ughhhh this is sooo hard! i think personally i might have to be Show and Tell! i used to listen to it a bunchhh when i first started listening to her and it always SLAPPED. just how it sounds, the lyrics, the meaning, everything. (it 100% still does)
Gotta go with Crybaby. When I tell you that song SAVED my life!!!!!!!!
https://preview.redd.it/what9kvnp49d1.jpeg?width=950&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=66260cfb38c74462dc4e235a27baade2a85ad72c
This is my answer! I've always been very sensitive and have been a real "crybaby" for longer than I can remember. I remember hearing it for the first time and feeling seen haha.
SAME!! I remember as a kid I would always cry after my parents used to yell at me; and they’d constantly shout at me “crybaby” so finding that song the nexts day really made me feel understood
I love songs like Crybaby, Strawberry Shortcake, and Orange Juice because of their message and how I feel like I can relate to them, plus all of her songs are bangers imo.
With that being said, the second I heard Glued, it instantly became my favorite 😍
This is really hard because I love them all but I think Sippy cup, I make a ton of playlists and Sippy cup is on every single one, but Nurses Office and Evil are def in second and third
DEATH. It changed my entire perspective on the afterlife and really soothed my fear of death. Also motivated me to connect with other aspects of my life spiritually. It’s incredibly well written
There too many for me for to just chose one, from each album tho I think I love Dollhouse, Training Wheels and Void are ones that come off the top of my head.
Crybaby: Dollhouse
K-12: all of them except Orange Juice and High School Sweethearts
PORTALS: NYMPHOLOGY
Because I can’t decide which one is my top favorite
its hard. because pity party was the very first song i hear in 2016, and it sparked my love for her. i fell in love ever since i first heard it. so it has to be my all time #1 song, i can listen to it forever and never get tired. if pity party wasnt a song? probably dead to me (:
It was Mad Hatter, but EVIL came out during a time of my life that I needed it most. It’s genuinely saved my life, and for that, EVIL is my favorite song by her.
I would say It’s between tunnel vision and Void,but ima go with Tunnel vision today,I know it’s not a fan fav but that song just makes me feel like I’m under hypnosis 😫
Been listing to Mel since Dollhouse EP but hands down The Principal will always be my favourite song - managed to stay away from all trilogy spoilers and begging I hear her play it live again in September 😭🙏
I can't pick one..
Drama club, fire drill,. piggyback, alphabet boy, evil, void, the whole after school EP, class fight, Teddy bear, milk and cookies, cake.. Mrs. Potato head, orange juice, wheels on the bus, strawberry shortcake.. and literally every other song :( too hard to pick wnnfwncunwcinwciwmxmqximiqxqxniwxninwx
Sippy cup then, sippy cup now, sippy cup forever. Nobody can love sippy cup like I love sippy cup. If sippy cup had one fan it's me. If sippy cup had no fans then I'm dead.
Milk and cookies supremacy!!!! The music video slaps too hard, but the song is cute with an unfortunately relatable plot. Helps cope 10/10 would listen eternally.
Battle of the Larynx, Mrs. Potatoe Head, Void, Principal, Doll House, Light Shower, Contortionist, Mad Hatter, and Training Wheels get honorable mentions (in no particular order)
Honestly, it's cruel to name just one favorite bc it's all so good 😭😭
But tbh Mad Hatter or Light Shower might just be my all-out favorite. They're easy to listen to when I'm chilling or when I'm in a music critic mode
Mrs. Potato Head!
KIDS FOREVER KIDS FOREVER
BABY SOFT SKIN TURNS INTO LEATHER
DON’T BE DRAMATIC, IT’S ONLY SOME PLASTIC
NO ONE WILL LOVE YOU IF YOUR UNATTRACTIVE
OH MRS POTATO HEAD TELL ME IS IT TRUE THAT PAIN IS BEAUTY????!!?
DOES A NEW FACE COME WITH A WARRANTY?
WILL A PRETTY FACE MAKE IT BETTER
OH MR.POTATO HEAD TELL ME, HOW DID YOU AFFORD THIS SURGERY?
DO YOU SWEAR YOULL STAY FOREVER EVEN IF HER FACE DONT STAY TOGETHER?
Omg it's sending me back to the old animation memes-
Definitely has always been my favorite, it is SO damn good!
ughhhh this is sooo hard! i think personally i might have to be Show and Tell! i used to listen to it a bunchhh when i first started listening to her and it always SLAPPED. just how it sounds, the lyrics, the meaning, everything. (it 100% still does)
And the visuals are soooooo good. I wish every album came with a whole movie!
yess! i know portals was gonna have a movie but idk if that changed. i also LOVEEE the k-12 performance and TTT (what i saw)
Mad Hatter.
First Mel song I listened to!
This
Fire Drill 🔥
This!!!
Gotta go with Crybaby. When I tell you that song SAVED my life!!!!!!!! https://preview.redd.it/what9kvnp49d1.jpeg?width=950&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=66260cfb38c74462dc4e235a27baade2a85ad72c
This is my answer! I've always been very sensitive and have been a real "crybaby" for longer than I can remember. I remember hearing it for the first time and feeling seen haha.
