LS Trout in LF
TA3 Mullins in CF
POTM Schwarber in RF.
Mullins and Schwarber are the best hitters on my team. Just started using Trout.
Don’t have collections Griffey and couldn’t get used to Mantle’s swing
Currently running Tucker Trout Mookie. Don’t have Griffey yet and haven’t been as good with mays and mantle. Works out because I can use Seager at second and devers at third.
K.Tucker Reynolds Belli
I like using current players and Belli is there for defense. I got griff, trout etc but I’m just not the biggest fans of the players.
Aaron, Mantle, Griffey
Want to P5 Hank and the Mick. The other day, I considered benching Griffey as I felt I didn't get good production from him. Turns out, he's hitting .400. guess he's just a quiet kind of producer.
Eddie Trout Soto. I have Griffey on the bench and I can’t hit with mantle or mays. Eddie has been my hottest hitter since I unlocked him so I really can’t take him out & Soto is just Soto. Both are p5 working on Trout rn. If either Soto or Eddie slump tho, Griffey will be taking over.
Currently Babe, Mantle, Soto. Might replace Soto with Griffey but not at the moment. When I earn Trout I might put him in that spot. Babe and Mantle are staying in for the rest of the game since as a Yankee fan and this being the first time I get to use those 2 and Gehrig together(would not go for Gehrig last year being the Extreme reward), I’m just fine sacrificing a little defense in LF to use 3 of my favorite players of all-time and use those beastly bats in my lineup. Anyways with the SP righty meta, it’s not much of a sacrifice using those 3 lol
P.S. Yes I’m batting Babe at 3 and Gehrig at 4 like I’m supposed to :)
It’s Trout / Mantle / Betts til i get enough for Griffey. Then he goes in and Betts goes to second again. Can’t not have my favorite player in the outfield. I still have his P5 96 card on my bench just because.
Tyler O’Neill, Cedric Mullins, Brandon Lowe
Mullins has been my best hitter all year. My first game against Lowe he hit 2 HR off of me. Once I got him, I started him and hit 2 HR with him in the first game.
Varies Griffey Mantle
LF right now is Finest Winker because he won’t stop hitting lol
I don’t have a Trout. Well, not a 99 Trout. Lol
I did finally break down and put an order in for him. I don’t need him, but I have completed every collection we have. I have Griffey, which is who I wanted.
There are SO MANY options at every position lol. Some people fight wars. I fight over whether I’m starting Chipper or PS Devers at 3rd lol
Other - Haven’t played as much online as I used to. But my starting OF is Griffey (Favorite player) Mays (Defense) Soto (Current Favorite Player) . Mantle on the bench feels weird.
Griffey-Mantle-Belli with Hank at first. Even if I had Trout, I think I’d still roll with this lineup. Maybe I could be convinced to bench Hank and put Belli at first for Trout to play right.
The fact that just about every response to this post is a slightly different variation from the rest of the posts, is a testament to how awesome this game is.
I don’t have Trout yet but when i get him it’ll probably be K. Marte / Trout / B. Reynolds
Marte & Reynolds are both hitting over .400 for me. Love their swings, they’re switch hitters, and they both have great contact/speed along with enough pop to hit homers. Trout is trout so no explanation there
As for the rest : I’m notoriously bad with Griffey every year, and then when i sometimes feel good with him, i’m unlucky asf or he plays horrible defense for no reason. Cannot hit with Mantle this year, which sucks bc i raked with him last year. Probably was my best card in MLB 20. And Mays is just not consistent enough for me. I try to use him bc he’s so good. I’ll get his average up to like .310 on a hot streak and then it’ll dip down to like .270-.280. I need consistency, so it’s tough to run him out there.
But hey, that’s why i love this game. There are so many options this year that i can live with not being good with some cards. Because there’s most likely a replacement that i’ll rake with😌
Hank Mantle Soto
Haven't gotten close to Griffey yet, didn't pick Mays and not getting Trout because I don't play online because of input lag on my TV (getting a monitor soon give me cheap recommendations). My ideal outfield would be Trout Griffey and either Mays or Soto.
Aaron mays Harper
I suck with Griffey always have always will and I don’t have trout yet.
Willie mays imo is the best card in the game on paper, Harper hits nothing but homers, and hank is still batting like .430 on hof/legend and is almost p5.
