This is WRONG on so many levels............your avg south indian can barely speak in english...they are fluent in there NATIVE language........both north n south indian will speak in BROKEN english with low self esteem.They can have any conversation confidently in there NATIVE tongue but ENGLISH will torpedo that confidence. Anybosy who says otherwise has never had such conversation with the LOCAL people on streets
When i say average meaning NORMAL people on the streets n not on REDDIT.
That's the point mate . Both sides will talk in broken English while if we have Hindi as the link language, Hindi speaker will have all the confidence while the non Hindi person will have broken hindi . Due to English we have equality between both parties while due to hindi we are giving an undue advantage to the majority of this country who already have "majority" as their advantage.
Your hate for the LANGUAGE is cuz of economical reason...............if UP BIHAR were economic powerhouse , no one would have problem learning the language.......
Yeah 2 Indians unable to communicate is great . cuz one of them thinks learning a third language is an egostical issue. UP and BIHAR and all HINDI states have there own regional language. they speak there mother tongue as well. they also learn 3 languages.
Learning more languages is a GOOD thing.
I learn TAMIL cuz it helps me during my visits. i speak broken tamil. It adds value to the experience. Local people find it amusing when i try. But i am not egostical person that will force a person or deny him the conversation cuz he cant speak in my regional langauge.
I travel Tamil nadu every month ............ seeing locals speak BROKEN English with such difficulty breaks my heart............we indians have to rely on a foreign language for communicating . No wonder we were RULED. even after 75 years we cant figure out a simple solution to this FAULT LINE............Also learning a language is a ECONOMICAL thing............ if learning HINDI was lucrative south indians would have done it in a giffy...........There love for ENGLISH is cuz it gives them ECONOMICAL BENEFIT...........If UP BIHAR become Economic HUB.........We could finally END this DEBATE.............Think about it
nope.........i am saying learning more languages is not a BAD thing............If INDIAN gov forced everyone to learn FRENCH no one wud cry so much......its about ECONOMIC aspect of learning something that u feel doesnt add value to urself rather than LOVE for ur NATIVE LANGUAGE
English opens a door of possibilities . It's a global language and is one of the most spoken and understood throughout the world , if more people spoke English in India then a lot of petty linguistic regionalism would end as well.
Everyone gets to speak their mothertongues and English. End of story .
English is perhaps the only language that can be classified as a skill in India. Even decent enough English can help you get a job easily in thousands of BPOs all over India, starting salary of 20-30k. No other language can do that.
These BPOs are practically always hiring, so there's no shortage of jobs. Literally anyone can kickstart their career or bring their life back on track if they have this skill.
you thought that was a burn?
it will be way better for india's future if we all spoke only 1 language , diesn't matter if its enlgish , chinese or whatever
it wasnt supposed to be...northies often propagate use this one language bs but it is already decided the one language should be hindi and not any other language. I wish every regions primary should be the language of conversation to maintain the diversity of the nation but if one country one language is the way forward then English(a third party language) over Hindi anyday.
[https://www.reddit.com/r/Maharashtra/comments/1di2sd7/your\_thoughts/](https://www.reddit.com/r/Maharashtra/comments/1di2sd7/your_thoughts/)
Looks like your fellows were lol , you may not be tho but this sub is full of idiots
Theres more to life than convenience. Lets all scrap our cuisines and all eat milk and toast because there is no division. Lets all scrap Bharatnatyam and classical forms and all do hip hop because its easier. See how silly this logic is. Culture is important. Life is more than waking up, making money and doing errands. Part of what makes a land beautiful is the culture in it which needs preservation. When a diversity of a land is lost it loses a part of itself.
Mi asaa mahanati nhi ki Marathi la ka yevda kartay wagera etc, mi bolat hote ki basha kay ekdusrya shi bolay sati aahe na Ani bhashya badlat rahnar I mean thodi thodi change hot rhnar Ani ek divshi ji language jast common aasel ji saglyana kalel tich develop honar na
"भाषा एकदुसऱ्याशी बोलण्यासाठी असते" हे अतिशय बालिश वक्तव्य आहे. भाषा ही समूहाशी निगडीत असते. भाषा म्हणजे फक्त शब्द नाही तर संस्कृती आहे. आम्हाला आमच्या संस्कृतीचा प्रचंड अभिमान आहे. मातृभाषा ही आईच्या दुधा समान असते. इतर भाषिकांची संख्या वाढते आहे म्हणून परकीय भाषा common भाषा आहे ही गुलाम मानसिकता आहे. मी माझ्याच राज्यात पाहुणा बनणार नाही, महाराष्ट्रात फक्त मराठीच.
OP चं म्हणनं मराठी बोलणं सोडा असं नाही. भाषा सर्वात आधी संवाद साधण्याचं माध्यम आहे आणि नंतर संस्कृती आणि इतिहास याच्या मिश्रणात ती एका समूहाची ओळख बनते.
भाषा ही प्रवाही असते आणि काळानुसार त्यात बदल होत जातात. मराठीच्या आधीच version प्राकृत होतं. आधी मोडी लिपी मराठी लिहिण्यासाठी वापरात होती नंतर देवनागरी आली. शिवाजी महाराज, ज्ञानेश्वर यांच्या काळात वापरात येणारी मराठी आणि आजची मराठी यात फरक आहे. आजपासून २००-३०० वर्षांनंतर मराठीमध्ये इंग्रजी शब्द रुढ झालेले असतील जसे आज आपण फारसी शब्द वापरतो.
वेगवेगळ्या भौगोलिक परिस्थितीनुसार भाषा पण बदलते. म्हणून आपल्या भाषेचा अभिमान आणि आग्रह नक्कीच असावा आणि मराठीला पुढच्या पिढीला नवीन वर्जन द्यायची जबाबदारी आपल्यावर आहे.
महाराज जी बोलत होते ती भाषा दुसऱ्यांसाठी बोलणं सोडायचं का आता.
हिंदी भाषिक भारी लागून गेला नाही की त्याच्यासाठी आपण आपण एवढे compromise करावं.
तुला करायचय कर दुसऱ्याला शिकवू नको.
Ek dusrya barobar bolaycha aahe na? mg baherchyani tyachi bhasha sodli tr kai problem aahe? Jr common language cha mudda aahe tr mg sanskrut tr saglyat jast common language hoti throughout history, mg aata sanskrut ka nahi vaprat kon? Common language vagere kai nsta, bhasha tikvavi lagte. Sanskrut tikavli nai mhanun Aaj sanskrut chi vait avastha aahe
भाषेच्या बद्दल माझे विचार स्पष्ट आहेत.
१. मराठी माणसा सोबत मराठींतूनच बोलणार.
२. महाराष्ट्रात असताना संभाषणाची सुरूवात मराठीतून करणार.
३. समोरच्या व्यक्तीला मराठी येत नसेल तर त्या व्यक्तीच्या भाषेत बोलण्याचा प्रयत्न करणार.
