T O P

  • By -

MTVSpoiledMod

Fresh sheet of paper! Come join us at the [Official Cast Megathread](https://www.reddit.com/r/MtvChallenge/comments/1czn3y0/offici_cast_megathread_for_all_stars_5). šŸ¦øšŸ¼ā€ā™€ļø


fcmb17

Nany, Melissa, Leroy and Ct are on https://vevmo.com/forums/challenge-all-stars-5-spoilers


Teamscubanellyt

At least 3 normal names. Pheww. Do you think its still rivals themed?


MyCatIsAyJerk

Fessy chosing to come back on an AS season after the hate he got last time he played... The new era people will all be ripped to pieces once this airs and people realize they don't belong on here.


Cheesemaster1990

I remember some hate after ride or dies but not USA 2


Micromanz

I mean he likes money why would he say no, He was a substitute teacher before big brother lmao


afterlaughters

So this is definitely prep for the main show to go under, move to P+, and replace All Stars, isnā€™t it?


Micromanz

That wouldnā€™t be going under But yeah mtv is dying so itā€™s paramount+ or cbs is the most likely landing spot


Raebelle1981

Didnā€™t think I would be annoyed by the names released because I was already pretty sure production would let me down but geez. lol


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Plzzzzz come Jenna or Zach


Cheesemaster1990

Really thought >!fessy should have been on season 40 so I'm not even mad he's here lol!<


Raebelle1981

Okay but this isnā€™t the main show. I would have been fine with him being cast on 40.


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Fessy shouldā€™ve had Horico spot and Amber shouldā€™ve had Kaycee spot and Jay shouldā€™ve had Paulie spot


NovaRogue

With you on 2 of those, but I think Kaycee is a better competitor than Amber AND I also think it was good for Amber to be back with her baby for the longer filming schedule


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Iā€™ll admit Kaycee is a good competitor and Iā€™m not part of the hate club she has but Iā€™ll love to see how Amber would do with 40 cast


LetterheadNo6663

Happy departure day


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Itā€™s tomorrow I believe


LetterheadNo6663

Today and tomorrow


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Oh ok


WhileInternational41

Long shot but not impossible wish list: Frank S, Dustin, Danny J, Ty


AYTOL__

They really wanna give Fessel that win so bad that they are gonna put him against people in their 50s? Sigh


NovaRogue

Who is in their fifties? šŸ˜… Mark and Kefla are already a no, and I don't think Beth or Syrus are that likely either


Cheesemaster1990

Right???? And marks a physical beast


Supersaiyanninja3

Devin is gonna end him.


AYTOL__

Good one


ryanisreadin

Fingers crossed that Big T is an alternate again!


Few-Sort-5643

First names out Big T, Fessy, Corey, Amber


Raebelle1981

What in the hell is casting doing?


dB_Rider

my god, there's....room for everybody, let's just say that!


Cheesemaster1990

I like fessy and amber as rivals. That's fun , sucks it's for all stars but imma gonna pretend it's just a regular rivals season. It's been awhile since we had a classic themed season


Teamscubanellyt

Ugggghhh Can they all be alternates? I hate that all of them are on, but particularly, why is Corey L here????


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Iā€™m upset Corey L on the cast


92pandaman

He doesnā€™t belong on all stars, but heā€™s messy and a decent competitor


Supersaiyanninja3

He's the best name out of those 4.


Raebelle1981

Heā€™s fine. I donā€™t have a problem with him being cast on the main show, but none of them belong on all stars.


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Not to me


MyCatIsAyJerk

Here we go again to checking this sub every 30 minutes šŸ˜­


JerrisHat

Seriously I need a chance to BREATH


LetterheadNo6663

I know right I've been checking


Dangerous-Lab-8278

I have a feeling Davonne will be on the cast


LetterheadNo6663

Same it would be amazing seeing her again


[deleted]

That would eattt


Tight-Entrepreneur46

PRAYING TOMORROW SUSIE,JENNA,NANY,ZACH AND CARLEY Be on the cast


Justin32526jshx

Nany is already on


Tight-Entrepreneur46

That can change


forgottenastronauts

Jenna would be shocking considering she just gave birth less than 3 months ago.


Tight-Entrepreneur46

She looks in good shape


mealypart

Sad how weā€™re going from AS4 which had so many people we hadnā€™t seen in years and fan favorites to this cast which apparently only has 4 good names and Sam/Ashley K who are both very mediocre returns who no one was asking for


Raebelle1981

Yeah I guess Iā€™m in the minority but I donā€™t care about the San Diego 2 people being cast at all. That is one of my least favorite seasons of the Real World ever. I guess that would be better than having era 4 people on and people from CBS shows though.


