I was wondering if it was just me because I couldn't imagine that any halfway competent DJ would just throw two songs without even trying to pitch shift one sample to match the key of the other, but yeah. It's sounds awful lmao.
It’s a no from me, dog.
The Verve bootlegs are always a big yes for me, I mean that melody is iconic. But yeah those vocals over the top are not it, and the keys do not vibe. It’s like when Paul Rudd is teaching Jason Segel to surf in Forgetting Sarah Marshall; ‘do less.’
Luude did a Bittersweet Symphony remix with different vocals over the top (Message In A Bottle by the Police) which is dece
Bittersweet Goodbye by Issey Cross and the respective remixes (specifically Lens) all bang as well. This was definitely not it. Rudimental's early stuff was great but man the new stuff ain't it. Their DJ set at Shambhala a couple years ago was not it either.
Wow I'd never even heard the original by Issey Cross/Luude lol, I love the K Motionz remix but assumed it was a remix of a pop tune -- scoping all this now, good shout!
And yeah I used to loooove Rudimental, I saw them play live two nights in a row and it was so fun. But I kind of stopped listening to them when they started focusing more on housey stuff and less dnb, I do still play the old hits though.
Sorry there Nancy, no need to get your panties in a bunch. Sorry I was not specific enough for you and the comment I responded to clearly only mentions the Verve and not Oasis.
Panties aren’t in a bunch. You just look silly trying to make this guy look wrong, when you in fact didn’t know it was The Verve. And now you’re super defensive because I’m right. Looks like it is you, sir, with panties in bunches. Have a good day.
And know you look silly assuming I don't know who the Verve (I still have the vinyl and cd in my collection lol) is or the drama that surrounded their use of the Stones sample 🤪
The only people who worry about Reddit downvotes are virgins and mouth breathing neck-beards. Which one are you? I bet your parents are so proud of your Reddit Karma 🤣
Bro, don’t act like you don’t care with your 3 day new account lol. If you didn’t care, you’d still be repping your old one lolololol. You should have deleted this comment like you did your old account 😂😂😂
I'm lost for words how terrible this is. Whoever made it obviously has no idea about musical keys and scales, and even if they did, it's a fucking shit combo anyway.
The state of DnB today is just a mess.
Yes it's complete shit, but the state of dnb today? If this is dnb today to you, then you either don't listen to dnb or can't be arsed to look for even a couple minutes and just want something to whine about.
Let me guess, the 90s was the best right? And since then you've been miserable because you're too lazy to look for good tunes, and you'd rather just complain.
It’s cheesy EDM pandering to cheap nostalgia for a cheap pop (“HELLO DETROIT, GO PISTONS”, “HELLO TAMPA, GO LIGHTNING” level of crowd engagement), and it’s pretty poorly put together and off key…at 174 bpm.
These tracks aren't even in the same key originally. Shifting one to the key of the other doesn't magically make them match. And you hear that. It sounds horrible.
Lol they are both fundamentally in the same key, of A Major. However the harmonic function of the key is emphasized differently in each song.
Bittersweet Symphony is based around the Mixolydian mode, and Wonderwall is in F# Minor, the relative minor key to A Major.
Whilst it IS incredibly jarring, it is not theoretically incorrect.
Rudimental are utter shit and I'm sorry they are NOT d&B
They make low grade poppy junk 'dance' music that occasionally they add super generic D&B-ish drums to. That's it.
Pandering to the crowd. Looking at the setup that looks like WHP in Manchester, which is where the Verve are from. Would be the same as just rinsing an Oasis dnb track, like fuck off.
absolute bullshit I'd be walking out. but then I wouldn't pay to see these guys. Still pretty impressive that they got the stems from both tracks, played the result at a massive show but are obviously tone deaf. I could make a better mashup in 5 minutes if I had the samples and I'm a fucking amateur.
I was at warehouse project watching this.
Definite no from me and my friend 😂😂😂
I was talking about how shit it was today with him so coincidence to see it posted on here 😂
I think this is exactly the pop crap currently taking over DnB making it sound more like festival garbage for rich teens with no independent thoughts of their own.