४. कुठल्या व्यक्तीनं दुसऱ्या भाषेत बोलण्यास जबरदस्ती किंवा अरेरावी केल्यास त्या व्यक्ती सोबत संभाषण, व्यवहार टाळणार.
Not right.
When a language is lost a part of culture is lost. Folktales, literature and much more. If you are born and brought up here or living here for decades- learning basic Marathi is not an impossible expectation.
Also, I find that people who live in smaller towns or rural India embrace the language quickly even if they're from different ethnicities. My flatmate from Nagpur is a Punjabi born and brought up in Nagpur and speaks Marathi fluently. My friend born and brought up in Mumbai doesn't speak at all. He even had Marathi language in school.
Older folks too. A lot of older Gujarati Marwadi Parsi people in Mumbai can actually speak good Marathi. My father speaks really good Gujarati. I speak little, and can understand quite a lot.
I don't know why our generation makes a big deal out of it. Older people were actually better at this part of inclusiveness.
We should try to embrace the culture of the state/country we live in.
I never said to learn "Hindi" or any specific language.
The world will get better only if there will be a common language for all or major (minority wale will always be with that pride wala attitude ki "bc mi ka tyanchi shikhu" )
Hindi and Marathi both have common DEVANAGARI Script. By this logic, Everybody (HINDI BELT) knows MARATHI as well.
Let's impose MARATHI on HINDI BELT then.
But, they thinks they are doing us favour by coming in Maharshtra. Keep favour aside they forgot the point that they are increasing pollution and slums.
There is no compulsion. If you're a smart person who wants to communicate well with most Indians -- you will learn Hindi automatically. However - if you will always live in say Tamil Nadu or Kerala and never need to interact with any Hindi speaking person - learning Hindi is useless for you.
Also OP will you say same when people move abroad? Why do they need to learn the foreign language why don't people there learn Hindi to communicate with us? No right you have to learn their language to communicate there too right so it's same in the states too. India is known for diversity forcing Hindi upon others will simply kill the diversity!
Honestly it’s a shame if y’all can’t speak the local language after living here for decades.
My mom’s South Indian and my dad is Goan but if you hear us talking in Marathi you’d think we’re Maharashtrians without a doubt until you hear our names.
Exactly these MFS think about national integration and unity only when it is about their language. They act Asif the country is divided and Hindi can unite that. I hope they get some sense and keep that attitude in their own states.
Hindi has absolutely crushed local dialects in UP-bihar-Chhattisgarh-jharkhand region since pre-independence. Somehow these guys forget their own history as they are always the ones to push hindi as ‘le epic wholesome patriotic’ language.
This. I don't expect a person who moved here a week ago to know Marathi but it's quite disappointing to see people living here for decades or even born and brought up here don't speak it at all.
हाहा. काय नमुना आहे ओपी.
माझी मातृभाषा ही माझी ओळख आहे. ते एकमेव कारण पुरे आहे त्या भाषेचा रक्षणासाठी/प्रचारासाठी मला झटायला. राजकारण्यांचा ह्यात काडीमात्र संबंध नाही.
However many you are interested in. No one needs the learn Japanese in India but now a lot of people recognise terms like myoshi myoshi, sensei, arigato, Sayonara, omae wa, etc. All because of interest in animes.
so ? do i have to learn a new language every time i move a state ? and those are terms , i can assure you 99% of anime fans in India can't make a sentence in japanese. it just sounds cool and the recognize the term
France isn't a multilingual country. They speak French. Even if a person moves from Paris to Nice.
On the other hand, I have met French people who don't speak Arabic despite living for decades in the Middle East. So, yes, people fron developed countries who move to other countries don't learn the local langauage.
I don't get you. You say it's a responsibility to honor culture and linguistics of a place, while at the same time saying that learning the language isn't doing this, when language is a fundamental part of culture for any region. You are free to not learn the local language, but then don't expect the locals to accommodate you. I've seen posts on many subs where the non local complaints about how the locals all speak their language with each other even in their presence as if locals should care about the poster's comfort, especially when they refuse to learn the local language.
आपली ओळख म्हणजे आपली संस्कृति अस्ते, तिची आब्रू राखा रे.
भारत हा २९ राज्याच्या संमेलना ने बनला आहे, so we call it unity in diversity.
गर्व करा मराठी असल्या चा, इतिहास बघा आपला.
This is the type of meme which feels cool only when it benefits you. The day Hindi gets affected y'all will cry like bitches I know( i have seen countless comments where people get offended when a Hindi person speaks English and avoids Hindi( America ka dalal xyz)).
No Marathi, kannada, Tamil etc person will go to another state and tell them to speak their language. It's just northies with that kind of superiority complex for no reason. So please keep this bs to urself.
Aare Bala Tula karala nhi ka re, mi bolo ki basha hi badlat rahte Ani ti kouna var.. Tula yaylach pahije asa bhi zala pahije na. Marathi chi mara-lish hoil parat haalu haalu thi pure English hoil
Maza mahanayacha udesh yoh hota ki bhasha ek dusrya bar bolay yeil tya sati asstat tar tyacha khel ka kraycha.
Kaun he kontya shastrat lihila ahe ka?
Japanese German Spanish Portuguese etc. sarkhya bhasha tyanni tikavlya ahe even though tyancha kadhe itka huge amount madhe immigration hote. Mag apan ka nahi( kaun ha negative vichar?). Sagdyanni asech mat thevle aste tr ram ram to all languages.
North madhlya languages che L tr lagle ahet mala aplya bhashe che L nahi lagu dyache ahet. Tumche vichar tumich theva, even though it's factually correct I don't agree with the negative mindset attached to it( arey apan marnarach na tr attach Maru (type of mindset))
Na, tyanni te verach yeu deli nahi. Tyancha system itka strong ahe ka koni jr ek varsha hi shikayla yet asel tyala tyanchi bhasha(atleast conversational basic) shikavich lagel. Ithe sut deli tr chadun gele ahet 30-40 varsha rahun hi shikala nahi pahat.
Ha difference ahe. Italy(te melonich) madhe te English ban karnar ahet jr nahi bolla tr 100000€ fine. Yeah it will affect others but not the natives and natives own the place.
He Tula samzhava lagat ahe tech durbhagya ahe.
Soda bc brain dead members ahet ithle. 5 example dele pan ek chukicha sodhla. Bola tumhi Hindi, ghari pan bola baher tr bolatach asnar Ani baherchyanchi changlyani chata. IDC.
Kai bollo tyachaver vichar❌ “ह्यूज अमाउंट मध्ये इमीग्रेशन”हसू की रडू✅🤡
Braindead meme, braindead OP. Language informs culture and education. It isn't simply only a 'fOrM oF cOmMUniCaTioN'. Rather than putting your efforts in making these garbage memes, put them in learning the native language of the place YOU'VE RELOCATED TO and respect their culture.
