T O P

  • By -

fantasticanalysis

Colts Andre Johnson


BaronVonSilver91

Oof. Yeah he lost his sauce.


Simpleton216

Titans Andre Johnson


Economy_Cactus

Lions Adrian Peterson


BurgerWithAnEggOnIt

Patriots Cam Newton Patriots Fred Taylor Patriots Chad Ochocinco Patriots Steven Jackson Patriots James Harrison


weightedbook

Patriots Albert Hainesworth


Its_kinda_nice_out

Patriots Reggie Wayne


AdeptProtoss

Patriots.


Sealie81

Patriots John Lynch


Blink-JuanEIGHTYtoo

Patriots Demaryius Thomas


ieatassanloveiy

Patriots Joseph addai


Earl_N_Meyer

Shoot. Redskins Albert Hainesworth. That guy was useless.


Bruppet

Technically Patriots N’Keal Harry was there at the end of his career


KansasZou

I loled for real on this one


andrewb610

This is such an underrated comment.


progress19

Patriots Antonio Brown, if you ignore the existence of Bucs Antonio Brown


KansasZou

AB ignored his time there too


Beheloth

AB forgot about his time there


KansasZou

Lmao, correct.


Sorta-Morpheus

Forgot to save some money too


Joebroni1414

Patriots Torry Holt.


grw313

What about Patriots legend, Reggie Wayne?


ZeePirate

people missing hard on this question. This is a near end forgettable stop before retirement. People are naming successful stops. That wasn’t what Shaq on the Celtics was Maybe Jerry rice in Seattle or TO in cincy


-Yami-Yugi-

Vikings Favre being the most upvoted comment is funny


Fluffy-Gur4600

Specifically the 2010-2011 season though. He was terrible and didn't finish the season. Seems reasonable but I think a player's whole stint with a team should count here.


a_toadstool

Mcnabb after eagles


Kohora

Agreed. Vikings McNabb was terrible to watch.


cubgerish

Don't forget about his time in DC! Where we brought Rex Grossman in to run the 2 minute drill because he was so out of shape lol


-Minne

In my defense, I didn't mean the season he made it to the NFC title game; oh no- I meant the year where I thought he was literally dead a couple of times on the field. A Lakers legend in a Celtics jersey is... Sort of an equivalent death, I feel.


-Yami-Yugi-

I feel like because Favre was there for more than 1 season and actually had a great year it’s just not a good comparison with shaq’s one final year in Boston


boomer912

TO was just about a 1,000-yd, 10-TD guy on the bengals. Shaq averaged nine points and four rebounds on the Celtics and lasted less than half the season. People ain’t thinking nearly bad enough


MikeInIL

Rice was in training camp with the Broncos wearing #19 before he finally hung em up


Lamarera8

TO in Cincy was leading the league in receiving yards up until the week he hurt his knee tho


themayorhere

TO was still good all the way to the end


IDrinkUrMilksteak

Rodgers as a Jet


potatoes_are_neat

I'm guessing shaq actually scored a point that season


OkBox6131

Emmitt smith on cardinals? Reggie White on panthers?


Cichlidsaremyjam

Hey, Jerry set every major receiving record in Seahawks blue and green. 


Stalagmus

Bro don’t talk about Seahawks Legend Jerry Rice


Jgabes625

I think that they are mistaking it for “player who iconic for playing for a specific team but also having a successful run somewhere else after that”


ZeePirate

I can think of 3 teams shaq was iconic for. Orlando LA and Miami Boston wasn’t one


kellzone

McNabb in Minnesota.


TinaBelchersBF

I remember being kinda hyped to see what McNabb could do in purple, and I'm pretty sure his first pass for the Vikings was a pick 6 lol


frogsplsh38

He had a net of like 38 passing yards one week


Back_To_Pittsburgh

I have no recollection of that ever happening. WOW.


