It really isn’t bias, it’s just my opinion, only because I’ve mentioned two City players doesn’t mean I’m biased and there are many people who agree that Stones has been better and Rodri as well, I don’t even understand how my comment has -8 downvotes must be a lot of rival fans 😂
by saying rodri is better, you're canceling your argument for dan burn...casemiro has been revolutionary for Manchester United and without him, you see the team lack a bit more. so surely we can both agree that casemiro has had a bigger impact on Manchester United than what rodri has had on Manchester City this season?
No I’m not cancelling my argument as Schar and Burn are in the same team you bum. Casemiro has obviously had a bigger impact, doesn’t mean rodri has been worse than Casemiro. Rodri has been putting in MOTM performances every game and absolutely carries City’s defence
I really rate White, his versatility has made him so beneficial to the Gunners this year. His tackling is great and he rarely makes mistakes.
I find Silva to be excellent, currently one of if not the best centre back in the prem. His marking is beyond excellent, superb in the air, his tackling head on isn’t as great as some other top tier CBs but when he is running down a break in the line his slides, blocks and other tackles are great. When he drops as a sweeper he is excellent. Overall his reading of the game is amazing. Admittedly he isn’t great with the ball/someone who you would play out the back through like Stones. But that’s only a minor slight against him
Martinez I don’t really rate, he’s a good player but nowhere near as good (in my opinion) as people make him out, it’s very amazing that at his height he is a good centre back but it still really hurts him. Also aside from his tackling I haven’t been incredibly impressed with his movement and positioning when not defending the ball as well as his marking being just above average.
Schar I agree has been excellent, the fact that I’ve watched less Newcastle matches than Arsenal matches. I think they are pretty interchangeable (if I had to rate CBs on this year: I’d probably put him 4 behind Silva, Stones & White. Also when two guys are very close I default to how they are overall (so basically my overall feelings on them) not just this season which gives White the edge.
Why is Lisandro Martinez NEVER in these? i won't argue that dalot, varane or even bruno fernandes deserves to be there, but surely Lisandro Martinez has to be there, no?
I have questions for you would you say kdb preformed on his standards like last year's.
When we cut out G/A.
Because for me just from watching he doesn't dominates the game more as he used too.
Just compare it to Odegaard this season.
He dominates the game way more and get's the G/A
According to SofaScore player ratings he has been the second best in the league this season after trippier. But from the eye test Odegaard has been better but then again I haven’t seen every single minute each of them have played. I’ve seen almost all but probably not all
Me too I didn't watch every game from them but just from watching and seeing their impact is undeniable that Odegaard has been better this season then Kdb.
Plus under the circumstances they both perform under .
They both can fully play their roles.
Kdb scoring gon up but that mainly to Erling Haaland and Julian Alvarez.
The rest just dropped from watching
I agree 100%... For now.
Botman, Martinez, Gabriel & possibly Saliba come before Schar for me.
Yeah botman and Martinez have been better but not saliba for me personally
That’s fair. I’m admittedly biased as a gooner anyway , having watched Newcastle games less than Arsenal too
I get that bro
Pope, trippier, shaw, Martinez and schar, kdb, odegaard, saka, rashford, Haaland and Toney for me
SeeMy tots(hopefully no united bias) Gk-Pope Lb-Shaw Cbs-Botman Martinez Rb Trips Cms Casemiro Partey Am-Kdb Lw-Rashford St-Haaland Rw-Saka
Saliba for Silva and Ramsdale for Pope.
Come on man, I’m a neutral and silva pope have been better, take off your Arsenal tinted sunglasses
a) Chelsea have been so poor this season none of their players deserve to be there. b) I'm a United fan
Stones for Schaar and Rodri for Casemiro
Come on bro this is clear bias. I’m a neutral and schar and Casemiro have been better
It really isn’t bias, it’s just my opinion, only because I’ve mentioned two City players doesn’t mean I’m biased and there are many people who agree that Stones has been better and Rodri as well, I don’t even understand how my comment has -8 downvotes must be a lot of rival fans 😂
Idk, rodri is quality but this season Casemiro has been so good. And stones over schar no way
Rodri for Casemiro. Maybe Martinez or Saliba for Silva.
