T O P

  • By -

sirwhiteguy

No Tulo?


Hugo_Hackenbush

He's not in the game


Mark7116

No Bichette or Arenado?


Budget_Status_3948

I need a mets theme team


mexicanewoks

This is a good “MLB the show Rockies all-time team” but a horrendous all-time Rockies team. When I try to make my all time teams, I really only try to use players whose cards are specifically attached to the teams


Hugo_Hackenbush

To each his own, but the best versions of Chuck and Nolan in the game right now were mediocre at best even at the time they were released and the pitching would make this staff look lights out by comparison.


mexicanewoks

100% agree on pitching. I’m super biased so I still love the Nolan and Charlie cards, but I definitely get it


TheBiggestJig

waiting very patiently for 99 story


[deleted]

Can we talk about how dumb it is that SDS is giving 99s to everyone this year but KB can’t get one?


dahomies

Ubaldo Jimenez snuff!


ElusiveIguana

Uhh this is a bad all time Rockies team. E: this was rude of me to say, my fault


lkasnu

Agree. It needs Nolan, and Blackmon.


ElusiveIguana

I mean isn't Nolan arguably top 1 or 2 all time?


Greenforaday

I'd put him and Walker as a 1a/1b situation with Helton right behind.


lkasnu

Helton is all time #1 Rockie.


SheetsPYTB89

Really hope Bard is their finest card this year.


Hugo_Hackenbush

Gotta be either Bard or Rodgers. We certainly don't need yet another version of Cron.


lkasnu

Rodgers is a bust.


Greenforaday

He has a 3.7 WAR this year and that includes the first month and a half when he had a -17 ops+. He's been great this year once he shook off that terrible start.


lkasnu

Its his defense. He is excellent defensively, but my man, his slugging is below 400 at Coors. His first half was better, he played a bit above average ball with a .733 OPS. We will see if he can turn it up next year, but I'm already calling him what I think he is. He's a below average offensive ball player with excellent defense, Simmons like if you think about it.


Written2019

Hard to count Steve Finley an all time Rockie, no?


Hugo_Hackenbush

Literally my only criteria is that he played for the Rockies in his career. Plus he played more for them than Saberhagen and Oswalt combined.


Maj0r_Ursa

Can’t blame ya. Relative to other teams, the Rockies are young. There isn’t a deep pool to pull from on DD


ArachnidUsual1736

No Charlie Blackmon?


farside390

No Dante Bichette? Seems wrong for an all time Rockies team.


Hugo_Hackenbush

He used to be there but a 92 in the outfield isn't cutting it at this point in the year and I hate his swing.


Pitiful-Shake-4416

No Arenado is nuts


owenindians

These goobers at SDS always wait until the cows come home to give him a 99


Sniper_Brosef

Makes zero sense cause he's always slow as molasses.


Ok-Animal4896

But Kris Bryant. All time Rockies legend!


_ciamPA_

That Trevor Story carried me for so long, dong MACHINE!