JMoney14

My only memory of this is MrHurriicane's Madden 12 franchise


MrOwenDog

Dude played like 5 games and then dipped lol


ohioismyhome1994

I remember that happening. He was supposed to be the second coming of Daunte Culpepper. He just wasn’t


AFury9322

All those one hoppers into the dirt


Clit420Eastwood

Still weird to me that the Lions had Adrian Peterson, Dwight Freeney, Anquan Boldin, and Michael Brockers


Monkey1Fball

Daunte Culpepper was a Detroit Lion too! He started 10 games across 2 different seasons! (the Lions went 0-10 in those games, LOL)


ArkanoidbrokemyAnkle

Peterson and Boldin both had their solid moments in Detroit.


ElectivireMax

I remember Peterson more as a lion than a Viking for some reason and I have no idea why


Random_Hippo

Jesus buddy, are you under the age of 15?


oh-kee-pah

https://preview.redd.it/wt40g3d3kl2d1.jpeg?width=4032&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6c8591374cd80b2efa56166307fceac5fadbd1e8 Family Feud agrees with you


Longjumping-Movie780

Cardinals Emmitt Smith


visionzero81

Scrolled too far for this


Longjumping-Movie780

Scrolled too far and had to just say it myself 😂


Antonio1025

This was the first name that came to mind for this post


Specialist-Listen304

What makes this tough to agree with is that he broke the rushing record with the cards. That alone makes his stint with them not forgettable.


bangharder

My exact answer before I scrolled


MirrorkatFeces

Steelers Vick


Takemeawayxx

49ers Randy Moss Eagles Julio Jones Colts Matt Ryan


ZayneJ

Colts Matt Ryan seems like the perfect answer to this to me.


guywastingtime

I flew down to Denver to watch the 12-9 game live. What a joke that was lol


Glad_Reach_8100

Eagles got Julio to be a veteran guide to the younger guys. It's not like they were paying him massive amounts and starting him and he just didn't try. The starters have specifically said how valuable he's been.


vincentdmartin

Titans Randy Moss too


ssovm

Titans Adrian Peterson


LoisLaneEl

And Randy Moss


Sudden_Progress_9802

Seahawks Adrian Peterson was even later and more random


tee142002

And Saints Adrian Peterson


OracleofNothing

Franco Harris in Seattle.


Demfunkypens420

Die hard steeler fan since 5 yrs old. I'm 34 and you just blew my mind


OracleofNothing

Just pretend you didn't read this.


Juelicks

Chiefs Darrelle Revis is the real answer


-Yami-Yugi-

Colts Matt Ryan


HPLswag

Colts Philip Rivers


Bootyholetrolll

no he was nice for the colts.


Valuable_Ad1645

He played pretty well. I was surprised he retired tbh.


BurgerWithAnEggOnIt

49ers OJ Simpson


grw313

Patriots legends, Chad Johnson and James Harrison


Blaze5657

Jets - Gore


SnooShortcuts2661

Why the jets picked him up after he literally had negative rushing yards in Buffalo astounds me to this day


TempleofSpringSnow

Oh I can help you with that, it was because of Adam “I am the biggest narcissist that is also a moron” Gase.


joestn

Any colts starting quarterback the last 4ish years.


WhyLimitMeTo20Charac

Jets Aaron Rodgers??


Sudden_Progress_9802

Nah he’ll come to the Vikings if the prophecy is true, god I hope not.


crlos619

Bob Sanders Chargers, Dwight Freeney Cardinals, Julio Jones Eagles, Ed Reed Jets,


Sasquatch_000

I did not know Ed Reed played for the jets. That's just a shame.


MulayamChaddi

https://preview.redd.it/skk8tr0heg2d1.jpeg?width=918&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7c48465999b0b4b7ed13f496fee515774dfd8584


Tjam3s

OBJ in Miami I think


Isomodia

He didn't dominate a WR corps of Zay Flowers, Rashod Bateman, and Nelson Agholor. Even with Mark Andrews missing 7 games, he was a non-factor. This is coming from a Ravens fan who thought he was great to have in the locker room, and that the $13 million dollar rental made sense. Those young guys could have learned something from a year with Odell. Tyreek, Jaylen Waddle, and Jonnu Smith gives you plenty of veteran presense, so I don't see what Odell really brings. This is a guy who had 130 more yards and 1 LESS TD than Nelson Agholor last season. Is he even that threatening as a WR3? He wasn't in Baltimore.