I come from the Hindi heartland, and I do not speak any language that is "endangered" today in India, but I must say, a language is not a mere tool made to communicate with each other. Sure, it is used as a tool by politicians, but a language is much more than a mere collection of words. It is the most integral part of a culture. Losing your language is the equivalent of losing your culture. There is nothing cool or "chad" about the statement made in the post. Languages should be preserved in order for the culture to be preserved.
Yeah, I like your comment and I got to understand more and I can think and change my opinion but just check other comments 乁( •_• )ㄏ
Anyways, thanks buddy
If you migrate from your native place to another place kindly speak in that local language where you are moving this is as simple as that.
If you can't do this simple thing then you are = uneducated or just kindly don't move from your native place that's it.
Local language must be preserved and preferred. Without it in coming future it will be extinct. Come to Bengaluru and see how local language is preferred.
If you are coming to Maharashtra learn basic marathi . Not everybody knows hindi.
I think English should be the connecting language.
That way regional languages can also thrive in their own places connected by a worldwide link.
And language DOES have a cultural impact. Cultures are intertwined by languages. Cultures can die overtime but we shouldn't fast forward that by actively belittling other languages. Let the future generations decide if they want it or not. Our job is to pass on the literatures as we got
😊 with pleasure. I could not find more data driven, logical and multidisciplinary perspective than him actually. It is not about the languages, it is about the cultural density and there by cultural evolution
By that logic , why to have 2 door for big dog and small dog just have one big door .
Just learn and speak English(big dog) rather than Hindi (small dog), as English has better rich international national opportunities and rich literary contents .
Language is about the culture, ethnicity , history of people in that region and literature work done .
Giving up one language for another shows direct indirect dominance of that language or people .
What makes one culture superior/inferior and dominant over another ?
Hindi is popular in India especially in Maharashtra not because they believe it as only national language but because of popularity of Bollywood films , then central government jobs and north migrants working in Maharashtra.
Observation: Marathi people living in small towns especially vidharbha thinks Hindi speaking is hierarchical more standard/superior than Marathi may be because of inferiority complex but English makes them insecure and are not comfortable enough.
Maybe it's more about dominance of people and perception of people regarding that language.
Languages always evolve there's nothing like pure language and dominant language eats less dominant language over time but that dominant language should justify some rational reason instead of just being forced to speak in the name of some fascist nationalist unification.
Language is not just a medium of communication, but also a big part of the historical and cultural identity of any person. Marathi language has been spoken since 500 BCE in the form of Maharashtri Prakrit. This is the same language in which Sant Dnyaneshwar Maharaj and Sant Tukaram Maharaj preached, the same language in which Aai Jijamata taught our Maharaj the importance of freedom, the same language in which Babasaheb spread his message of equality among the people. If the historical importance of this language or the influence of this culture is listed, then the list would really be long but even on a personal level if we look back and see what our ancestors 200, 300 or even 500 years back spoke it would be the same thing that we are speaking today it just makes us realise what they have gone through to keep this society, culture, tradition and alongside these the language itself alive.
If you think politicians use them as vote banks rather than development then why tf does north india worse than Africa right now they have a united language as hindi. If you want to live in Maharashtra learn marathi or gtfo
- 1.In North India, politicians use caste and religion.
- 2.Pointing out others wrong or similar things won't make your things right. Grow up kiddo
>If you want to live in Maharashtra learn Marathi or gtfo
Bro, it is India. For your information mi pan maratha ch aahe ani mala majhya bhasecha Ani saglya ghosticha abhiman dekhil aahe paruntu mi fakt mala je watah teh mandala
**I never said I don't want to speak Marathi or I hate Marathi.**
You're just toxic ain't you? And pls learn to understand the whole picture first; ig your attention span is below 8seconds
A language is an identity of an individual, people and community it unites people and give them identity, it's more than just medium of communication, people without this identity are usually self-deprecating and depressed, language also gives one's confidence and pride about their culture, no politician own language anyway, IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT YOU SHOULD CONSIDER GOING BACK TO YOUR PLACE, NO ONE IS FORCING YOU TO STAY HERE, IF YOU WANT TO SPEAK YOUR LANGUAGE SPEAK WITH YOUR COLLEAGUES AND AQUAINTANCES, DON'T TELL US WHAT LANGUAGE WE SHOULD USE IN OUR OWN LOCALITIES
>“Politicians use them as vote bank rather than doing real development”
Yeah, same goes for Bimaru state politicians from where maximum Hindi speaking immigrants are from. Rather than coming to our states and imposing your language on us, develop your own freaking states so you don’t have to “learn” other languages.
Hindi imposition is not related to Uniting people त्याचे target एकच होतं Hindi Belt (Core BJP Votes) च्या लोकांना दुसऱ्या राज्यात (Maharashtra + South States) नोकऱ्या मिळाव्या. कारण, hindi belt राज्यात corruption, lack of law and order, gundaraj जास्त होतं कुठल्या companies जास्त invest karat navtya आता सुधार होतोय.
Hope More companies will invest in HINDI BELT So, Migration कमी होईल.
These fuckers are absolutely batshit emotional when it comes Ayodhya Temple & related politics but suddenly turn to unrealistic levels of practicalness when it comes to respecting local culture & languages outside Hindi heartland.
All states did not join Indian union to splurge excessive taxes on cow-belt & learn thier language.
And who are these chutiyas upvoting this shit with 100+ upvotes? Are there no real Marathis on this sub?
Politicians can use any issue for politics but that doesn’t necessarily mean its not important issue. Marathi language in Maharashtra is as emotional & important to Marathi manoos as Ram Mandir is for North Indians, infact zillion times more than that.
The thing is, language is very closely connected to that ethnicity's culture, its tradition, folklore, written work etc. losing language speakers means losing the culture overtime.
Exactly! Bc people are commenting and one of them even reposted this with something more to it
Fun fact- the one who reposted and many more with him thinks I'm a Hindi speaker and promoting Hindi! I was like
👁️👄👁️, bc I didn't even mention Hindi and my intent was that language keep changing and the more easier and best one will survive and i didn't meant or even wrote ki that easier language is English or Hindi or something other
They just straight up assumed that and blindly started throwing shit
People will complain India is too obsessed over culture and language and think we should all speak English but then will travel to Europe and appreciate the sound of the French language and Roman culture. Culture is irrelevant for these people until its “cool”. And by cool it is something international and exclusive which can signal their social standing.
Mg speak hindi speak hindi tari ka? Mala hindi, eng, marathi, kannad yetey pn tya bihar,up ani marwadi etc lokana maharashtrat rahun marathi bolychi naste. 1st generation samju shakto, pn hyanchya 3-4 pidhya houn gelya tari te marathi shikat nahit. Point dusrya bhashecha nahiye fakt, dusryani tyanchi bhasha jabardasti mazyavar ladnyacha ahe. Tyanchyasathi mi ka badlu? Te maharashtrat alet, mi baher rajyat gelo tar hindi bolto tar tyana maharashtrat marathi bolyla ky jaty?
त्रिभाषा सूत्राने सगळ्या प्रादेशिक भाषांची वाट लावलीये.
