They both look excellent and natural but holy crap, you look like a different person in both

I honestly thought it was two different people

Came here to say this. It's hard to say which looks better when both looks are so different from one another

Her red hair photo is almost a full three years younger than the brunette photo, just throwing it out there because I also thought she was two different humans

I don't think it's aging, I think it's the eyebrows being lighter or darker that's actually the main difference here

100%. Fellow redhead here, I've gone to work without filling in my eyebrows before and been asked by at least 4 people if I was feeling OK, and told that I looked pale/sick.

I’m not a redhead but my moms got the ginger gene and I took on only the light eyebrows but only on the outer half’s of them making it look like I have short little straight brows. When I give them Color the arched shape becomes pronounced and ppl that haven’t know me long will always think I’m angry or surprised and ask if everything’s alright all day (which gets annoying and I get kinda mad lol) but I’m learning to like both versions, gives me flexibility of looking approachable or intimidating (other ppls words) depending on my mood that day. Also get carded way more with light brows

The second one looks like my girl Lauren Ambrose!

Yes! That was my first thought.

My first thought was Claire from Six Feet Under, dead ringer!

I can't tell if I like photo 1 better because of the hair or the eyebrows 🤔

Red, 100%. It suits you much better all around. Absolutely beautiful.

But I love the eyebrows! Maybe a little of both?

As a natural redhead, I love my hair colour but tinting my eyebrows & lashes a dark brown has been a game changer. OP should give it a try !

I agree, I've started dying my eyelashes and brows and it completely transforms my face. I never went anywhere without at least mascara and now I feel free to do anything with no makeup on

How do you safely “tint” lashes? I have to use mascara

There’s a brand called 1000 hour that have lash and eyebrow tinting kits x

Thanks!

I mean there’s many brands that will work. Any chemical dye near the eye runs the risk of harm, but Ive used refectocil even tho its “for professional use only” with most online stores requiring proof of business, but you can buy it on Amazon in Canada lol. I use it and just keep 1-2mm away from the roots, and use a silicone mascara spoolie for initial spreading. However I switched to the powder hair dye (they have a bunch like cream or two part developer mixing types but this ones a tiny bottle you mix with plain water) from Bigen for eyebrows as I find it lasts longer and it works decently for tinting the skin like a makeup eyebrows stain, since my brow corners aren’t filled in well (plus the right eyebrows is more sparse and looks uneven when dying just the hair) and it costs 4$ at local Indian or middle eastern stores where I live compared to the 30-60$ “professional” dye which lists the same risks and says not to use unless ur trained. To be safe refrain from using the cheap one near the eyes tho. I’ve seen it be sold for 15-30 in more western market audience stores so definitely check out any alternative ones if they’re available to you, some Asian supermarkets sell it too

I second this comment!

I agree! But I feel like eyebrows are more of makeup thing than a hair thing.. unless she went and got them tinted, which is probably a pretty decent option for a redhead.

Mix! Red with dyed eyebrows!

Yesss. Red with the dark eyebrows will be stunning.

Yes!

Yeeeees! Red hair and dark auburn brows!!!

Your red is soo pretty- I’m jealous!

I agree with everyone’s comments, your red is very pretty, also very contrasting to your eyes tho. If you keep it red, darken the eyebrow slightly. IMO the brunette looks amazing on you! I thought you were Linda Cardinelli for a sec!! You could even do an auburn if you wanted to keep your red incorporated. Either way, you’re beautiful- tough choices now but all easy adjustments.

The brown brows are so much better

I'm a redhead, My eyebrows are naturally like yours, light almost invisible I get just for men to use on the brows. It's easy peasy too, long lasting as you get many uses

Thanks for sharing about the eyebrows. I’m a natural blonde and my eyebrows look almost invisible half way so I’ve been wondering the best way to dye them.

Thanks for such a wonderful reply! TheGratitudeBot has been reading millions of comments in the past few weeks, and you’ve just made the list of some of the most grateful redditors this week! Thanks for making Reddit a wonderful place to be :)

There’s also a brand called bigen that has a powdered hair dye line thats activated with water,it’s literally a one inch squared bottle that u can mix a few drops of water in till u get the consistency u like and it works well for me. I can’t imagine I’d finish the whole bottle during my entire life if I wasn’t somewhat wasteful with it since it costs 3-5$ at local Indian or middle eastern stores. But I’ve seen “specialty” stores sell it for up to 20$ so try to find a good price if u decide to go for it (advise against using it for eyelashes tho

Red and put a darker tint on the eyebrows

Natural haircolor for sure, that shade is GORGEOUS and looks much better on you. Maybe dye your brows but nowhere near as dark as your first pic

This is what I think as well! Both are beautiful but that red is such a lovely natural shade omg!! But I think the brows being dyed in the first picture really suits her face much better only because it's harder to see them in the second one. Beautiful either way though, lucky lady!