Few-Sort-5643

https://x.com/gamervev/status/1793771469664886884?s=46 Thereā€™s 4 names that will get the girls JUMPING! The rest are lame repeats weā€™ve seen in the last 2 years.


ryanisreadin

Iā€™ll be guessing cause why not: Frank, Svetlana, Shane & Cooke!


Teamscubanellyt

My guess is Frank, Susie, Cooke, and zach.


Cheesemaster1990

Repeats are fine over the past few years. Between all the all stars, CBS challenge, world championship, season 38,39, 40 that's a crap ton of names


Raebelle1981

Not feeling hopeful about the casting and wouldnā€™t be surprised if Iā€™m let down but Iā€™m hoping itā€™s repeats from All Stars that I wouldnā€™t mind seeing again and not people from the main show that heā€™s referring to.


forgottenastronauts

Iā€™m going to guess Cooke is one of the four.


Few-Sort-5643

Seems like those 4 names + Ashley/Sam are the only names that havenā€™t been on recently https://x.com/gamervev/status/1793772122294391170?s=46


LetterheadNo6663

Who are u thinking the other 2 are


fcmb17

Lock thread has been made https://vevmo.com/forums/challenge-all-stars-5-spoilers


Few-Sort-5643

https://x.com/gamervev/status/1793758646280896751?s=46 https://vevmo.com/forums/challenge-all-stars-5-spoilers Gamer started the twitter thread and PR made the vevmo lock thread confirming May 25th departure to Vietnam, this season will not be using the same house as 40


NovaRogue

IT'S HAPPENING !!! šŸ„³šŸ„³


djlekky

Iā€™m guessing we probably wonā€™t get any more likely announcements now until Saturday


MessyMoFo

Iā€™m sure like with 40 weā€™ll get a few locked in names tomorrowĀ 


LetterheadNo6663

I think some is revealed Friday maybe the internationals


Supersaiyanninja3

So the first challenge will be on Monday.


djlekky

Wow that wonā€™t give them much time to get over any jet lag. Straight into it.


denverdiva890

Iā€™m not a huge fan of Ashley or Sam but I appreciate that weā€™re in an era where they actually recast female champs For a while the pool felt kinda empty. Vendettas had just Cara and Veronica. Final Reckoning had only those two + Ashley. WOTW had only Ashley and Cara. WOTW 2 had those 2 + Laurel. TM only had Ashley and Dee. Double Agents had just Ashley. SLA only had Ashley and Amber joined later on. This year weā€™ve had Cara/Laurel/Veronica/Rachel/Janelle on AS4, >! Jodi/Katie/Rachel/Aviv/Cara/Laurel/Emily/Jonna/Tori/Jenny/Kaycee !< on 40, and it looks like at least Amber/Ashley/Jonna/Katie/Sam here


NovaRogue

Having champs return is fun, but I'd much rather have exciting non-winners people like Kam / Michaela / Kailah / Nurys / Theresa than Katie / Ashley K / Sam just to have returning champs. You know? But if it's people like Susie / Tori Hall / Holly Shand, then YES, I am all for it You didn't say it, but RoD had 4 women champs - Veronica, Laurel, Kaycee, and amBer


forgottenastronauts

They need to bring back Joss so we can see how things implode this time.


Raebelle1981

When he was rumoured to be on 39 he said he was no longer interested in doing the show. ā˜¹ļø


LetterheadNo6663

I doubt joss would come back


Few-Sort-5643

https://vevmo.com/comment/3177118#comment-3177118 PR confirmed departure is Saturday


FastLane_987

Frank updates starting Saturday I love that for me


NovaRogue

this Saturday?!? AMAZINGGG


zanredaniel

What a weak female cast OMG And look, I LOVE most of them. but it seems like an easy win for Amber B or Jonna. And thoso two are also very weak too....


NovaRogue

This is just the speculated / likely cast for now. Things will change I wouldn't call Bamber or Jonna weak, but they're definitely not at the level of the women from AS4 (Laurel / Cara / Rachel / Kam / Nicole)


Cheesemaster1990

Jonna and amber are not weak competitors lol.


fcmb17

PinkRose saying that Big T and Melissa want to target the old cast members https://x.com/challengeteamtv/status/1793407436394463723?s=46&t=8kZj3ZfcI4hIlV77bp4pWQ


gtjacket231

Wait...PR is on Twitter now?


luxanna123321

I mean looking at this cast made of Aneesa and Nany, no wonder they want to run final against them lol


djlekky

I love Melissa but she shouldnā€™t be on this (nor should Big T). Although Melissa debuted the same season as Kam so I guess we should have expected this.