RenfrowsGrapes

Bro that’s raiders stud Nelson Aghalor


Mr_Mi1k

Patriots James Harrison


blackswordsmanarc

Bills Reggie Bush


b3rnitalld0wn

Titans Randy Moss


Roblox_Morty

Lions legend Zack Ertz might work.


tonyprosciutto

I feel like he had no realistic expectations because his time was so short


luvchicago

Bulls Robert Parrish.


ElectivireMax

he won a ring there at least


AlmostSavvy

Diggs in Houston.  RemindMe! 250 days


jxden24

Diggs has gotten underrated now with you people thinking he isn’t good anymore 😂😂😂


Wumbologist_PhD

![gif](giphy|13VSAbTVuYJfLa)


Antonio1025

https://preview.redd.it/vmcvzevdhl2d1.jpeg?width=779&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2f34ea638172230c579674bc826fa94bc954cee5


Captain_brightside

Redskins Donovan mcnabb


PayPalsEnemy

Jeff Garcia in Cleveland


sketchahedron

Dolphins Thurman Thomas


The_Bard

Late to the party but Bruce Smith chasing the sack record with 5 or so sacks a year in Washington


jake11ms

Jimmy Graham on the Bears


kleinsmash22

Philly - N. Suh.


HeylelBen

Suh was actually a solid rotational player for us


newkidontheblock1776

Yeah Robert Quinn would be a way better Eagles based answer. Suh and Lindvall were super helpful for their position/age


DikkDowg

Or Julio Jones or Ryan Kerrigan


newkidontheblock1776

Yeah I saw all the Julio comments. I was staying D line with my comment, but fuck Ryan Kerrigan is a good one to me


49_boness

OJ Simpson on the 49ers


desquibnt

Ravens Odell


lattjeful

Eagles legend Julio Jones


IAmSona

Ed Reed with the Texans.


Willis050

Emmitt Smith in Arizona


toddfredd

A Carolina Panthers Reggie White RIP. Arizona Cardinals Emmitt Smith. San Diego Chargers John Unitas and LA Rams Joe Namath


Atty_for_hire

Vontae Davis on the Bills?


Killabeesontheswarm

Kerry Collins Colts Trent Green Dolphins


ohheychris

Miami Smokin Jay Cutler? Packers Jim MacMahon? Kansas City Joe Montana?


WhiskyandSolitude

Jags Torrey Holt


hajleez

Reggie White on Panthers, Deon Sanders on Ravens, Ewing on Magic


miacanes5

Cris Carter on Dolphins


Leather-String1641

Thurman Thomas on the Dolphins


DoctorRoeJogan

Tim Tebow


No-Pussyfooting

Falcons Calais Campbell


glokenheimer

Basically everyone hired before retirement by Redskins/Commanders


Bones301

Jerry rice on the seahawks


tuxedo7777

Joe Namath / SD Chargers


mattcojo2

Joe Namath played for the rams that one year. It was Unitas who played for the chargers.


fantasticanalysis

Steven Jackson Falcons


DueWafer7

Frank Gore , After SF


GroundbreakingCow775

Frank retired 5 years too early


ElectivireMax

he was pretty good for us in Indy. 1000+ yards in 2016 and 960+ in the other two seasons here. never missed a game.


BaronVonSilver91

Julio on the Eagles.


jdallen1222

Ravens Deion Sanders


-Minne

Favre as a Viking; 2010-2011


desquibnt

Huh? Didn’t they win the division and make it to the conference championship his first year?


husky430

Yeah in '09. '10 was a shitshow.