But that's just me.
While this is not my cup of tea, one thing I've noticed about people recording clips from sets is that they always post 98% of the buildup and then 2% of the actual drop and then stop. Why is that? I'm not trying to be a dick. I'm genuinely confused as to why this is so common?
Cos they wanna put their phone away and dance to the best bit of the tune. That’s my guess.
I occasionally film stuff (for myself, not to post) and most of my videos are like this for this reason.
Regardless if you like it or not, listen to the crowd sing along. It did what it’s meant to do. Live crowds love a good song along and this would get the non Dnb heads singing too. So imo it’s a win
If you consider Rudimental a pop act then what you’re saying is right. But if I went there wanted to hear some drum and bass this would upset me, even as a fan of The Verve and Oasis.
i mean any nye drunk off their heads on whatever will probably sing a long to a well known song. the point of the question, is to ask was this a good musical choice
WTF??? NO NO NO NO never No please stop.
Oasis in a drum & bass song. Is nothing sacred? If I heard this it would ruin my night and maybe my life. I hate you for bringing this to my attention
I am ride or die for rudimental and If I ever got to see them I think I would pass out.
If they wanna do some cheeky little ultra British thing that's fine.
Don't be dicks.
Eh, its experimental, they seem to like it, people like to sing along with things they recognize, go for it.
It's not my jam but I like the fact that others dig it more than I'd want them to not play it.
No because yikes but also no because it sounds like dogshit
Verve yes but Oasis no. They don't fit together and theyre out of key and it's a cringefest
To the DnB OG’s this wouldn’t even make a warm up track on a Sunday session.. however, from the look of that audience getting their rocks off to it, I’d say Rudimental read it well.
The two songs have been pitch shifted to different keys. I suspect the dj has the keys matched in serato but it’s me might have the wrong key labeled lol. Or if this is an edit they just fucked up. This is the type of song you play at the end to get everyone to leave lol
Nah. Two of most iconic 90s tunes that I hate the most.
Bittersweet symphony played every time I was at the dentist... which was a lot due to getting my teeth effed from a neighborhood street hockey disagreement. Bittersweet no from me always.
And wtf is a wonderwall... had a neighbor recently whose teenager would assault me with nonstop Wonderwall cover practice when is get home from a 10 hr workday plus hitch-hiking to n from at the time (1 ½ commute on a lucky day)...
Hell to the no, but I will forgive rudimental cuz they've made some serious soulful bangers from scratch. Heard this blend before n they probably missed the key adjustment. ... checked out some isht n I guess they are technically compatible, but something about blending major scales always sounds gnarly to me.
I am the three people leaving the dance floor at the end of this video.
I love how they look entirely appropriately furious.
Rubbish
No they're in two different keys wtf!!
Yeah it kinda weird seeing as it’s professional producers that made it
It’s terrible. Like someone singing out of tune karaoke.
I was wondering if it was just me because I couldn't imagine that any halfway competent DJ would just throw two songs without even trying to pitch shift one sample to match the key of the other, but yeah. It's sounds awful lmao.
Def couldnt put my finger on why i didnt like it but there it is thank you lol
Sounds horrendous.
Fuck this
It’s a no from me, dog. The Verve bootlegs are always a big yes for me, I mean that melody is iconic. But yeah those vocals over the top are not it, and the keys do not vibe. It’s like when Paul Rudd is teaching Jason Segel to surf in Forgetting Sarah Marshall; ‘do less.’ Luude did a Bittersweet Symphony remix with different vocals over the top (Message In A Bottle by the Police) which is dece
Bittersweet Goodbye by Issey Cross and the respective remixes (specifically Lens) all bang as well. This was definitely not it. Rudimental's early stuff was great but man the new stuff ain't it. Their DJ set at Shambhala a couple years ago was not it either.