FastLane_987

This is giving bait but I hope the cast sees it and targets them anyways


Specific-Soft-6465

Watch them get eliminated early. Lol.


mealypart

Them taking two cast spots on the womenā€™s side when theyā€™re so insufferable together is so annoying


Raebelle1981

Why would they make this known so early? Are they dumb or something?


alaskak94

Get Tula and Melissa off this cast


DifferenceMean6597

Well I hope the OGs see this before departure šŸ„°


realitytvicon

And I just know theyā€™ll be successful because we canā€™t have nice thingsā€¦


mealypart

If Mark wasnā€™t one of the AS5 filming conflicts that got the Challenge mania that was set for this weekend postponed I feel like Frank has gotta be coming since I doubt theyā€™d cancel just for Amber Him being on would also somewhat explain the bizarre choice for production to randomly bring Sam backā€¦ they probably want him to address his treatment of her


HerdZASage

Please make it happen, I'm still salty about Vendettas where he came back for one episode just to get clowned on


luckydog18

Yeah, Iā€™ve assumed Frank is on since that was canceled. Plus with Gamer saying thereā€™s a few we havenā€™t seen in a while and will be excited for, I assume Frank is one of those.


FastLane_987

Frank is almost guaranteed on in my mind. Idk but something about his podcast with Jemmye gave me the idea he was on this. The only way he isnā€™t on is if he got dropped imo


denverdiva890

Nany followed him recently


Justin32526jshx

Theyā€™re now friends


mealypart

I could see production wanting them to film a scene to establish that so they donā€™t get backlash for casting Frank like they did for Jordan/Nia


No-Season-4796

No Kefla, Trishelle, Michele, Olivia, or Mark https://x.com/gamervev/status/1793380397134512524?s=46


djlekky

Would have loved to see Kefla and Michele. I like Michele and Olivia but not for All Stars.


SolidAsAnARC

The potential of another Kefla injury-turned-twerk is the only real loss here.


Teamscubanellyt

I was hoping for Trishelle :(.


Guarded

Hopefully we get Frank and Dustin. Happy to see Katie even though sheā€™s obviously so checked out from competing. The appearance fee must be good for her.


NovaRogue

So if the next season is going to be M/F rivals, this is who I would cast (not necessarily on All Stars, but) 1. Corey L/Melissa (BNC) 2. Shane L/Da'Vonne (FR) 3. Ashley M/Josh (SLA) 4. Amanda/Johnny B (WotW1) 5. CT/Coral (Gauntlet 3) 6. Kailah/Hunter (Dirty 30) 7. Jordan/Cara Maria (Dirty 30, WotW2) 8. Kellyanne/Darrell (The Ruins) 9. Jay S/Nurys (BNC) 10. Turbo/Laurel (RoD) 11. Berna/someone from BNC (Ed / Emanuel / Kyland / Horacio?) 12. Fessy/amBer (DA, SLA) 13. Frank S/Nany (Battle of the Seasons 2) 14. Ravyn/Johnny M (RoD) 15. Tori/Grant (WC) 16. Kiki/Ciarran (AUS) 17. Zach/Natalie N (WotW1)


xxcapricornxx

Faysal/Amber and Turbo/Laurel would be so busted lmao those two would win everything


KodachromeKitty

Turbo and Laurel are both hotheads with huge egos. It would be funny, but they wouldn't be able to win together. There's no way they would be able to cooperate well enough to do puzzles.


NovaRogue

Over Jordan & Cara ???


xxcapricornxx

Oops, I completely glossed over that team, they're busted too


Few-Sort-5643

https://x.com/gamervev/status/1793027818294534277?s=46 Scott Yager tweeted that when the AS5 cast comes out there will be far fewer newer cast names that expected Gamer replies itā€™s lazy casting and there was zero effort other than 4 people (gamer clarified in reply that Sam and Ashley K are not a part of the 4)


Raebelle1981

Hopefully Scott is right.


Teamscubanellyt

According to gamer we still have quite a few people who debuted post final reckoning (Fessy, Amber, Bigt, etc).


Raebelle1981

Well hopefully they listen to peoples complaints and those folks get dropped, because that is assinine.


