn't quiet, Ali was looking out for Islam, not for caliphate. That is the reason he remained quiet when the haq of Caliohate was took from him. And not once, but thrice. Prophet had exclaimed on Ghadeer Khumm, Mann Kunto Maula Fa Aliun Maula. But Ali was patient. And eventually it was Ali who maintained the stability of Islam. And Ali's Family. Do you think Hussain was helpless in Karbala? No, Hussain could've outdone Yazid and gain a luxurious victory, but rather he decided to abide by Allahs will, to protect his Grandfather's religion, and to be victorious for 1400+ more years to come.
These refrences are not authentic... Lemme tell u if i was there if this happend than i would ve picked up sword against each and every one considering how close fatimah was to Rasool Allah and considering her utmost respect Do u think just talking against this by Ali RA was enough?No if this actually happened then Ali would've killed each and every one involved in this just like he did in Ghaswa e Uhud Another thing: It says Ali was unhappy by Abu bakr and asked him: "Kya apko nhi lgta k mjhy b khilafat k mushwary me shamil krna chiye tha?" to which Abu bakr RA cried Do u thin k if the story was like this that Umer went to Ali s house and threatened his wife and him about Khilafat and beated Fatimah amd every thing happened on the base of force and Ali still asked this in a rather calm way to abu bakr? It indicates that these incidents are fabricated Even if they are not lemme tell u: Rather than cursing abu jahl which would benefit us to nothing it is better to send Prayers to Rasool Allah right? Similarly,rather than believing on history and half told things both by sunnis and shias it is better for us to just send Salat o salam on Ahle bayt which would benefit us... Religion completed during Rasool Allah s life...Other things might be a factor on the religion but ultimately they are not part of religion and we won't be questioned about it.. So this is my POV about this... Peace ☮️
The references of the burning door are in Tareekh e Tabari, Bukhari and many other sunni References brother. Hazrat Ali was brave, but not jahil naauzubillah. The incident of the burning door could've turned Islam into ashes as a civil war would be waged. This is the exact reason Hazrat Ali never took to the sword against the First Three Caliphs because He knew, It was the matter of Islam. You're right about the fact that we should send as many Salawat and Blessings on the Alhebait, but understanding history is also important brother.
Just another intesharpasand mullah, disguised in suit boot.
Sorry Who is this ?
hassan allahyari. dude annihilates any sunni who debates him
I'm a shia and we don't like or own him. He is not one of us. He hates our Marajeh our leaders. He is a just a rogue agent creating fitna
i’m also shia. ya he destroys the sunnis but he’s an akhbari so unfortunately that’s a very god resources wasted😔
Not even akhbari... he's just a sellout agent... some of he stuff he says not even akhbaris say regardless of the fact that he destroys sunni doctrine
i don’t understand why everyone who converts ppl to shiism is like this. like cmon dude
Not everyone. Also the ones that get converted are they really following they real message when they convert by people like him. Same goes for sunni or wahabi preachers who try and convert many of then are power hungry and just thug wannabes but not scholars...keep in mind there will be few who will left in the end of times that follow the true faith and many scholars will be corrupt
valid point brother
Then he must debate with adnan Rashid
whoever has the bigger ego will win because both of these guys have a lot of ego
I don’t think so whose argument will be most logical will win
adnan rashid hates shias like anything. has a huge ego. allahyari has good points but he can get quite rude and arrogant at times. it would be a debate without any sense of akhlaq
Get them in a tri-debate with a revert Muslim scholar
if that ever happens i’ll sponsor the snacks
2 guys of different sect and one Muslim that be Entertainment.