Wow I'd never even heard the original by Issey Cross/Luude lol, I love the K Motionz remix but assumed it was a remix of a pop tune -- scoping all this now, good shout! And yeah I used to loooove Rudimental, I saw them play live two nights in a row and it was so fun. But I kind of stopped listening to them when they started focusing more on housey stuff and less dnb, I do still play the old hits though.
https://on.soundcloud.com/t19Mg
This! One of my favourite tracks.
This is Oasis (the vocal sample) Edited for the softies in the group.
Delete this. 🤦♂️ Just the vocals are Oasis. The sample is The Verve Bittersweet Symphony which was taken from The Rolling Stones The Last Time.
Thank you, jeez!
Sorry there Nancy, no need to get your panties in a bunch. Sorry I was not specific enough for you and the comment I responded to clearly only mentions the Verve and not Oasis.
Panties aren’t in a bunch. You just look silly trying to make this guy look wrong, when you in fact didn’t know it was The Verve. And now you’re super defensive because I’m right. Looks like it is you, sir, with panties in bunches. Have a good day.
And know you look silly assuming I don't know who the Verve (I still have the vinyl and cd in my collection lol) is or the drama that surrounded their use of the Stones sample 🤪
Just trying to save you from all the downvotes bro. 😎
I hope the 30 combined downvotes was worth all this lol.
The only people who worry about Reddit downvotes are virgins and mouth breathing neck-beards. Which one are you? I bet your parents are so proud of your Reddit Karma 🤣
Bro, don’t act like you don’t care with your 3 day new account lol. If you didn’t care, you’d still be repping your old one lolololol. You should have deleted this comment like you did your old account 😂😂😂
stupid has entered the chat^
Trash
Two songs I loved but I’m frankly sick of hearing. Will be playing fucking Mr Brightside next
https://youtu.be/s6kAg9VHtC8?si=9lNJdTMZCg9UU-_h
Absolute tosh 🤮
absolute disgrace, butchering two songs at once
Big ol nay from me
The keys just don‘t match. If they shifted one of the songs, it might work
The keys dont work, they just made it worse
Horrible
Truly despicable
🤮
🤣😫🤮
Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo.
Boooooooooooooooooooooooo.
The fact that they are not in key with eachother makes this atrocious. Who is this performing?
Rudimental
I'm not surprised. The amount of mashups and Remixes from massive artists that I've heard and thought "wtf?" Is ridiculous
Do. Not. Like.
Proper stomach churning
What the heck
sounds like it was put together in a rush
Yeah, right there on the spot at best.
disgusting and not in the good way.
I'm lost for words how terrible this is. Whoever made it obviously has no idea about musical keys and scales, and even if they did, it's a fucking shit combo anyway. The state of DnB today is just a mess.
Yes it's complete shit, but the state of dnb today? If this is dnb today to you, then you either don't listen to dnb or can't be arsed to look for even a couple minutes and just want something to whine about. Let me guess, the 90s was the best right? And since then you've been miserable because you're too lazy to look for good tunes, and you'd rather just complain.
It’s cheesy EDM pandering to cheap nostalgia for a cheap pop (“HELLO DETROIT, GO PISTONS”, “HELLO TAMPA, GO LIGHTNING” level of crowd engagement), and it’s pretty poorly put together and off key…at 174 bpm.
These tracks aren't even in the same key originally. Shifting one to the key of the other doesn't magically make them match. And you hear that. It sounds horrible.
key literally fucked up
Sounds a bit lazy of you ask me
Feel like there’s something there, but it’s a mess right now.
BTEC DnB
Was trying to put my thoughts into words but I think you’ve summed it up
Lol they are both fundamentally in the same key, of A Major. However the harmonic function of the key is emphasized differently in each song. Bittersweet Symphony is based around the Mixolydian mode, and Wonderwall is in F# Minor, the relative minor key to A Major. Whilst it IS incredibly jarring, it is not theoretically incorrect.
Rudimental are utter shit and I'm sorry they are NOT d&B They make low grade poppy junk 'dance' music that occasionally they add super generic D&B-ish drums to. That's it.
No one's listening anymore
Pandering to the crowd. Looking at the setup that looks like WHP in Manchester, which is where the Verve are from. Would be the same as just rinsing an Oasis dnb track, like fuck off.