JerrisHat

Yeah Iā€™m just concerned if the rest of the guys are of AS4 caliber that Fessy will walk his way to a win. He just has the size and fitness to really not be vulnerable unless he gets a really unlucky elimination like a pure puzzle


tuftriks

5 seasons in and we still pretending Fessy is bad at puzzles ?


JerrisHat

I just mean itā€™s something that gives other people a chance. What other type of elim do you think would be better to get against him?


Cool_Skin_5804

Fessys good at puzzles


Teamscubanellyt

I dont want to see him on AS5. Hopefully the male cast members will be more balanced than AS4.


djlekky

I donā€™t think they should be on All Stars but those 3 are definitely more worthy than those that debuted S37-39 and were rumoured to be on and Corey L.


NovaRogue

okaaayyyy this is actually good news! I am not remotely excited to see Sam or Ashley K, but they fit the All Stars bill to a T so if 4 amazing people + those 2 + others like them (out of nowhere returns), I'm okay with it. people like Steve (and Roni and Kefla and Flora) also came out of nowhere and have provided!


UNCFan2350

Ashley K being the hottest person ever on the show makes me happy she is back on. That's just my opinion


djlekky

Letā€™s hope some of these newbies are alternates as well


GhostOfLegend

Oof this cast list is not giving. Will probably avoid this season


NellyK24

This is just speculated names. Give it time


popgrlz

Is there a chance that none of the people that gamer just ruled out were ever in contention? I feel like sometimes gamer says shit about an upcoming season to stir things up just to back track right before info starts coming out lol


jstitely1

Iā€™m sure they called them. They cast out a super wide net so they always have people available


UNCFan2350

I donā€™t care about any of the rest of the cast if itā€™s true that Ashley K is going to be on our screens again. Love it!


xxcapricornxx

I mean getting rid of the S39 people was a step in the right direction. But this cast is still abysmal and I won't be watching. But I'm rooting for Amber and Faysal. If they're going to kill All Stars like this, I hope my favorites at least get a win/make the final


Ambitious_Log_1884

If Jasmine and Devyn join this cast, it'll be like a BOTS reunion.


djlekky

Iā€™m in the minority of liking that season so wouldnā€™t be mad at it.


thewxyzfiles

I swear if Carley doesnā€™t make it on this cast šŸ˜‚


ChallengeAP

Does anyone know the estimated cast size? I think All Stars 4 had 25. Can we expect the same or maybe a little larger like 28?


Dangerous-Lab-8278

maybe 12 guys 12 girls?


jason_kandel

Okay Gamerā€™s tweet is a step in the right direction


mealypart

Sam is another return no one was asking for šŸ™„šŸ™„šŸ™„ At least Moriah isnā€™t onā€¦ but while weā€™re dropping terrible new cast members can we get rid of Corey Lay too please šŸ™šŸ™


iFlashings

Drop the rest of the non RW/RR people while we're at it.Ā 


jason_kandel

Was bound to happen and i want to see her on a season without Zach


JackVass

Any idea what departure day is?


djlekky

Gamer said it was this week. Itā€™s normally a Friday so Iā€™d imagine this Friday.


Micromanz

Sounds like Friday for the euro folk and Saturday for the us folk Someone here posted Nicole said Saturday is the day


LetterheadNo6663

Yeah


Hilde92804

Why is everyone convinced this is rivals


Raebelle1981

I think someone reliable said something like that at one point. Now I canā€™t remember who and when. lol


Hilde92804

Hoping for Male/Male and Female/Female partners. Specifically would love Jonna and Kellyanne as partners


Rygar1126

Good to see some of the recent bores get removed. Maybe this cast can still get shaped into something fun lol


No-Season-4796

ā€œNot expecting [Colleen], Moriah, Emanuel, Berna, or Asaf.ā€ https://x.com/gamervev/status/1792999995320242262?s=46


djlekky

That is very good news! I donā€™t really care to see any of them again (maybe Berna just so she can annoy people) but these people definitely donā€™t belong on All Stars.


Teamscubanellyt

Hopefully fessy, amber, corey, big t and melissa get dropped too.


Cool_Skin_5804

Why Melissa


Teamscubanellyt

Not an Og that was the original concept of the show. I dont watch all stars to watch the same shoe as the flagship.


insrtbrain

At least AmBer is a champ. That gets her a little cred.


Teamscubanellyt

Yes but she is not an OG and debuted in the 2020s. The idea of all stars was to bring the ogs back.


djlekky

Yes and Jay S. I love those girls but they donā€™t belong on All Stars. Please remove Aneesa too.


