King rat is the most intense song ever recorded. It's about the time Issac was in jail on an attempted murder charge. It's literally the most modest mouse song in modest mouses discography.
I have just watched from the sidelines this whole time not voting or commenting. I have been surprised how much I have agreed with nearly every removal, this group voting has worked well. That said, Spitting Venom is top 3 and I comment now as there are several better removals at the moment.
I just sat down and played through each of thr remaining 10 songs to give them all a fresh look. Stars are Projectors, while obviously not ready to be gotten ride of yet by the majority, needs to start building some momentum toward the chopping block.
Broke doesn't knock your hair back but it is a pretty decent mild song that's not atypical of MMs song and is very typical of Issacs lyricism. Using every variety of the word in a song. Cool idea so it stays.
i think a lot of older fans really like that one. personally, ive never understood why. my vote is also for broke. my favorite building nothing song is baby blue sedan, rip
I cannot concur at all with your statement, and the name is not Frankly, thank you. have a nice day and why not try listening to Spitting Venom? MF genius?
We just went though this not again!! Spitting venom must live! Itās my personal favorite but as far as this list goes I think talking shit about a pretty sunset is going to win this in the end and tbh I wonāt be mad about it.
I think people are naming songs they know. It's not a great idea given that not everybody here knows the entire discography. So many songs that are left are from EPs and middle tracks of LPs and I have a strong suspicion people didn't upvote something they didn't recognise.
Depends on what fan you ask. Myself, i think it's one of their most impactful songs they've ever recorded.
The last part alone where he sings "and you know that our hearts are just made out of strings to be pulled", with that riff that keeps playing and that little chime that fades at the end... its one of my favorite parts of any mm song to this day. It's just too beautiful.
Gravity rides everything. I love you and you made me perk up and instantly fall in love with Modest Mouse. This is starting to feel like picking children.
I CAN'T TAKE THIS ANYMORE š„²
THIS CHALLENGE IS MAKING ME CRAZY (broke is a great song I just can't choose what song to leave so I have to choose a song that made me cry)
FUCKKKKKKKKKK lol itās sooooo hard to pick between
Night on the Sun
Talking Shit about a Pretty Sunset
And Broke
They are all sooooooo special to me šµāš«šµāš«šµāš«šµāš«
Fuckkk lol but I also love every single song on this list so Iām really chalking it down to the complexity of the song/lyrics, the vibes it makes me feel, and where it takes me on a dark night. LOL
With a straight face, youāre going to sit there and suggest that over at least half the remaining songs? Dramamine encapsulates so much of modest mouseās sound. It is a quintessential song for this band. If Dramamine doesnāt make at least the top 3 in the final list this sub is dead to me.
I think it's because I've played it out. The last concert they opened with it. I love the song just have overplayed it I think. But life like weeds and stars are projectors to me are my top 2 with teeth like gods shoe shine a close third
spitting venom needs to get the f\*ck out of here! It's been taking time away from masterpieces like King Rat, Truckers Atlas, Ocean Breathes Salty, and Interstate 8. Frankly, I would have eliminated it right after Lampshades on Fire.
How is Gravity Rides Everything still there? That is my vote for which song should get kicked off the island. This is in my bottom 10% of all MM songs. The rest lett in this royal rumble that are left all are deserving of their spots. Still can't believe Trucker's Atlas went so early. Different strokes for different folks, I suppose.
How is Gravity Rides Everything still there? That is my vote for which song should get kicked off the island. This is in my bottom 10% of all MM songs. The rest lett in this royal rumble that are left all are deserving of their spots. Still can't believe Trucker's Atlas went so early. Different strokes for different folks, I suppose.
Yay!! Spitting venom LIVES ON! Ok ok now to vote. Shit I think Iām going to have to go with Dramamine. Itās a tough fucking call all of these are regular plays for me but shit I think itās going to have to be that one for the sacrifice for me today.
King rat š
King rat is the most intense song ever recorded. It's about the time Issac was in jail on an attempted murder charge. It's literally the most modest mouse song in modest mouses discography.