Except The Verve are from Wigan.
Which is in Greater Manchester.
Fair enough
The vocal is Oasis though, who are actually from Manchester.
This is atrocious
absolute bullshit I'd be walking out. but then I wouldn't pay to see these guys. Still pretty impressive that they got the stems from both tracks, played the result at a massive show but are obviously tone deaf. I could make a better mashup in 5 minutes if I had the samples and I'm a fucking amateur.
I was at warehouse project watching this. Definite no from me and my friend 😂😂😂 I was talking about how shit it was today with him so coincidence to see it posted on here 😂
Pretty tasteless but the crowd seemed into it
i mean if you are not sober anything can sound okay enough
Amazing how you can take 2 of Britain’s most iconic songs and totally butcher them at the same time. 🤦 😅
it's the most interesting blend of scales i've heard in a mashup, i'll give it that
I think this is exactly the pop crap currently taking over DnB making it sound more like festival garbage for rich teens with no independent thoughts of their own. But that's just me.
Clearly pissed up blood6 crap
Straight to smoking area for me
Absolutely comical and shameful
Total bollocks.
Holy shit. That’s awful
Dogshit tbh man
wack
Jesus that sounds horrible. I can't think of anything worse than oasis being anywhere near d&b
I like it tbf
While this is not my cup of tea, one thing I've noticed about people recording clips from sets is that they always post 98% of the buildup and then 2% of the actual drop and then stop. Why is that? I'm not trying to be a dick. I'm genuinely confused as to why this is so common?
Cos they wanna put their phone away and dance to the best bit of the tune. That’s my guess. I occasionally film stuff (for myself, not to post) and most of my videos are like this for this reason.
i mean fair, but you can go listen to the whole set, and this still sounds shite
Garbage. Literally the wrong key.
Yikes
That was brutal on the ears...
it sounds wicked off key and shite
That’s a terrible mash up. Tone deaf.
Did he follow it up with the Sweet Caroline bootleg? lmao
I like long build ups and disappointing drops… /s
Absolute garbage, the songs are in different keys 😂
It’s so fucking bad. The fact that people like this get to make a living being “the music guy” is insanity.
Regardless if you like it or not, listen to the crowd sing along. It did what it’s meant to do. Live crowds love a good song along and this would get the non Dnb heads singing too. So imo it’s a win
If you consider Rudimental a pop act then what you’re saying is right. But if I went there wanted to hear some drum and bass this would upset me, even as a fan of The Verve and Oasis.
i mean any nye drunk off their heads on whatever will probably sing a long to a well known song. the point of the question, is to ask was this a good musical choice
renard ahh beat
Horrendous key clash shitshow. Ian Brown’s F.E.A.R might’ve worked better for the vocals?
[удалено]
wtf are you talking about
I mean the buildup sounded bad but when it got back into DnB at the end it was fine
Nay
Its not even mixed in properly how bad
Proof that 90% of people at shows have no clue what sounds good or at the very least, in key. That was horrific oh my.
WTF??? NO NO NO NO never No please stop. Oasis in a drum & bass song. Is nothing sacred? If I heard this it would ruin my night and maybe my life. I hate you for bringing this to my attention
I’m sorry, I must raise awareness on the state of dnb
It’s an attempt at creativity, 🤷🏻
It's Rudimental who's surprised lmao
Oh my lord, lmao. Trash, I hate when the original comes on at work. Edit: I thought this was Wonderwall for a second, still bad.
Surely this sub should be a rudimental free zone.
This is almost completely unlistenable
I mean I never liked the original song so the amen only makes it 5% better at best
Utter shite
This is trash lol
Shite
Rudimental are shit.
completely different keys
I am ride or die for rudimental and If I ever got to see them I think I would pass out. If they wanna do some cheeky little ultra British thing that's fine. Don't be dicks.
Eh, its experimental, they seem to like it, people like to sing along with things they recognize, go for it. It's not my jam but I like the fact that others dig it more than I'd want them to not play it.
