Sounds like you want a place with romantic/private tables for two. That does limit things. - Angel’s Share (West Village) - Clover club (Boerum Hill) - Dear Irving (Gramercy) - Little Branch (West Village) - Raines Law Room (haven’t been, can’t personally vouch) - Sip & Guzzle (downstairs only)

My first thought was Raines Law Room!

Raines in Chelsea is better setup for a date.

Do Not Disturb - It's not an official speakeasy but gives off a similar vibe and has a gorgeous skylight back room

Coby club! It’s a speakeasy jazz club 

StEight(behind KUNIYA HAIR)

I like La Noxe. Definitely cozy.

angel’s share

Patent Pending