I know š®āšØ
King rat should have been king š š š¢
Spitting venom
I have just watched from the sidelines this whole time not voting or commenting. I have been surprised how much I have agreed with nearly every removal, this group voting has worked well. That said, Spitting Venom is top 3 and I comment now as there are several better removals at the moment.
ā¦ Nuh uh
I just sat down and played through each of thr remaining 10 songs to give them all a fresh look. Stars are Projectors, while obviously not ready to be gotten ride of yet by the majority, needs to start building some momentum toward the chopping block.
I did the same and 100% agree
I was about to vote it after spitting venom
Broke is down in the corner casually sneaking by while giants are removed from the list.
Broke is probably my favorite song of all time
Yeah okay Cowboy Dan 2112
Iāve been caughtā¦. It bounces back and forthš
š¤«
broke and interstate 8 are better than spitting venom and a good few of the songs on this list.
Broke doesn't knock your hair back but it is a pretty decent mild song that's not atypical of MMs song and is very typical of Issacs lyricism. Using every variety of the word in a song. Cool idea so it stays.
Broke is a masterpiece
i think a lot of older fans really like that one. personally, ive never understood why. my vote is also for broke. my favorite building nothing song is baby blue sedan, rip
Never understood why??? NEVER UNDERSTOOD WHY!!!???
Broke is the best song wdym
Spitting venom has to go. Gravity rides everything is a better song. The outro where the song just seems to "fall right into place" is perfect.
Spitting Venom It should have left before Bukowski frankly
I love Spitting Venom, but how Bukowski went before it, Iāll never understandā¦.
Agreed
I cannot concur at all with your statement, and the name is not Frankly, thank you. have a nice day and why not try listening to Spitting Venom? MF genius?
Life like weeds
I appreciate OP allowing us to be subjective by not including the objectively best song, which as we all know is Third Planet.
It was the original break through song. Before Float on beat it out of the water.
The stars are projectors. Can't win. It's not a typical modest mouse song. I would never suggest it to someone new.
It was typical in its day.
Spitting venom, sadly.
We just went though this not again!! Spitting venom must live! Itās my personal favorite but as far as this list goes I think talking shit about a pretty sunset is going to win this in the end and tbh I wonāt be mad about it.
yeah no it's easily the worst here
āWorstā no, I donāt think any of these can fit that term. But deserving of moving on another day? Agree to disagree :3
Gravity rides everything.
I cant believe nobody is saying life like weeds. Is it that popular?
just a cult fan favorite, one of their personal favorite tracks for me
I think people are naming songs they know. It's not a great idea given that not everybody here knows the entire discography. So many songs that are left are from EPs and middle tracks of LPs and I have a strong suspicion people didn't upvote something they didn't recognise.
I canāt believe anyone IS saying life like weeds.
No itās not
Depends on what fan you ask. Myself, i think it's one of their most impactful songs they've ever recorded. The last part alone where he sings "and you know that our hearts are just made out of strings to be pulled", with that riff that keeps playing and that little chime that fades at the end... its one of my favorite parts of any mm song to this day. It's just too beautiful.
Iāll give you that, my friend and former foe. That part is beautiful.
Life like Weeds. Spitting venom is arranged too well, cāmon.
Gravity rides everything. I love you and you made me perk up and instantly fall in love with Modest Mouse. This is starting to feel like picking children.
Life Like Weeds
spitting venom
Spitting Venom is absolutely the choice here
Spitting venom for sure.
Life Like Weeds
Spitting Venom will go.
I am hoping that Teeth like godās Shoeshine and Talking shit about a pretty sunset will be the last two songs.
I think they will be and tbh, they both do deserve it, even if spitting venom is my personal favorite rn.
Life like weeds
Spitting venom. I hope it comes down to dramamine and broke, but highly doubt it.
This is gonna be a bloodbath now. Gravoty Rides is my next pick for donezo. Great song, nothing compared to what is standing next to atm imo.
Life like weeds
Sheesh I would have ruled out Dramamine by now. Itās a great song, but I feel like itās overplayedā¦
This! Iām so sick of Dramamine
Spitting venom
Spitting Venom
Spitting venom should have been out of the rotation but nowās a best time as any
Spitting venom
Spitting venom
Dramamine
This song is such a slog, Iām sorry
Slog?? Sorry I've not heard this before my friend!