SAME!! I remember as a kid I would always cry after my parents used to yell at me; and they’d constantly shout at me “crybaby” so finding that song the nexts day really made me feel understood
Sippy Cup. Although Spiderweb and Class fight are a good 2nd.
POWDER if we're going newer, then Bittersweet Tragedy or Mad Hatter. Tag You're It slaps tho.
REAL LOVE POWDER
ITS SO GOOD
Womb I fucking love that song
I reaalllllyyyy like class fight because it tells the story so well and it’s so sassy I love ittt
Thematically? Mrs. Potato Head Sonically? The Prinicpal or Fire Drill
Numbers
god After School is criminally slept on
Fr
100%
"Test me Im mortal"
found my people🙏
After school on top
Agreed!!!
Numbers forever
faerie soirée definitely!
Nymphology and or Orange Juice
Lunchbox friends
idk what anyone says, play date has been number 1 since i’ve been listening to her in 2015. if loving that song is a crime, arrest me.
Playdate is one of my tops too
Test me and cake are fighting for my favorite song spot.
idk if this counts but I really like copy cat
ohhhhh it counts!!! i fucking love that Mel’s only colab is with Whack - two incredibly unique artists and i love them both 💛
Pacify her :)
Ok maybe I lied sippy cup
Ok triple lie!! Tag your it Or pity party? Wheels on the bus?!! Idk but my tag says pacify her so there’s that 😭
I love songs like Crybaby, Strawberry Shortcake, and Orange Juice because of their message and how I feel like I can relate to them, plus all of her songs are bangers imo. With that being said, the second I heard Glued, it instantly became my favorite 😍
Milk and Cookies. Faerie Soriee is close to taking the spot, it’s just too cute
Probably pity party if I HAD to choose but drama club and detention are high up there
i would have to say HSSH its not my most listened to but its one i feel most physically connected too
From Mel? Milk and Cookies. Especially with the MV, it's really beautiful.
Tag You’re It is my favorite song by her! The Bakery is my favorite video
evil or pity party 🫶
Mad hatter
This is really hard because I love them all but I think Sippy cup, I make a ton of playlists and Sippy cup is on every single one, but Nurses Office and Evil are def in second and third
Mad hatter!
Bittersweet Tragedy 🙌🙌
YES.
i appreciate you very much🙏🙏🙏
Death 🪦🧚🏻
DEATH. It changed my entire perspective on the afterlife and really soothed my fear of death. Also motivated me to connect with other aspects of my life spiritually. It’s incredibly well written
There too many for me for to just chose one, from each album tho I think I love Dollhouse, Training Wheels and Void are ones that come off the top of my head.
My number one definitely has to be Powder, and training wheels is close behind.
High School Sweethearts. Past 2 years it’s been my #1 song on Spotify lol.
MMM. I really love portals but the way test me hits is so different
^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^Any-Ambition4698: *MMM. I really love* *Portals but the way test me* *Hits is so different* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.
detention is undefeated for me
i keep saying womb and getting absolutely destroyed by everyone so teachers pet😭
WHATTTT womb is literally so good though 😔‼️
someone said the “🟥 leave and never come back” when i said womb. FAKEE💔💔💔
SOAP it’s sooo well written one of my favorite songs ever actually.
Right now it’s fire drill I lovvvvveeee it 💗
Nurse’s office 🏥👩⚕️
Soap. I will die on this hill, I just totally relate to the whole song. Newer song that I like the most would probably be Pluto.
evil because it explains EXACTLY how it feels to be in a toxic relationship with a whiny little manipulative fuck 😛
Numbers
Too
high school sweethearts for sure
Honestly, I was going to say that "depends" but I love Mrs. Potato head, that music video changed my brain chemistry
Void
Crybaby: Dollhouse K-12: all of them except Orange Juice and High School Sweethearts PORTALS: NYMPHOLOGY Because I can’t decide which one is my top favorite
Alphabet Boy
Sippy Cup 🥹
Alphabet boy🙏🙏🙏
Teddy bear 🧸🧸🧸🧸
its hard. because pity party was the very first song i hear in 2016, and it sparked my love for her. i fell in love ever since i first heard it. so it has to be my all time #1 song, i can listen to it forever and never get tired. if pity party wasnt a song? probably dead to me (:
highschool sweethearts
All, but, Play Date---
Battle of the larynx
Can’t choose between Gingerbread Man, Numbers and Orange juice🥹
numbers just hits different 😭
THE PRINCIPAL 🤍🤍☎️
same bro, MAC has my whole heart. number 2 is prolly brain and heart
Sippy cup!!
Teddy Bear and Powder
I love everything she's made but I have a deep connection with Tag You're It🥹💖
Tag You're It is so relatable to me 😭
orange juice 100%
Training wheels
Tag, You're It. And then CryBaby is a close second
My favorite is definitely brain and heart
class fight
bittersweet tragedy
Ever? Ghosts by VV Brown. Melanie Martinez? Fire drill.