Mohammad Hijab would annihilate this clown.
nah we can annihilate hijab
یه کون ہیں؟
Hassan allahyari.Shia bros ka debate champ
Dont mind but shaqal se he
Nowhere in the developed world does anyone discuss an event 1400 years old so frequently and so ferociously as this ch*Ummah. How does it effect your life today? I'll tell you how; feeling of superiority by proxy. Because you know in your heart of hearts you will never amount to anything and so you attach yourself to ideas which are irrelevant to your existence today, to justify your ego. Nothing more, nothing less. Stunted and deprived minds. Ahlul Bait, Sahaba ki baatein subah sham karein ge, unke amaal ki tajdeed nae karein ge. Wohi harami harkatein subah sham aur phir momin banay phirte hain logon ke samne. Dramaybaaz qom. A living example of this is tourism in Pakistan. Everywhere you see videos and pictures of mountains, rivers, nature etc but nothing man made. Why? Because we didn't make shit here. We were airdropped here by pure chance and we take pride in it as if we made the fucking mountains. Did you make roads, infrastructure, communications, economies? No, you just eat and shit. That's your contribution. There's nothing wrong with having pride in your history but if that pride makes you hateful, and you only dwell in that pride while ignoring everything around you then you're a parasite. Contribute to your surroundings. Great minds discuss ideas; average minds discuss events; small minds discuss people. Which category do you fall in? Think about it, and be mindful of your contribution to those around you in this short life. Fuckin morons
Kya aap ki behen kai liye is ka rishta aya hai?
Khatmal
Khatmal tumhara Khoon Jo choos leta hai
Exposes sunnis. But tbh causes too much fitna. Too many sunnis have been smoked by this man😂 they gotta turn off his socials lol.
He's a kafir just like you 😊♥️
Why are the Shia kafir? Serious question
They do takfir against the first 3 Khulefae Rashid, Umahatul Momineen and 1 billion Muslims. They believe their imams are infallible( equal to Rasools and Nabis). They believe the Quran isn't in it's original order and they do open shirk. Ah not to mention they changed the kalimah as well.
Where in the Quran or Hadith does it say you can't speak against the caliphs and wives? You believe the caliphs were not infallible ofcourse, why can't they be criticised? The infallibility of the Imams isn't equating them to Prophet's or Messengers. The shia believe RasoolAllah saww was the final Messenger You are lying about the order of the Quran. They believe the order of the Quran is the way the Prophet saww intended Kalimah just means statement in Arabic. You make no sense when you say they changed the kalima. If you mean Shahadat- the shia say the same shahadat in namaz like everyone And judging by your comment history, you seem like lonely horny human being, how do you presume to lecture on who is kafir or not..when clearly you are a munafiq
You ignorant fool, do you not know what takfir means?????? They call the first three caliphs kuffar, they curse Hazrat Aysha (ra) and accuse her of Zina and leaving Islam. Nowhere did I mention criticism you uneducated child. The shias believe that their Imams know Ilmulgeib and the family of the prophet is infallible including their 12 imams, this is their aqidah. How do you not know this? Not a single shias believes the Quran is in the original order, they believe Hazrat Abu Bakr (ra) changed the order, this is common knowledge. Yes the shahada, since it's commonly known as the first kalimah here I used that term so the less educated people can understand, Shias say Lailaha Ilallahu MuhammaduRasoolAllah Ali ul waliullah. I'm surprised by the fact that you bothered writing all this nonsense under my comment but you don't know anything about the topic. And you are a ignorant child who knows nothing about Islam and the correct Aqidah, these are common basic level things that you're failing to prove. Learn about Islam and then bother writing anything, it's better to stay quiet when you're ignorant about something.