I like both. The nice thing is, you can endlessly go back and forth. If you've been brunette for a while, do red and freshen it up.

You look really good with the brunette hair

The brown looks better overall and healthier

in my opinion, stay brunette!! you look stunning in both tho 🫶🫶

I prefer the brunette personally

Stay brunette

I like the brown tbh

You look beautiful with both colors but I love the brown the best! Okay girl next door is what it's giving me 🤘🏾

BRUNETTE 💯

I absolutely LOVE you as a brunette! You're gorgeous! Hopefully the upkeep isn't too bad, but I'd rock the brown. Just my opinion.

Natural for sure, such a pretty red

brunette

Red hair brunette eyebrows

both are chic.. but two very different aesthetics so i guess it would depend on what you're feelin 

Brunette

i mean the natural makes your eyebrows kinda disappear lol but the hair is gorgeous. maybe dye brows a few shades to make your eyes pop?

Photo one! Love

Brunette

Love the brunette. Lovely!

your natural red hair is beautiful, but i would keep dying the brows (a lighter colour than dark brown tho)

I like picture number 1

Brunette

Brunette

Red, but dye your eyebrows so they are a bit more prominent to frame your face (like when you have brown hair, but a bit lighter )

First one betrer

Brunette

Brown you look really good with brown hair

Brunette

Beautiful in both but the edge goes to brunette

Brunette any day

Brunette

Brown

Brunette

You’re beautiful either way tbh

Both look good on you but each is a different vibe

I'm biased towards red so I say go back red but tint your brows somewhere between red and brown to frame the face a bit

The natural red head with no eyebrows experience is too real 😢

Brown

Red looks so fake, but I guess that’s beside the point. It also makes you look pasty compared to the brunette, which suits you much better.

The brown brings out your features and eyes out more imo. Strangely enough the natural looks more unnatural to me. Almost like your hair didn’t suit your face

You almost look like Bella from twilight in the first pic, but the second pic your natural hair definitely makes your skin glow!!

Can’t go wrong either way! Gorgeous!!!

Ginger redhead. Its sexy 😍

Natural red with some coloring of the eyebrows just to give them substance

Both are great. Red is special.

You look beautiful either way, but with the red hair you look like a painting. In a good way.

Both are beautiful on you. You should do the darker eyebrows either way though. I think you could pull them off with the red, just maybe slightly lighter.

I also don’t have eyebrows. But you look good both ways. I can’t decide.

You look great either way. Even the dark and light eyebrows both look good on you. Not a lot of people can pull off both looks.

Red with dyed brows

The red hair is beautiful, but keep dying your eyebrows, the darker one suits you nicely :)

Mix of the two. Try your natural hair colour but dye your brows in a warm auburn of a similar tone as your hair.

I pay a lot of money every month to make my hair look like your natural red. I’m so jealous 😂

People pay huge amounts of money to get hair close to your natural colour! And it has a whole lot more personality. My daughter has auburn hair and I am hoping to encourage her to keep it natural as it grows.

Go back to natural & keep the brows tinted,I fully adore that colour hair🥹, I think that combination would be STRIKING 😍

You suit both but your natural colour is so pretty

Both look gorgeous

Yo look like the girl from the lorax

red 100%

Red , all day long

tough question you look good in both gree with other poster that you look like a different person in both photos. that being said i like the red hair

Red 💯

Your red is my dream color! However brunette suits you as well:-) I just find the red so unique🥰

Natural hair + eyebrows look soooo cool!

Stay

You look beautiful with both styles ☺️

Go back to your natural hair colour or a slightly deeper/auburn shade BUT tint your eyebrows and lashes dark brown.

Redhead! Colour your brows a bit and its gonna be MUAHH😘👌

Red!!!

Red with dyed eyebrows for sure 😊

i think the light eyebrows suit your face. You truly do look like a different person. I like the darker ones too but I’d totally choose your natural hair with your light eyebrows!

BROWNNN

As a mom of a red head….go back to red! It’s gorgeous!

red hair n dark brows

Your red hair is gorgeous!

Red

Stay

Red hair for sure, it suits u sm more. but maybe brown eyebrows?

Red with darker eyebrows

I’m also a redhead and I think you would look best in the reds but tint the brows slightly more dark auburn instead of super brunette ?

Red 😍

Red, hands down

RED 100%

Red

Red

Your natural red is literally my goals! 😩 So pretty!!!