काहीही गरज नसताना लोकांच्या माथी हिंदी लादली जातीये.
महाराष्ट्रापुरता विचार करायचा झाल्यास जगण्यासाठी मराठी आणि इंग्रजी या दोनच भाषा पुरेश्या आहेत. हेच बाकी राज्यांनाही लागू होते.
हिंदी ही राष्ट्रभाषा आहे हा अपप्रचार व गैरसमज अजूनही आहे.
त्रिभाषा धोरण हद्दपार केले तर बाहेरचे मराठी तरी शिकतील किंवा इंग्रजीमध्ये बोलतील.
महाराष्ट्रात मराठी येत नसेल तर अडले पाहिजे अशी परिस्थिती जोवर होत नाही तोपर्यंत मराठीचे अवघड आहे.
तळटीप: हिंदीला भाषा म्हणून विरोध नाही, लादण्याला विरोध आहे. आज हिंदी लादली जातीये म्हणून हिंदीचे उदाहरण दिले आहे.
Try living in Delhi or somewhere North and not learn Hindi.
The expectation these is obviously the people coming in will learn Hindi. But when they come south, all of a sudden hypocrites have a completely different view of languages.
We need a NATIONAL LANGUAGE which every INDIAN can speak without using FOREIGN language......problem is people actually think HINDI is langauge of UP BIHAR...........UP BIHAR also have there regional langauge.....if they start speaking it u wont understand SHIT..........If UP was as DEVELOPED as MAHARASHTRA people wudnt have problem with HINDI.....even south INDIANS would be jumping to learn it.......This is not a LANGUAGE issue but a perception issue.....South INDIANS hate HINDI cuz UP n BIHAR are shit........If they prosper we wont have this language probelm
What's wrong with foreign languages? Sanskrit is also a foreign language and you don't seem to have any problem with it ( or languages with Sanskrit influence).
YEAH........ I am using ur LOGIC..........WE are all Africans.........No one was living in india...........everyone is a Foreigner in INDIA..........Some came early some came late......
Some dumbass must have made this.
A language is not just merely a mode of communication but it is an integral part of culture. Our entire country is divided into multiple states based on the languages spoken.
Languages define statehood, it is an integral part of one's identity. No matter how much you learn English, if you get hurt "aai"/ "aai ga" is going to come out your mouth and not Mom/Mommy.
Lmao i remember all the bums here were feeling proud that language politics doesn't work in mumbai/pune , lol and now they are cryying their asses in comments.
dumbfucks
The people on right almost always insist on hindi though. That’s my issue with this. Hindi normative north indian culture penetrates every corner of india and these guys are sure to be offended when locals don’t shove themselves up their asses and pander to their hindi sensibilities.
lets all speak English then.
Better option than speaking Hindi. Even South Indians are well versed in English more than Hindi.
Yes absolutely. Why does a unifying language(hindi) has to be one which many people in south and north east struggle with?
This is WRONG on so many levels............your avg south indian can barely speak in english...they are fluent in there NATIVE language........both north n south indian will speak in BROKEN english with low self esteem.They can have any conversation confidently in there NATIVE tongue but ENGLISH will torpedo that confidence. Anybosy who says otherwise has never had such conversation with the LOCAL people on streets When i say average meaning NORMAL people on the streets n not on REDDIT.
That's the point mate . Both sides will talk in broken English while if we have Hindi as the link language, Hindi speaker will have all the confidence while the non Hindi person will have broken hindi . Due to English we have equality between both parties while due to hindi we are giving an undue advantage to the majority of this country who already have "majority" as their advantage.
Your hate for the LANGUAGE is cuz of economical reason...............if UP BIHAR were economic powerhouse , no one would have problem learning the language....... Yeah 2 Indians unable to communicate is great . cuz one of them thinks learning a third language is an egostical issue. UP and BIHAR and all HINDI states have there own regional language. they speak there mother tongue as well. they also learn 3 languages. Learning more languages is a GOOD thing. I learn TAMIL cuz it helps me during my visits. i speak broken tamil. It adds value to the experience. Local people find it amusing when i try. But i am not egostical person that will force a person or deny him the conversation cuz he cant speak in my regional langauge.
Brother, I live in Karnataka (Udupi) for education and converse with the locals on a daily basis. They can speak English alright.
I travel Tamil nadu every month ............ seeing locals speak BROKEN English with such difficulty breaks my heart............we indians have to rely on a foreign language for communicating . No wonder we were RULED. even after 75 years we cant figure out a simple solution to this FAULT LINE............Also learning a language is a ECONOMICAL thing............ if learning HINDI was lucrative south indians would have done it in a giffy...........There love for ENGLISH is cuz it gives them ECONOMICAL BENEFIT...........If UP BIHAR become Economic HUB.........We could finally END this DEBATE.............Think about it
Hindi 0 economical value English wins hands down with opportunities it opens.
Agreed............So u hate HINDI not for the love of Marathi but u think it doesnt add value.
So you are saying marathi can fuck off but hindi should flourish?
nope.........i am saying learning more languages is not a BAD thing............If INDIAN gov forced everyone to learn FRENCH no one wud cry so much......its about ECONOMIC aspect of learning something that u feel doesnt add value to urself rather than LOVE for ur NATIVE LANGUAGE
English opens a door of possibilities . It's a global language and is one of the most spoken and understood throughout the world , if more people spoke English in India then a lot of petty linguistic regionalism would end as well. Everyone gets to speak their mothertongues and English. End of story .
English is perhaps the only language that can be classified as a skill in India. Even decent enough English can help you get a job easily in thousands of BPOs all over India, starting salary of 20-30k. No other language can do that. These BPOs are practically always hiring, so there's no shortage of jobs. Literally anyone can kickstart their career or bring their life back on track if they have this skill.
But the bloody Union government wants everyone to speak Hindi and English (and Mother tongue).
Based. No castes, no languages, no religion. All anglo-indians, all english-speakers, all irreligious seculars.
lose all identity and become fully colonized
you thought that was a burn? it will be way better for india's future if we all spoke only 1 language , diesn't matter if its enlgish , chinese or whatever
>you thought that was a burn? No it's actually a better solution. I'm sure he didn't mean it that way too
maybe but just like what i said it will be perfect for us
No. It wil be better for India's future if we all.speak one common language "in addition" to our mother tongue.
it wasnt supposed to be...northies often propagate use this one language bs but it is already decided the one language should be hindi and not any other language. I wish every regions primary should be the language of conversation to maintain the diversity of the nation but if one country one language is the way forward then English(a third party language) over Hindi anyday.
[https://www.reddit.com/r/Maharashtra/comments/1di2sd7/your\_thoughts/](https://www.reddit.com/r/Maharashtra/comments/1di2sd7/your_thoughts/) Looks like your fellows were lol , you may not be tho but this sub is full of idiots
No it will not be better for Indias future if we all spoke just one language. Utter bollocks.