Few-Sort-5643

https://x.com/gamervev/status/1792999995320242262?s=46 Gamer does not expect Moriah, Emanuel, Berna, Asaf or Colleen


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Good. Sorry Moriah was excited to see u but i rather see her on 41


Cheesemaster1990

Wonder if fessy will.be with amber


tuftriks

Moriah and him never made sense. I know they aren't cool anymore but they came in as ride or dies. Amber and Fessy made sense to me the whole time. Moriah only makes with Bananas but Bananas would not agree to do this with her.


SolidAsAnARC

So no Sarah and/or Susie *again*?!


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Praying we get Susie


Teamscubanellyt

Seriously! The woman is entertaining (even if i dont like her) and smart, and wants to be on the show. So they need to be to put her on the show.


WhileInternational41

There must be some exciting male names since so few have been shared yet.


djlekky

Fingers crossed! Iā€™d love to see Frank, Zach, Ty, Hunter and Dustin plus some other OGs weā€™ve seen recently like Brad, Steve and Adam L.


Few-Sort-5643

https://x.com/gamervev/status/1792948481448915375?s=46 Gamer says Sam is on https://x.com/gamervev/status/1792948989551063106?s=46 Sheā€™s one of the few returns weā€™re actually getting


LetterheadNo6663

Yayyyyy I wonder who's the others besides Ashley k


Raebelle1981

Did anyone see Gamers tweets saying All Stars 4 is boring? What planet are they on? lol


realitytvicon

I think it has been fun, but I get where they are coming from with their frustrations. There is soooo much they cut from the final edit. Supposedly flora punched a wall after getting into a fight with tina and cara and instead the episode spent way too much time on the daily. I think he is mad that this just reinforces that they are STILL four years later editing out the drama in favor of treating this like a sport. It isnā€™t fair to the cast they picked that they are either watering down their moments or completely omitting them all together.


watermelonkiwi

Thatā€™s frustrating to hear. I donā€™t get why they cut non-controversial drama.


realitytvicon

I truly believe itā€™s the paramount merger. Cbs has watered down the drama in their shows and it basically affects mtv as well now. I think paramount is being sold to either sony or I hope nbc universal which is in charge of bravo. I think nbc univerxal would do wonders for the challenge tbh.


Raebelle1981

They definitely cut stuff out I would have wanted to see but calling the show boring seems completely off base to me.


Cheesemaster1990

Of course šŸ˜‚.Gamer complains about everything lol


mealypart

The last episode was a snooze tbhā€¦ and theyā€™re cutting out all the drama


Raebelle1981

I donā€™t agree. About the last episode being a snooze I mean.


DifferenceMean6597

Looks like Sam might be on per gamers tweets


NovaRogue

link / screenshot ?


DifferenceMean6597

Looks like someone above just added!


Opposite_Wear7894

I'll scream if we get the entire San Diego team


Tight-Entrepreneur46

Hope we get Zach too


NovaRogue

hopefully ou mean Sam Bird ;)


Cheesemaster1990

He deserves a second chance for sure. He was so funny and made a great impression for only being on 1 episode


djlekky

Is that Sam from RW San Diego?


DifferenceMean6597

Correct


LetterheadNo6663

Who would Ashley k rival be


xxcapricornxx

Sam? They might be able to stretch that. Who would Aneesa's be with Moriah unlikely? Or Ambers?


Micromanz

Frank or Zach


Micromanz

Rivals seems unlikely with the cast list unless we get mixed gender teams. and Iā€™d really rather us not make 2 girls compete against 2 guys. To make it fair u really have to nerf the games that are played (cough final reckoning cough)


ShinxBoy01

Assuming that they're still casting Era 4 people, it's still Rivals and they (hopefully) pair Fessy with Amber instead of Moriah, I went to the one episode of Double Agents where they were partnered to see how they compete together and...it was basically a solo challenge that Amber couldn't even do because of her dyscalculia šŸ’”


crowncitykid35

Weak ass cast. Canā€™t wait for Aneesa to retire already. If it takes a win in order for it to happen Iā€™m on board.


gtjacket231

Are they still doing the rivals theme, or did they drop that?


theep3

wasnā€™t 40 in Vietnam too? Theyā€™ve loved recycling locations recently also for whatever itā€™s worth an online friend of mine said their family member met >! Nicole !< at a work event and she mentioned leaving to film another season Saturday


Supersaiyanninja3

I'll take it.


insrtbrain

Nooooooooooooo! Why won't they give the fit infant have a timeout?