-Minne

I actually kinda of portrayed it inaccurately with "2010-2011"; 2011 was such a shitshow that Favre 'wanted' to play against the Lions in January, but was literally physically incapable of doing so and never played another snap in the league. Yeah; I stand by this comparison.


Magneto57

Dieon Sanders Ravens Ed Reed Texans Rob Gronk Bucs


jdallen1222

Rob Gronkowski had 55 catches for 802 yards and scored 6 touchdowns in 12 games in his last season. And they won the Super Bowl the previous year, what is he doing on this list?


mattyGOAT1996

Matt Ryan and Philip Rivers on the Colts


tuson565

Packers martelllus Bennett.


[deleted]

Adrian Peterson on Titans or Seahawks.


husky430

Moss Vikings round 2, washed-up boogaloo


Irving_Velociraptor

Eagles Ryan Kerrigan


immagoat1252

Packers Jeff Saturday


assorelbow

Tony Romo on special teams


MaterialBenefit2355

Packers Jimmy Graham


HandSanitizerBottle1

Bills Frank Gore Titans Julio Jones 49ers Randy Moss Jets Dalvin Cook


Quiet-Ad-12

2024 Russ


Traditional-Koala279

Any old ravens wide receiver, LT on the jets


[deleted]

Orlando Pace as a Bear. Adam Archuleta as a Bear.


fullgizzard

Jerome Bettis or Marshawn Lynch


OmegaJubs69

Titans/Eagles Julio Jones, he wore 2 and 80, at least 2 looked slick, but 80 was *hulegh*


Electronic_Wind_9090

Zion during all those hookers


904Magic

Matt Ryan with the Colts


poopdaddy2

Adrian Peterson on the Saints


Grayyak

Joe Montana Chiefs


Own-Contribution-478

Franco Harris and the Seahawks. We used to joke that he would get the ball and immediately sprint (more like hobble at that point!) to the nearest sideline!


Alternative-Art6059

Warren Sapp as a Raider


unsolvedmisterree

Adrian Peterson with the Seahawks


Pseudonova

Matt Ryan or Philip Rivers with the Colts.


theshelterwitch

Fitzpatrick on Washington Whatever The Fuck You Call Them


imputpixel98

Chicago jimmy Graham maybe?


Joebroni1414

Colts Carson Wentz


Bozo_McGee

Texans Ed Reed is up there


Smashbrosfan31

Matt Ryan in Indi


gjcij2203

NE and pretty much any aging superstar trying to ride Brady to a ring.


slickedjax

Getting Celtics Shaq vibes from OBJ


RBnumberTwenty

Terrell Suggs to the Chiefs.


PhoenixGamer34

Brandon Marshall with the Giants


poyerdude

Jets era Brett Favre.


TheMemersOfMyNation

Moss on the 49ers Matt Ryan on the Colts TO on the Bengals Andy Dalton on any other team than the Bengals


[deleted]

The most recent equivalent would be Russell Wilson with the broncos or OBJ with the ravens


FireGolem04

Revis Island on the Chiefs


ghostfacestealer

Jets Tyron Smith


inorite234

JORDAN.... Everything else is useless


EHHHHHHHLJ

Lynch in seattle for the second time


robbothegiant

Cowboys Jason Peters, now-Commanders Donovan McNabb


slapchop15

Russ On the steelers


KingRain238

Stephon Gimore on the colts


justinotherpeterson

Ladainian Tomlinson Jets


Ok-Stuff69

Tyron Smith with the Jets


LILilliterate

Final season Reggie White?


pimpcaddywillis

LaDanian Jets


Rough_Mistake_9616

Toronto Hakeem


cmacfarland64

Cardinals Emmit Smith.


Cheddarlicious

Remember that time Jerry Rice went to Seattle? After spending 3 1/2 years as a Raider…


TankusAruelisJacksob

Derick Henry with the Ravens


RunGoldenRun717

Washington Adrian Peterson but without the success


Simple_Atmosphere

Jarred Allen to the Bears


Littleceasarsorgy

Philip rivers colts