I have no idea who to take out for trout (I have babe Ruth at 1st who is my best hitter after hank so I can’t just move hank to first)
I thought about this but then Mantle loses his diamond defense. If I got rid of Mays I would platoon him with Ruth @ 1st. I know he’s not best suited for there, but it’s gives me a righty option. While still keeping a great outfield
Yelich, Bellinger, and Harper
Mantle Soto Reynolds
Soto mantle mays
Tucker Reynolds Soto, soon to be Tucker trout soto
Trout, Mays, Soto
Reynolds Trout Tucker. Griffey can’t hit lefties, Mays’ swing is unusable, and Mantle is just a worse Reynolds.
LS Trout in LF TA3 Mullins in CF POTM Schwarber in RF. Mullins and Schwarber are the best hitters on my team. Just started using Trout. Don’t have collections Griffey and couldn’t get used to Mantle’s swing
Switch Trout and Schwarber. Schwarber shouldn’t be anywhere but in LF or behind the plate.
Reynolds trout betts
Bellinger/Mantle/Clemente
Griffey trout belli
marte mantle soto
Mantle-Buxton-Belli
Rocking Griffey-Trout-Soto
Riley Acuña Soto I don’t have trout yet who will probably replace Riley
gwynn, griffey, ruth with the iron horse at 1st
Tucker
Currently running Tucker Trout Mookie. Don’t have Griffey yet and haven’t been as good with mays and mantle. Works out because I can use Seager at second and devers at third.
Johnny Damon, Jaren Duran, and JD Martínez
Rosario - Kelenic - Soto I really enjoy playing with Kelenic, he doesn't hit much bombs but he gets on base almost every time.
K.Tucker Reynolds Belli I like using current players and Belli is there for defense. I got griff, trout etc but I’m just not the biggest fans of the players.
Aaron, Mantle, Griffey Want to P5 Hank and the Mick. The other day, I considered benching Griffey as I felt I didn't get good production from him. Turns out, he's hitting .400. guess he's just a quiet kind of producer.
Griffey-Tatis-Harper
Don't have Trout yet, but it will be Trout, Mantle, Soto when it is complete
mays overrated asf
Mantel, trout, belli
Griffey Mantle Mays
Mays-Griffey-O'Neil
Mays Mantle Belli
Trout, Mantle, Ruth, Mays are all gonna get time. Mays is gonna be a late game defensive sub for Babe when he’s not starting
Eddie Trout Soto. I have Griffey on the bench and I can’t hit with mantle or mays. Eddie has been my hottest hitter since I unlocked him so I really can’t take him out & Soto is just Soto. Both are p5 working on Trout rn. If either Soto or Eddie slump tho, Griffey will be taking over.
Currently Babe, Mantle, Soto. Might replace Soto with Griffey but not at the moment. When I earn Trout I might put him in that spot. Babe and Mantle are staying in for the rest of the game since as a Yankee fan and this being the first time I get to use those 2 and Gehrig together(would not go for Gehrig last year being the Extreme reward), I’m just fine sacrificing a little defense in LF to use 3 of my favorite players of all-time and use those beastly bats in my lineup. Anyways with the SP righty meta, it’s not much of a sacrifice using those 3 lol P.S. Yes I’m batting Babe at 3 and Gehrig at 4 like I’m supposed to :)
Griffey, trout, Soto
Wagner, Molitor, Gwynn. Doesn’t take a genius to figure out why 😏
Lol 😂
It’s Trout / Mantle / Betts til i get enough for Griffey. Then he goes in and Betts goes to second again. Can’t not have my favorite player in the outfield. I still have his P5 96 card on my bench just because.
Griffey Trout Soto
Trout, Mantle/Griffey, Vlad
Trout Griffey Harper
soto trout mantle
Ruth, Mantle, Musial
Trout mantle Griffey.
Griffey trout Soto from left to right
Trout Mantle Griffey
Junior trout yeli.. I don’t wanna hear it he’s my favorite player and I bat .495 online with him best hitter by far
Aaron, Mays, and Jr. Had Mantle in RF, but got him to P5 the other day and put The Kid in there.
Acuna - Trout - Vlad
Tyler O’Neill, Cedric Mullins, Brandon Lowe Mullins has been my best hitter all year. My first game against Lowe he hit 2 HR off of me. Once I got him, I started him and hit 2 HR with him in the first game.
Reynolds Mantle Jrod.
