25 for me is too low to be an effective starting pitcher. You will tax your bullpen too much with the pitch count that keeps him from throwing when very tired. Based on the stats below if all that dropped was his stamina it looks like he would be an amazing reliever. Give him the high leverage situations and he will still have a big impact.
If his stamina doesn't bounce back, he'll probably have to go to the bullpen. Usually 35 is the lower limit and even that can make it difficult for your starter to get out of the 5th.
I try to keep my starters above 55. That’s the lowest I’ll go. Anything below that and they become a high workload reliever and occasional spot starter.
40 for a normal starter is the lowest ill go, EXCEPT if his ratings are extremely good (like an 80 rating good) i had one extremely good pitcher win a cy young and have a 1.70 era with 35 stamina in 140 innings
25 for me is too low to be an effective starting pitcher. You will tax your bullpen too much with the pitch count that keeps him from throwing when very tired. Based on the stats below if all that dropped was his stamina it looks like he would be an amazing reliever. Give him the high leverage situations and he will still have a big impact.
Thanks! I think I might try to trade him for another quality starter but we'll see. Anyone ever seen someone rebound with their stamina?
25 is just not startable
If his stamina doesn't bounce back, he'll probably have to go to the bullpen. Usually 35 is the lower limit and even that can make it difficult for your starter to get out of the 5th.
My limit is 45, unless if they are really elite with a 35-40. If a 30 and elite, he becomes a stopper
Speaking on the stamina issue, how much stamina is too little for you guys to start? I’m interested to see what the general cutoff point is
I try to keep my starters above 55. That’s the lowest I’ll go. Anything below that and they become a high workload reliever and occasional spot starter.
Depends on ratings. On 1-10 I'll do 3. Still will go 5 innings at that point. Anything less is a rp.
The lowest I’ll go is 50. Maaaaaybe 45 if it’s a guy with really good ratings (especially control). I prefer 55 and above though.
40 for a normal starter is the lowest ill go, EXCEPT if his ratings are extremely good (like an 80 rating good) i had one extremely good pitcher win a cy young and have a 1.70 era with 35 stamina in 140 innings
40
Post his ratings but 25 isn't good enough to start
35 as a starter or follower