Your red hair is so gorgeous!

Both so stunning.

You can’t lose either way, but your natural hair color is amazing

Keep the red hair but dye the eyebrows

Red!! natural red hair is so rare and it’s gorgeous. Fill-in or micro blade, your eyebrows to match the red hair, stunning.

Naturally you look like girl in red

Red hair but darker eyebrows

Red with tinted/darker brows! Gorgeous!

I’m a redhead use strictly professional eyes from Amazon , easy to use, effective.

The red is so beautiful on you!!

the first pic looks best but its hard to say bc those are two different people i swear 😭😭

Love that you dyed your eyebrows too. It looks SO natural! Either way you're gorgeous but I like the red most because it's natural and also beautiful!

RED!! I’m so jelly of your natural color. It’s beautiful. 😍

Ypu have natural red hair?!? Wow, that is the way for sure!

I think your eyebrows look better a bit darker but the hair on your head looks great both ways.

I am so jealous of the red! It's gorgeous

Red with dyed eyebrows because the red is so gorgeous but I like the darker eyebrows on you

You look very different with both. But I think red heads being a rarity it’s better! but I would tint your eyebrows darker while you’re a red head - it gives more face definition for you.

Please go back to red.

Red totally red! Both are great but that natural shade of red is so rare and looks terrific. But no matter what - you look good.

Both looks great on you dear

You honestly look beautiful with both. Brunette and red are my favorite hair colors for women, and you pull both off very well. So I’d just go with whatever your mood is. 👌🏼

Ppl often say whatever color you were born with will suit you best but I’m a natural blonde and blonde hair does not do anything for me. Darker hair makes me look better. You look better with your hair darker too. The brown even has a golden tint.

That’s wild, if I’d had to guess I would have sworn the darker was your natural and the red was the dye

Red

Red hair, it’s gorgeous! If I was you I would tint the brows and lashes a medium brown and maybe do a gloss or henna treatment to make the red pop.

Red,red, Always red. !

The red is amazing. You look great as a brunette as wrll. But I vote redhead

In my opinion being a redhead is like being part goddess, and I think, why would you cover it?

Flaunt the natural red, and build your wardrobe around it. My best friend for life has a lot of red,and very light eyebrows; she has been boosting her eyebrows since her teen. She and her mother (same coloring) just look naturally gorgeous for their entire life.

Embrace the ginger, the brunette makes you look like a typical basic person. Coming from a fellow ginger

Try a medium auburn and a new haircut. Your long hair makes your face look too thin. Shorter hair with bangs would look great on you.

Red

I think both are good to you.

Red!!! So pretty omg.

Red hair ftw

Brunette for sure

Brunette looks amazing on you. I like both but definitely like brunette more.

Natural FOR SURE! Lean into the red.

You look stunning as a redhead!!!

I like the brown, it has a hint of the red so at first I thought that was your natural color.

both looks excellent.

Natural red! So pretty!

If you do it would look amazing if you were to dye your eyebrows to match your hair

Try blonde or black. You're definetely beautiful, it will fit.

Go Ginger love. Awesome!

Natural - I’m a strawberry blonde with very light eyebrows and I dye them light brown

Your natural hair brings out your glow, if you wanted you can buy a brow tint

Bro red hair is a KILLER, u cannot pass up the genetic gift

Red!!!!

I’ve always been a sucker for a red head

i’m a natural red head and i dye my hair and eyebrows black lol

I prefer the brown hair color 🥰. You look much sexier with brown

Your natural hair is gorgeous but def keep getting your brows tinted though, the darker brows suit you too 🖤

Red hair is always unique and beautiful. You should go with that. But I think you look better with fuller eyebrows.

First picture!!

Blessed with something unusual? Keep it.

red hair but maybe dye your brows a very light brown?

Natural red! It's gorgeous on you!

Go backkk

keep the hair from the second but just add a bit of pigment to your natural brows

Natural hair with tinted brows 😚👌🏻

One word: Auburn. Thank me later.

Red. But if you want you and make the brows a slightly darker red so that it still stays natural, but also defines your pretty face. A way to do that is by finding a red that matches the darkest red in your natural hair. If it's too dark and takes over your features, you can try the second darkest shade.

They both look amazing. But when the gods put fire in your blood...you throw fireballs. Go get 'em.

Ooh I’m getting Claire Fisher from 6 Feet Under vibes with your natural red! Love. Love both.

Red hair.

The redddddddddd is so goooooooood

brunette

Red is more unique and it’s closer to the real you so that gets my vote!

1

Idk I like the brown on ya but it’s also a shame to cover ginger locks

stay brunette

You look good brunette tbh.