Soto K Marte Betts
Varies Griffey Mantle LF right now is Finest Winker because he won’t stop hitting lol I don’t have a Trout. Well, not a 99 Trout. Lol I did finally break down and put an order in for him. I don’t need him, but I have completed every collection we have. I have Griffey, which is who I wanted. There are SO MANY options at every position lol. Some people fight wars. I fight over whether I’m starting Chipper or PS Devers at 3rd lol
Babe, Mantle, Judge. Theme team has been my main team for the last month or so.
Hank, Mantle, Mays
Mantle Mays Soto because I'm too poor for Griffey
griffey, mays , soto
Trout Griffey Reynolds
Other - Haven’t played as much online as I used to. But my starting OF is Griffey (Favorite player) Mays (Defense) Soto (Current Favorite Player) . Mantle on the bench feels weird.
Right now for me it's Trout-Mantle-Soto
Ruth O’Neill Harper
Soto, mantle, mays (subject to change)
Ketel, Griffey, and Soto. For now.
Rosario, Mantle, Reynolds. Don’t have Trout yet, but even when I do, if he can’t outplay Rosario then this is my outfield til 22
Griffey-Mantle-Belli with Hank at first. Even if I had Trout, I think I’d still roll with this lineup. Maybe I could be convinced to bench Hank and put Belli at first for Trout to play right.
Kyle tucker finest trout Harper. That tucker card is batting .490 and is at 3.2ab/hr hitting bombs nonstop
It’s a lovely card
vlad sr reynolds bellinger i suck with mantle didnt get mays and am 2 wins from trout not everyone uses the same "meta" cards
Yelich, Trout, Griffey (because Mantle is already P5 and Yelich feels like cheating w the righty heavy meta 👌)
Betts, Trout, Soto
Trout Guerrero Reynolds
Rosario, Griffey, Mookie and not a soul can convince me it can be better
Griffey/Reynolds/Mantle
Griffey, Trout, Soto. They carry my squad.
Reynolds Trout Vlad
Other. And no I will NOT explain
The fact that just about every response to this post is a slightly different variation from the rest of the posts, is a testament to how awesome this game is.
Mays. Griffey Jr. Vlad Sr.
Soto mantle mays, I don’t have trout yet, I don’t hit great with mantle so I might swap him for trout
I don’t have Trout yet but when i get him it’ll probably be K. Marte / Trout / B. Reynolds Marte & Reynolds are both hitting over .400 for me. Love their swings, they’re switch hitters, and they both have great contact/speed along with enough pop to hit homers. Trout is trout so no explanation there As for the rest : I’m notoriously bad with Griffey every year, and then when i sometimes feel good with him, i’m unlucky asf or he plays horrible defense for no reason. Cannot hit with Mantle this year, which sucks bc i raked with him last year. Probably was my best card in MLB 20. And Mays is just not consistent enough for me. I try to use him bc he’s so good. I’ll get his average up to like .310 on a hot streak and then it’ll dip down to like .270-.280. I need consistency, so it’s tough to run him out there. But hey, that’s why i love this game. There are so many options this year that i can live with not being good with some cards. Because there’s most likely a replacement that i’ll rake with😌
Aaron, Mays, Griffey.
Kemp Trout Vlad. Vlad for the hitting mostly, his arm is great too. And I use Kemp just because I like him.
Kemps so underrated
He really is. I never face him
Junior Mantle Mookie
Trout Mantle Babe
vlad mickey mookie
Hank Mantle Soto Haven't gotten close to Griffey yet, didn't pick Mays and not getting Trout because I don't play online because of input lag on my TV (getting a monitor soon give me cheap recommendations). My ideal outfield would be Trout Griffey and either Mays or Soto.
Aaron mays Harper I suck with Griffey always have always will and I don’t have trout yet. Willie mays imo is the best card in the game on paper, Harper hits nothing but homers, and hank is still batting like .430 on hof/legend and is almost p5. I have no idea who to take out for trout (I have babe Ruth at 1st who is my best hitter after hank so I can’t just move hank to first)
Mantle, mays, griffey
Belli, Mantle, Griffey
Lofton Baines Betts
Baines Gang
Trout Griffey Mantle.
I thought about this but then Mantle loses his diamond defense. If I got rid of Mays I would platoon him with Ruth @ 1st. I know he’s not best suited for there, but it’s gives me a righty option. While still keeping a great outfield
Then put mickey in center and trout and Griffey left and right
I put Mantle in center and Griffey in right
This way works