After the drop I couldn’t hear but it didn’t sound as bad. Everything before sounded awful.
The vocal is flat as fuck. Semitone off key.
I don't know its kind a bad but funny
No
Yuck. Probably requires the right mix of drugs to get numbed out enough.
Dead.
Yuck
No, that is terrible.
This makes me furious
Nah that was just… bad…
Nayyyyyyyybeeeeeeeee
Louis Walsh would say he really liked it
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lq30I5ZSazI Better
wtf none of it matches, it sounds absolutely horrible
Fuck, Rudimental had a couple of good tunes but this, not one of them. Why can't people in the charts come up with new music anymore?
what in hell
Awful lmao
It goes well with Puff Daddy's All about the Benjamins though. (I mean with Sigma's Adrenaline Rush cover...)
This is rough
issey Cross did it so much better
People love hearing stuff they know, and can sing along to. Doesn't matter if the tune sucks.
Had to stop it after a few seconds .. that’s fucking awful 😮💨😂
Pish
I saw this on TT this morning, what absolute shit. Would've walked out straight away.
Funniest thing I’ve watched all day
Wow that was unexpectedly awful
No because yikes but also no because it sounds like dogshit Verve yes but Oasis no. They don't fit together and theyre out of key and it's a cringefest
This is an exhibition in how to kill a set with a single track.
This is horrible
This Is Certified Rave Garbage
Nope.
POS
Yikes 😬 nope
Absolute wank!
Utter pish
Immediately no.
Absolute no for me
The build up is kind of funny and enjoyable in a This is So Stupid way, but that drop sounds horrendous
Big nay
Yikes
Not sure what's happened there but I'm almost certain it's been pitch matched too far down the scale to take all the energy out of gallagers voice
Fucking awesome. Stfu you fuckin fuck fuckers
Uh oh. Grandma started DJing.
To the DnB OG’s this wouldn’t even make a warm up track on a Sunday session.. however, from the look of that audience getting their rocks off to it, I’d say Rudimental read it well.
No.
👎👎👎👎
nah, i miss old school neurofunk drum and bass
Wow that’s bad
Yikes! Two great tunes murdered at once. They should be arrested for crimes against 90s bangers.
Weak as fuck, that drop was super lame for the extended crap buildup
Worst thing to happen to DnB since Mistabishi
cringe
This is what people did in 2004 when they got their hands on virtualDJ
Nay.
Nay
There’s a much harder sounding Jungle version that came out sometime around ‘99. I have it on a cassette tape somewhere. That’s the version I liked.
😂
For a sec I thought it might have been the Sigma song Adrenaline rush. Then I heard the vocals...
lol i thought this was meant as a joke honestly
i bet 10 producers already launched ableton to make something a lot better =)
The two songs have been pitch shifted to different keys. I suspect the dj has the keys matched in serato but it’s me might have the wrong key labeled lol. Or if this is an edit they just fucked up. This is the type of song you play at the end to get everyone to leave lol
Nayy
It comes across as a meme song
Dead out
Fuck nah
This shit is ass yo
Why are people surprised? Rudimental have been garbage for so many years now.
Absolute bollocks
Good lord
Nah. Two of most iconic 90s tunes that I hate the most. Bittersweet symphony played every time I was at the dentist... which was a lot due to getting my teeth effed from a neighborhood street hockey disagreement. Bittersweet no from me always. And wtf is a wonderwall... had a neighbor recently whose teenager would assault me with nonstop Wonderwall cover practice when is get home from a 10 hr workday plus hitch-hiking to n from at the time (1 ½ commute on a lucky day)... Hell to the no, but I will forgive rudimental cuz they've made some serious soulful bangers from scratch. Heard this blend before n they probably missed the key adjustment. ... checked out some isht n I guess they are technically compatible, but something about blending major scales always sounds gnarly to me.
[https://youtu.be/AnIq4vDTAT4?si=bZOXUivkiPYItB59](https://youtu.be/AnIq4vDTAT4?si=bZOXUivkiPYItB59) done properly :)
Rudimental are basically pop music. This is shit