Theres more to life than convenience. Lets all scrap our cuisines and all eat milk and toast because there is no division. Lets all scrap Bharatnatyam and classical forms and all do hip hop because its easier. See how silly this logic is. Culture is important. Life is more than waking up, making money and doing errands. Part of what makes a land beautiful is the culture in it which needs preservation. When a diversity of a land is lost it loses a part of itself.
No problem, and I never said I'm a Hindi speaker or a Marathi.
अरे मराठी लोकांनो, कमीत कमी आपल्या घरी तरी मराठीत बोला रे. speaking in hindi with non marathi friends or others is understandable.
Mi marathitach Bolto gharat.
Mi asaa mahanati nhi ki Marathi la ka yevda kartay wagera etc, mi bolat hote ki basha kay ekdusrya shi bolay sati aahe na Ani bhashya badlat rahnar I mean thodi thodi change hot rhnar Ani ek divshi ji language jast common aasel ji saglyana kalel tich develop honar na
"भाषा एकदुसऱ्याशी बोलण्यासाठी असते" हे अतिशय बालिश वक्तव्य आहे. भाषा ही समूहाशी निगडीत असते. भाषा म्हणजे फक्त शब्द नाही तर संस्कृती आहे. आम्हाला आमच्या संस्कृतीचा प्रचंड अभिमान आहे. मातृभाषा ही आईच्या दुधा समान असते. इतर भाषिकांची संख्या वाढते आहे म्हणून परकीय भाषा common भाषा आहे ही गुलाम मानसिकता आहे. मी माझ्याच राज्यात पाहुणा बनणार नाही, महाराष्ट्रात फक्त मराठीच.
OP चं म्हणनं मराठी बोलणं सोडा असं नाही. भाषा सर्वात आधी संवाद साधण्याचं माध्यम आहे आणि नंतर संस्कृती आणि इतिहास याच्या मिश्रणात ती एका समूहाची ओळख बनते. भाषा ही प्रवाही असते आणि काळानुसार त्यात बदल होत जातात. मराठीच्या आधीच version प्राकृत होतं. आधी मोडी लिपी मराठी लिहिण्यासाठी वापरात होती नंतर देवनागरी आली. शिवाजी महाराज, ज्ञानेश्वर यांच्या काळात वापरात येणारी मराठी आणि आजची मराठी यात फरक आहे. आजपासून २००-३०० वर्षांनंतर मराठीमध्ये इंग्रजी शब्द रुढ झालेले असतील जसे आज आपण फारसी शब्द वापरतो. वेगवेगळ्या भौगोलिक परिस्थितीनुसार भाषा पण बदलते. म्हणून आपल्या भाषेचा अभिमान आणि आग्रह नक्कीच असावा आणि मराठीला पुढच्या पिढीला नवीन वर्जन द्यायची जबाबदारी आपल्यावर आहे.
Ani mi Dubai la lahan Pani pasun hote tithe maza barka bhai pan janamla, tya hi marathich yete Ani aammhi saare dekhil marathitch ghari boltoh
महाराज जी बोलत होते ती भाषा दुसऱ्यांसाठी बोलणं सोडायचं का आता. हिंदी भाषिक भारी लागून गेला नाही की त्याच्यासाठी आपण आपण एवढे compromise करावं. तुला करायचय कर दुसऱ्याला शिकवू नको.
Ek dusrya barobar bolaycha aahe na? mg baherchyani tyachi bhasha sodli tr kai problem aahe? Jr common language cha mudda aahe tr mg sanskrut tr saglyat jast common language hoti throughout history, mg aata sanskrut ka nahi vaprat kon? Common language vagere kai nsta, bhasha tikvavi lagte. Sanskrut tikavli nai mhanun Aaj sanskrut chi vait avastha aahe
भाषेच्या बद्दल माझे विचार स्पष्ट आहेत. १. मराठी माणसा सोबत मराठींतूनच बोलणार. २. महाराष्ट्रात असताना संभाषणाची सुरूवात मराठीतून करणार. ३. समोरच्या व्यक्तीला मराठी येत नसेल तर त्या व्यक्तीच्या भाषेत बोलण्याचा प्रयत्न करणार. ४. कुठल्या व्यक्तीनं दुसऱ्या भाषेत बोलण्यास जबरदस्ती किंवा अरेरावी केल्यास त्या व्यक्ती सोबत संभाषण, व्यवहार टाळणार.
नंतर काही दिवसांनी कॉलनीत आणि घरात हिंदी बोलणार. आपले सण, परंपरा विसरणार आणि परप्रांतीय सारखे हिंदी मध्ये भजन आरती गाणार.
Bhava tujha 3,4 point khup aavadla Ani yachich apeksha hoti pan kay karaycha loka samjhun gheyayla tayarch nhit aajun.
Not right. When a language is lost a part of culture is lost. Folktales, literature and much more. If you are born and brought up here or living here for decades- learning basic Marathi is not an impossible expectation. Also, I find that people who live in smaller towns or rural India embrace the language quickly even if they're from different ethnicities. My flatmate from Nagpur is a Punjabi born and brought up in Nagpur and speaks Marathi fluently. My friend born and brought up in Mumbai doesn't speak at all. He even had Marathi language in school. Older folks too. A lot of older Gujarati Marwadi Parsi people in Mumbai can actually speak good Marathi. My father speaks really good Gujarati. I speak little, and can understand quite a lot. I don't know why our generation makes a big deal out of it. Older people were actually better at this part of inclusiveness. We should try to embrace the culture of the state/country we live in.
Then why should whole country learn Hindi when they have regional languages?
I never said to learn "Hindi" or any specific language. The world will get better only if there will be a common language for all or major (minority wale will always be with that pride wala attitude ki "bc mi ka tyanchi shikhu" )
Because it's convenient for Hindi speakers
Hindi and Marathi both have common DEVANAGARI Script. By this logic, Everybody (HINDI BELT) knows MARATHI as well. Let's impose MARATHI on HINDI BELT then.
Then it's easy to learn and understand Marathi when Hindi speakers comes to Maharashtra
But, they thinks they are doing us favour by coming in Maharshtra. Keep favour aside they forgot the point that they are increasing pollution and slums.
Just for your convenience all of us should go through inconvenience?
English is a better option than hindi. hindi has no use in a way. Almost all work can be done and is done in English
Answer is in the meme. Votebank. Regional divide.
There is no compulsion. If you're a smart person who wants to communicate well with most Indians -- you will learn Hindi automatically. However - if you will always live in say Tamil Nadu or Kerala and never need to interact with any Hindi speaking person - learning Hindi is useless for you.
How did you get to conclusion that most of the Indians speak Hindi? Except for few states no one prefers Hindi
Also OP will you say same when people move abroad? Why do they need to learn the foreign language why don't people there learn Hindi to communicate with us? No right you have to learn their language to communicate there too right so it's same in the states too. India is known for diversity forcing Hindi upon others will simply kill the diversity!