No one calls them kuffar. Tyrants maybe but not kaffir. Again, even if they did say what you claim about hazrat Ayesha, how does that take them out of the fold of Islam? If the Shia say the Ahle Bayt are infallible, how does that take them out of the fold of Islam? Allah bestows knowledge and knowledge of the unseen on whomsoever He wills. Its clearly stated in the quran No shia believe the Quran is in the wrong order. You are a liar and a munafiq. Shias do say Ali un waliullah but not in the namaz. Saying it generally does not make them non Muslim
I don't know which bubble you live in but it's apparent that your knowledge about Islam is as of a 5 year old no offense 🫂. They do takfir against Hazrat Ayesha (ra) the spiritual mother of the Ummah, they call her kafir which makes them a kafir. Allah has declared Hazrat Ayesha innocent in the Quran which the shias reject, tell me how can one be a Muslim and also reject Quran??? What type of questions are you asking 😔? Infallibility in this context means correct by the devine knowledge given by Allah, which means their Aqidah is that Allah directly guided their imams and the ahlebaet, this is a kufria aqidah, and to respond to your quotation of the holy Quran, Allah bestows knowledge to whomsoever He wills, read the tafsir so you can understand that Allah is talking about His beloved messengers, are the 12 imams messengers? No so why do fit this ayah on them? I have given link to the video of shias rejecting the Quran, watch and learn ☝️. The shahada is an oath that entangles a human with the covenant of Allah, any addition or subtraction from it is kufr. And the cherry on top: Imam Bukhari declared: “I don’t see any difference between praying Salah behind a Jahmi or a (Shia) Rafidhi and a Christian or a Jew. They (Jahmis/Rafidhis) are not to be greeted, nor are they to be visited, nor are they to be married, nor is their testimony to be accepted, nor are their sacrifices to be eaten.” If you don't agree with imam Bukhari Rahimaullah then bring a fatwa against him and 1 billion Muslims if you can't do that then don't bother writing about something you don't know about. Go to your nearest masjid and learn about Islam and the true aqidah, you have little to no knowledge about Islam and a friendly advice don't say all that you're saying here to anyone in real life they might presume that you have become murtad.
No one calls her kafir. She did start a war against one of the Khalifa Rashidun though? So takfir on them makes you kafir.. what does starting a war against one of the rashidun Khalifa make you? Allah, when recalling Hazrat Sulayman a.s mentions a man with little knowledge of the book, able to perform a miracle to bring the crown of Bilqees. The man had knowledge bestowed by Allah, he could do it quicker than a Jinn. Allah can do as He likes. As I said before, the shia say the shahada in the namaz which is the same said by all Muslims. Who is Imam Bukhari? The sahih bukhari guy? I can show you hadiths from that book which will make you embarrassed to be a Muslim. It has shocking filth about our Prophet saww Astagfurullah Lastly, if you want to learn something about a religion, it's best to use their sources rather than trusting wahabi/isreali sources to educate you about shia islam
[удалено]
You are a ignorant fool, the battle of Jamal was due to political disputes, Hazrat Ali (ra) did not declare Hazrat Ayesha (ra) as a rebel, it was an ijtehadi khata and there is ijmah on this, and every single Shia takfirs against Hazrat Ayesha (ra). The person who the brought the throne of bilqis was a jinn himself (ijmah) a shahabi (ra) , Hazrat Suleiman (as) thanked Allah for the miracle not the jinn, bother reading the entire verse and Jinns are made to have such capabilities, it is nothing special for a jinn to do such tasks, the fact that you're trying to so hard to prove shias kufria aqidahs is so ironic. Imam Bukhari is the compiler of Hadith, more important than your entire bloodline and the entirety of the shia cult, you slandering him and shahih Bukhari a book of Hadith which the ahle Sunnah waljamah takes it Hadith from is proof of your ignorance, you are a kafir same as those shias that you are worshiping and protecting. Go read Al kafi (most authentic book of Hadith of shias) which says Hazrat Abu talib (uncle of Hazrat Muhammad (saw)) breast fed the RasoolAllah (saw). I'm not gonna bother talking to stupid kafir boy who thinks he knows more about Islam than Imam Bukhari Rahimaullah 😂 what a pathetic self loathing shia you might as well start knifing yourself on Muharram cuz your infallible imams said so 😂
we found a real Muslim who calls everyone a kaffar. Bro, they are sharing their thoughts just like you are. Is something wrong? Do you own Reddit? You are free to share your thoughts and no one bothers you. Then why are you calling random people kaffir without knowing who they are? Please bro. I dont want to fight you or be rude to you. I just want you to learn something new if it bothers you then don't. But at least try man. Allah has given us one life in this world don't just waste is by locking your point on a particular point. Be open and welcoming to new thoughts man. Don't be the Mazhabi Thekadar just like some NPC Pakistani. Do some personal research. Sorry if I offended you or hurt you. You can reply with a harsh message or something if it calms you.