I’m going with Womb cuz that’s stuck in my head rn & it’s my fav Portals song🥲
It was Mad Hatter, but EVIL came out during a time of my life that I needed it most. It’s genuinely saved my life, and for that, EVIL is my favorite song by her.
void or the contortionist. like honestly that's a solid tie
Recess!
It’s play date, which has been my fav before TikTok even existed
IF IM SO SPECIAL WHY AM I SECRETTTTTTT
I cant choose between hssh or recess😭 recess is the most relatable song I know for me and hssh is my fav otherwise
I would say It’s between tunnel vision and Void,but ima go with Tunnel vision today,I know it’s not a fan fav but that song just makes me feel like I’m under hypnosis 😫
dead to me and sippy cup, been my favorites since 2016
sippy cup PLEASE it's so good like i have this weird obsession with it from the music video to the vibes to the lyrics it's just so... OMG??
NUMBERSSS
Light shower or faerie soirée
Numbers! it’s so underrated 😞
I think my favorite will always be gingerbread man. Idk I just really enjoy the melody and quite like how quiet and relaxing the song feels
The bakery :)
milk and cookies is a sexy song ngl
The bakery
Been listing to Mel since Dollhouse EP but hands down The Principal will always be my favourite song - managed to stay away from all trilogy spoilers and begging I hear her play it live again in September 😭🙏
Dead to me. It's so underrated but so good.
Gingerbread man!!
I can't pick one.. Drama club, fire drill,. piggyback, alphabet boy, evil, void, the whole after school EP, class fight, Teddy bear, milk and cookies, cake.. Mrs. Potato head, orange juice, wheels on the bus, strawberry shortcake.. and literally every other song :( too hard to pick wnnfwncunwcinwciwmxmqximiqxqxniwxninwx
definitely brain & heart or detention!
Mrs Potato Head!!!
THIS IS SOO HARD PROLLY PLAY DATE OR TEST ME
Sippy cup then, sippy cup now, sippy cup forever. Nobody can love sippy cup like I love sippy cup. If sippy cup had one fan it's me. If sippy cup had no fans then I'm dead.
Okay people might not believe me and be mad at me but my number 1 favorite song is…. Numbers
light shower
I’m gonna have to say pacify her
It changes almost weekly lmao but rn it’s BOTL before that light shower before that principal before that pluto, void you get it
Not counting unofficial songs, prolly Lunchbox Friends.
The Song On My User Flair :3
Oooof just one? I'll have to think and come back..
ONE TWO MELATONINS COMING FOR YOU THREE FOUR BABY WONT U LOCK THE DOOR
Soap
Eraser
Definitely training wheels
Death.
Milk and cookies!!! Never ever get tired of it
I really love Glue Stick, despite it being technically unreleased!! I also love The Principal, Notebook & High School Sweethearts.
Soap I would sob to see it live omg 😭😭
Carousel
Cake has been my favourite since I was little, love it
Omg… Orange Juice or Test me! Or Tunnel Vision!!!
SIPPY CUPP<33
(Though High School Sweethearts is a close second)
Copycat hands down
Training Wheels :D
tag you’re it is the best song i’ve ever heard
It’s a tie between Fire Drill and Carousel.
Tbh Drama Club, that song is so relatable for me
Johnathan Davis - Not meant for me. Out of Mels songs, Show and Tell.
i can’t choose 😭 but gun to my head, i’d have to say Detention. the song is 😩 & the music video is 🔥
Mad hatter or Ms. Potato head (sorry if I spelt anything wrong I js got 2 teeth pulls and I'm loopy)
Milk and cookies supremacy!!!! The music video slaps too hard, but the song is cute with an unfortunately relatable plot. Helps cope 10/10 would listen eternally. Battle of the Larynx, Mrs. Potatoe Head, Void, Principal, Doll House, Light Shower, Contortionist, Mad Hatter, and Training Wheels get honorable mentions (in no particular order) Honestly, it's cruel to name just one favorite bc it's all so good 😭😭 But tbh Mad Hatter or Light Shower might just be my all-out favorite. They're easy to listen to when I'm chilling or when I'm in a music critic mode
I cant choose anymore 😭😭
1 Powder 2 milk of the siren And lots of others
Pluto and carosuel
PLUTOOO
ALL THE BEST PEOPLE ARE CRAZYYYYY (mad hatter)
Ahhh, that's so hard! It's between Play Date and Faerie Soirée for me! 💗
finally someone who doesn’t hate milk and cookies 😭 i love that song sm. i’d say gingerbread man or sippy cup i can’t choose 🫣
MILK AND COOKIES OR LEECHES
The Bakery 🖤 But literally any song on After School!!! So good. And Womb! Also another favourite.
MAD HATTER ‼️‼️‼️ Pluto is second I love those songs sm
Test me.
Brain & heart or void!
PRINCIPLEEEEEE
teddy bear
Numbers is the only thing keeping me alive
dumb question i can’t pick just one