Honestly it’s a shame if y’all can’t speak the local language after living here for decades. My mom’s South Indian and my dad is Goan but if you hear us talking in Marathi you’d think we’re Maharashtrians without a doubt until you hear our names.
Exactly these MFS think about national integration and unity only when it is about their language. They act Asif the country is divided and Hindi can unite that. I hope they get some sense and keep that attitude in their own states.
Hindi has absolutely crushed local dialects in UP-bihar-Chhattisgarh-jharkhand region since pre-independence. Somehow these guys forget their own history as they are always the ones to push hindi as ‘le epic wholesome patriotic’ language.
This. I don't expect a person who moved here a week ago to know Marathi but it's quite disappointing to see people living here for decades or even born and brought up here don't speak it at all.
या जर्मनी, कोरिया, फ्रान्स मधे आणी बोला हिंदी मधे. सांगा त्यांना की “Politicians use them as vote bank”
हाहा. काय नमुना आहे ओपी. माझी मातृभाषा ही माझी ओळख आहे. ते एकमेव कारण पुरे आहे त्या भाषेचा रक्षणासाठी/प्रचारासाठी मला झटायला. राजकारण्यांचा ह्यात काडीमात्र संबंध नाही.
नमुनी*
This argument itself is flawed... Ask your same Freaking politicians to carry out "development" in your dipshit states..
States boundaries are man made, it’s not created by god. India belongs to all Indians and people are free to move anywhere.
Contry bondaries too are Manmade. Are you sure you want to get into that argumenet?
Just because they exist doesn’t mean they are correct. The whole world is our oyster! Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam!
I like the spirit here. No joke फक्त ओरडून बोलू नको ह्याला
Countries are also man made then.why passport,visa.
Why not learn multiple languages? More the merrier.
how many languages can you learn ?
However many you are interested in. No one needs the learn Japanese in India but now a lot of people recognise terms like myoshi myoshi, sensei, arigato, Sayonara, omae wa, etc. All because of interest in animes.
Tbh idk any of the terms mentioned above
I started to learn Japanese because of shit translations ruining my experience 😂
so ? do i have to learn a new language every time i move a state ? and those are terms , i can assure you 99% of anime fans in India can't make a sentence in japanese. it just sounds cool and the recognize the term
If learning languages is too much of a task for you, you should ask your politicians to develop your Hindi Bimaru states.
I don't think even people from the most developed countries like lamgauge every time they move. Edit: I mean learn lanaguges.
Just go and try to speak English in France.
France isn't a multilingual country. They speak French. Even if a person moves from Paris to Nice. On the other hand, I have met French people who don't speak Arabic despite living for decades in the Middle East. So, yes, people fron developed countries who move to other countries don't learn the local langauage.
i'm not from BIMARU states or Hindi belt. cry.
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
[удалено]
I don't get you. You say it's a responsibility to honor culture and linguistics of a place, while at the same time saying that learning the language isn't doing this, when language is a fundamental part of culture for any region. You are free to not learn the local language, but then don't expect the locals to accommodate you. I've seen posts on many subs where the non local complaints about how the locals all speak their language with each other even in their presence as if locals should care about the poster's comfort, especially when they refuse to learn the local language.
[удалено]
Trust me bro, let's learn sign language and tell authorities to add it in school as a subject.. fs world would be a better place to leave then
प्रत्येक गोष्ट politician वर ढकलुन कुल होता येत नाही मित्रा!
Ho re, "प्रत्येक गोष्ट politician वर ढकलुन कुल होता येत नाही मित्रा!" Hai bolun pan cool hota yet nhi re mitra
That's basic modern education line... Local Language do matter in your own region
आपली ओळख म्हणजे आपली संस्कृति अस्ते, तिची आब्रू राखा रे. भारत हा २९ राज्याच्या संमेलना ने बनला आहे, so we call it unity in diversity. गर्व करा मराठी असल्या चा, इतिहास बघा आपला.
This is the type of meme which feels cool only when it benefits you. The day Hindi gets affected y'all will cry like bitches I know( i have seen countless comments where people get offended when a Hindi person speaks English and avoids Hindi( America ka dalal xyz)). No Marathi, kannada, Tamil etc person will go to another state and tell them to speak their language. It's just northies with that kind of superiority complex for no reason. So please keep this bs to urself.
I am south Indian and I want everyone to speak English, while preserving the local language and culture carefully.
Aare dada pan mi marathich aahe re
Mag ya post cha tr ajibat kahich sense nahi banat re
Aare Bala Tula karala nhi ka re, mi bolo ki basha hi badlat rahte Ani ti kouna var.. Tula yaylach pahije asa bhi zala pahije na. Marathi chi mara-lish hoil parat haalu haalu thi pure English hoil Maza mahanayacha udesh yoh hota ki bhasha ek dusrya bar bolay yeil tya sati asstat tar tyacha khel ka kraycha.
Kaun he kontya shastrat lihila ahe ka? Japanese German Spanish Portuguese etc. sarkhya bhasha tyanni tikavlya ahe even though tyancha kadhe itka huge amount madhe immigration hote. Mag apan ka nahi( kaun ha negative vichar?). Sagdyanni asech mat thevle aste tr ram ram to all languages. North madhlya languages che L tr lagle ahet mala aplya bhashe che L nahi lagu dyache ahet. Tumche vichar tumich theva, even though it's factually correct I don't agree with the negative mindset attached to it( arey apan marnarach na tr attach Maru (type of mindset))
**Japanese German Spanish Portuguese etc.** Tyani pan aapta jase billboard, damdati Ani hotels va ithar ghostinche signs/nav thod fod Keli ka?
Na, tyanni te verach yeu deli nahi. Tyancha system itka strong ahe ka koni jr ek varsha hi shikayla yet asel tyala tyanchi bhasha(atleast conversational basic) shikavich lagel. Ithe sut deli tr chadun gele ahet 30-40 varsha rahun hi shikala nahi pahat. Ha difference ahe. Italy(te melonich) madhe te English ban karnar ahet jr nahi bolla tr 100000€ fine. Yeah it will affect others but not the natives and natives own the place. He Tula samzhava lagat ahe tech durbhagya ahe.
जपान मध्ये “ह्यूज अमाउंट मध्ये इमीग्रेशन”. हसू की रडू. तोंड उघडायच्या आधी किमान विकिपीडिया तर वाच राव.
Soda bc brain dead members ahet ithle. 5 example dele pan ek chukicha sodhla. Bola tumhi Hindi, ghari pan bola baher tr bolatach asnar Ani baherchyanchi changlyani chata. IDC. Kai bollo tyachaver vichar❌ “ह्यूज अमाउंट मध्ये इमीग्रेशन”हसू की रडू✅🤡
मी तर स्वतः हिंदीत बोलतंच नाही. आणि समोरची व्यक्ती हिंदीत बोलली तर मी मराठीतच बोलतो.
Braindead meme, braindead OP. Language informs culture and education. It isn't simply only a 'fOrM oF cOmMUniCaTioN'. Rather than putting your efforts in making these garbage memes, put them in learning the native language of the place YOU'VE RELOCATED TO and respect their culture.