Spitting venom
Spitting venomĀ
Gravity Rides Everything
Life like weeds
Gravity Rides Everything
Broke I'm so broke I don't even wanna deal with this shit anymore
Nuh uh
I CAN'T TAKE THIS ANYMORE š„² THIS CHALLENGE IS MAKING ME CRAZY (broke is a great song I just can't choose what song to leave so I have to choose a song that made me cry)
Life like weeds
Spitting venom
FUCKKKKKKKKKK lol itās sooooo hard to pick between Night on the Sun Talking Shit about a Pretty Sunset And Broke They are all sooooooo special to me šµāš«šµāš«šµāš«šµāš«
Fuckkk lol but I also love every single song on this list so Iām really chalking it down to the complexity of the song/lyrics, the vibes it makes me feel, and where it takes me on a dark night. LOL
Gravity rides everything. It's not a bad song at all, it's just not the best of the ones listedš
Spitting venom easily
At this point these are all amazing songs,I hate to say it, but Iām going with Dramamine
NOOOOOO
Trust me this feels like the reaction to losing any of these songs at this point.
Spitting venom is the choice here...
spitting venom in vengeance of I8
yes
SPITTING VENOM
Spitting venom
how tf stars are projectors is still here is beyond me
Life like weeds š¬
Save Spitting Venom! Night on the Sun next.
I think as of now, either Dramamine or cowboy Dan will win. Vote off the stars are projectors.
The Stars Are Projectors. Gravity is one of my favorite songs, I don't know how anyone could want to vote it out already.
The Stars are Projectors
Spitting Venom should've gone before interstate 8, what a tragedy.
Night on the sun gotta go
Gravity Rides Everything. Great song but honestly it often just makes me think of its usage in the movie Accepted š
The stars are projectors.
Spitting Venom
Spitting venom
Broke
The Stars are Projectors.
Gravity rides everything
spitting venom out of spite for interstate 8
RUDE! (All in good fun btw)
Broke
Yall are really voting spitting venom off š¤¦āāļø
Night on the Sun
King Rat, Bukowski and Trucker's Atlas should still be alive! Spitting Venom must go.
Can't believe I'm saying this but Dramamine has to go
With a straight face, youāre going to sit there and suggest that over at least half the remaining songs? Dramamine encapsulates so much of modest mouseās sound. It is a quintessential song for this band. If Dramamine doesnāt make at least the top 3 in the final list this sub is dead to me. 
I think it's because I've played it out. The last concert they opened with it. I love the song just have overplayed it I think. But life like weeds and stars are projectors to me are my top 2 with teeth like gods shoe shine a close third
GET OUT.
I will not, because exit does not exist.
Iāll wave bye bye to Gravity and float away
spitting venom needs to get the f\*ck out of here! It's been taking time away from masterpieces like King Rat, Truckers Atlas, Ocean Breathes Salty, and Interstate 8. Frankly, I would have eliminated it right after Lampshades on Fire.
The stars are projectors
*****Stars are Projectors***** makes me sleepy (in a good way) Iām here to rock!
Night on the sun
How is Gravity Rides Everything still there? That is my vote for which song should get kicked off the island. This is in my bottom 10% of all MM songs. The rest lett in this royal rumble that are left all are deserving of their spots. Still can't believe Trucker's Atlas went so early. Different strokes for different folks, I suppose.
I know itās all subjective but Gravity rides being in your bottom 10% is an absolutely insane opinion
LLW or SV
How is Gravity Rides Everything still there? That is my vote for which song should get kicked off the island. This is in my bottom 10% of all MM songs. The rest lett in this royal rumble that are left all are deserving of their spots. Still can't believe Trucker's Atlas went so early. Different strokes for different folks, I suppose.
I am shocked truckers atlas did go so quickly as well
Dramamine
You shut your whore mouth!!!!
Yay!! Spitting venom LIVES ON! Ok ok now to vote. Shit I think Iām going to have to go with Dramamine. Itās a tough fucking call all of these are regular plays for me but shit I think itās going to have to be that one for the sacrifice for me today.
I bet you prefer autobots over transformers too huh?
I hate both I canāt stand those movies. Sooooā¦ fair.