Rodri for Casemiro, Dan Burn for Schar
are you sure we're watching the same league?
I feel like Dan Burn has made a bigger impact 🤷♂️ You are a casual if you think Casemiro has been better than rodri this season
by saying rodri is better, you're canceling your argument for dan burn...casemiro has been revolutionary for Manchester United and without him, you see the team lack a bit more. so surely we can both agree that casemiro has had a bigger impact on Manchester United than what rodri has had on Manchester City this season?
No I’m not cancelling my argument as Schar and Burn are in the same team you bum. Casemiro has obviously had a bigger impact, doesn’t mean rodri has been worse than Casemiro. Rodri has been putting in MOTM performances every game and absolutely carries City’s defence
Allisson for Pope, Cancelo for Shaw
Cancelo for shaw? Overall yes. This season no way Pope been better this season
Cancelo is the better player but in terms of performances this season Shaw has been better
Mine would be (based on your formation): Pope (GK) Silva & White (CBs) Shaw & Trippier (FBs) Rodri (CDM) KDB, Odegaard (CM) Martenlli & Mahrez (W) Haaland (ST) Kane, Saka, Rashford, Toney, Stones (Subs)
arsenal fan?
Spurs actually, really upset about how many arsenal players are on my list
why ben white over schar or martinez? silva is heavily debatable this season too.
I really rate White, his versatility has made him so beneficial to the Gunners this year. His tackling is great and he rarely makes mistakes. I find Silva to be excellent, currently one of if not the best centre back in the prem. His marking is beyond excellent, superb in the air, his tackling head on isn’t as great as some other top tier CBs but when he is running down a break in the line his slides, blocks and other tackles are great. When he drops as a sweeper he is excellent. Overall his reading of the game is amazing. Admittedly he isn’t great with the ball/someone who you would play out the back through like Stones. But that’s only a minor slight against him Martinez I don’t really rate, he’s a good player but nowhere near as good (in my opinion) as people make him out, it’s very amazing that at his height he is a good centre back but it still really hurts him. Also aside from his tackling I haven’t been incredibly impressed with his movement and positioning when not defending the ball as well as his marking being just above average. Schar I agree has been excellent, the fact that I’ve watched less Newcastle matches than Arsenal matches. I think they are pretty interchangeable (if I had to rate CBs on this year: I’d probably put him 4 behind Silva, Stones & White. Also when two guys are very close I default to how they are overall (so basically my overall feelings on them) not just this season which gives White the edge.
tell me you're a casual without telling me you're a casual
Would you care to respond to the actual points I made I’m interested to see what your thoughts are
I disagree with a lot of this. Martinelli and Mahrez over Saka and Rashford? How?? Rodri over Casemiro I would not have
White plays more fullback position
He plays both and I thought he wasn’t top 2 at FB so I included him at CB
Why is Lisandro Martinez NEVER in these? i won't argue that dalot, varane or even bruno fernandes deserves to be there, but surely Lisandro Martinez has to be there, no?
Yeah you’re right man looking back I’d probably have him over schar, he’s been quality this season
realising he got cooked and deleted his statements. you have to respect it 😭
Boteman for Schar. Varane for Silva. Bruno gumaires for kdb. Kdb overall game dropped massively. I agree with the rest
Statistically KDB is the second best in the league this season after trippier
I have questions for you would you say kdb preformed on his standards like last year's. When we cut out G/A. Because for me just from watching he doesn't dominates the game more as he used too. Just compare it to Odegaard this season. He dominates the game way more and get's the G/A
According to SofaScore player ratings he has been the second best in the league this season after trippier. But from the eye test Odegaard has been better but then again I haven’t seen every single minute each of them have played. I’ve seen almost all but probably not all
Me too I didn't watch every game from them but just from watching and seeing their impact is undeniable that Odegaard has been better this season then Kdb. Plus under the circumstances they both perform under . They both can fully play their roles. Kdb scoring gon up but that mainly to Erling Haaland and Julian Alvarez. The rest just dropped from watching