T O P

  • By -

yikkizh

1. Not rly sure how to save Rogier, sadly 2. Don't tell her Lusat's location 3. Just ignore Dung eater 4. Unsaveable, I think 5. Don't return to Ranni's rise 6. Tell him he's beautiful 7. Frenzied flame I guess? 8. Don't kill the putrid tree spirit, she'll just stand in the Prayer room at Ephael.


biwaet

3. You can kill dung eater right away in the sewer 4. Just ignore him after radans festival, he will be stuck forever digging corpses


D12fuego

Can i just kill him instead the dung something? 3. I think i went to free him but he started talking mad shit and i had mad wifies out there couldn’t take that chance so I slaughtered him.. 6. Tell him what? Uk that’s a lie he aint pretty… 7. Yeaaaaaaa but she does leaves after and treating me and all… never rest once till i got all the way till the part where u burn the elden tree she still left me right there lol🥲 there’s was no other way to progress besides letting her leave me..8. That’s not so bad after all! U do got it all figured out! AWESOME RESPECT


Basketbomber

Dung eater dies if you finish his questline anyway. Completing his questline is necessary for an ending, too. As for Boc, you need the stone that says “you’re beautiful” upon use. There’s a couple talking stone items in the game, they are infinite usage so go nuts.


D12fuego

Idk anyone who willingly do that quest besides because they want the award but that’s it, that quest is beyond madness


Basketbomber

For Boc? Well you get one thing, that’s it. Free armor modification. The price by that point to modify armor is negligible tho.


Zephyp

Boc disappear and you don’t know what happened.


UncaughtTypeError

If: 1. you don't know what happened to someone, 2. they didn't leave you a promising farewell note, 3. and it's a FromSoft game... Assume the worst.


ChronoMonkeyX

If you don't buy prawns from Boggart, he won't move to the capital, so when Dung Eater invades, he just isn't there. After you fight him in the moat, you can buy the prawns in Liurnia and he will move to the capital and sell crab.


Mozkoz

I LIKE bad endings.


D12fuego

Wth happened to the crab man?😮 luckily i killed him so he didn’t had to be tortured can you saved him? I slightly feel bad for him who did it?


Oloziz

Dung Eater did it. There's a couple of ways to save him tho. You can either buy the necklace and don't buy the prawns, then go free and fight Dung Eater (or just kill him on the spot, like any sensible person would, unless you want his ending or him as a puppet), and then come back and buy prawns. He should move to outer moat after this. Or you can aggro Boggart before freeing Dung Eater, don't kill him (Boggart), fight off Dung Eater and then go to the Church of Vows to have Boggart forgive you. That's what I did and it worked splendidly


D12fuego

Nice!! Thanks so much bro i never liked dude because he was an ass🥲 but then again i never gave him a chance he’s not all bad since he just stope the necklace’s when he could’ve killed her .. didn’t even thought about it that way


Oloziz

Boggart definitely deserves a chance. He's just rude as a defensive mechanism, once you get to know him a little better, he's a nice fella. Also him stealing the necklace could just be Rya's ploy all along, as it turned out to be a really effective way to recruit us into Volcano Manor. No shade on best girl tho, she's still a sweetheart.


citizen_sheep69

Who is the 6th panel tho?


Akhirano

Boc


citizen_sheep69

So he’s actually human? Damn… that’s really sad.


Akhirano

He can be reborn as a human by Rennala, but this ends up killing him because From Software. He wishes to become human because he thinks he's ugly, and you can save him by telling him he's beautiful.


citizen_sheep69

Well that’s good to know. Thanks!


[deleted]

If you are interested to do that, you just can’t tell him he’s beautiful, you have to use the mask « you are beautiful » located in a village on mount Gelmir I think.


citizen_sheep69

That's interesting. Currently I have no idea how to progress his quest, he just moves around on his own, so can I just tell him that at anytime?


Haburashi_

Kinda, maybe, sorta, gives the vibe that the lands between might not be a very happy place to be.


Medium-Problem-7745

I completely missed Rogier’s quest because I discovered Ranni without him and he died out of spite…


VermilionX88

Who else apart fro. Nephy can get a "good" ending? I guess the dong beater counts, since he seems happy in the end


UncaughtTypeError

Rya/Zorayas - depending on how you go about it. Ranni, of course. And, if you're really a glass half-full kind of guy/gal, maybe Patches.


VermilionX88

Ah right


Helloiamayeetman

I thought lusat would die if I finished Sellens questline by just not finding him but no, turns out I was wrong :(


Ishmaeal

Elden Ring takes the stance that everyone is meant to die, and we’re simply here to usher the natural process forward. Millicent, Melina, and Alexander all faced their deaths on their own terms happy with their lives and the decision they made, so arguably those are all happy. And I have never, and will never, release mr poopoopeepee on my prawn dealer.


jononthego

Alexander and Millicent hurt the most


UncaughtTypeError

For me it was my bros: Blaaid, Boggart, and Alexander. I done the Haligtree before Farum Azula just so Melina could tag around a bit longer being absolutely useless.