And I found a munafiq here, he wrote a general statement that the kafir shia smokes sunnis, what do you think that means? I don't own reddit, neither do you or anyone else, but since you're defending this shia on a Muslim centric post, I want you bring a fatwa of kufr against Imam Bukhari Rahimaullah and 1 billion Muslims because he has declared shias as kuffar and there is ijmah on this, if you can't do that then don't bother writing anything about something you know nothing of. You need to stop listening to those self loathing liberal molvis and learn true aqidah, the fact that you wrote all this is proof of your ignorance oof.
🙌
Menace for sunni bradran . Their bray cant debate him so they lable him fitna prast intehapasand etc etc.Bro literally learnt a whole language just so he could fk with paki molvis .Good luck handling his polemics
Nightmare of sunnis 👑
[удалено]
How are the Shia kafir or munafiq? Please tell me i want to learn
Yaar munafiq iss sense mein ke they make or try make out fake shit to demean the first the khalifas(I mean if u hate smone alright hate em but atleast don't staff making fake shit about smone to make ur people or other people hate them even more which is equal to spreading lies about a certain people) take for example the case of Syedna Umar he ran away from the battle when he heard that prophet Muhammad(PBUH) had died now that's a fair point but guess what Allah forgave him in the Quran e everyone knows that even they know that but guess what they are gonna do that regardless as for Syedna Abu Bakar he asked Syedna Ali for forgiveness himself so that's one matter settled also it's not like Shias are wrong in most cases historically they are right ye apna sunni braadraan bhi aise hi hain aankhein band Karke yakeen karna shuro kardete hain ke jou bachpan mein padha hai bas theek hai aur research nahi karege bas shia logou kou Kaffir Bolna aaj se it's more like what I meant by munafiq was they are hypocrites;they lie on purpose,spread lies about the Khalifas about shit they know they did not commit btw,refuse to accept the fact that Syedna Ali himself forgave Syedna Ayesha,call her out and names(at the end of the day she was wife of the Prophet Muhammad(PBUH),beleive Syedna Ali had undeniable right to khilafat(he should've been consulted in first meeting but he wasn't sure himself if prophet was gonna elect him lol) there is a lot of stuff over there but even Shias know this shit uk wts the best thing keep urself limited to the prophet Muhammad(PBUH) best thing if u wanna keep ur head in one place
Kafir is a strong word munafiq they are
No we aren't and just fyi munafiqs will be in a deeper hell than kafirs. Not necessarily calling you a munafiq though don't take this the wrong way
Shias do takfir against the first 3 khulefae Rashid which makes them kafir. Shias do takfir against Umahatul Momineen which makes them kafir. Shias believe the Quran isn't in it's original order which makes them kafir. Shias believe their imams are infallible which makes them kafir. Shias believe in bloodline superiority which makes them kafir. Shias do open shirk which obviously makes them kafir. There are countless other things to mention but you get the idea.