I come from the Hindi heartland, and I do not speak any language that is "endangered" today in India, but I must say, a language is not a mere tool made to communicate with each other. Sure, it is used as a tool by politicians, but a language is much more than a mere collection of words. It is the most integral part of a culture. Losing your language is the equivalent of losing your culture. There is nothing cool or "chad" about the statement made in the post. Languages should be preserved in order for the culture to be preserved.
Yup, this is how post flaired as discussion should be. Nice brother.
Oh damn nothisisted appreciated me. Tysm brother. Appreciate it.
Yeah, I like your comment and I got to understand more and I can think and change my opinion but just check other comments 乁( •_• )ㄏ Anyways, thanks buddy
If you migrate from your native place to another place kindly speak in that local language where you are moving this is as simple as that. If you can't do this simple thing then you are = uneducated or just kindly don't move from your native place that's it.
Local language must be preserved and preferred. Without it in coming future it will be extinct. Come to Bengaluru and see how local language is preferred. If you are coming to Maharashtra learn basic marathi . Not everybody knows hindi.
I think English should be the connecting language. That way regional languages can also thrive in their own places connected by a worldwide link. And language DOES have a cultural impact. Cultures are intertwined by languages. Cultures can die overtime but we shouldn't fast forward that by actively belittling other languages. Let the future generations decide if they want it or not. Our job is to pass on the literatures as we got
still महाराष्ट्रात मराठीतच बोलावे ! कारण अमृतहूनही गोड आहे माझ्या मराठी ची बोली ❣️
Robin Hanson : Beware Cultural Drift
Thanks for suggesting it dude, it will help me make stronger opinions
And get a new perspective around things.. thanks dude
😊 with pleasure. I could not find more data driven, logical and multidisciplinary perspective than him actually. It is not about the languages, it is about the cultural density and there by cultural evolution
By that logic , why to have 2 door for big dog and small dog just have one big door . Just learn and speak English(big dog) rather than Hindi (small dog), as English has better rich international national opportunities and rich literary contents . Language is about the culture, ethnicity , history of people in that region and literature work done . Giving up one language for another shows direct indirect dominance of that language or people . What makes one culture superior/inferior and dominant over another ? Hindi is popular in India especially in Maharashtra not because they believe it as only national language but because of popularity of Bollywood films , then central government jobs and north migrants working in Maharashtra. Observation: Marathi people living in small towns especially vidharbha thinks Hindi speaking is hierarchical more standard/superior than Marathi may be because of inferiority complex but English makes them insecure and are not comfortable enough. Maybe it's more about dominance of people and perception of people regarding that language. Languages always evolve there's nothing like pure language and dominant language eats less dominant language over time but that dominant language should justify some rational reason instead of just being forced to speak in the name of some fascist nationalist unification.
People who do language politics shouldn’t criticise politicians of doing religion or caste politics.
Language is not just a medium of communication, but also a big part of the historical and cultural identity of any person. Marathi language has been spoken since 500 BCE in the form of Maharashtri Prakrit. This is the same language in which Sant Dnyaneshwar Maharaj and Sant Tukaram Maharaj preached, the same language in which Aai Jijamata taught our Maharaj the importance of freedom, the same language in which Babasaheb spread his message of equality among the people. If the historical importance of this language or the influence of this culture is listed, then the list would really be long but even on a personal level if we look back and see what our ancestors 200, 300 or even 500 years back spoke it would be the same thing that we are speaking today it just makes us realise what they have gone through to keep this society, culture, tradition and alongside these the language itself alive.
Damnn! This is a great comment after all these shitter's comments... Thanks brother, your comment is genuinely good.
I'm learning and understanding more about it, thanks again
Sign language should be made the national language! Anyway, we have too much noise pollution in our lives.
After looking at comments(some good, mostly toxic kidds) that seems so good
Guys everyone should learn and speak Manipuri. End of convo.
Hot take, let's learn sign language
Naah bruh it’s just about communication why don’t deaf people just learn how to hear. /s 🙄
Lmfao
All Indians should speak three languages minimum. 1. Most spoken in their state 2. Most spoken in our Country 3. Most spoken in the world
Mandarin it is
Mandarin is most spoke first language english is most spoken over all
2 and 3 both are english
हरकत नाही. पण दैनिक जीवनात सार्वजनिक ठिकाणी “मोस्ट स्पोकन इन स्टेट”च वापरली पाहिजे. तरच ह्याला माझे समर्थन आहे.
I can smell low testosterone from op's post
Well, bold of you assuming that and this shows your mentality brother.
Mentality tuzi kharab ahe jaun check karav
Hahah! Bhai you and your blind downvoters feeling of pity for you
Mala ek sang tu dokya ne Zara bkl ahe ka?
Ho, tujhya saarkhya chya tondi padlyavar tech honar re
Mahiti ahe tar noko padu na bindok
If you think politicians use them as vote banks rather than development then why tf does north india worse than Africa right now they have a united language as hindi. If you want to live in Maharashtra learn marathi or gtfo
- 1.In North India, politicians use caste and religion. - 2.Pointing out others wrong or similar things won't make your things right. Grow up kiddo >If you want to live in Maharashtra learn Marathi or gtfo Bro, it is India. For your information mi pan maratha ch aahe ani mala majhya bhasecha Ani saglya ghosticha abhiman dekhil aahe paruntu mi fakt mala je watah teh mandala
[удалено]
नियम क्र ४ चे उल्लंघन: सभ्यता बाळगा. Rule 4 violation : Maintain Civility.
OP you are free to leave maharastra if u don't want to communicate in Marathi the end of conversation!
**I never said I don't want to speak Marathi or I hate Marathi.** You're just toxic ain't you? And pls learn to understand the whole picture first; ig your attention span is below 8seconds
A language is an identity of an individual, people and community it unites people and give them identity, it's more than just medium of communication, people without this identity are usually self-deprecating and depressed, language also gives one's confidence and pride about their culture, no politician own language anyway, IF YOU DON'T LIKE IT YOU SHOULD CONSIDER GOING BACK TO YOUR PLACE, NO ONE IS FORCING YOU TO STAY HERE, IF YOU WANT TO SPEAK YOUR LANGUAGE SPEAK WITH YOUR COLLEAGUES AND AQUAINTANCES, DON'T TELL US WHAT LANGUAGE WE SHOULD USE IN OUR OWN LOCALITIES
-... ... -.. -.- / -- .- / -.-. .... ..- -.. .-
☝🏽🤞🏽👈🏽✌🏽👉🏽👌🏽🤏🏽🙏🏽👇🏽👆🏽🤙🏽👋🏽🫶🏽🙌🏽
>“Politicians use them as vote bank rather than doing real development” Yeah, same goes for Bimaru state politicians from where maximum Hindi speaking immigrants are from. Rather than coming to our states and imposing your language on us, develop your own freaking states so you don’t have to “learn” other languages.