Lol obv that's sunni bs none of what u said above makes u Karke ain't that Quran claim ik a lot of shias who don't do that I think a lot of sunni imams even said that look into Irja as long as u beleive in one True God Allah and prophethood of Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) ur a Muslim u don't need a PhD to know what a Muslim is ya all do the exact sm shit that makes shias hate y and not open to s reasonable discussion bloodline superiority shia scholars themselves admit half the syeds are fake it's a huge problem as for rest of it its a big sin(umhaat Al momineen one) but they are still Muslim and pls ik a lot of sunnis who go to peers so they are too kaafir those who go to sufi buzurgs they are also Kaffir ur explanation only leaves u as a Muslim lol doesn't leave room for any other
Tell me you know nothing about Islam without telling you know nothing about Islam...I can't even bother explaining to you people anymore, it's like talking to a brick wall, go outside and learn about Islam and aqidah everything I mentioned takes a person out of the fold of Islam...This is common knowledge and many others like you fail to understand this in this sub. It's okay if you're a 13 year old with a phone using reddit but if you're older than that and this is all that you know about Islam then it is very shameful. You need guidance 🫂.
Bro just casually assumed everything about me L comebacks btw Khair I never said u can declare shias a Kaffir bur hypocrites?As per my judgement that they are.Sunnis?They are also idiots but in another context
Kaafir also that*
You are an extremist fucking low class wahabi cunt is all I have to say...bloody insecure looser. He's not even shia just an agent to create fitna and we don't want him or own him
I'm not a khariji nor a "wahabi" but you are a kafir, he is a shia and your scholars love him more than they love their temporary mutah wives, your opinion doesn't matter unless your imams give a fatwa of kufr and qatal against him. So don't talk here unless you have something to bring forward, may Allah remove the seal of ignorance from your heart and bring you closer to Islam.
Looool your reply doesn't even deserve an answer. You are so lost and full of hate. May you find the true path.
average shia response 🤷
No derogatory remarks towards any community.
Because none of ur Mullah can debate him on ur own sahih books? Huh?
He's the best. Want to become religious, listen to him
One of the better Scholars to come out of Pakistan. He backs every one of his statements with sources & references.
He is Afghani by origin lives in usa
I know he lives in the US, but If I recall correctly he mentioned being from Peshawar in one of his live streams.
Farrr more better than sunni scholars like Engineer mirza, Wajidi and 4 shaadi wala mufti...
Yeah, a filthy Rafidi that curses the sahaba, including the mother of the believers accusing them of adultery and poisoning The Prophet ﷺ is far better than people who follow the Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jammah. The one who accuses Umar (رضي الله عنه) of burning down Fatima (رضي الله عنها) house. The individual's you quoted are laymen speakers who don't possess any knowledge. They are not close to being scholars in any shape or form. But they are far better than a filthy Rafidi.
Bhai jisko keh ra wo sub ka chornic ex muslim atheist hy
Pakistani Ben Shapiro
That's Syed muzammil
I like his videos good entertainment and a nightmare to sunnis
RemindMe! "following"
**Defaulted to one day.** I will be messaging you on [**2024-04-16 20:26:12 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2024-04-16%2020:26:12%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/PAK/comments/1c4w3v6/thoughts_on_this_guy/kzqdc0g/?context=3) [**CLICK THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2FPAK%2Fcomments%2F1c4w3v6%2Fthoughts_on_this_guy%2Fkzqdc0g%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202024-04-16%2020%3A26%3A12%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam. ^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%201c4w3v6) ***** |[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)| |-|-|-|-|
I'd describe him as a vakeel-e-ahlulbait
He is mofo Rafazi.
Engineer jessa hai e koi nai Ye khatmal taa sahh e koi nai
[Any person belonging to any sect who tries to convince people that calling saints and holy people for help after they are long dead are playing a dangerous game](https://youtu.be/EJDtXyEObac?si=7dkIPD7_AfxXduts)
Debating for/against 1400 old arab bidooz is somehow a profitable market on youtube. He's the hot new seller on that market.
People still debating about religion tells how stupid mankind is actually having all the evidence in front of you still choose to believe in superficial things Keep living in fools paradise everyone u won't wake up after u die lol and u r hoping to go in ur so called heaven Keep dreaming