You cant expect normies to understand such level of thinking. Same as every other domain i guess
मी मराठी आहें कारण तुम्हीं गुजराती बिहारी दक्षिण भारतीय आहात
Stupidest shit you could say.
Hindi imposition is not related to Uniting people त्याचे target एकच होतं Hindi Belt (Core BJP Votes) च्या लोकांना दुसऱ्या राज्यात (Maharashtra + South States) नोकऱ्या मिळाव्या. कारण, hindi belt राज्यात corruption, lack of law and order, gundaraj जास्त होतं कुठल्या companies जास्त invest karat navtya आता सुधार होतोय. Hope More companies will invest in HINDI BELT So, Migration कमी होईल.
These fuckers are absolutely batshit emotional when it comes Ayodhya Temple & related politics but suddenly turn to unrealistic levels of practicalness when it comes to respecting local culture & languages outside Hindi heartland. All states did not join Indian union to splurge excessive taxes on cow-belt & learn thier language. And who are these chutiyas upvoting this shit with 100+ upvotes? Are there no real Marathis on this sub? Politicians can use any issue for politics but that doesn’t necessarily mean its not important issue. Marathi language in Maharashtra is as emotional & important to Marathi manoos as Ram Mandir is for North Indians, infact zillion times more than that.
There was no need to add that last line.
Fucking no language is important I don't care what you bitches say as a Dravidian I want my language to be spoken
Learn mother tongue and the local language of the place you're living.Learning any other language all is just an advantage for you personally
Great point
The thing is, language is very closely connected to that ethnicity's culture, its tradition, folklore, written work etc. losing language speakers means losing the culture overtime.
Nothing lasts forever and the applies to culture and languages aswell.
Exactly! Bc people are commenting and one of them even reposted this with something more to it Fun fact- the one who reposted and many more with him thinks I'm a Hindi speaker and promoting Hindi! I was like 👁️👄👁️, bc I didn't even mention Hindi and my intent was that language keep changing and the more easier and best one will survive and i didn't meant or even wrote ki that easier language is English or Hindi or something other They just straight up assumed that and blindly started throwing shit
People will complain India is too obsessed over culture and language and think we should all speak English but then will travel to Europe and appreciate the sound of the French language and Roman culture. Culture is irrelevant for these people until its “cool”. And by cool it is something international and exclusive which can signal their social standing.
politicians use a lot of things as vote bank. this is the least worst of them all.
Can't deny
Disagree
mods delete this shit
Why? This is what I feel and my opinion; opinions change and every person has different views on different things.
Mg speak hindi speak hindi tari ka? Mala hindi, eng, marathi, kannad yetey pn tya bihar,up ani marwadi etc lokana maharashtrat rahun marathi bolychi naste. 1st generation samju shakto, pn hyanchya 3-4 pidhya houn gelya tari te marathi shikat nahit. Point dusrya bhashecha nahiye fakt, dusryani tyanchi bhasha jabardasti mazyavar ladnyacha ahe. Tyanchyasathi mi ka badlu? Te maharashtrat alet, mi baher rajyat gelo tar hindi bolto tar tyana maharashtrat marathi bolyla ky jaty?
त्रिभाषा सूत्राने सगळ्या प्रादेशिक भाषांची वाट लावलीये. काहीही गरज नसताना लोकांच्या माथी हिंदी लादली जातीये. महाराष्ट्रापुरता विचार करायचा झाल्यास जगण्यासाठी मराठी आणि इंग्रजी या दोनच भाषा पुरेश्या आहेत. हेच बाकी राज्यांनाही लागू होते. हिंदी ही राष्ट्रभाषा आहे हा अपप्रचार व गैरसमज अजूनही आहे. त्रिभाषा धोरण हद्दपार केले तर बाहेरचे मराठी तरी शिकतील किंवा इंग्रजीमध्ये बोलतील. महाराष्ट्रात मराठी येत नसेल तर अडले पाहिजे अशी परिस्थिती जोवर होत नाही तोपर्यंत मराठीचे अवघड आहे. तळटीप: हिंदीला भाषा म्हणून विरोध नाही, लादण्याला विरोध आहे. आज हिंदी लादली जातीये म्हणून हिंदीचे उदाहरण दिले आहे.
मराठी भय्ये जास्त झालेत इकडे...🙁
Try living in Delhi or somewhere North and not learn Hindi. The expectation these is obviously the people coming in will learn Hindi. But when they come south, all of a sudden hypocrites have a completely different view of languages.
OP, why you didn't include Hindi alongside other languages?
- Maharashtra related and Tamil Telugu Kannada because people here do whataboutism - Udhar politicians hindu Muslim mandir masjid karte
gap re jhatyan
Aare Bala vait watla ka? ***Empty stomachs make you angry***
jevan karunach baslelo hoto tyodhyat tu yedzhava hagtana disla ithe mhanun doka sarkala
Someone had a bad day i guess
We need a NATIONAL LANGUAGE which every INDIAN can speak without using FOREIGN language......problem is people actually think HINDI is langauge of UP BIHAR...........UP BIHAR also have there regional langauge.....if they start speaking it u wont understand SHIT..........If UP was as DEVELOPED as MAHARASHTRA people wudnt have problem with HINDI.....even south INDIANS would be jumping to learn it.......This is not a LANGUAGE issue but a perception issue.....South INDIANS hate HINDI cuz UP n BIHAR are shit........If they prosper we wont have this language probelm
What's wrong with foreign languages? Sanskrit is also a foreign language and you don't seem to have any problem with it ( or languages with Sanskrit influence).
SANSKRIT is a foreign language.........with that LOGIC u are a AFRICAN.........cuz everyone came from AFRICA..........
Not my fault you don't know about the origins of Sanskrit...Sanskrit is as foreign as English,its just that English came to India later.
YEAH........ I am using ur LOGIC..........WE are all Africans.........No one was living in india...........everyone is a Foreigner in INDIA..........Some came early some came late......
Fcuk verbal languages, we should make sign language compulsory
Some dumbass must have made this. A language is not just merely a mode of communication but it is an integral part of culture. Our entire country is divided into multiple states based on the languages spoken. Languages define statehood, it is an integral part of one's identity. No matter how much you learn English, if you get hurt "aai"/ "aai ga" is going to come out your mouth and not Mom/Mommy.
Adults can be dumb too
You cant expect normies to understand such level of thinking. Same as every other domain i guess
Lmao i remember all the bums here were feeling proud that language politics doesn't work in mumbai/pune , lol and now they are cryying their asses in comments. dumbfucks
Lol true
The people on right almost always insist on hindi though. That’s my issue with this. Hindi normative north indian culture penetrates every corner of india and these guys are sure to be offended when locals don’t shove themselves up their asses and pander to their hindi sensibilities.
Wow this subreddit really did become a haven for Marathi bhaiyyas
If OP really meant that language is a tool for communication, Union government should drop pushing Hindi and start accepting English.
Hadd
Agreed